Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: BJG on August 19, 2013, 04:38:14 PM

Title: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: BJG on August 19, 2013, 04:38:14 PM
I'm wondering if it's OK to play runs of press/draw notes without fingering each one...should I be thinking of fingering every note, or just the ones I need to, or a mix...?
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Stiamh on August 19, 2013, 04:46:52 PM
I'm wondering if it's OK to play runs of press/draw notes without fingering each one...should I be thinking of fingering every note, or just the ones I need to, or a mix...?

I don't see how you can play a note without fingering it... but if you mean: should you lift your finger between a press and a draw note on the same button? then the question has been asked and answered before.

English players tend to say that this is a good idea. Irish players tend to say it's not, unless there is a particular reason to want to separate or attack notes more than naturally happens when you change bellows direction. I think that's a fair summary of frequently expressed opinions, but I could be mistaken.

Or perhaps you meant something else?
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: BJG on August 19, 2013, 04:57:07 PM
OK, thanks!
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: ButtonBox21 on August 20, 2013, 12:20:28 PM
I think it may depend on what kind of music you are playing. When playing Irish or Cajun I don't life the finger on a press/draw. For Italian I was told that I should lift the finger on a press/draw, for a clean staccato sound, but old habits are hard to break. If you can, record yourself and play the tune using both methods. Use the one that sounds best for you.  :||:
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: pikey on August 20, 2013, 12:40:04 PM
I think it may depend on what kind of music you are playing. When playing Irish or Cajun I don't life the finger on a press/draw. For Italian I was told that I should lift the finger on a press/draw, for a clean staccato sound, but old habits are hard to break. If you can, record yourself and play the tune using both methods. Use the one that sounds best for you.  :||:

I vary it depending on the tune, particularly the speed of the tune.  Slower tunes benefit from separating each note. 
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Rob2Hook on August 20, 2013, 01:11:45 PM
There are players who pretty much insist on playing each note separately, e.g. Ed Rennie.  If you don't, the reversal of the bellows must be spot on and decisive, otherwise the reeds tend to "cough" a little as the directon changes.  Sorry, can't think of a better term, but the new note will not speak cleanly at first.  This is generally not a problem in fast runs but the co-ordination becomes more tricky at a slower pace.  With practice, it can be a very effective technique to get legato phrasing.

Rob.
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 20, 2013, 05:01:45 PM
There are players who pretty much insist on playing each note separately, e.g. Ed Rennie.  If you don't, the reversal of the bellows must be spot on and decisive, otherwise the reeds tend to "cough" a little as the directon changes.  Sorry, can't think of a better term, but the new note will not speak cleanly at first.  This is generally not a problem in fast runs but the co-ordination becomes more tricky at a slower pace.  With practice, it can be a very effective technique to get legato phrasing.
At Melodeons at Witney last November 2012, Christian Maes' workshop was partly about using the bellows to articulate the notes - i.e. the opposite to Ed Rennie's approach. Christian is very much a proponent of the idea of using the bellows as you would use your lungs when singing. He often keeps fingers down on the keys and uses the bellows to articulate separate notes and also to shape the notes as they are sounding. There is a lot to be said for this approach and it works especially well if you are positive and assertive with the bellows (it doesn't necessarily imply 'loud'!), which also helps overcome the 'coughing' effect which Rob mentions.

Here are some promotional videos of Christian's lovely playing taken from the Saltarelle website.

http://www.saltarelle.com/videos/nuage/Nuage02-christian3-do-re-c-d.m4v.SWF
http://www.saltarelle.com/videos/calirrhoe/Calirrhoe-2voices.m4v.SWF
http://www.saltarelle.com/videos/Connemara-III/Connemara-III-bando.m4v.SWF

Of course, there is never any one hard and fast way to play. The techniques of Ed Rennie and Christian Maes are both wonderful and can be adapted to suit the sort of music being played. Ideally we should all develop a technique which best suits the sort of music we like to play.
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 20, 2013, 05:35:42 PM
I agree with Steve - if it works for you it's right.  I'm an English-style player through-and-through, and I certainly don't lift off after/before every note; indeed, I'm a firm believer in saving energy and if two notes are on the same button but different directions then that's a calorie or two I don't have to burn.  Actually, I think a lot of the lift & punch of the English style of playing comes from the left hand, not the right, and depends more on bellows dynamics than fingering.

Graham
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: waltzman on August 20, 2013, 06:17:31 PM
I've always felt that the sound of shifting from one note to another on one button using the bellows was a part of the unique sound of the diatonic accordion.....a nice option when you want it that cannot be duplicated on a unisonoric instrument like the CBA or PA.
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: pikey on August 20, 2013, 06:42:25 PM
Learn all of the different techniques, then you can apply them subconsciously to any tune depending on how you want it to sound.

Players who do this always make melodeon's sound better than ''method' players.

The same is true for any instrument, including the voice.

I'll shut up now !!!
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 20, 2013, 07:09:29 PM
Learn all of the different techniques, then you can apply them subconsciously to any tune depending on how you want it to sound.

Players who do this always make melodeon's sound better than ''method' players.

The same is true for any instrument, including the voice.


Spot on!
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Stiamh on August 20, 2013, 07:14:15 PM
I confess there are a few things I don't understand about the "Ed Rennie" approach. Can anyone enlighten me?


I'm not trying to be clever here. I'm well aware that I have a lot to learn about different approaches to playing the box, and even playing the box in the style I aspire to myself. So any info. gratefully received!
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 20, 2013, 07:29:38 PM

Ed plays English dance music. He's played perhaps most notably for the Bismarcks. He is a good teacher, and he's quite open about the sort of music he plays, and what he teaches.

There is a load of his music on YouTube as Hohnerous, not from performances but I think as teaching aids. Have a listen.

He is brilliant to dance to. That's what he does. So staccato is right for that style. Never thought of his music as slow, but he's playing for dancers so speed, apart from ornamentation, is not the most important aspect. Lift and bounce are more important.

If you wanted to play in a different style, you might want to approach different teacher/player - horses for courses.

 :||:

Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 21, 2013, 12:23:48 AM
@Rob2Hook: I've never knowingly come across the "coughing" effect when reeds begin to speak. Just tried to produce it at home and really I can't hear it. Am I cloth-eared or what? Now I generally try to keep my bellows under tight control. Is this coughing something that is more likely to occur when your bellows are very wide open and/or waggling?
I think Rob is referring to the transient valve-rasping 'buzz' which can happen on the lower-pitched notes when there is a sudden change in bellows direction. At least that was my assumption...
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 21, 2013, 05:12:17 AM
@Rob2Hook: I've never knowingly come across the "coughing" effect when reeds begin to speak. Just tried to produce it at home and really I can't hear it. Am I cloth-eared or what? Now I generally try to keep my bellows under tight control. Is this coughing something that is more likely to occur when your bellows are very wide open and/or waggling?
I think Rob is referring to the transient valve-rasping 'buzz' which can happen on the lower-pitched notes when there is a sudden change in bellows direction. At least that was my assumption...

Can't say I've ever been aware of it either......
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: pikey on August 21, 2013, 05:50:06 AM

Ed plays English dance music. He's played perhaps most notably for the Bismarcks. He is a good teacher, and he's quite open about the sort of music he plays, and what he teaches.

There is a load of his music on YouTube as Hohnerous, not from performances but I think as teaching aids. Have a listen.

He is brilliant to dance to. That's what he does. So staccato is right for that style. Never thought of his music as slow, but he's playing for dancers so speed, apart from ornamentation, is not the most important aspect. Lift and bounce are more important.

If you wanted to play in a different style, you might want to approach different teacher/player - horses for courses.

 :||:
Listen to my stuff on TOTM on here, pikeyh on YouTube. I mix my styles.  ;)
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 21, 2013, 08:49:53 AM
I was paranoid about this when I started and thought that unless I articulated every note separately I would have to go and sit on the naughty step!

Nowadays, I mix and match both styles. Lately I've been having another look at Galopede and that is a tune that can be played in both ways which are both meritorious in my humble opinion.

As has been said many times on this forum, the melodeon is a folk instrument and as such, you can more or less please yourself how you play it!!  >:E
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Helena Handcart on August 21, 2013, 10:25:07 AM
I was paranoid about this when I started and thought that unless I articulated every note separately I would have to go and sit on the naughty step!

Les I absolutely know what you mean - I was exactly the same.  I thought if I did not lift my fingers off between notes the bad fairies would come and infest my cutlery drawer (or similar fate).

I also mix and match playing styles now but I think that this is one of those areas, like introducing the left hand very early in the learning process, that is easier to do if you practice it from the start rather than trying to learn it later on. Recently I have noticed a tendency to speed up and 'slur' notes in my playing and returning to a more staccato style for practice has helped this enormously.

Helena
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on August 27, 2013, 09:41:27 PM
I don't know how it happened, but I've only just found myself "playing by tapping", rather than keeping the finger down until it's time to go on to the next button, and I certainly relish the freedom it gives me. Contrary to what I think I read above, I find the technique actually does allow me to play faster (or as others might say "up to speed").  :||:  :-*
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: pikey on August 27, 2013, 09:43:39 PM
I don't know how it happened, but I've only just found myself "playing by tapping", rather than keeping the finger down until it's time to go on to the next button, and I certainly relish the freedom it gives me. Contrary to what I think I read above, I find the technique actually does allow me to play faster (or as others might say "up to speed").  :||:  :-*

So now you're Noting Every Finger?  ;)
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on August 27, 2013, 10:30:41 PM
I was paranoid about this when I started and thought that unless I articulated every note separately I would have to go and sit on the naughty step!

Nowadays, I mix and match both styles. Lately I've been having another look at Galopede and that is a tune that can be played in both ways which are both meritorious in my humble opinion.

As has been said many times on this forum, the melodeon is a folk instrument and as such, you can more or less please yourself how you play it!!  >:E

Erm, that's not quite true is it or there wouldn't be anything like regional styles, different types of tunes for different styles of dances. Folk doesn't just mean "anything goes". I think that could be a little insulting and diminishes our traditions.

Sure, you can play in whatever way you wish, on your own. There's no law or anyone going to come round and force you to do anything, but if you wish to play with others, or for dances within a tradition then there are "rules" of a sort. You will be pressured by other musicians and by the dancers to get it "right".

What is "right" for Galopede and other English Country Dance tunes ... well the fact that there are people here who talk about an "English style" of playing means that it does exist.
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: george garside on August 27, 2013, 11:06:05 PM
I !

 

. Folk doesn't just mean "anything goes". I think that could be a little insulting and diminishes our traditions.
 

Am in full agreement with Andrew on this.   As the same tunes can occur in different regional  styles it is very important to know how to adapt  such a tune to the appropriate regional style rather than an 'anything goes' version which    in all likelihood  will  be way of the mark.

Having said that I think it vital that any  half deceent player should be equally at home changing notes ''on the button'' or '' on the bellows''  so either can be used  where appropriate.


george

 
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: george garside on August 27, 2013, 11:20:25 PM
perhaps  the 'anything goes' merchants should think in terms of  ''ear ear'!
george
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 28, 2013, 07:54:41 AM
I was paranoid about this when I started and thought that unless I articulated every note separately I would have to go and sit on the naughty step!

Nowadays, I mix and match both styles. Lately I've been having another look at Galopede and that is a tune that can be played in both ways which are both meritorious in my humble opinion.

As has been said many times on this forum, the melodeon is a folk instrument and as such, you can more or less please yourself how you play it!!  >:E

Erm, that's not quite true is it or there wouldn't be anything like regional styles, different types of tunes for different styles of dances. Folk doesn't just mean "anything goes". I think that could be a little insulting and diminishes our traditions.

Sure, you can play in whatever way you wish, on your own. There's no law or anyone going to come round and force you to do anything, but if you wish to play with others, or for dances within a tradition then there are "rules" of a sort. You will be pressured by other musicians and by the dancers to get it "right".

What is "right" for Galopede and other English Country Dance tunes ... well the fact that there are people here who talk about an "English style" of playing means that it does exist.

Duly noted.  Just for the record, I only play for my own amusement.
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: pikey on August 28, 2013, 08:01:47 AM
You keep playing how you want to Les, alone and in company, and ignore the purists. Folk is a rich tradition that deserves to be explored and experimented with, not stifled into any particular style.

Mix and match as much as you want, and enjoy playing about with tune styles. If that offends some one, then it's their problem, not yours !

 ;)



 
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Lester on August 28, 2013, 08:05:17 AM
You keep playing how you want to Les, alone and in company, and ignore the purists. Folk is a rich tradition that deserves to be explored and experimented with, not stifled into any particular style.

Mix and match as much as you want, and enjoy playing about with tune styles. If that offends some one, then it's their problem, not yours !

 ;)

+1
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 28, 2013, 08:35:11 AM
Thank you pikey and Lester.  Don't get me wrong, I do respect the tradition and I do understand and appreciate the rich heritage associated with this instrument.  I really don't wish to offend anyone with what I say or how I play.  I guess it's because I have come to the melodeon from a very different musical world than a lot of other players.
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on August 28, 2013, 05:30:01 PM
You keep playing how you want to Les, alone and in company, and ignore the purists. Folk is a rich tradition that deserves to be explored and experimented with, not stifled into any particular style.

Mix and match as much as you want, and enjoy playing about with tune styles. If that offends some one, then it's their problem, not yours !

 ;)

Sorry, if you think that I what I said was a plea for "purism", being offended by what people play or stopping them playing at all, then you missed my point by a country mile.
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: pikey on August 28, 2013, 07:55:38 PM
Hi Andrew, it was the bit about 'rules'. There shouldn't be any rules in a session about playing style. Eg if I want to play 'oh joe the boat is tipping over' as a waltz, then I'll do it. If I want to play 'peaches' by the Stranglers, then I'll do it (and have  ;) ) .

If I go to a session that has rules, I'll break them.

Nuff said.....  ;)

Pikey

Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Sage Herb on August 28, 2013, 09:23:25 PM
Surely the very notion of a session implies something that is social, ie takes some account of what others present wish to do? As Andrew implies, it's hardly surprising that particular sessions develop distinctive approaches to playing.

But that apart, if you started a tune at a particular speed in a particular key and in particular rhythm, wouldn't you expect the other musicians to follow suit? And wouldn't you reciprocate when someone else started a tune? And wouldn't that be a sort of rule (or custom, or whatever)?

Steve
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: pikey on August 28, 2013, 09:37:41 PM
Surely the very notion of a session implies something that is social, ie takes some account of what others present wish to do? As Andrew implies, it's hardly surprising that particular sessions develop distinctive approaches to playing.

But that apart, if you started a tune at a particular speed in a particular key and in particular rhythm, wouldn't you expect the other musicians to follow suit? And wouldn't you reciprocate when someone else started a tune? And wouldn't that be a sort of rule (or custom, or whatever)?

Steve

Exactly, I follow what was started.thats etiquette, not a rule.

 A rule is something like you'll have to play it as it was recorded. Or always in G because that's how we always play it.  Or always 2 as 2bs twice the back to the first A then stop because that's how Jimmy Shand recorded it. Or we only play 'folk' tunes and hat doesn't include First World War song tunes or Beatles hits or......   ;)
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on August 28, 2013, 11:02:40 PM
(before anyone else says it) Delilah.  >:E  :||:  :|glug
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: pikey on August 29, 2013, 08:05:16 AM
E
(before anyone else says it) Delilah.  >:E  :||:  :|glug

Or the Wrong Trousers , or Telstar, or........


 >:E
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: mory on August 29, 2013, 08:34:49 PM
Thank you pikey and Lester.  Don't get me wrong, I do respect the tradition and I do understand and appreciate the rich heritage associated with this instrument.  I really don't wish to offend anyone with what I say or how I play.  I guess it's because I have come to the melodeon from a very different musical world than a lot of other players.
I think you'd be surprised Les at the amount of people who arrive at the melodeon from a back ground similar to your own. All the Best mory
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Peter G on September 01, 2013, 10:23:11 PM
Bearing in mind the original post was from a 'new friend' I reckon it's important to develop the 'staccato' style of playing - it's one of the most difficult bits about learning to play a tune at reasonable tempo. I learnt initially from Mally's book, who is very sticky about it. Having spent a  few years feeling it was important to 'do it right' I'm now starting to allow myself the luxury of doing it the other way and finding (a) I can play some tricky bits in tunes which I was struggling with before, and (b) it actually sounds quite nice in some tunes, particularly Morris tunes. Always good to have more than one string to the bow (especially if you are a fiddler)  :||: (:)
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Stiamh on September 03, 2013, 02:43:22 AM
... the 'staccato' style of playing - it's one of the most difficult bits about learning to play a tune at reasonable tempo. [..]

... doing it the other way and finding I can play some tricky bits in tunes which I was struggling with before

Peter, I read your first statement as contradicting your second i.e. 1. to be able to play a tune at a good speed you have to play staccato and 2. if you abandon the attempt to play staccato things get easier.

Or perhaps I am being (wilfully) obtuse. Can you clarify?


Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: boxcall on September 03, 2013, 03:22:08 AM
I know for me ornamenting with a bellow change triplet (finger on button) comes easier and usually sounds better than when done up and down the row (lifting fingers)
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 03, 2013, 08:26:48 AM
Sorry, BJG, melnet just isn't constitutionally able to provide "quick queries".

It was allegedly founded in this mode, by three pioneering melodeonistas.
This offered assurance of majority opinion on what colour to have its pages  ;)
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: george garside on September 03, 2013, 11:03:10 AM
Bearing in mind the original post was from a 'new friend' I reckon it's important to develop the 'staccato' style of playing - it's one of the most difficult bits about learning to play a tune at reasonable tempo. I learnt initially from Mally's book, who is very sticky about it. Having spent a  few years feeling it was important to 'do it right' I'm now starting to allow myself the luxury of doing it the other way and finding (a) I can play some tricky bits in tunes which I was struggling with before, and (b) it actually sounds quite nice in some tunes, particularly Morris tunes. Always good to have more than one string to the bow (especially if you are a fiddler)  :||: (:)

I agree totally that being able to play 'staccato' or doing it whatever you want to call '' t'other way''  provides choice  and a different effect.  However  as 't'other way'  comes fairly naturally  to most people  LEARNING to play 'staccato' competently at all speeds is absolutely vital , otherwise their would be no choice in what to do where etc

george
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: pikey on September 03, 2013, 11:08:44 AM
Perfect timing for a plug for Theme of the Month....

Bob Cann was a master of staccato playing, and using the bellows to lift the tune. Listen and learn!   :||:
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Peter G on September 03, 2013, 07:30:06 PM
Hi steve; sorry if not clear - I just meant that it's easier to play a tune fast 'tother way (not staccato) so I can now play one or two particular tunes at a decent speed as I am allowing myself the luxury of not 'double fingering' on the section that was causing me trouble. Tho I still hope to achieve it in the future!
 (:)
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Stiamh on September 03, 2013, 08:01:57 PM
Thanks for the clarification Peter. It all makes sense to my poor tired brain now!
Title: Re: Quick query - fingering every note?
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 03, 2013, 11:48:23 PM
Having come to this thread rather late, I want to pick up on the adverse reaction to the suggestion that there are 'rules' when trying to play in a particular style.

Some people pointed out, quite rightly that, when playing in a session, one should be free to play however one wishes (within reason  >:E). However, there are certain techniques ('rules' is perhaps too strong a term) that need to be taken into account if one wants to play in a particular style. If these techniques are ignored, then the playing will not sound much like the style one is trying to emulate. For instance, if one plays a Cajun tune without playing in octaves and using the ornamentation that is so characteristic of that style, there is no way that the tune will sound Cajun.

Having taken up the one-row box last year, I began learning a range of tunes on it, mainly from East Anglia and from the Yorkshire Dales. It is only recently that I have begun to realise how different the styles of playing are in each of these areas. I can't yet define the differences, but they are there and I intend to spend part of this winter trying to identify the differences between them and apply them in my playing. My point is that there are techniques that define particular styles. We can ignore them if we wish, but if we do so we cannot claim to be playing in that style.

Thread drift alert: This post could take the discussion in a different direction, so, if melnetters want to pursue this further, perhaps we should do so in a separate thread.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal