Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: forrest on August 19, 2013, 10:34:19 PM
-
Not sure if this topic belongs here or in 'makes and models'; but when did melodeons/accordeons change from being a 'box' to the more streamline shape similar to the Paolo Solari's, Coronas, etc? From whence did this design originate?
-
I've always thought there was something of Art Deco about the curved shape and parallel lines in the grille of an Erica or the classic Paolos. No doubt in parallel with contemporaneous design in so many areas, including cars.
But while cars have moved on, why have all the artisan makers gone back to very boxy treble cabinet shapes? Ease of manufacture, surely, but IMO most of them are just dead ugly in comparison with the earlier curves - something that no amount of filigree CVC fretwork in the grille can make up for. Or little flourishes on the ends of keyboards that make some makers' work resemble cluny Edwardian sideboards or massive Welsh dressers (with the shiny white buttons doing duty as plates) :P
(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/ff/1934ChryslerAirflow.jpg/320px-1934ChryslerAirflow.jpg)
-
Or little flourishes on the ends of keyboards that make some makers' work resemble cluny Edwardian sideboards or massive Welsh dressers (with the shiny white buttons doing duty as plates
Best description ever...les mots absolument justes...
-
Or little flourishes on the ends of keyboards that make some makers' work resemble cluny Edwardian sideboards or massive Welsh dressers (with the shiny white buttons doing duty as plates
Best description ever...les mots absolument justes...
Cheers Baz :|glug BTW I think I meant to write "clunky" sideboards - Edwardian is far too modern to get into Le musée de Cluny (http://www.musee-moyenage.fr/) and anyway I'm sure medieval luthiers would have made something far more elegant. ;)
-
LOL
I general I prefer a more boxy shape. Some curvy boxes make me cringe.
-
Wow
-
... when did melodeons/accordeons change from being a 'box' to the more streamline shape similar to the Paolo Solari's, Coronas, etc?
From what I can gather, it started off with American piano accordion makers in 1937 and was almost immediately taken up by the Italians. However, Hohner didn't bring out their streamlined Coronas and Ericas until 1955.
From whence did this design originate?
I've always put it down to the 1930's obsession/fashion for streamlining, especially of cars, railway locomotives and aircraft.
-
Agree that in most luthier's work this fashion seems to have passed. Early Gaillards were very rounded, I asked if he could do it for mine and got a straight no. My more recent van der Aa came with all corners rounded off. It isn't quite streamlined in the 1950 sense, but is much nicer to hold.
Wiki says that streamlining in trains got going in the 30's, and that the first was 1905!
-
surely it must have something to do with material availability i.e. the invention of moldable plastic which enabled crude but nevertheless efficient woodwork to be clothed in ''pearloid'' so as to look modern and posh! - and no doubt cheaper to mass produce than bespoke cabinet making. Personally I am perfectly happy with pearloid or posh woodwork provided the thing plays well!
george
-
surely it must have something to do with material availability i.e. the invention of moldable plastic which enabled crude but nevertheless efficient woodwork to be clothed in ''pearloid'' so as to look modern and posh! - and no doubt cheaper to mass produce than bespoke cabinet making. Personally I am perfectly happy with pearloid or posh woodwork provided the thing plays well!
george
Actually, my curiosity was generated by the amount of extra work that might have been entailed in the making of this shape. My main contact is my Italian made Pistelli box, probably made in the 50's or 60's, but I am not certain of the date. The Pistelli is not precisely a high end instrument, but the general form underlying it's green celluloid is built of shaped wooden pieces that I am sure took quite a bit of planning to cut, shape and fit, along with getting keyboard, buttons, and mechanism all lined up and working. The innards of the instrument suggests that the shop where it was made did not have a high degree of technical production machinery, but more likely was hand-made by elves in a quaint corner somewhere in the back streets of Teramo. This would demonstrate to me, anyway, a certain attentiveness to the aesthetics of the form, and also of the resultant ergonomics of playing the box, rather than an expedient for mass production. Of course, now they could probably be duplicated on a 3D printer...
-
It may also had a bit to do with the difficulty of skinning objects with sharp corners using celluloid.
Celluloid was not you because it was "cheap" but because it allowed the use of lighter weight woods. Th celluloid laid over a crafted wood body becomes a sort of tension structure like the skin on an airplane. It is also very tough.
-
Hadn't thought of that at all....but a very interesting observation! A monocoque structure! Thanks Kimric! (:)
-
I've always thought there was something of Art Deco about the curved shape and parallel lines in the grille of an Erica or the classic Paolos. No doubt in parallel with contemporaneous design in so many areas, including cars.
But while cars have moved on, why have all the artisan makers gone back to very boxy treble cabinet shapes? Ease of manufacture, surely, but IMO most of them are just dead ugly in comparison with the earlier curves - something that no amount of filigree CVC fretwork in the grille can make up for. Or little flourishes on the ends of keyboards that make some makers' work resemble cluny Edwardian sideboards or massive Welsh dressers (with the shiny white buttons doing duty as plates) :P
(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/ff/1934ChryslerAirflow.jpg/320px-1934ChryslerAirflow.jpg)
I always assumed that the return to simple wooden boxes was in large part because manufacturers wanted to avoid the hassle and hazards associated with working with celluloid. Pitty because simple wooden wooden boxes are not so comfy at the bass side and some seem to get tatty fairly quick, having said that they should also be easier to repair or spruce up on a DIY basis.
There is nothing to stop makers producing more curved boxes in natural wood, this would however demand nicer wood and a higher level of cabinet making than required when covering with celluloid.
-
There is nothing to stop makers producing more curved boxes in natural wood, this would however demand nicer wood and a higher level of cabinet making than required when covering with celluloid.
The only one I can think who do this is Briggs http://www.briggsaccordions.com/images%20outside%202.html
Looks like an old english car, very simple and beautifull design.
-
There is nothing to stop makers producing more curved boxes in natural wood, this would however demand nicer wood and a higher level of cabinet making than required when covering with celluloid.
The only one I can think who do this is Briggs.
Also Paddy Clancy (http://www.paddyclancy.com/accordions.html). The effect is spoiled IMO by the overly elaborate and flashy metal grilles.
Regarding nicer wood and finer cabinet making, I dunno: Hohner Ericas and Double Rays look pretty nice when stripped down to bare wood à la Martin Quinn.
-
The only one I can think who do this is Briggs http://www.briggsaccordions.com/images%20outside%202.html
Looks like an old english car, very simple and beautifull design.
[/quote]
Had never heard of these before and have no idea how they play but that is one seriously nice looking, if seriously expensive, button box.
-
"The only one I can think who do this is Briggs http://www.briggsaccordions.com/images%20outside%202.html
Looks like an old english car, very simple and beautifull design."
Etienne, that is a beautiful box.
John
-
Rees is drooling over a lovely Dino Baffetti on FaceAche
https://scontent-a-lhr.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-prn2/1238363_390667701062675_2009405601_n.jpg
Chris B.
-
Rees is drooling over a lovely Dino Baffetti on FaceAche
https://scontent-a-lhr.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-prn2/1238363_390667701062675_2009405601_n.jpg
Chris B.
A really 60's one, even in the color, fantastic piece.
-
... my curiosity was generated by the amount of extra work that might have been entailed in the making of this shape. My main contact is my Italian made Pistelli box, probably made in the 50's or 60's, but I am not certain of the date.
From what I've been told by accordion manufacturers, you're right about the extra work, but I'd reckon your Pistelli box (especially with those couplers) is more likely from the '40s.
-
Rees is drooling over a lovely Dino Baffetti on FaceAche
https://scontent-a-lhr.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-prn2/1238363_390667701062675_2009405601_n.jpg
Chris B.
Wow - that melodeon is mint!
Literally ... that's it's flavour.
-
Nice color. I had a Cruchinelli piano accordion in that same color,all the contrasting parts were salmon pink and it had pearl keys. It was a bit shocking.
-
I shouldn't have looked at that Briggs website..... :-\