Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Grape Ape on August 20, 2013, 02:20:12 PM

Title: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: Grape Ape on August 20, 2013, 02:20:12 PM
Ok so I need help. Most of it is not the type that can be offered on this site, but at least the urgent care I require is the sort for which this site might have a remedy.  Thursday I am going to make a three hour drive to look at a Hohner Club Morino described as in mint condition.  It is in CF.  I play a GC and play mostly French stuff, so a couple of questions:
1 What is wrong with me?
2 Is it as easy to find tab for CF as it is for GC?
3 Will I have to relearn everything?
4 does $1800 (asking price maybe negotiable) sound too high for a box described as mint? I am in the US so these don't show up often

Please help, not much time
Title: Re: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: forrest on August 20, 2013, 03:30:22 PM
Even if a box is absolutely pristine on the exterior, it may need work to be a good player, depending on its' age. Squeezeboxes survive best when played regularly, and kept in a cool, dry, environment. If not, sometimes the bellows will stiffen, valves curl, etc.

   Don't be overwhelmed by the 'mint' part, although a pristine box is a good place to start. How does it sound? Is it beautiful to your ears, or shrill and unpleasant? If the latter case, expect to have it tuned, and probably new wax and valves, which could cost hundred$. Ask if it has been tuned recently and by whom.

 Try each button for smoothness of action and try each reed in and out to see if they start evenly and responsively. If the box has not been played regularly, it may need a warm-up. Play it moderately hard for about 15 minutes or so, and see if it sounds better. Sometimes small glitches clear up after a bit of playing.

  Ask to see the interior....is the owner capable of opening the box? Look for brown rust on the reeds, relative cleanliness of the interior (has this box been breathing tobacco smoke or dust in a bar-room band somewhere?) Are the leather valves lying flat on the reedplates or are they curling and twisting every which way? Are all the switch mechanisms clean and operate smoothly?

   The price sounds high, but these things don't come along every day. If it is well maintained, and ready to play, it could be fine. If it is out of tune, needs wax and valves, then you will have to sink more money into it to get your dream instrument.

  As for C/F....that's a personal decision. Best wishes, drive safely  (:)
Title: Re: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: pikey on August 20, 2013, 06:46:03 PM
That is a VeRY high price for a Morino Club. Mine was mint, and cost £650 including shipping from Germany, including case, and straps in excellent condition.
Title: Re: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: Theo on August 20, 2013, 07:17:58 PM
Agree with previous comments.

With regard to tab, you can use the same tab on CF as in GC, the music will just come transposed up fourth.
Title: Re: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: Adam-T on August 20, 2013, 07:43:22 PM
That is a VeRY high price for a Morino Club. Mine was mint, and cost £650 including shipping from Germany, including case, and straps in excellent condition.

Mine too - lovely condition, original case and straps, it had been checked over too ..... same deal as Pikey
Title: Re: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: KLR on August 20, 2013, 09:53:26 PM
And myself too - I'm in the US and paid $500 for a Club Morino that works fine, excepting that the solo M and H reeds aren't speaking in the top of their range for some reason.  All accounts I've come across suggest less than $1k for one of these - they have an amazing high level of construction but the audience for them is next to nothing any more, which tempers the market price a fair bit, it seems.
Title: Re: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: AirTime on August 20, 2013, 10:08:32 PM
I would add that you need to be sure that a Hohner Morino is what you actually want. It's easy to fall into the trap of thinking that a bigger, more complex box is going to offer you a lot more possiblities, but you have to consider what kind of music you are interested in playing & whether a Morino is the instrument best suited to that style of music.
Title: Re: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: pikey on August 21, 2013, 05:46:42 AM
And myself too - I'm in the US and paid $500 for a Club Morino that works fine, excepting that the solo M and H reeds aren't speaking in the top of their range for some reason.  All accounts I've come across suggest less than $1k for one of these - they have an amazing high level of construction but the audience for them is next to nothing any more, which tempers the market price a fair bit, it seems.

Check the slide moves freely when you change registers. It might need a slight adjustment to align it with the holes. My Ouverture had the same issue. Also check the reed blocks are flat against the 'Fondo'
Title: Re: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: pikey on August 21, 2013, 05:48:04 AM
I would add that you need to be sure that a Hohner Morino is what you actually want. It's easy to fall into the trap of thinking that a bigger, more complex box is going to offer you a lot more possiblities, but you have to consider what kind of music you are interested in playing & whether a Morino is the instrument best suited to that style of music.

I love mine, even though it never gets played out in sessions !
Title: Re: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: Adam-T on August 21, 2013, 08:21:16 AM

I love mine, even though it never gets played out in sessions !

Same here , playing the Morino for morris type stuff is like mudwrestling a hippo - light and agile it is not .. it can be played with lots of bellows reversals if you`ve got the constitution but is really best played with long runs in each direction .
Title: Re: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 21, 2013, 08:46:09 AM
I went the D/G and C/F route for a while. C/F's strength to me was that it opened up the minors in D and G and that made a lot of sense while I was still married to a bagpiper.

You might have other reasons. eg Fred "Gazman" Lambierge (when I met him) played a lot in G on his C/F getting a Blue edge to his music without resorting to accidentals, then taking it somewhat further …

I have since sold mine on, preferring the I/IV/accs route. I and IV being G/C when I'm in a country grounded in those keys. That way I only lug one box to festivals.

If you don't intend to play with others, they say the flattened key boxes, eg Bb/Eb have a gorgeous sound. As ever, it all depends on "what you play"  ;) I think you should mull that over and make your plan.
Title: Re: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: ButtonBox21 on August 21, 2013, 12:32:42 PM
$1800 seems too high for any used Hohner, even if it is German made. If you are in the Northeast maybe you should check out The Button Box. They have a good selection of used boxes. You can also consult with Accordion Connection in NH. He is an authority on Hohner. Also, there is Alex Bell in NYC, Liberty Bellows in Philadelphia. In the Mid West is Castiglione accordion and Jim Laab Music Center and out in CA is Smythe's Accordion Center. He is a very knowledgeable Weltmeister dealer. You can also try eBay. I think you will find that there are a lot of good used two and three row boxes out there for reasonable prices. Good hunting. :||:
Title: Re: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: Adam-T on August 21, 2013, 02:14:00 PM
The Club Morino isn`t an ordinary Hohner, in fact it`s the most opulent melodeon they ever made (including the Shand Morino which was bigger and now worth far far more but a more simpler design with less voices and a standard PA bass machine) - The Club Morino is the kind of thing which would cost about £8000 if they made it now given that it`s 5 voice, used top reeds, loaded it with fancy woods, chrome plated internal parts, brass screws and carefully crafted workmanship .. the N models are built more like Golas inside than Morinos and look far better on the inside than the outside (they look ordinary on the inside) ..

There`s no way you can lump these things in the same bracket as Coronas and Pokerworks - they`re only not worth much because no one wants them - as for no hohner being worth $1800, I`d love a 50s Shand morino for that price - you`d not get ANY shand Morino, even a 70s vintage tatty one in need of an overhaul for 1800 US Bucks .....

Club Morino - N Insides

Title: Re: Please save me from MADness!!!!
Post by: Grape Ape on August 21, 2013, 02:25:25 PM
I thank everyone for the advice, this site really is a wealth of information.  First, while the Morino is not my "dream" box, it is one that I want.  My dream box is probably one made by Marc Serafini.  I do tend to play with long pushes and pulls, and only play alone, so session concerns do not apply.  I have contacted the shops listed above and have even purchased a box in the past from the button box, they were great to deal with.  The seller is one of the dealers listed above, but I do not want to disparage the dealer, so they will remain nameless.  I have decided to hold out and wait until one presents itself at a better price, though that could be a while, so it was with some regret I emailed the seller telling his price was too high. For the record, I know there are great boxes out there T great prices, but I want a Morino, in the meantime, I still have my other boxes to keep me well entertained. Thanks again to all who replied.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal