Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: WestOz on August 22, 2013, 09:31:19 AM

Title: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: WestOz on August 22, 2013, 09:31:19 AM
A poll conducted on this site as to which Melnetters were involved with Morris Dancing indicated that a majority (2/3rds) of those who responded were dancers, musicians or both.
I wonder if those respondents (and any others) could give their opinions as to which is the "best melodeon for Morris", and why.
 
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Rob2Hook on August 22, 2013, 09:44:22 AM
Hmmm, don't know that there is truly a best box for morris.  There are, of course, several types of morris and each has a somewhat different style of music to suit.  The workhouse for all types is a Pokerwork/erica and a good one can do everything required of it whereas an unfettled Chinese version can be difficult, to say the least.  A good loud box is handy and notable examples would be the Pokerwork, Dino Baffetti BPII, Oakwood, Sandpiper and that's just thinking of the more effective ones in local sides - covering NW, Border and Cotswold styles.

Rob.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 22, 2013, 10:05:58 AM
fairly wet tunes Hohners seem to work pretty well. The emphasis should I think be on the dance
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Adam-T on August 22, 2013, 10:12:06 AM
I`d definately vote for the Erica . Loud, durable, Reliable, easy and cheap to fix if you do break it (so last forever), there are samples from the 50s still playing on happily without repairs - has That traditional sound .. the Pokerwork has too but less comfortable to play and a bit less rugged...
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Paul J. on August 22, 2013, 12:59:12 PM
As mentioned elsewhere it depends very much on the type of dancing and the style/identity of the team (and prefered musical key in some cases). In general pokerworks and Ericas seem to do well. I no longer have a Hohner in D/G but I find my Castagnari Tommy serves well when I play for a North West team, along side a variety of instruments, including other melodeons, mandolin, whistle, guitar and harmonicas. Its slighty smaller size is usefule when on a tour.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 22, 2013, 01:00:40 PM
Side 1 - Dino Baffeti (don't know model) and Castagnari Lilly
Dinos are the workhorse boxes

Side 2 - ditto, except lead musicians play PAs.

Haven't particularly discussed reasons, but small, loud, rugged and (for Dinos) cost are in there. Both Cotswold.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 22, 2013, 01:02:10 PM
One with a few miles on the clock so you don't get too upset when it's left in the rain, knocked off a table, tripped over by someone's size 12s or has beer spilt over it..........
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: IanD on August 22, 2013, 01:35:05 PM
One with a few miles on the clock so you don't get too upset when it's left in the rain, knocked off a table, tripped over by someone's size 12s or has beer spilt over it..........

Assuming you've got a couple of grand to spare, a Baffetti Binci, Dedic tuned, insured through New Moon so if it gets damaged or trashed or nicked you can either fix it or go out and buy a replacement :-)

(which is why I don't use my Oakwood for morris any more)

If you want something reasonably small and loud for playing outdoors there's nothing to touch it. There are obviously better boxes for other purposes...
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: DDickie on August 22, 2013, 02:57:51 PM
A (loud  ;)) D/G such as a Hohner Pokerwerk or Erica (other makes are available).
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 22, 2013, 03:03:43 PM
Shameless plug....  ;D

This melodeon (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12759.msg156830.html#msg156830) is brilliant for morris, and it is for sale!  (:)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: IanD on August 22, 2013, 03:32:44 PM
A (loud  ;)) D/G such as a Hohner Pokerwerk or Erica (other makes are available).

You call that a loud D/G? THIS (picks up Baffetti Binci) is a *loud* D/G...
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Pat. on August 22, 2013, 04:03:57 PM
I am in not into Morris as such, but in my  opinion the only box would be a hohner pokerwork or Erica ,Morris is a traditional thing ,so why change what has been a mainstay for many decades.Good as some modern boxes are they do not look or sound traditional for the English music /dancing scene, it would be like playing Cajun with a bafetti,the tune is the same but the flavour is gone .That's my pennysworth any way.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on August 22, 2013, 04:14:19 PM
Hohner Erica gets my vote. You can literally throw it round your head, it really is a workhorse .
Won't stand being dunked in the River Sid though.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on August 22, 2013, 05:47:39 PM
I am in not into Morris as such, but in my  opinion the only box would be a hohner pokerwork or Erica ,Morris is a traditional thing ,so why change what has been a mainstay for many decades.Good as some modern boxes are they do not look or sound traditional for the English music /dancing scene, it would be like playing Cajun with a bafetti,the tune is the same but the flavour is gone .That's my pennysworth any way.
Pat, don't go down that route, otherwise the traditional instruments will arguably be the pipe and tabor or possibly fiddle for Cotswold Morris and probably concertina or brass for North West. The arrival of the D/G melodeon to Morris is post-WW2 - an 'invention' of Peter Kennedy.

The best melodeon for Morris is one played well for the dancers, to help drive and lift the dancing.

Personally I use either my Bafetti Binci or a Hohner Presswood, depending upon performance circumstances and weather !
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: IanD on August 22, 2013, 05:56:52 PM
I am in not into Morris as such, but in my  opinion the only box would be a hohner pokerwork or Erica ,Morris is a traditional thing ,so why change what has been a mainstay for many decades.Good as some modern boxes are they do not look or sound traditional for the English music /dancing scene, it would be like playing Cajun with a bafetti,the tune is the same but the flavour is gone .That's my pennysworth any way.

So what was traditional before the D/G pokerwork, introduced by Douglas Kennedy in the mid-1950s?

The pokerwork/Erica (tuned right) was/is popular because it has a bright sound that cuts through background noise, I played one for many years, as did many excellent morris musicians. Though they are brone to breaking reeds when played hard (lost 2 boxes on one morris tour once!), the bellows are weak, the pokerwork is uncomfortable to play, the action is horrible (better with some modifications) -- but they were undoubtedly the best morris box in their day, and are still a damn good one if you put up with the above flaws.

I agree that many of the (expensive) new European boxes don't work for morris, they're too dull and sweet-sounding and quiet -- just because they're high-quality doesn't mean they're the right tool for the job.

Unlike these the Oakwood (tuned right) was/is a great box for morris, I played that for many years too, as did quite a few excellent morris musicians (because they cost a damn site more than a pokerwork or Erica), everyone raved about the sound and they're lovely to play. But insurance is no good if you can't replace it.

So now I play a Binci Baffetti (tuned right), as do quite a lot of excellent morris musicians, and it sounds great -- if anything I'd say it's a little better than the Oakwood for morris, though not so good for other band and tune work, and less comfortable to play. But you can buy one today (for money), and replace it if broken. The "super" variant has a more subtle sound and is better (like the Oakwood) for other playing, but is more expensive and less good for morris than the standard one.

All these boxes have several things in common; they're 2-reed 8-bass D/G, small and light, with a bright cutting sound (tuned right) -- the Hohner has the sharpest edge to the sound but is probably the least loud and breaks most easily, the Oakwood has the "nicest" (but still bright) sound and is pretty damn loud, the Baffetti sound is in between on brightness and is almost certainly the loudest box on the planet, and none of the several people I know who play them (hard!) has had a reed go (yet...).

All are excellent for morris, and I've played all of them for years. But to answer the OP, as a box for morris I'd pick the Binci Baffetti if money permits, or an Erica if it doesn't.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 22, 2013, 06:01:27 PM
Next question:

Why does the OP want to know? Curi-o-osity or what?
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Pat. on August 22, 2013, 06:02:26 PM
Point taken Andy ,I was unaware that morris wth hohners were post war,,this is what happens when you comment on another genre that I know absolutely nothing about :-[ . but they still get my vote. They sound authentic and they are hard as nails.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: IanD on August 22, 2013, 06:23:33 PM
Point taken Andy ,I was unaware that morris wth hohners were post war,,this is what happens when you comment on another genre that I know absolutely nothing about :-[ . but they still get my vote. They sound authentic and they are hard as nails.

I'd have to disagree on the second point; for many years we (Hammersmith) used to own 2 boxes (first pokerworks, then Ericas) at any one time, and we replaced one per year -- so they lasted two years (this was seen as part of the essential running costs of the side!), and were then made available to people who wanted to learn, or sold off. Either way they were played *very* hard (solo, often in noisy environments, by loud players with strong left arms) and were pretty much knackered after two years, the bellows were worn out and the rate of reed failure became too high, which is why we always took both to bookings. I remember one booking where I got up to play the first dance and a reed went part way through, so I switched to the second box for the next dance and another reed went -- two boxes, both broken :-(

Eventually we got fed up with this so I went to Italy and collected a Castagnari Studio from the factory, which was the side's main box for quite a few years -- not as bright a sound as the hohners, but one Studio was much more reliable than two Ericas. Then we discovered Oakwoods (not paid for by the side!) and the rest is history...
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Malcolm on August 22, 2013, 07:05:44 PM
My D/G pokerwork did many years sterling service for Cotswold Morris but for my time in a clog band, a chorus of three Costalottis - my Salterelle Berry and a couple of Castagnaris - produced a good round sound to go with the two brass players and two drummers. But I have to admit for all-round grunt the Dino Bafettis do seem to be the box of choice these days - except perhaps for rapper where a melodeon just never seems right to me when compared with a concertina, whistle/recorder or fiddle. And I'd still prefer a solo fiddle for Cotswold morris - so much more atmospheric than any free reed instrument with due apologies for saying that in this Forum! - (PS: I've just noticed that the spell check doesn't like the word melodeon and offers any number of options including 'meltdown'!)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: pikey on August 22, 2013, 11:52:16 PM
Hohner polkerwork or erica every tine.

Someonle said Lilys. They are single reeded and quiet and hence not recommended.

Cajun one rows are good and loud but with chalenges for some tunes.

Bafetti bincis are LOUD but imho nowhere near as good as Hohners for Morris.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Ollie on August 23, 2013, 12:15:51 AM
Whatever box you feel comfortable playing, where you can get enough rhythm and drive to keep the dance going. For some that's a Pokerwork or Erica, for some that's a Binci, for others it's something totally different. I used a Beltuna Alex 3 for a while - not entirely recommended though, far too bloody heavy!
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 23, 2013, 12:32:54 AM
Whatever box you feel comfortable playing, where you can get enough rhythm and drive to keep the dance going. For some that's a Pokerwork or Erica, for some that's a Binci, for others it's something totally different....
Well said, Ollie!

Someone said Lilys. They are single reeded and quiet and hence not recommended.
Lilys are indeed single reeded, but quiet they are not! They are extraordinarily powerful and the sound cuts through like an ice skate through sheep poo.

The musician for Betty Lupton's plays a Lily and you can hear it at quite a distance away, above the sound of the clogs, bass drum, trombone, etc. 
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: EastAnglianTed on August 23, 2013, 12:45:11 AM
    "They are extraordinarily powerful and the sound cuts through like an ice skate through sheep poo."
    Hahaha. Castagnari should stick that on their website  >:E
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: nudiefish on August 23, 2013, 01:16:54 AM
When I think of the choices available today I think it is almost impossible to nominate a "best box" for Morris.   

I can say that I bought my Erica new in 1982 and it is still going great guns after thousands of foot-ups, bar sessions, folk festivals, ales, gigs and parties.   I have lived in the chilly weather of Canberra, the dry desert heat of Alice Springs and the subtropical humidity of Brisbane.   Frankly, I am somewhat amazed that it is still in almost perfect condition despite the unavoidable punishment it has endued in that time. 

I admit that sometimes those German reeds can sound slightly "harsh" when compared to more expensive machines, but they do cut through on a noisy or windy day.  They also blend in well with non-melodeon instruments. 

Any number of boxes would work well with Morris, but I can say with some certainty that the Pokerwork/Erica can take you where you need to go and be  brighter then you are the next morning.   
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Steve C. on August 23, 2013, 01:29:30 PM
Tell 'em Steve:  Lillys can peel paint at 300 yards.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Theo on August 23, 2013, 08:34:17 PM
I admit that sometimes those German reeds can sound slightly "harsh" when compared to more expensive machines,

Harsh sounding Hohner reeds are usually the result of the tuning being out, resulting in an unpleasant amount of tremolo.   Properly tuned a Hohner should sound bright, loud if you push it but should not be harsh.   They can even be swing tuned or even dry tuned, though some consider that to be a crime against nature! >:E
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Adam-T on August 23, 2013, 08:38:44 PM
They can even be swing tuned or even dry tuned, though some consider that to be a crime against nature! >:E

The thought makes me Shiver - Hohner only making Morganes and Merlins in Dry tuning is enough without tuners wantonly doing it to other models too ......
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Theo on August 23, 2013, 08:43:02 PM
This tuner only tunes to customers spec.  I don't promote any particular tuning.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Steve C. on August 24, 2013, 12:44:21 AM
The Morganes I have played were more in the swing or almost what we call "swing americano" tuning. 
Definitely not "dry".  "Dryish" for a Hohner, I guess....
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 24, 2013, 05:51:17 AM
A poll conducted on this site as to which Melnetters were involved with Morris Dancing indicated that a majority (2/3rds) of those who responded were dancers, musicians or both.
I wonder if those respondents (and any others) could give their opinions as to which is the "best melodeon for Morris", and why.
 

Can anyone please give me the link to this poll?

Thanks

Les
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 24, 2013, 08:21:10 AM
Lilys are indeed single reeded, but quiet they are not! They are extraordinarily powerful and the sound cuts through like an ice skate through sheep poo.

Concur about suitability, and I also liked the pseudo-concertina sound of the single reed. Lilly does cut the mustard ;) in many other respects, eg compactness, weight and (relative to bigger castas) price. My caveat is that the stress of loud morris play literally snapped 2 reeds on my Lilly, over about 10 years.

I was going to say the Hohner pokerwork ticked a lot of boxes. While melodeon is not 100% traditional, its fruity tone has a true niche in this role, but against that the single voice Lilly and concertina have a certain something in common with the older fiddle, and (oldest?) pipe/tabor.

nomination for post of the year for Steve's simile, though as a metaphor it'd be disqualified as "mixed"!
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: pikey on August 24, 2013, 08:38:50 AM
A poll conducted on this site as to which Melnetters were involved with Morris Dancing indicated that a majority (2/3rds) of those who responded were dancers, musicians or both.
I wonder if those respondents (and any others) could give their opinions as to which is the "best melodeon for Morris", and why.
 

Can anyone please give me the link to this poll?

Thanks

Les

Polkerwork or Erica  ;)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Ada on August 24, 2013, 11:55:44 AM
IMHOP a 3-voice Corona. If that's too big, a pokerwork or an Erica...
(spot the pattern developing here!) That said, my trusty old Nuage has quite a nice "cut" to it that makes up for the drier tuning when it comes to being heard.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: boxer on August 25, 2013, 07:24:42 PM
Andy Next Tune:

The melodeon was certainly used for morris dancing long before WW2.

Colne Royal Morris's musician used a C/C# melodeon in the period leading up to WW1.  The fact is well documented and is supported by photographic evidence.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Pat. on August 25, 2013, 08:24:40 PM
That's very reassuring for me after what I wrote earlier  (:)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on August 26, 2013, 10:16:55 AM
Andy Next Tune:

The melodeon was certainly used for morris dancing long before WW2.

Colne Royal Morris's musician used a C/C# melodeon in the period leading up to WW1.  The fact is well documented and is supported by photographic evidence.

I'm sure there is also evidence of people morris dancing to other melodeons such as one rows long before WW2.

The specific point I made in my earlier post was about the invention/arrival of the D/G melodeon to Morris dancing happened post WW2. And for a significant period after that, Hohner had a virtual monopoly on the D/G market.

Andy
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 26, 2013, 11:00:53 AM
We've discussed (and even voted) at length on this, and concluded that some poor decisions were madein setting up the Hohner D/G 3rd button start layout.

But yes, it did become mainstream after the war. There weren't too many other options? Casta now default 4th start for UK. I believe Hohner have not (yet?) made any changes, and in that context would buy a different make myself.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: DDickie on August 26, 2013, 07:14:40 PM
... for many years we (Hammersmith) used to own 2 boxes (first pokerworks, then Ericas) at any one time, and we replaced one per year -- so they lasted two years...

My Pokerwerk D/G is still going strong after 30 years of playing for Morris at least once every week - with only 1 treble reed  (it snapped!) and a few bass springs needing replacement  (:)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: WestOz on August 27, 2013, 02:19:21 AM
My reason for asking which was the best Melodeon for Morris was in part because of the windy climate I live, and the difficulty in projecting the music against the wind - I use a Hohner Pressedwood (a la Microbot). I have experimented with a copper horn, or trumpet fitted to the melodeon, with some slight success, offset by the extra kilo in weight.

The link requested by East Anglian Ted is  http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,225.msg82855.html#msg82855

Thanks to all for the opinions, which seem to lead to Pokerwork, Erica and Dino Baffetti Binci. Also, emphasis on correct tuning.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Theo on August 27, 2013, 08:38:31 AM
I use a Hohner Pressedwood
I generally find that the postwar Hohner Erica and Pokerwork, the ones with T reeds on aluminium plates, are louder than the various prewar versions based on the same shape box as the pokerwork. These have a great sound - very warm and mellow, but I do think the later ones are better if you need to squeeze out the last possible dB.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Adam-T on August 27, 2013, 08:52:48 AM
Later boxes are also more robust - those presswood fingerboards can be a bit fragile and that lovely natural wood finish is far from tough as old boots too . can`t beat a plastic fingerboard (or one of Pete`s new wooden ones) and Celluloid for a tough outdoor box .. no doubt hence the popularity of the Erica ..
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 27, 2013, 09:36:56 AM
Fairly hardwearing, those plastic fingerboards, I agree - but they feel so nasty compared with a wooden one. They have sharper edges everywhere and get either horribly sweaty or uncomfortably sticky. No arguments about an Erica as a morris box - I had two before the "posh" box, and now I've gone back to old 2915s for morris.  You can get them in lacquer or pearloid, too.......

Graham
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: pikey on August 27, 2013, 12:57:42 PM
My reason for asking which was the best Melodeon for Morris was in part because of the windy climate I live, and the difficulty in projecting the music against the wind - I use a Hohner Pressedwood (a la Microbot). I have experimented with a copper horn, or trumpet fitted to the melodeon, with some slight success, offset by the extra kilo in weight.

The link requested by East Anglian Ted is  http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,225.msg82855.html#msg82855

Thanks to all for the opinions, which seem to lead to Pokerwork, Erica and Dino Baffetti Binci. Also, emphasis on correct tuning.

Good choice.

According to the dancers in our team who aren't players (and hence aren't biased to any make), the sound from Castagnaris (including Lilys!), Hohner Liliputs, Salterelles, Dino Bafetti Carnivals,  doesn't carry as well as Hohner Pokerworks/Ericas and Dino Bafetti Bincis - with either a swing tuning, or a stronger 'out of the box Hohner' tremelo .

Its also worth learning how to play Octaves on the right hand, to get even more volume. Plus learning just how far is sensible to push a box without risking damage. Checkout the thread in 'Teaching and learning' about how to play for Morris, there are lots of good tips in there.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Bob Ellis on August 27, 2013, 01:03:26 PM
Although I play either a Pariselle or a Castagnari Benny for morris, I don't need the sound to be especially loud because there are usually anything from one or two to seven or eight other musicians around m when I play for Crook Morris. However, I am always impressed by Ian, the sole musician with Carreg Las, who plays a Hohner Pokerwork loudly enough to be heard clearly in the largest arena.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: pikey on August 27, 2013, 01:06:42 PM
Although I play either a Pariselle or a Castagnari Benny for morris, I don't need the sound to be especially loud because there are usually anything from one or two to seven or eight other musicians around m when I play for Crook Morris. However, I am always impressed by Ian, the sole musician with Carreg Las, who plays a Hohner Pokerwork loudly enough to be heard clearly in the largest arena.

You havent heard mine yet........   >:E    :||:
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Bob Ellis on August 27, 2013, 03:39:41 PM
I am always impressed by Ian, the sole musician with Carreg Las, who plays a Hohner Pokerwork loudly enough to be heard clearly in the largest arena.

You havent heard mine yet........   >:E    :||:

I presume we are talking about your tuba/euphonium or whatever you were playing in the Elsinore. It saved me a visit to the doctors by clearing the wax out of my ears.  >:E
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: pikey on August 27, 2013, 05:23:40 PM
I am always impressed by Ian, the sole musician with Carreg Las, who plays a Hohner Pokerwork loudly enough to be heard clearly in the largest arena.

You havent heard mine yet........   >:E    :||:

I presume we are talking about your tuba/euphonium or whatever you were playing in the Elsinore. It saved me a visit to the doctors by clearing the wax out of my ears.  >:E

PARDON????  ;)

I MEANT MY OLD POKERWORK .......
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on August 30, 2013, 08:14:31 PM
Ouch!
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: squeezy on August 31, 2013, 12:01:11 AM
I think you're all wrong ... the best melodeon for Morris is clearly the one that William Kimber played - and he INVENTED Morris!
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Ollie on August 31, 2013, 02:15:47 AM
I think you're all wrong ... the best melodeon for Morris is clearly the one that William Kimber played - and he INVENTED Morris!

'Arf.  ;D


I once saw a member of a Morris band (a handful of other melodeons, assorted percussion as per usual) playing a Pokerwork... linked up to a small portable amplifier.  :o

*facepalm*
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: squeezy on August 31, 2013, 08:00:32 AM
Apologies for the flippancy above ... But I always wonder when I see the sort of question in the title of this thread whether the person asking is actually winding us up!  It might as well be asking "should I put marmite or honey on my toast?"

The questions I asked myself before trying to answer the question when I started playing for morris were:

Is it light enough to carry around all day?
Is it in the same key as the other musicians play?
Is it loud?
How much do I mind if it rains on this box in the middle of a dance?

But mainly the question was:

Which box do I own at the moment?

Ok then ... I'll use that one!
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Anahata on August 31, 2013, 09:00:42 AM
I once saw a member of a Morris band (a handful of other melodeons, assorted percussion as per usual) playing a Pokerwork... linked up to a small portable amplifier.  :o

Some years ago I saw a melodeon player in the Straw Bear procession using a Pignose amp strapped to his back.
Since dance teams seem to like to have the music in front of them in a procession, despite the fact that you hear far less from behind the player, this seemed an eminently sensible idea.

(Pig Dyke never had that problem with the Sousaphone, of course, nor will they with Kathryn's alto Sax.)

Also... (and back on topic) I was more or less ordered to get an Oakwood by the squire of Hammersmith morris after trying to compete with the Richmond-on-Thames traffic with a Pokerwork, on a day when Ian wasn't there with his Oakwood. I did, of course, and the rest is history...

However, almost the only time I ever played my Pokerwork instead of the Oakwood for Pig Dyke, I got a compliment from one of the dancers about how good the music sounded. I'm not sure if she realised I was playing a different box. Since I only use the Oakwood for dance music now, perhaps I should get it tuned wetter next time it goes in for tuning.

But mainly the question was:

Which box do I own at the moment?

Ok then ... I'll use that one!

What - all seven of them at once?
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Lester on August 31, 2013, 09:23:03 AM
What - all seven of them at once?

Only 7 - lightweight  ;)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: george garside on August 31, 2013, 10:11:41 AM
My reason for asking which was the best Melodeon for Morris was in part because of the windy climate I live, and the difficulty in projecting the music against the wind - 

But why try to 'project' against the wind  when standing at the other side/end or whatever of the dancers means that the sound you make/project is carried towards the dancers totally free of charge by the wind! In which case it does not need to be particularly loud.  Thus located I never had any problem as far as volume is concerned using a pokerwork at around half throttle - and at windy seasides etc.

george
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: squeezy on August 31, 2013, 10:35:10 AM

What - all seven of them at once?


It was only one back then!
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: pikey on August 31, 2013, 12:04:59 PM
What - all seven of them at once?

Only 7 - lightweight  ;)

Must be a beginner......  ;)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: pikey on August 31, 2013, 12:06:03 PM
O for those halcyon days when there wasn't any choice.......

 ;)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Owen Woods on August 31, 2013, 02:33:49 PM
Apologies for the flippancy above ... But I always wonder when I see the sort of question in the title of this thread whether the person asking is actually winding us up!  It might as well be asking "should I put marmite or honey on my toast?"

I'm not sure I understand your analogy, since the answer to that question is quite obviously "honey" :P
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Lester on August 31, 2013, 04:05:18 PM
Apologies for the flippancy above ... But I always wonder when I see the sort of question in the title of this thread whether the person asking is actually winding us up!  It might as well be asking "should I put marmite or honey on my toast?"

I'm not sure I understand your analogy, since the answer to that question is quite obviously "honey" :P

Honey OR marmite   Yes!
Honey AND marmite   NO!!!   (:)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: IanD on September 02, 2013, 03:17:19 PM
My reason for asking which was the best Melodeon for Morris was in part because of the windy climate I live, and the difficulty in projecting the music against the wind - I use a Hohner Pressedwood (a la Microbot). I have experimented with a copper horn, or trumpet fitted to the melodeon, with some slight success, offset by the extra kilo in weight.

The link requested by East Anglian Ted is  http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,225.msg82855.html#msg82855

Thanks to all for the opinions, which seem to lead to Pokerwork, Erica and Dino Baffetti Binci. Also, emphasis on correct tuning.

Good choice.

According to the dancers in our team who aren't players (and hence aren't biased to any make), the sound from Castagnaris (including Lilys!), Hohner Liliputs, Salterelles, Dino Bafetti Carnivals,  doesn't carry as well as Hohner Pokerworks/Ericas and Dino Bafetti Bincis - with either a swing tuning, or a stronger 'out of the box Hohner' tremelo .

Its also worth learning how to play Octaves on the right hand, to get even more volume. Plus learning just how far is sensible to push a box without risking damage. Checkout the thread in 'Teaching and learning' about how to play for Morris, there are lots of good tips in there.

I've mentioned this before, but tuning does make a big difference to the perceived "cutting power" and volume. Once when Nielsen retuned my Oakwood he got it wrong and tuned it to concert/2Hz sharp instead of 2Hz sharp/2Hz flat, and the dancers complained that it was too quiet even though I hadn't told them anything.

For two detuned notes (or vocal vibrato) experiments have shown that the perceived volume (especially with background noise) goes up with the beat rate, starting to flatten off above about 4Hz and reaches a maximum (no further increase) at about 7Hz -- thought most people would think tuning this wet sounds pretty nasty, it's what opera singers consistently use when trying to project absolute maximum volume.

Right-hand octaves (but not all the time) and punching in right-hand chords on heavy beats also give a big increase in punch and perceived volume.

Our dancers (and musicians) have settled on the Baffetti Binci as the box of choice, which is why we had four at practice a few weeks back...
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: baz parkes on September 02, 2013, 03:32:35 PM
Also... (and back on topic) I was more or less ordered to get an Oakwood by the squire of Hammersmith morris after trying to compete with the Richmond-on-Thames traffic with a Pokerwork, on a day when Ian wasn't there with his Oakwood. I did, of course, and the rest is history..
[/quote

was he paying?  :|glug
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Graham Spencer on September 02, 2013, 04:31:18 PM
Apologies for the flippancy above ... But I always wonder when I see the sort of question in the title of this thread whether the person asking is actually winding us up!  It might as well be asking "should I put marmite or honey on my toast?"

I'm not sure I understand your analogy, since the answer to that question is quite obviously "honey" :P

No, the answer is "marmalade".... ;)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Peter G on September 02, 2013, 07:17:20 PM
I only have a Pokerwork and a Castagnari tommy (which is far too expensive to risk damage by taking outside)  but I was once recommended a Bafetti Balck Pearl as being sturdy and loud so good for morris - comments ladies and gents?
Peter
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: malcolmbebb on September 02, 2013, 09:14:57 PM
I know one player who plays a Black Pearl, couple of other Dino players with other models.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: IanD on September 02, 2013, 09:49:23 PM
I only have a Pokerwork and a Castagnari tommy (which is far too expensive to risk damage by taking outside)  but I was once recommended a Bafetti Balck Pearl as being sturdy and loud so good for morris - comments ladies and gents?
Peter

The Black Pearl is the celluloid version of the wooden Carnival II so the two are pretty much equivalent except maybe celluloid finish is more damage-resistant, both are very good reasonably-priced boxes for morris.

The Baffetti Binci is a Carnival II with Binci reeds, a more open grille and an added bass end stop; it's considerably louder and brighter than either of the above which is why it's very highly rated for morris, but it's also about 50% more expensive.

You pays your money and you takes your choice... :-)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: IanD on September 02, 2013, 09:56:03 PM
Also... (and back on topic) I was more or less ordered to get an Oakwood by the squire of Hammersmith morris after trying to compete with the Richmond-on-Thames traffic with a Pokerwork, on a day when Ian wasn't there with his Oakwood. I did, of course, and the rest is history..
[/quote

was he paying?  :|glug
No, but I strongly suspect Anahata was looking for a good excuse to get one anyway ;-)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Anahata on September 02, 2013, 10:24:41 PM
The Black Pearl is the celluloid version of the wooden Carnival II
...
The Baffetti Binci is a Carnival II with Binci reeds, a more open grille and an added bass end stop; it's considerably louder and brighter than either of the above

I looked at a Black Pearl when I was looking for a new box, and it was one of the few other boxes I liked, but without a doubt the Oakwood was brighter in tone.

No, but I strongly suspect Anahata was looking for a good excuse to get one anyway ;-)

Funny you should say that...
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Adam-T on September 03, 2013, 07:13:22 AM
I had a a black pearl II and although it was a lovely box, I found it far less than projecting compared to the Hohner pair, in fact if anything it was on the muffled side - the older Window Celebration-III in A/D I have is a lot clearer and has more tremelo but is still "Civilised" compared to an Erica or Pokerwork  ..

I really like my late 80s D/G Baffetti Irish-1 LMMM, (Native D/G too not a re-tuned C#/D or anything) for Morris but despite being compact for a 4 voice (based on the trad Paolo mould) many would find it a handful.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: IanD on September 03, 2013, 10:33:59 PM
I had a a black pearl II and although it was a lovely box, I found it far less than projecting compared to the Hohner pair, in fact if anything it was on the muffled side - the older Window Celebration-III in A/D I have is a lot clearer and has more tremelo but is still "Civilised" compared to an Erica or Pokerwork  ..

I really like my late 80s D/G Baffetti Irish-1 LMMM, (Native D/G too not a re-tuned C#/D or anything) for Morris but despite being compact for a 4 voice (based on the trad Paolo mould) many would find it a handful.

Like I said earlier, I think there's a big step-up in "morris quality" between the Black Pearl/Carnival II and the Baffetti Binci which more than justifies the cost difference -- soundwise I'd prefer an Erica to the cheaper Baffettis (which are better built and nicer to play), but IMHO both are better morris boxes than most of the more expensive continental ones.

I'd still say that for a cheaper morris box the Erica is the best, and that the Baffetti Binci is better assuming you can afford one. YMMV...
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: george garside on September 03, 2013, 11:14:16 PM
having read right through this thread I can only think that some must be very well off to be able to afford to use various assorted ''costaloties'' for the rough and tumble of morris in varying weather conditions and within and without of assorted pubs full of  morris persons in various states of beer swilling!

Hohner pokerworks were at one time more or less the standard box for morris and  the dancers never complained about the volume, tone, 'carrying power' or whatever of the music so why do they now appear , going from  comments on this thread, to need  aforementioned assorted costaloties?

For me the best Morris box is and will remain  a cheap secondhand pokerwork  , and yes, I  do have a couple of ''costafairlylotties'' so am in no way biased against them - but have no wish to bring about their  premature demise!


george >:E ;)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: pikey on September 03, 2013, 11:18:33 PM
Seconded !
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 04, 2013, 09:42:59 AM
having read right through this thread I can only think that some must be very well off to be able to afford to use various assorted ''costaloties'' for the rough and tumble of morris in varying weather conditions and within and without of assorted pubs full of  morris persons in various states of beer swilling!

Hohner pokerworks were at one time more or less the standard box for morris and  the dancers never complained about the volume, tone, 'carrying power' or whatever of the music so why do they now appear , going from  comments on this thread, to need  aforementioned assorted costaloties?

For me the best Morris box is and will remain  a cheap secondhand pokerwork  , and yes, I  do have a couple of ''costafairlylotties'' so am in no way biased against them - but have no wish to bring about their  premature demise!
It also depends on how strictly the title of this thread is interpreted. I'm not inviting a debate on how 'Morris' is defined, but let's suppose that we take it to mean 'what is the best melodeon for playing for traditional dance outdoors'.

I play for Ouse Washes Molly Dancers. We have five musicians who play melodeon (although we are rarely all there altogether at any one spot). Of those five, four of us play Castagnari melodeons (Handry, Hascy, Laura, Studio) and one plays a Saltarelle (Nuage). For our dances it is the quality and the variations of the sound we produce which is important. It's not just about volume or carrying power, although we have that too.

Many of the Ouse Washes dances are theatrical - they tell a story, sometimes very sinister. The variety of tonal range which our instruments have allow us to change the sound from bright to dark, loud to soft, as required. Our music is an integral part of the performance, not just some accompanying noise. We could not achieve the effects we want just using Pokerworks.

Yes - our instruments cost more than Pokerworks and although we take care of them, it doesn't mean we get paranoid about them. If there is a light drizzle we will take advantage of strategically held umbrellas, but heavy rain will rule out a performance from the dancers as well as the musicians. After we've played, the instruments go back in their cases and this means that they are pretty much protected from beer-swilers in the pub. This is basic, common-sense, care and attention. Anyone who perpetually carries their instrument around unprotected, dangling by a strap from their shoulder, is asking for trouble.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: george garside on September 04, 2013, 12:43:47 PM
   

  For our dances it is the quality and the variations of the sound we produce which is important. It's not just about volume or carrying power, although we have that too.

Many of the Ouse Washes dances are theatrical - they tell a story, sometimes very sinister. The variety of tonal range which our instruments have allow us to change the sound from bright to dark, loud to soft, as required. 

Tony Hall seems to do quite nicely in this respect with the humble pokerwork(s)

george
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: ladydetemps on September 04, 2013, 03:54:27 PM
Who's this Morris chap anyway? ;)  >:E
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 04, 2013, 04:11:36 PM
For our dances it is the quality and the variations of the sound we produce which is important. It's not just about volume or carrying power, although we have that too.

Many of the Ouse Washes dances are theatrical - they tell a story, sometimes very sinister. The variety of tonal range which our instruments have allow us to change the sound from bright to dark, loud to soft, as required. 

Tony Hall seems to do quite nicely in this respect with the humble pokerwork(s)
Maybe so, and make no mistake, I think Tony's playing is superb. But as far as I'm aware I don't think he plays for Morris or other outdoor dance.

P.S. I've sorted your quotes out for you, George  ;)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: David J on September 12, 2013, 02:26:17 PM
Well, having read this thread I would have to concur 100% with Ian Dedic - probably because I have a Dedic tuned Baffetti Binci - but from my perspective it ticks all the boxes for morris playing. It's loud, dynamic and lightweight, so it's absolutely no problem to play and carry around all day at a festival. If you can afford one of course.

I also use a Pokerwork, which according to some of the dancers in my side sounds louder, so I think wetter tuning certainly has a perceived difference. The basses do not project half as well though, and as regards playing quality there is no contest. It's slower, clunkier and even though I wear a padded sports wrist band, the thin bass end strap and the sharp corner leave aches and pains after a whole day (I know, I'm not manly enough etc). Don't get me wrong, I love the Hohner sound, and if I was playing for a Cotswold side I might use it more, probably in a vain attempt to sound more like John K . . .
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Anahata on September 12, 2013, 07:18:12 PM
I also use a Pokerwork, which according to some of the dancers in my side sounds louder, so I think wetter tuning certainly has a perceived difference. The basses do not project half as well though

Funny thing about basses - the Pokerwork has some quite low reeds on the bass, but deep != loud and the low notes simply don't carry. The DB Binci has basses with much more sound at higher pitches (three reeds vs. the Pokerwork's two, and the extra one's an octave higher) and that's what you actually hear at a distance. Ian's Oakwood also has three reeds on the basses, and that contributes a lot to its overall loudness and carrying power.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: IanD on September 12, 2013, 10:59:19 PM
I also use a Pokerwork, which according to some of the dancers in my side sounds louder, so I think wetter tuning certainly has a perceived difference. The basses do not project half as well though

Funny thing about basses - the Pokerwork has some quite low reeds on the bass, but deep != loud and the low notes simply don't carry. The DB Binci has basses with much more sound at higher pitches (three reeds vs. the Pokerwork's two, and the extra one's an octave higher) and that's what you actually hear at a distance. Ian's Oakwood also has three reeds on the basses, and that contributes a lot to its overall loudness and carrying power.
Indeed it does, that was one of the design changes I got Martyn to do when he made it (along with bigger bass reed blocks) to improve the weak bass end of the Oakwoods he'd made up to then. Three reeds on the bass notes as well as the chords also equalises the volume and tone a bit better between the bass and the chord which I think sounds better.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Helena Handcart on September 12, 2013, 11:29:20 PM
I have a Dedic tuned Baffetti Binci

A very lovely thing it is too...

I also use a Pokerwork ... and even though I wear a padded sports wrist band, the thin bass end strap and the sharp corner leave aches and pains after a whole day (I know, I'm not manly enough etc).

I wear a leather wrist strap and have never had a problem. I do hope this does not mean I'm more manly than you?  (:)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on September 13, 2013, 12:43:33 AM
 Rusticated Chanson for me gang.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Ollie on September 13, 2013, 12:50:04 AM
What hasn't been mentioned (and apologies if this opens a can of worms) is how one plays. You could have a Baffetti Binci, but unless you play with a degree of force, you still won't be heard at the other end of the set. I've seen too many Morris players who play as if they're playing at home trying not to annoy the neighbours...
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on September 13, 2013, 01:17:03 AM
On a serious note you are so right Ollie
But for outdoors Morris you do need a box with some wellie
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: David J on September 13, 2013, 01:28:47 PM
I also use a Pokerwork ... and even though I wear a padded sports wrist band, the thin bass end strap and the sharp corner leave aches and pains after a whole day (I know, I'm not manly enough etc).

I wear a leather wrist strap and have never had a problem. I do hope this does not mean I'm more manly than you?  (:)

[/quote]

Cheek. I did rather set myself up for that though....
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: IanD on September 13, 2013, 02:39:43 PM
What hasn't been mentioned (and apologies if this opens a can of worms) is how one plays. You could have a Baffetti Binci, but unless you play with a degree of force, you still won't be heard at the other end of the set. I've seen too many Morris players who play as if they're playing at home trying not to annoy the neighbours...
If you're not sweating like the dancers after a hard set outdoors you're not playing hard enough...  >:E
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Helena Handcart on September 13, 2013, 02:58:21 PM
I also use a Pokerwork ... and even though I wear a padded sports wrist band, the thin bass end strap and the sharp corner leave aches and pains after a whole day (I know, I'm not manly enough etc).

I wear a leather wrist strap and have never had a problem. I do hope this does not mean I'm more manly than you?  (:)


Cheek. I did rather set myself up for that though....

Hmm... actually I was alluding to my own singular lack of feminine grace  (:)  :|glug

Back on topic, while I don't think the melnet collective will ever reach a consensus on what is the best melodeon for morris, I'm pretty sure that comfort when playing for extended periods is something we would all hope for in our ideal morris box.  A waterproof one would be nice too....

Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Adam-T on September 13, 2013, 02:59:50 PM
I spoke to Morris - He bought an Erica ..........................  ;D
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Steve C. on September 13, 2013, 10:04:08 PM
Morris + Erica =  :|bl
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: pikey on September 14, 2013, 08:09:03 AM
I also use a Pokerwork ... and even though I wear a padded sports wrist band, the thin bass end strap and the sharp corner leave aches and pains after a whole day (I know, I'm not manly enough etc).

I wear a leather wrist strap and have never had a problem. I do hope this does not mean I'm more manly than you?  (:)


Cheek. I did rather set myself up for that though....
[/quote]

So do I, and it has a dent to demonstrate 37 years of hard labour!

I agree with Ollie, there are too many Morris players who seem to be afraid of their box, and tickle it gently like a vestal virgin on a harp.

Give it WELLIE !!!!!

 >:E
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: pikey on September 14, 2013, 08:11:06 AM
What hasn't been mentioned (and apologies if this opens a can of worms) is how one plays. You could have a Baffetti Binci, but unless you play with a degree of force, you still won't be heard at the other end of the set. I've seen too many Morris players who play as if they're playing at home trying not to annoy the neighbours...
If you're not sweating like the dancers after a hard set outdoors you're not playing hard enough...  >:E

Like !!
Does that account for the characteristic odour ?  >:E
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: george garside on September 14, 2013, 10:08:13 AM
I never play '''with force''  and using a humble pokerwork never had any complaints about not being heard by Morris dancers and that included some occasions when I was playing solo.   Same goes for rapper for which I always played solo .   I did however make sure me (and band if present) stood  upwind of the dancers  and not too far away!  On one occasion when I was unable to play and the only other available musician was a whistlist .He played right up to and almost amongst the dancers and it worked  fine.

To me playing ''with force'' has a heavy cost in terms of loss of musicality

george >:E ;)

Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 14, 2013, 02:42:55 PM
I also like to play upwind of the dancers...for various reasons.  >:E

I disagree, though, with those who advocate 'giving it welly'. Like George, I think there is a cost in terms of loss of musicality, but, more importantly, playing hard loses the ability to emphasize certain notes because all the notes are played equally loudly. Placing emphasis on certain notes helps to provide 'lift' and the light and shade you put into your playing helps the dancers interpret the dance, both of which are more important than sheer loudness.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: george garside on September 14, 2013, 04:03:10 PM
Ive never really understood why probably the majority of Morris players play all the time on full volume .  The ideal is to do the bulk of it at about half throttle so that as Bob says you can go louder or SOFTER  at any time and put some character into a tune.  Its just a question of treating a melodeon as a musial instrument!


george >:E ;)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 14, 2013, 04:51:30 PM
The trouble is there are times when you do need wellie.
Having danced several professionals this year,  somehow always behind a loud band I've lost the tunes in my head. Our 2 main box players do play strongly, and upped it for these events but still got lost in the mush of other massed bands.
There are times when even a Pokerwork and DB Oakwood special played hard still can't be heard...... And at those times nothing could be heard unless something was amplified ( shudder )
Q
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: george garside on September 14, 2013, 06:16:01 PM
The trouble is there are times when you do need wellie.
 
There are times when even a Pokerwork and DB Oakwood special played hard still can't be heard...... And at those times nothing could be heard unless something was amplified ( shudder )
Q

in those cirumstances  by playing hard is  futile

george
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Steve C. on September 14, 2013, 06:16:56 PM
Trupenny--

This is when I would take out the dreaded chiff and fipple.  >:E
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 14, 2013, 06:43:00 PM
George: whilst I agree with your sentiment, if you're expected to take part in a procession then you have to make the best of it. By necessity you can't always lag behind to create a musical break as the procession organisers expect it to be kept together.
It ain't easy!
As Steve says, it's when our whistle player comes into her own, and out trombone player also has a valuable role keeping the beat.
Q
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: george garside on September 14, 2013, 07:55:22 PM
and a decent drum can help!

george
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Walkingoaktree on September 14, 2013, 08:21:37 PM
I have played for Morris for over 20 years and tried quite a few box's. The best all rounder still has to be the Honher pokerwork for sheer endurance and projection. I have a Catagniari Nik that I find nice for Cotswold indoors and a Tomy that suits Border (with the stop out) But for price, power and playability the pokerwork takes some beating. P.S. Mine is an original made in Germany. I wouldn't swear to the Chinese made ones:I have heard some negative comments about them but have no personal experience.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 14, 2013, 10:28:59 PM
Welcome, Walkingoaktree. I don't know whether you have just joined or having been lurking in the background for a while, but welcome either way.

Your point about Chinese boxes is well made (but they don't appear to be).

There are,of course, other boxes that work well for morris, but none other than the German made Hohners that are anywhere near the original poster's price bracket.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Lester on September 14, 2013, 10:35:01 PM
From my experience of Chinese Hohners that have come through my workshop the early ones did suffer from some quality control issues, mostly broken bass springs, but the later ones seem fine with two exceptions; 1) the bellows tape seems to be made of bog paper, 2) the tuning/set up is only up to Hohner's normal lack of standard. So don't be put off by the fact a Hohner is Chinese as it only needs a visit to your fettler of choice to make it very playable. It is almost certain that any second hand  German Hohner will also need some tender loving care as well.

Mind you I play a Swiss made Erica and it is practically perfect in every way  ;)
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: IanD on September 15, 2013, 10:34:23 PM
I also like to play upwind of the dancers...for various reasons.  >:E

I disagree, though, with those who advocate 'giving it welly'. Like George, I think there is a cost in terms of loss of musicality, but, more importantly, playing hard loses the ability to emphasize certain notes because all the notes are played equally loudly. Placing emphasis on certain notes helps to provide 'lift' and the light and shade you put into your playing helps the dancers interpret the dance, both of which are more important than sheer loudness.

Just because you're playing loudly overall (which I certainly do outdoors) in no way means you have to not have dynamics and play all the notes at the same volume (which I certainly don't!). You still need to leave enough in reserve to punch in louder notes where the emphasis of the dance required them. If you don't, that's just poor musicianship.

Nobody's ever told me that my playing doesn't lift the dancers, in fact exactly the opposite, it's the guiding principle of what I do. One of Rumworth did say to me this afternoon, "Bloody hell, that box of yours is loud!" -- but he also said it sounded fantastic to dance to...
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 15, 2013, 11:53:26 PM
Just because you're playing loudly overall (which I certainly do outdoors) in no way means you have to not have dynamics and play all the notes at the same volume (which I certainly don't!). You still need to leave enough in reserve to punch in louder notes where the emphasis of the dance required them. If you don't, that's just poor musicianship.

Nobody's ever told me that my playing doesn't lift the dancers, in fact exactly the opposite, it's the guiding principle of what I do. One of Rumworth did say to me this afternoon, "Bloody hell, that box of yours is loud!" -- but he also said it sounded fantastic to dance to...

I couldn't agree more, Ian. Your playing is loud and lifts the dancers, because the loudness does not impede you from introducing light and shade into your playing. My point was that some musicians play for morris as though loudness was the only thing that matters. Of course, one must play loud enough to be heard clearly, but I was trying to say that good morris musicianship requires more than that, as you demonstrate so well in your playing.
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: IanD on September 16, 2013, 01:53:19 PM
Just because you're playing loudly overall (which I certainly do outdoors) in no way means you have to not have dynamics and play all the notes at the same volume (which I certainly don't!). You still need to leave enough in reserve to punch in louder notes where the emphasis of the dance required them. If you don't, that's just poor musicianship.

Nobody's ever told me that my playing doesn't lift the dancers, in fact exactly the opposite, it's the guiding principle of what I do. One of Rumworth did say to me this afternoon, "Bloody hell, that box of yours is loud!" -- but he also said it sounded fantastic to dance to...

I couldn't agree more, Ian. Your playing is loud and lifts the dancers, because the loudness does not impede you from introducing light and shade into your playing. My point was that some musicians play for morris as though loudness was the only thing that matters. Of course, one must play loud enough to be heard clearly, but I was trying to say that good morris musicianship requires more than that, as you demonstrate so well in your playing.

Thanks, the cheque's in the post :-)

What some people don't realise is that it actually *sounds* louder (easier to hear and follow in a noisy environment) if you have gaps between the notes, louder and quiter notes (dynamics!), basses with pauses in to emphasize the stepping -- the average volume measured with an SPL meter may be lower than thrashing the box flat out all the time, but it's easier for the dancers to hear and follow because your ear responds best to time-varying sounds, Also your arm hurts less and the reeds last longer...
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Owen Woods on September 16, 2013, 03:31:29 PM
All very true!
Title: Re: What is the best Melodeon for Morris?
Post by: Anahata on September 16, 2013, 04:19:15 PM
What some people don't realise is that it actually *sounds* louder (easier to hear and follow in a noisy environment) if you have gaps between the notes, louder and quieter notes (dynamics!), basses with pauses in to emphasize the stepping -- the average volume measured with an SPL meter may be lower than thrashing the box flat out all the time, but it's easier for the dancers to hear and follow because your ear responds best to time-varying sounds

Yes, for morris you're competing with the dynamics of a drum!
(as in pipe and tabor, still the best thing to dance to when played well)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal