Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Nick Hudis on January 28, 2009, 06:06:41 PM
-
I recently played my little Hohner Liliput to my mother who is 83. She immediately recognized the instrument and came up with an interesting story.
Just after the war in the late 40's she went on a walking holiday in the Swiss and Italian alps guided by a former member of the French Resistence. Apparantly whenever they met German hikers in chalets and inns, the German's produced little accordions out of their rucksacks just like the Liliput and played and sang. Given that at that time in history Germans were not the most popular people in Europe, these little accordions did a lot to break down ill will and establish friendship between people who only a year or two before had been killing each other.
Now that's a nice thing to know about melodeons.
-
Yes, it's good to know how melodeons can bring people together. Last year I took one of my boxes to Pakistan in my backpack. While I was staying in a rural area I met a builder who played a harmonium. We sat around one evening on the building site with some of his workmates taking it in turn to play. He sang and played Punjabi love songs. I belted out some Cotswold morris, etc., across the rice fields. Neither of us understood much of the other's language, but the reeds did the talking. It was a great evening. There was one bizarre thing, though, that I still haven't puzzled out. I make plenty of mistakes when I'm playing (being a relative newcomer to squeezeboxes), but my mistakes that evening often got applauded. Were people just being sympathetic? Or did they think my discords with accidental changes in tempo were clever improvisations?
-
I find this topic very interesting - and I would guess that there's a book in it somewhere. The close connection with The Salvation Army and the concertina is well documented, but not so with the Melodeon, which is a shame. I've a number of pics in my collection which prove my point - but I attach one of my favourite:
A bunch of Hallelujah Lasses taken at the turn of the century (around 1911 apparently). Note the melodeon right in centre of the photo.
AL
-
Just a side point...
Stories about melodeon history, particularly those relating to specific instruments, would be well suited for inclusion into the Melodeon Database (http://wiki.melodeon.net/wiki/Main_page (http://wiki.melodeon.net/wiki/Main_page)) on this site. Rather than get lost in a mass of forum posts, 'Database' entries should be much easier for others to find and discover.
Although the instrument pages have a formal structure at the top, any relevant information can be added below, including stories, historical photos and other items of interest. Also, if you have a lot of additional stuff - say, a long story - there's no harm in including that in an additional page and linking to it. If you're not sure, ask me or one of the administrators how to achieve what you've got in mind.
Lastly, if you have any other, more general, ideas about how the database might usefully store historic reference information, please let us know.
Guy
-
Not to detract from the usefulness of the database, but the forum is very searchable. That's how I originally found it. Anyone using Google to search for melodeons and related topics like repair, construction, history, and general rag chewing would be hard pressed to do even a "bad" search and not have Google return a link to the exact post. It would take an administrator to verify this, but I think that's where we get the referrals for all those one-off "how much is grand dad's box worth?" posts in the buy/sell forum.
-
I recently played my little Hohner Liliput to my mother who is 83. She immediately recognized the instrument and came up with an interesting story.
Just after the war in the late 40's she went on a walking holiday in the Swiss and Italian alps guided by a former member of the French Resistence. Apparantly whenever they met German hikers in chalets and inns, the German's produced little accordions out of their rucksacks just like the Liliput and played and sang. Given that at that time in history Germans were not the most popular people in Europe, these little accordions did a lot to break down ill will and establish friendship between people who only a year or two before had been killing each other.
Now that's a nice thing to know about melodeons.
For those who might not know, the Liliput and the Preciosa were both made specifically for this market -- the Preciosa in particular is an object lesson in how to get the largest possible amount of melodeon into the smallest possible space, with little touches like the internal bellows lock that means there are no bellows straps to come undone if the instrument is packed into a tight corner.
Which begs the question -- if they were so popular and useful why did Hohner stop making them? Maybe they cost too much to make compared to bigger boxes with much simpler construction, and cost was all-important after the war...
Ian
-
The innardsof the Liliput are quite complex so was it a money saving measure in production?
I love 'em, I've got a favourite in Eb/Bb
-
The innardsof the Liliput are quite complex so was it a money saving measure in production?
I love 'em, I've got a favourite in Eb/Bb
Probably, this was my guess -- the Preciosa is even more ingenious (read: even harder to build)...
Still, it's a pity there's no real modern equivalent :-(
Ian
-
Could somebody upload a photo of these little instruments, I'm intrigued by anything small like this.
-
Could somebody upload a photo of these little instruments, I'm intrigued by anything small like this.
Here you are, one of the outside and one of the inside -- for scale, it's about 20cm tall...
Ian
-
The inside of the Hohner 48 key concertina I bought some 30 years ago has also two layers of reed blocks at each side.
-
The inside of the Hohner 48 key concertina I bought some 30 years ago has also two layers of reed blocks at each side.
This construction does pack a lot of flat-mounted reeds into a small space -- and I'm sure Theo can tell us (no swearing, please :-) just how easy this makes them to tune...
Ian
-
In response to the comment left above, yes, this site does have a useful search facility and I wouldn't want to undermine its usefullness. However, the Database offers the potential to bring together information in a way that Search can never do. It's a communal resource that will only achieve success if people are prepared to contribute their own knowledge. As it stands, we now have a whole load of forum posts about the Lilliput and Preciosa, yet on the Database neither are present. If you want to build a cool reference resource, you know what to do...
-
In response to the comment left above, yes, this site does have a useful search facility and I wouldn't want to undermine its usefullness.
I wasn't referring to this site's search facility. I was referring to how easy it is to find the information on the site using other search engines. Had nothing to do with the database, but in that regard it makes the database almost redundant - although it could be useful to have it all organized in one place.
What's with the italics?
-
In response to the comment left above, yes, this site does have a useful search facility and I wouldn't want to undermine its usefullness.
I wasn't referring to this site's search facility. I was referring to how easy it is to find the information on the site using other search engines. Had nothing to do with the database, but in that regard it makes the database almost redundant - although it could be useful to have it all organized in one place.
What's with the italics?
OK then, have a look at these sample reports http://wiki.melodeon.net/wiki/Sandbox (http://wiki.melodeon.net/wiki/Sandbox). Yes, these are dynamic queries* that will update themselves as people enter new information at source. You can't do that with a standard search engine - keyword recognition will only take you so far. The Database has its key information annotated so that it's meaningful to computers as well as humans. Thus, we can achieve reports and queries that would otherwise be impossible with regular web technology. As more information is added, the impact of this will grow.
Also, the ability for people to add their own thoughts and content to pages could eventually lead to a resource that extends far beyond the mere factual listings found on manufactuer's sites. It's just down to users to buy into the possibilities...
The italics were an attempt to avoid branching from this thread's true purpose. I seem to have failed...
Guy
* Anyone can create custom reports like this, or, if they're unsure about how to go about it, request that an administrator do it.
-
I was referring to how easy it is to find the information on the site using other search engines. Had nothing to do with the database, but in that regard it makes the database almost redundant - although it could be useful to have it all organized in one place.
What's with the italics?
I'm so surprised by Finnhorse. :o The database came about because it is almost impossible to find any particular information about specific instruments you may have seen on the Forum earlier. As a forum for people interested in Melodeons the database is designed to grow into a definitive reference source. It can only do that if members are willing to input the information. It is simple enough, if you are making a post ,just to copy the releveant information and drop it in the database. Try it, you may like it, after all you wouldn't want to be thought of as a Luddite would you ? :D
-
... As it stands, we now have a whole load of forum posts about the Lilliput and Preciosa, yet on the Database neither are present. If you want to build a cool reference resource, you know what to do...
We do now, based on the information in the Hohner history document. More info would be nice...
-
In response to the comment left above, yes, this site does have a useful search facility and I wouldn't want to undermine its usefullness.
I wasn't referring to this site's search facility. I was referring to how easy it is to find the information on the site using other search engines. Had nothing to do with the database, but in that regard it makes the database almost redundant - although it could be useful to have it all organized in one place.
What's with the italics?
OK then, have a look at these sample reports http://wiki.melodeon.net/wiki/Sandbox (http://wiki.melodeon.net/wiki/Sandbox). Yes, these are dynamic queries* that will update themselves as people enter new information at source. You can't do that with a standard search engine - keyword recognition will only take you so far. The Database has its key information annotated so that it's meaningful to computers as well as humans. Thus, we can achieve reports and queries that would otherwise be impossible with regular web technology. As more information is added, the impact of this will grow.
Also, the ability for people to add their own thoughts and content to pages could eventually lead to a resource that extends far beyond the mere factual listings found on manufactuer's sites. It's just down to users to buy into the possibilities...
The italics were an attempt to avoid branching from this thread's true purpose. I seem to have failed...
Guy
* Anyone can create custom reports like this, or, if they're unsure about how to go about it, request that an administrator do it.
Drifting a little farther from the OP, does having key information annotated (read: meaningful to computers) make the database easier to find with an external search engine, or only more easily searchable while on the site? Because I was specifically referring to the ability of melodeon lamers (such as myself) to find the site/information they need if they weren't aware the site existed to be searched in the first place - hence the point of the original search, and why it's good that engines like Google bring you here (mel.net). That was what prompted my original reply (OR :)?).
(this post EDITED to correct a Misplaced Modifier of Mass Destruction)
-
Finding information we don't know exists...
Sounds suspiciously like Donald Rundsfelts "unknown unknowns" ;)
-
Drifting a little farther from the OP, does having key information annotated (read: meaningful to computers) make the database easier to find with an external search engine, or only more easily searchable while on the site? Because I was specifically referring to the ability of melodeon lamers (such as myself) to find the site/information they need if they weren't aware it existed. That was what prompted my original reply (OR :)).
Hmm, there's probably no straightforward answer to that at the moment. The Database uses Mediawiki as its core engine, the same system that powers Wikipedia. Thus, given the Wikipedia entries get found by search engines, you'd expect others to be found too. The additional functionality that allows data to be 'marked up' as having meaning comes from an extra bit of software called Semantic Mediawiki (SMW). This software is one aspect of a phenomenon known as the 'semantic web' (and sometimes as 'Web 3.0') - supposedly the next major shift in internet use. At the moment, this is still niche technology, so mainstream support for it is thin and non-standard. As such, our marked-up data is unlikely, at the moment, to be useful outside of the Database itself. But in the future, even the near future, who knows? What I do know, though, is that if the raw data isn't there at all, nothing will happen.
Although this all sounds a bit techy, the reality is that SMW allows us to create a system where the involved stuff is hidden from regular users. So far, it seems that contributors new to the system have been managing to add information in the right place without the need for much assistance. Creating custom reports, though, does require a bit more knowledge, although it's not exactly 'rocket science'. We'll have to work out, over time, the options for making that more accessible. In the meantime, if you want something specific, just ask.
Guy
-
Could somebody upload a photo of these little instruments, I'm intrigued by anything small like this.
Here you are, one of the outside and one of the inside -- for scale, it's about 20cm tall...
Ian
Did Hohner use the same reeds in the lilliput and the preciosa? Weren't they manufactured around the same time?
-
Could somebody upload a photo of these little instruments, I'm intrigued by anything small like this.
Here you are, one of the outside and one of the inside -- for scale, it's about 20cm tall...
Ian
Did Hohner use the same reeds in the lilliput and the preciosa? Weren't they manufactured around the same time?
I believe the reeds are the same, I'm sure Theo can confirm this. In the Liliput they're conventionally mounted in reed blocks which means the box has to be bigger (taller) than the Preciosa where they're flat-mounted -- as you can see from the internal photo the reeds (which have narrower frames than normal) are packed together with almost no gaps and totally fill the end of the box, you couldn't make it any smaller if you tried.
Ian
-
.....Just after the war in the late 40's she went on a walking holiday in the Swiss and Italian alps guided by a former member of the French Resistance. Apparently whenever they met German hikers in chalets and inns, the German's produced little accordions out of their rucksacks just like the Lilliput and played and sang.....
Just to return briefly to the original posting - wasn't there something involving the Youth Movement in Nazi Germany promoting the playing of accordions (in particular the Student 1) and melodeons like the Lilliput? If so, maybe this is where some of them learned to play as youths. There's a huge mural on the end wall of the former Nazi Air Ministry building in Berlin (which came under western control during cold war days) which shows farm workers parading triumphantly from the fields being led by two piano accordionists and a button accordion player.
Mike
-
I'm so surprised by Finnhorse. :o The database came about because it is almost impossible to find any particular information about specific instruments you may have seen on the Forum earlier. As a forum for people interested in Melodeons the database is designed to grow into a definitive reference source. It can only do that if members are willing to input the information. It is simple enough, if you are making a post ,just to copy the releveant information and drop it in the database. Try it, you may like it, after all you wouldn't want to be thought of as a Luddite would you ? :D
OK. Suppose I wanted to help with the database. Does my regular log in for melnet work, or do I need to create a new account? Are there some tips about what sorts of things we should add? For example, my Castagnari is a Roma, but it looks quite different to the one in the picture; should I upload another photo for you?
I am entirely content in principle to put my melodeons on there, I just am not very sure about what you're after.
-
I recently played my little Hohner Liliput to my mother who is 83. She immediately recognized the instrument and came up with an interesting story.
Just after the war in the late 40's she went on a walking holiday in the Swiss and Italian alps guided by a former member of the French Resistence. Apparantly whenever they met German hikers in chalets and inns, the German's produced little accordions out of their rucksacks just like the Liliput and played and sang. Given that at that time in history Germans were not the most popular people in Europe, these little accordions did a lot to break down ill will and establish friendship between people who only a year or two before had been killing each other.
Now that's a nice thing to know about melodeons.
My Liliput is one of the late red pearloid ones, and when I bought it the person I bought it off said that they were intended for Nazi soldiers to carry around in their rucksacks. I work on the principle that it is completely rehabilitated now; and my plan is to carry it around in my rucksack at folk festivals all summer long, and probably to take it off on holiday with me as well in my hand luggage.
-
OK. Suppose I wanted to help with the database. Does my regular log in for melnet work, or do I need to create a new account? Are there some tips about what sorts of things we should add? For example, my Castagnari is a Roma, but it looks quite different to the one in the picture; should I upload another photo for you?
I am entirely content in principle to put my melodeons on there, I just am not very sure about what you're after.
Hi Alison
We spoke about your Roma and I'm sure it would be a great addition to the database. Here's the page. In order to stop malicious entries from outsiders you press the "Instrument Database Team" tag and just add your details and one of the wizards will give the magic ring to gain entry. I'm supposed to able to do it for you but I'm still an apprentice. Once ordained you can add whatever content you wish.
Thanks for your support.
Martin
-
My Liliput is one of the late red pearloid ones, and when I bought it the person I bought it off said that they were intended for Nazi soldiers to carry around in their rucksacks. I work on the principle that it is completely rehabilitated now; and my plan is to carry it around in my rucksack at folk festivals all summer long, and probably to take it off on holiday with me as well in my hand luggage.
I'm not sure about the social history of the Preciosa, but I'm pretty sure that the Liliput was originally designed as a children's instrument. The light weight, smaller buttons, and generally reduced size were, I think, designed to make the thing an entry-level instrument for kids joining club clubs. The teaching materials that I've seen labeled "Liliput" usually feature cartoonish pictures of small, plump children frisking around with bunnies, lambs, and butterflies. The tunes tend to reflect this marketing slant ("Woodland Flowers", "Fairy Glade" etc). Mine arrived from its original owner very lightly used, as he'd be given it as a lad, and had never taken to it. Theo has suggested to me that Castagnari's decision to name their "children's" box the Lily is a nod to the designers of the Liliput.
I think the Liluput's repurposing as the Wehrmacht's melodeon of choice was incidental. What I find interesting is that these little boxes are so extraordinarily popular. Many of them have, I suspect, been through three totally different sets of hands by now: the original young owners, the WWII German soldiers, and now, lovingly restored, Melodeon enthusiasts in search of a portable instrument. Maybe only a few thousand were made, but what a successful design! How many other box designs have been so frequently used for such diverse purposes?
-
OK. Suppose I wanted to help with the database. Does my regular log in for melnet work, or do I need to create a new account? Are there some tips about what sorts of things we should add? For example, my Castagnari is a Roma, but it looks quite different to the one in the picture; should I upload another photo for you?
I am entirely content in principle to put my melodeons on there, I just am not very sure about what you're after.
We've set the Database up so it's very easy to enter the basic, common information about a given instrument. You just use 'Add a melodeon' or, if the instrument exists, just 'Edit' to open the form so that you can fill in the details. Via the same form, we've also made it so that it's easy to upload one standard photo, which will be displayed at the top of the page.
If you want to add more photos to a page, that's great - but you need to do it slightly differently. Once you've signed up and logged in (pm me if you're still unsure about this...), you can use the Upload File link in the bottom left-hand corner to load as many photos as you like. Once loaded, you just add a 'double square brackets' link to each photo from the page that you would like to see it on. Rather than try and guess at what this means, I've just added some more photos to the Giordy page, to demonstrate how it's done - see http://wiki.melodeon.net/wiki/Castagnari_Giordy (http://wiki.melodeon.net/wiki/Castagnari_Giordy). Also, feel free to add any history, background stories, reviews or anything else you think is relevant. See the Morgane page - http://wiki.melodeon.net/wiki/Hohner_Morgane (http://wiki.melodeon.net/wiki/Hohner_Morgane) - as another example of what can be done.
If you try it and it doesn't work out as you're expecting, just send one of us a message and we'll sort it out for you.
Guy
-
Thanks so much for the photos Ian.
I think they're wonderful little instruments. What would one call the layout (I'm a novice), is it like a little club?
Do these ever come up for sale, or are they much coveted by their owners? what would one pay if available?
Thanks again Hopey
-
Thanks so much for the photos Ian.
I think they're wonderful little instruments. What would one call the layout (I'm a novice), is it like a little club?
Do these ever come up for sale, or are they much coveted by their owners? what would one pay if available?
Thanks again Hopey
As built they're exactly like a 25-button club, most commonly in C/F. They come up quite often on Ebay in Germany, less often in other European countries, even less often here. Quite a lot of the ones in the UK have been restored, converted to D/G and de-clubbed, often by Theo.
An decent unrestored C/F is around £200 in Germany, restoring and converting the keys costs at least double that so you're looking at £600 or more for a nice rebuilt D/G one. Once most people have one like this I think they're reluctant to let go...
Cheers
Ian
-
I've bought and sold quite a few whilst looking for the dream boxes for myself. Keep an eye on German eBay.
They are superb little things.
I got my first one on a climbing holiday in the Dolomites in the early 60s from a junk shop in Cortina , as I said earlier I love the Eb/Bb model
They are 'Club' tuned and some people have C/F boxes retuned to D/G - Pity I think but everyone to their own goat! Chaque un a son gout?
Mike
-
As built they're exactly like a 25-button club, most commonly in C/F. They come up quite often on Ebay in Germany, less often in other European countries, even less often here. Quite a lot of the ones in the UK have been restored, converted to D/G and de-clubbed, often by Theo.
An decent unrestored C/F is around £200 in Germany, restoring and converting the keys costs at least double that so you're looking at £600 or more for a nice rebuilt D/G one. Once most people have one like this I think they're reluctant to let go...
Cheers
Ian
I'd echo that - I followed exactly that route - bought on German e-Bay - then shipped off to Theo. The result is a brilliant little box - great Hohner sound and tons of volume. You wouldn't think it was over 60 years old!
When you compare what you can buy new for the same money........
If you don't want to gamble on eBay Germany, then Pete Grassby normally has a small selection of Lilliputs and sometimes Preciosas just waiting for sale to a happy owner.
Andy
-
My Liliput is Bb/Eb which gives it a particularly mellow sound. I bought it on ebay from Mike Wild who is a regular here. Best £300 I ever spent. I've tried a Preciosa at Theo's but the Liliput is about as small as my long double jointed fingers can manage. I think the Liliput has a better sound too, more rounded and less brash. I doesn't go in my rucsac like those old German alpinists, but I wouldn't dream of going on holiday without it. Holidays usually involve cramming two people, one dog, a guitar, a harp, clothes, walking gear and a couple weeks of food and booze into a Nissan Micra. The Liliput is a real asset!
-
I face the same dilemma: I bought mine as a back-packable jolly-box, but I like it so much, I can't bring myself to abuse it.
-
Eagle Music do a small gig bag designed for a Casta Lilly which works well for a Lilliput. However it only has a single shoulder strap, rather than full backpack straps.
Definitely good 'holiday' boxes - small and light.
Andy
-
Mine came in a little suitcase with a handle and a keyed lock....but no key
-
The usual little brown fibre 'faux leather' box. But aren't they authentic?
-
I envy anyone with a Preciosa or Lilliput, so many tonal possibilities in a lightweight box, if they're as well built as the old Clubs they must be fine instruments indeed..aside from that [and I wish I could remember the link to this information...urban legend or fact?]..apparently the Nazi regime considered accordions to be a low-class "dumbing-down" of culture and wanted to shut down their production, and the Hohner company ,in order to survive responded by commissioning literate musicians to create arrangements of classical music written specifically for accordion, to show that the accordion was capable of "high" culture [where the humble one row would have figured I can only wonder...perhaps taking the viola part, depending on the key?] Melodeon players in tuxes surrounded by banks of melodeons and assistants standing by not to turn pages but to hand the players the appropriate melodeon as the music moved from one key to another?..and no foot tapping allowed...
-
The ironic thing is that after the war anything to do with 'das volk' meant the accordeons were put in attics and are only now coming out. that explains why 'Celtic' music was taken up with enthusiasm by young Germans. My Brother has lived in Germany since the 60s and explained all this to me.
-
and no foot tapping allowed...
yes, that did for your man Shand!
AL