Melodeon.net Forums
Forum and website admin => Wish lists => Topic started by: Theo on September 12, 2013, 08:32:22 PM
-
I'm considering introducing a daily limit on the number of messages a user can post to the forum.
Reasons for this are:
To encourage new members and infrequent posters to contribute. I've had a good number of private comments from people who feel a bit overawed by the sheer volume of posts from a few regular contributors and who therefore keep quiet. I don't think this is healthy.
To make regular posters pause for a few seconds (or more) to consider what readers will get from their comment.
To curtail "me too" posts
Comments welcome.
-
Yes please, I have almost stopped commenting except on my tune-a-say and repair issues due to the number of nil-content posts and some people banging on about their pet subjects.
-
To encourage new members and infrequent posters to contribute. I've had a good number of private comments from people who feel a bit overawed by the sheer volume of posts from a few regular contributors and who therefore keep quiet. I don't think this is healthy.
Surprised at that, but if that's what people are saying than it must be true, for some at least.
To make regular posters pause for a few seconds (or more) to consider what readers will get from their comment.
That does look sensible and gets straight to the heart of the matter.
-
Potsting sounds painful :o
A potential issue with limits is that, at least on the forum I moderate, you can get round it by deleting posts. It really doesn't matter on that one as it's ephemeral trivia, but a lot of melnet is more towards the reference material and threads lose their sense when posts are deleted.
I know it's effort etc and one hopes those deleted would be of the trivial variety, but it's a consideration in deciding where to set the bar.
-
To make regular posters pause for a few seconds (or more) to consider what readers will get from their comment.
That does look sensible and gets straight to the heart of the matter.
Another way this could be implemented is to introduce a time limit between posts from one member, rather than just a limit on the number of posts.
-
Another way this could be implemented is to introduce a time limit between posts from one member, rather than just a limit on the number of posts.
Not so good when you have a single short time window in the day to do all your melnetting.
Not me usually, but it does happen sometimes.
-
I think it would be a shame if it had to come to that. I'd like to think that a polite word to those in question, or announcement in general to all forum members would make people think. If some people then still don't get the message, maybe this would be a good idea, but we're (mostly) all adults, and I hope this issue can be resolved without such a drastic measure.
-
One of the nice things about Mel.net is that you can come back after 10 minutes and there will be new posts to read, its a nice active forum and I personally feel that this post limit would affect that and achieve little in terms of making new people post.
On top of that, the small posts of banter add to the sense of community on this forum. Stopping them from happening would harm that and also potentially lead to more dead threads.
-
Banter is all very well, but some people do seem to banter a bit too much, and it can get in the way of threads. Chris's recent thread on the melodeon heyday is a good example. Little jibes and 'banter' got so much that Chris felt the need to close the topic, because people weren't taking it seriously.
-
I can see the sense of this. I'm probably a culprit as am stuck at home and frankly a bit bored. Actually tried to look the recent numbers up on my "stats" yesterday, but it only gives things like average hour of day :-\
A few considered posts are well better than an exchange of one liners. If you do this I think a daily limit is the better idea. Some people have to do all their posts in a small time window for personal reasons
-
Seems a bit extreme...I'm only a newbie here but I like the liveliness and frivolity of the place. But...
if that's what people are saying than it must be true, for some at least
...I guess.
Hmm.
One of the nice things about Mel.net is that you can come back after 10 minutes and there will be new posts to read, its a nice active forum and I personally feel that this post limit would affect that and achieve little in terms of making new people post.
On top of that, the small posts of banter add to the sense of community on this forum. Stopping them from happening would harm that and also potentially lead to more dead threads.
Inclined to agree with that as well.
-
I haven't perceived a problem (maybe I am the problem? don't think so ... but ... ) but my experience with forums tells me this is a friendly, inviting forum with an extremely low level of cliquishness and off-putting behaviors. My experience with social gatherings (and mel.net is one of those) is that they always seem intimidating to some who wish to enter in. I would be against posting limits. But, of course, if that's what is decided, I will support Theo.
-
I agree with BJG, it sounds a bit extreme. Surely Theo, if someone was overdoing it a bit, a private word from you would be enough? There are many topics that I don't enjoy or am not interested in at all and I just don't read them. The !*%*^$ limericks(!) for example and the 'engineering' stuff - but hey, this is a site for all kinds of folk, not just me and surely we pick and choose what we want to read and what we want to join in with. I can imagine that some people would find it a bit clique at times, but I don't see it as a problem.
Melodeon.net is a fantastic, thriving community of musical folk who are always ready to help and advise each other. It is also full of fun and leg-pulling as well as the more serious stuff.
I also suspect that there are a few people on here who maybe live alone or spend long periods alone. If I am right, then the contact these people have with others, albeit electronic, is important. Forgive me if I am wrong, but maybe it is some of those who write more than others. Well, they might write too often but hell, they contribute a lot, have taught me a lot and as far as I'm concerned they are more than welcome here. So that's my two ha'pence!
-
For what its worth I think that the very existence of this thread, with its assorted views , will draw the matter to the attention of the few who may be over exuberent posters from time to time . This may well result a degree of 'moderation' ocuring on the ancient principle of '' if the cap fits'' etc
george ;)
-
As a member for some years, who posts much less than others, I am opposed to this. I perhaps am forgetting someone but of the constant posters that come to mind, I love them all, including their hobbyhorses. There are a few who have hobbyhorses for which I have a specific affection and when they post I think: "I hope he'll mention X"--I say "he" because I cannot remember any staunch hobbyhorse riders who are female. If I am forgetting some obsessive equestrienne I apologize.
-
Theo - sorry to learn you have had some complaints.
Nevertheless, I also feel that putting a daily, or a time limit on the number of posts would be a backward and somewhat negative step, for the reasons given by Ollie, Gary, Nfldbox and others too. I feel it would detract from the excellent community atmosphere of melnet; I too love all the types of posts we get here, both the technical and the trivial. If there are any threads I don't wish to follow, I simply don't read them.
This has to be one of the most friendly forums on the internet and I would be sad if that changed, however subtly.
-
Though it puts the burden on Theo a bit, a "stern word" from him ought to do it, when (if) it happens.
I had a "stern word" a couple years ago (on a different issue) and it was "effective". :Ph
Theo, is it my mistaken impression, but don't you read every post? Maybe you need a bagman.
-
If this was aimed at me, then I withdraw gracefully :'(
-
As a newer member I am not sure my input is valid, but while it is true I have sometimes been overwhelmed by the numerous and sometimes way over my head responses I get from some of my questions, rather than finding them intimidating, I find them informative and at times downright entertaining and funny. i guess I prefer to be overwhelmed than underwhelmed.
Also, I am one of those people with very little free time and what time I have is usually spent playing. In the meantime questions, thoughts and comments to other people's posts build up in my head, and when I do have free time, which I have had the past few days due to painful dental issues which are agitated by playing, I tend to try to get caught up all at once.
This site has been a great resource for me, as well as an entertaining window into life across the pond. There are so many characters on this site it surprises me someone hasn't made a reality tv show of it. For what it's worth, I think it would be a shame to restrict that.
-
Rather than a 'global' posting limit. Why not warn the specific offenders that if they continue that those certain people will get a posting limit. Rather than punishing the many for actions of the few.
-
I'm not sure where the perceived problem lies. I can easily imagine any action as proposed may prove to the detriment of the forum.
I'm not in favour of censorship and feel that generally the open hearted and open minded spirit of the forum works very well to mitigate behaviour outside that spirit. (Sorry, I seem to be in a lyrical mood this morning!!)
Perhaps this thread will have been enough to encourage a little restraint.
Bob
-
Hmmm ! I haven't posted or followed melnet for a while, got rather disgruntled by the attitude and response from some of the membership; but that's another story.
Even though I have issues with the forum, I totally disagree with any limits on postings and the imposition of time constraints, as it would be completely against the spirit and feel of the forum, and would ultimately be to its detriment.
When I first joined melnet, I read the articles that interested me, and then eventually joined in by posing questions that I needed answers to. After quite some time, I eventually replied to a few posts, when I thought that I had something to add to the conversation. On more than one occasion, someone would post my exact same thoughts just before I was about to put fingers to keys, so I either replied in agreement and added something, or didn't reply at all (you have to be quick on melnet), but the choice was mine. By imposing some kind of limit or censorship you will end up by alienating those people that you are hoping to help, as the sensitive, knowledgeable, and experienced posters will eventually refrain from responding, which is no way to maintain the long term existence of the site. Clearly we all have something to bring to the table, even if it's not melodeon connected, and new members should be encouraged to have their say, and as mentioned in a previous posting, a word in the ear of those that offend should be more than sufficient. As in any group gathering, you will always get the sado's, but the vast majority of decent caring members shouldn't be penalised by the actions of the few. It really would be a shame to loose such an interesting and sometimes amusing site.
-
I am not quite a newbie to this forum, I have posted for help & information and always received courteous answers to basic and sometimes stupid questions.
I contribute zero to most posts, but the interest, knowledge & passion from the forum members in discussion is enormous to me. I would be sad those live and breathing posts could starve.
However offenders need to be told if their is a problem and address the issue.
To encourage new members and infrequent posters to contribute
I am not sure limiting posts will encourage new or infrequent posters to contribute. Its just a matter of having something meaningful to add, and that can be overwhelming in the company of so many virtuoso Melodeon musicians.
PS I will try and get involved, but I might end up being one of the offenders!!! Oh such is Life (Ned Kelly)
-
I'm not in favour of censorship
By imposing some kind of limit or censorship ...
Woa there! This suggestion is not about censorship. Any limit would be applied equally to all.
-
Theo - sorry to learn you have had some complaints.
Nevertheless, I also feel that putting a daily, or a time limit on the number of posts would be a backward and somewhat negative step, for the reasons given by Ollie, Gary, Nfldbox and others too. I feel it would detract from the excellent community atmosphere of melnet; I too love all the types of posts we get here, both the technical and the trivial. If there are any threads I don't wish to follow, I simply don't read them.
This has to be one of the most friendly forums on the internet and I would be sad if that changed, however subtly.
Steve - my thoughts exactly.
I also think that Theo does an excellent job in the occasionally necessary "holding the ring" when things get a bit heated or OTT, without adding the extra work that would likely arise from this suggestion. Any system-imposed limit would be rather too mechanistic, especially for this friendly and free-flowing forum.
-
May I echo Lester's request for a 'thread ignore' filter on the 'unread posts' action. That is, if SMF has such facility?
I used to follow the Contact Bridge forum on the old usenet readers, and it made it easy to remove distracting stuff about eg complex tournament/player/card deal rotations; fascinating to Tournament Director types but not to the humble player.
Similarly here, we all have different interests, so it'd be the art of the possible. The facility on usenet was called 'unfollow'. Such a gadget would bypass and ameliorate, rather than address the primary issue wrt excessive posting
Kudos points awarded incidentally to our Mods for floating this for discussion in their own wish list area, rather than simply imposing it :||:
-
Yes, there's a plugin - http://custom.simplemachines.org/mods/index.php?mod=1193 - still being actively supported too it seems. Not tested it myself of course.
-
overall I have absolutely no problem with any of the stuff posted on melnet. If I am not keen on the way a thread is developing or the way its going I either ignore it or perhaps just glance swiftly over it in case it is changing for the better , that is 'the better'' to me as an individual.'
What I am not keen on others may consider to be the bees knees, dogs bollocks or whatever so perhaps best in peace left to sort itself out as things often do!
george
-
On further consideration, I'm not so sure it would be a good idea.
As internet forums (fora?) go, melnet is already exemplary in general decency and considerate behaviour by its members.
Where things start falling below the usual high standards, judicious closing of threads and PMs to offenders seem do the trick. Even the practice of moving material from one thread to another to keep thing on topic helps a lot with reducing confusion and frustration.
An "ignore thread" switch might be useful to some, but it might also have the effect of encouraging others to post more drivel, on the basis "you don't have to read it if you don't want to, so I'll post what I like". That's not in keeping with the notion of this being a community of people with a common interest.
-
This thread is seeming to present the idea that perhaps the participants are not keeping their feet on a pre-conceived path, and need to be steered in between the curbs. This would beg the situation that the mods would then have to produce some sort of manifesto about what's important and what's not. Personally, I have found this forum to be the most good-natured, polite, helpful, and informative of any I have joined. Interests here are quite diverse, as are the members, and ignoring a post or thread is only a mouse-click away.
-
This thread is seeming to present the idea that perhaps the participants are not keeping their feet on a pre-conceived path, and need to be steered in between the curbs. This would beg the situation that the mods would then have to produce some sort of manifesto about what's important and what's not. Personally, I have found this forum to be the most good-natured, polite, helpful, and informative of any I have joined. Interests here are quite diverse, as are the members, and ignoring a post or thread is only a mouse-click away.
Fully agree with that.
Is that reply a one liner?
-
This thread is seeming to present the idea that perhaps the participants are not keeping their feet on a pre-conceived path, and need to be steered in between the curbs. This would beg the situation that the mods would then have to produce some sort of manifesto about what's important and what's not. Personally, I have found this forum to be the most good-natured, polite, helpful, and informative of any I have joined. Interests here are quite diverse, as are the members, and ignoring a post or thread is only a mouse-click away.
Addendum: This is not meant to construe that I condone thoughtless off-topic posting, as I think we all know we are here to discuss the world of melodeons. Aren't we? ;)
-
This thread is seeming to present the idea that perhaps the participants are not keeping their feet on a pre-conceived path
You are making it sound terribly prescriptive!
Things that can go wrong (though neither happens here nearly as much they do in other places):
- useful discussions getting hijacked by lengthy off-topic diversions, making it hard for those who are genuinely interested in the original topic to follow it, and frustrating if they haven't much time.
- disagreements that descend into holy wars, politics and personal insults.
-
This thread is seeming to present the idea that perhaps the participants are not keeping their feet on a pre-conceived path
You are making it sound terribly prescriptive!
Things that can go wrong (though neither happens here nearly as much they do in other places):
- useful discussions getting hijacked by lengthy off-topic diversions, making it hard for those who are genuinely interested in the original topic to follow it, and frustrating if they haven't much time.
- disagreements that descend into holy wars, politics and personal insults.
I agree with you on 'what can go wrong' and have seen whole forums collapse into rubble ( witness the old rec.musicmakers squeezebox from the 1990's). I am also not a fan of strict perscriptive-ness. But I also don't think that limiting posts is necessarily wrong....but how to decide a fair number? Would it curtail a relative and interesting topic? Who might be left outside? ???
-
Them that pays the piper calls the tune. The forum owners have certainly created one of the best.
It's my impression that most "newbies" are suitably impressed by the kind, trustworthy, loyal, helpful.....etc. responses they get. They certainly often say so.
On the other hand, it would be nice if some of the newer folks were encouraged to use the search boxes, as many of the questions they have have been already addressed, at great length in existing threads.
What might be nice, though more work for the mods, would be to have on the home page or forum home page a note to new users to try the search function before posting. Then they could enter the conversation with some base of information.
But I do sometimes like thread drift and the noodling path it sometimes takes. Does make it hard to track down a subject sometimes.
Keep out: politics, most sex stuff (exception for melodeon porn), most drug stuff (exception of melodeon crack).
-
But I also don't think that limiting posts is necessarily wrong....but how to decide a fair number? Would it curtail a relative and interesting topic?
No it would not curtail an interesting topic, just slow the pace...
What might be nice, though more work for the mods, would be to have on the home page or forum home page a note to new users to try the search function before posting.
Thanks, that is a useful suggestion and will take all of a couple of minutes to add to the welcome message. What will take longer is to improve the search function, which is not very good. There seems to be an add-on for SMF that takes you to a Google search of the forum.
-
Google used to offer standard code for a site search, I used it for my Bridge archive. Brings all the power of synonym search and spelling correction to the job.
With the bonus of targetted melodeon adverts on one's Facebook page ;)
-
Just add site:melodeon.net into your search terms on a standard Google search.
-
But I also don't think that limiting posts is necessarily wrong....but how to decide a fair number? Would it curtail a relative and interesting topic?
No it would not curtail an interesting topic, just slow the pace...
One further plea for retaining things as they are...
I am slightly dyslexic and often make mistakes when typing. Mostly I correct these before hitting the 'post' button, but I don't always spot all of them. I know there is also a 'preview' button which I do make use of. Nevertheless, some errors often slip through and I don't notice them until the post is displayed on the forum. When things are bad, I sometimes make such a b*****ks of my initial post (and quite often change my mind too!) that I delete my post almost immediately after posting and then resubmit a clean, new version. This also avoids the 'last edited by...' message which appears on the footer of a heavily edited post.
If there were to be a limit on the number of posts in a given time period, depending on what that frequency was, I might perhaps find myself limited in the ability to correct my sometimes horrendous errors. :(
-
I didn't want to get involved in this thread, but as a frequent poster I suppose I must.
It seems most of the replies are against some automatic regulatory restriction and I agree with that.
Yes, there is flippancy and downright stupidness (Limericks?) but the majority of people who post to this site are decent honest and genuine. If a restriction was imposed, You , the best gang in the world would not be reading this.
Now let's go compose a Limerick. >:E
-
I didn't want to get involved in this thread, but as a frequent poster I suppose I must.
It seems most of the replies are against some automatic regulatory restriction and I agree with that.
Yes, there is flippancy and downright stupidness (Limericks?) but the majority of people who post to this site are decent honest and genuine. If a restriction was imposed, You , the best gang in the world would not be reading this.
Now let's go compose a Limerick. >:E
Absolutely incorrigible!
-
In proposing a limit to the number of posts, Theo, you are offering a solution without specifying the nature of the problem. You mentioned some complaints/criticisms you have received, but you have not been very specific about their nature (perhaps intentionally).
I raise this because we might be able to suggest alternative solutions if we understood more clearly the nature of the problem.
Speaking for myself, I haven't noticed any problem in what I consider to be an excellent, informative and very well-mannered forum. If a thread doesn't interest me, I don't read it. However, it does concern me that imposing a limit on the number of posts might have unforeseen deleterious consequences.
-
What might be nice, though more work for the mods, would be to have on the home page or forum home page a note to new users to try the search function before posting.
Thanks, that is a useful suggestion and will take all of a couple of minutes to add to the welcome message. What will take longer is to improve the search function, which is not very good. There seems to be an add-on for SMF that takes you to a Google search of the forum.
Perhaps slightly off topic, but ... there are topics that are amenable to this, but I don't actually come to the forum for information per se. I come for conversation about information. Probably preaching to the choir here.
-
'I come for conversation about information'. I wanted to say exactly that but couldn't find the words. Thanks Gary. ;)
-
Gary, what I was going for was a comment I think that was made regarding reluctance of new members from posting.
It "seems like" many new posters are looking for information, sometimes in areas that have been treaded and re-retreaded, such as what is a good box to learn on, are 1 rows easier to play than 2 rows, what key(s), can I fix/tune my own box, etc.
Bob, good point. If leadership would be so kind, maybe they could more clearly outline what it is we are trying to fix......
-
Theo - sorry to learn you have had some complaints.
Nevertheless, I also feel that putting a daily, or a time limit on the number of posts would be a backward and somewhat negative step, for the reasons given by Ollie, Gary, Nfldbox and others too. I feel it would detract from the excellent community atmosphere of melnet; I too love all the types of posts we get here, both the technical and the trivial. If there are any threads I don't wish to follow, I simply don't read them.
This has to be one of the most friendly forums on the internet and I would be sad if that changed, however subtly.
I completely agree with the above,well put steve.
-
I don't know if this speaks directly to a root cause, but maybe we could have an annual "bake sale" and buy the forum some bandwidth credits.
I get the impression that the "buy and sell" honoraria sent in are inadequate to support the considerable fixed expenses of the ISP.
-
Steve C
That really needs a new topic, I don't see it's relevance here, it is just speculation and is incorrect. My suggestions were prompted by the reasons I gave. There is no shortage of money in the kitty.
-
Quote, from Theo "there's no shortage of money in the kitty"
There'll be even more when the Melnet book of Limericks comes out. 8)
-
Quote, from Theo "there's no shortage of money in the kitty"
There'll be even more when the Melnet book of Limericks comes out. 8)
Not just incorrigible, but an out-and-out recidivist as well. Tut-tut.
-
;D
Quote, from Theo "there's no shortage of money in the kitty"
There'll be even more when the Melnet book of Limericks comes out. 8)
Not just incorrigible, but an out-and-out recidivist as well. Tut-tut.
:'( ;D
-
Well, surely the nature of the issue (I refuse to see a problem) is kinda key.
While encouraging new people to search before asking and thus ask in a more informed (or confused) manner is probably a good idea, you don't (I think) want this to be a place where people come, search, read and depart in silence. If at least some of them don't join in then stagnation is possible and perceived cliquishness more likely.
My other forum has an incredibly detailed FAQ (well FMR, but same principle) sticky which is very helpful (not slaved over by a mod, btw but a forum person). Problem is many live queries arethen answered by "read the FMR" which is not helpful and not the melnet way. Where else could you go and ask a genuine but naive question and without fail get a helpful, polite, enthusiastic response that will make you feel better about yourself and probably give you a giggle?
Yes you get thread drift "I'm looking for a pink melodeon, any suggestions?" may well dissolve into a debate on the sound characteristics of pink and whether light pink or hot pink are more resonant, most of which will go over your head but you'll know people are interested, come out with some suggestions on what to choose AND where to get them, which bus to catch to the obscure Italian village that is the only place that makes them, an introduction to a tuner to fettle it and on a good day a limerick to cheer you on your way. AND some of those may have come from legendary players whose feet we are unworthy to wash, at that!
I doubt there are many forums that provide such an all round service.
I also personally like the one liner quips - it proves there are real people here and they take no time to read as well as usually raising a smile and the odd guffaw. They also contributed strongly to my staying, having wandered in randomly*.
Incredibly long walls of text on only vaguely related topics are probably more of an issue for me as ignoring them takes longer (and they make me feel inadequate). However, without those there'd be no quips. I also work for the government, so skipping over turgid prose is my speciality ;)
Anyhoo tl:dr not sure it's broken, actually
* maybe not such a good thing, then
-
Beautifully put Lyra, even if Etienne did think you were Sir. ;)
-
This shall be my last "me too" post.
This shall be my last devoid of serious content post (fingers crossed).
Seriously, though, good to hear that it is not a financial issue. My mistaken surmise.
-
But what if one is really really feeling an exceptionally strong "me too" as I am at this moment with every word that Lyra just said? Is there another way i could put it? As a relative newbie to this site this thread is becoming exactly why I spend so much time on it. That and the fact that I live in a melodeon void, and really have no one else to answer my questions or just talk boxes with. :(
-
It "seems like" many new posters are looking for information, sometimes in areas that have been treaded and re-retreaded, such as what is a good box to learn on, are 1 rows easier to play than 2 rows
Although it's always sensible to search a forum first if looking for specific information, it's easier said than done. I don't know if the second was an actual example but I just experimentally tried a couple of searches and didn't come up with anything useful. That's nothing to do with the search function; it's just that terms like "one row" and "two row" are so general you'd have to plough through a lot of posts to see if you could find anything. I think forums like this are inevitably going to have quite a lot of repeated questions. I guess a FAQ is the best answer to that. How about heading the forum with a "Welcome" section with a beginner's FAQ and a place where people could introduce themselves? (Another possibility would be some kind of "beginners" section where people could post trivial repetitive questions without fear of intruding on more esoteric debates, the ones about limericks etc.)
My other forum has an incredibly detailed FAQ (well FMR, but same principle) sticky which is very helpful (not slaved over by a mod, btw but a forum person). Problem is many live queries arethen answered by "read the FMR" which is not helpful and not the melnet way.
I don't think the existence of a FAQ would necessarily lead to peremptory "read the FAQ" posts, any more than simple questions are presently met with the even more soul-destroying "use Google". On some forums being able to politely direct someone's attention to information in a FAQ is an effective timesaver for everyone, and if people want to make more personal replies they still can.
I don't actually come to the forum for information per se. I come for conversation about information.
That's a nice comment. I recently posted a query on a another unrelated forum which was doubtless the kind of thing that had often been posted on forums before, but still elicited quite a lively and informative thread-drifting debate. Questions about one thing on Melnet often seem to lead to answers about another!
-
I'm on Melnet at least twice a day because it is friendly and an enormous source of information, some of which I don't properly understand but is always interesting. Looking things up doesn't really work most times for me, mainly because my knowledge of all things melodeon is not too good. For example, the term Helicon has always puzzled me and the explanation on 'Melodeon Terms' didn't help over much, but an enquiry on here yesterday came up with very understandable descriptions pretty quickly.( OOM PA ) I do post when something hits the spot, and yes, sometimes it is a 'me too', but I also go weeks without posting. Would I accrue valuable house points after long silent periods? I can't be the only one to admire Lyra's posting on this, it seemed to cover the subject admirably...
-
What's your thinking so far Theo? (:)
-
This seems to have two directions - one for newbies posting "previously asked" questions, and one for the more, shall we say, light hearted posting.
I suspect that Theo's concerns centre around the latter, although I've not noticed any specifics, or indeed proposals for any specific limits. I am assuming no PMs have been issued on that matter. 8)
FAQs have their uses, but going back to my early days on Usenet in the early 90s I recall frequent exhortations to "Read the **** FAQ" - to me a clear indication that they have never worked. I suspect for UK users FAQ means " I can't be Fagged to Answer your Question" (not my original choice, but I couldn't have two As). A few more information files distilled out might be good, but I think newbies should be allowed, if not encouraged, to post their initial questions without any pressure or "guidance".
Theo suggested that a posting limit would only slow down helpful discussions, not kill them. I take the opposite view. If you've got to wait until tomorrow to post (or get) an answer, most will lose interest and the topic will have moved on anyway. So I think people won't bother. And unless any limit is applied unequally, with "heavyweight" users being allowed more posts than "flippant" users, the most helpful people will be capped most.
And apart from any "fairness" issues, that would be a pig to operate so I can't see it happening.
Another side effect might be that people would seek to put more into long posts - unless there was a character count limit - so there would be more long indigestible posts. (like this one ::)
As for the "more prolific" users - can't really comment, not having much experience of one-line posts or limericks, myself, ::) but it is a clear indication that the users are comfortable with a forum and as others have said, they are not universally unwelcome. But I also think the names that come to mind would be amenable to a gentle prod from a list admin without taking it it to heart, and while that's a bit more work for the admins (and I have been there) it might be worth a try to start with.
Finally, I don't think Theo specifically said "complaints" - but of course, wherever you are, there are those more predisposed to complain than others...
-
I also personally like the one liner quips - it proves there are real people here and they take no time to read as well as usually raising a smile and the odd guffaw. They also contributed strongly to my staying, having wandered in randomly*.
Incredibly long walls of text on only vaguely related topics are probably more of an issue for me as ignoring them takes longer.....
* maybe not such a good thing, then
Good points.....and I have been witness to very few incidents of flaming on this forum. Perhaps they are expunged automatically :o
On the issue of search, I must confess that I have found the search engine to be painfully ineffective. If it was more useful, perhaps new users could find much of the well discussed information they are seeking. I have searched every which way for a keyword that I know exists on a former thread, to no avail. Sometimes they appear quite by accident.
-
I have searched every which way for a keyword that I know exists on a former thread, to no avail. Sometimes they appear quite by accident.
Seconded, it is a bit rusty
-
Thank you all for the thoughtful and varied responses. The clear consensus is that a daily posting limit is not seen as a good thins, so I will not give it another thought.
-
Good points.....and I have been witness to very few incidents of flaming on this forum. Perhaps they are expunged automatically :o
No, the Hand of god does move, I have seen it.
-
Good points.....and I have been witness to very few incidents of flaming on this forum. Perhaps they are expunged automatically :o
No, the Hand of god does move, I have seen it.
Then you are truly blessed, brother ::)
Edited to add: Perhaps we need an Angelic e-mote >:E
-
To make regular posters pause for a few seconds (or more) to consider what readers will get from their comment.
Totally agree, too many people are posting on non-melodeon topics far too often.
Still, another couple of hundred posts and I,ll be a "hero member"
Hooray for insomnia, I mean melodeon related insomnia. John
That does look sensible and gets straight to the heart of the matter.
Another way this could be implemented is to introduce a time limit between posts from one member, rather than just a limit on the number of posts.