Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: waltzman on January 31, 2009, 01:05:40 PM

Title: "dedic" tuning
Post by: waltzman on January 31, 2009, 01:05:40 PM
I'm  tuning an Erika club with the "dedic" tuning as I understand it which is 8 cents above and below each note for every reed set.  I've noticed that the higher reeds seem to beat faster than the lower reeds.  Is this normal?
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: Falseknight on January 31, 2009, 02:05:27 PM
That is because you are using cents (hundredths of a semitone) as a reference not the absolute frequency.  Frequency measure is logarithmic, not linear

The beat rate depends on the frequency difference between the two sources in hertz, not in cents.  A difference of 1 hertz produces a beat rate of 1 beat per second no matter what frequency you apply it at.

I think you might have some re-tuning to do - the beat rate should be constant.
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: RGF on January 31, 2009, 02:15:37 PM
Yes, it is. In order for the beat rate to remain constant going up the scale, the gap in pitch between reeds in each pair has to decrease as you go up. (Can't remember exactly the amount......someone else here will certainly know. I'm really just a beginner.)

On the instruments I have tuned for myself, I've split the difference, so that the reed sets become progressively closer in pitch, but not so much as to keep a constant beat rate. The beat rate increases somewhat as you move up the scale, but not so much as it would with a constant pitch difference between each of the reeds in a given pair.

Hmmm. Hope I've helped to clarify, and not muddled it more!

Bob
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: RGF on January 31, 2009, 02:18:17 PM
By the way, is there a name for the type of tuning I described? Anybody know?

Bob
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: waltzman on January 31, 2009, 02:38:42 PM
That is because you are using cents (hundredths of a semitone) as a reference not the absolute frequency.  Frequency measure is logarithmic, not linear

The beat rate depends on the frequency difference between the two sources in hertz, not in cents.  A difference of 1 hertz produces a beat rate of 1 beat per second no matter what frequency you apply it at.

I think you might have some re-tuning to do - the beat rate should be constant.

I am using a peterson 'stroboflip' tuner which gives me the option of using 'cents' above and below a fixed tone or I can change the reference 440 A up or down by however many hertz.  If I change the 440 reference up and down by a fixed amount (say 4 Hz) will that automatically take care of the logrithmic change up the scale or would I need to vary the Hz?
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: Falseknight on January 31, 2009, 02:59:33 PM
Not familiar with the tuner so I'm not quite sure what you mean.  If you you take A=440 as reference, you need to set the "A" 440Hz reed pair to 436Hz and 444Hz.  For A 880 Hz (octave) you again need to set the reed pair at 876Hz and 884Hz to give a constant beat rate of 8 beats per second.  I am not sure how your tuner sets the dead reference for each note you are tuning, but if I understand what you want to do, one reed needs to be tuned sharp of reference by the same number of hertz ans the other reed is tuned flat.  Your chosen  beat rate is the difference.  If you want to change the beat rate with frequency (I've no idea how desirable this would be) tune in cents
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: IanD on February 01, 2009, 05:03:22 PM
That is because you are using cents (hundredths of a semitone) as a reference not the absolute frequency.  Frequency measure is logarithmic, not linear

The beat rate depends on the frequency difference between the two sources in hertz, not in cents.  A difference of 1 hertz produces a beat rate of 1 beat per second no matter what frequency you apply it at.

I think you might have some re-tuning to do - the beat rate should be constant.

I am using a peterson 'stroboflip' tuner which gives me the option of using 'cents' above and below a fixed tone or I can change the reference 440 A up or down by however many hertz.  If I change the 440 reference up and down by a fixed amount (say 4 Hz) will that automatically take care of the logrithmic change up the scale or would I need to vary the Hz?

If you change the reference then you'll have to alter the shift for every reed -- 4Hz for tuning A440, 2Hz for tuning A880 and so on.

If your tuner only allows an offset in cents then you'll also have to change this offset for each reed. A semitone (100 cents) is a pitch change of just under 6%, which is 26Hz for A440 -- so for A440 1Hz=4 cents, for A880 1Hz=2cents and so on.

Assuming you want 4Hz between reeds, for A440 the reeds are therefore 8 cents sharp and flat, with corresponding changes for different pitches:

A880   +/-4 cents     (or shift A440 reference by +/-1Hz)
D586   +/-6 cents     (or shift A440 reference by +/-1.5Hz)
A440   +/-8 cents     (or shift A440 reference by +/-2Hz)
D293   +/-12 cents   (or shift A440 reference by +/-3Hz)
A220   +/-16 cents   (or shift A440 reference by +/-4Hz)

I'm sure you can work out the ones in between :-)

Cheers

Ian

P.S. A tuner that can have offset specified in Hz is *much* easier...
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: waltzman on February 01, 2009, 05:33:32 PM

If you change the reference then you'll have to alter the shift for every reed -- 4Hz for tuning A440, 2Hz for tuning A880 and so on.

If your tuner only allows an offset in cents then you'll also have to change this offset for each reed. A semitone (100 cents) is a pitch change of just under 6%, which is 26Hz for A440 -- so for A440 1Hz=4 cents, for A880 1Hz=2cents and so on.

Assuming you want 4Hz between reeds, for A440 the reeds are therefore 8 cents sharp and flat, with corresponding changes for different pitches:

A880   +/-4 cents     (or shift A440 reference by +/-1Hz)
D586   +/-6 cents     (or shift A440 reference by +/-1.5Hz)
A440   +/-8 cents     (or shift A440 reference by +/-2Hz)
D293   +/-12 cents   (or shift A440 reference by +/-3Hz)
A220   +/-16 cents   (or shift A440 reference by +/-4Hz)

I'm sure you can work out the ones in between :-)

Cheers

Ian

P.S. A tuner that can have offset specified in Hz is *much* easier...


Thanks very much for the information.  Like 'Tallship' once said of himself with his Hohner project 'it's a good job I have infinite patience.'  With each octave the frequency of the tone doubles so the +/- cents would be cut in half.  This is the conclusion I already reached using my ear.  I tuned the treble range from +/- 8 cents down to +/- 2 cents which seems to sound about right.  For those of you who may have a Peterson Stroboflip tuner I can tell you that changing the reference A440 +/- 4Hz does NOT seem to work.  It actually results in a larger gap with the higher notes.


Michael
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: IanD on February 01, 2009, 05:35:50 PM


Thanks very much for the information.  Like 'Tallship' once said of himself with his Hohner project 'it's a good job I have infinite patience.'  With each octave the frequency of the tone doubles so the +/- cents would be cut in half.  This is the conclusion I already reached using my ear.  I tuned the treble range from +/- 8 cents down to +/- 2 cents which seems to sound about right.  For those of you who may have a Peterson Stroboflip tuner I can tell you that changing the reference A440 +/- 4Hz does NOT seem to work.  It actually results in a larger gap with the higher notes.


Michael

That's what the right-hand column in the table I posted showed :-)

Ian
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: old geezer on February 06, 2009, 11:44:23 AM
can "dedic" tuning be used for other than 2 reed combinations??

can this tuning be applied to say, my CCs Corso, which has a 3 voice arrangement?
if this could be done, would I be correct to assume one reed would be tuned say 2- cents, the next = temperament and the third 2+ cents.

I have recently read that, this tuning is not a popular one; so should I return the box to the dark from whence it recently came?

If this tuning can be applied to other than 2 voice melodeons, how would a 4 stop be tuned?
I normally play using the 2 clarinet and baritone reed combination in D.

jack in OZ
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: Theo on February 06, 2009, 12:26:28 PM
can "dedic" tuning be used for other than 2 reed combinations??

can this tuning be applied to say, my CCs Corso, which has a 3 voice arrangement?
if this could be done, would I be correct to assume one reed would be tuned say 2- cents, the next = temperament and the third 2+ cents.

Three mid range reeds are almost always tuned with one at concert pitch, one above and one below. 

An additional possibility here is that the high reed and the low reed may be tuned a different offset from the middle reed, eg you might have (in cents) -6, 0, +12 or various other combinations.  This give a more complex pattern of interference between the three pitches resulting in a richer set of harmonics.
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: waltzman on February 06, 2009, 01:16:02 PM
can "dedic" tuning be used for other than 2 reed combinations??

can this tuning be applied to say, my CCs Corso, which has a 3 voice arrangement?
if this could be done, would I be correct to assume one reed would be tuned say 2- cents, the next = temperament and the third 2+ cents.

Three mid range reeds are almost always tuned with one at concert pitch, one above and one below. 

An additional possibility here is that the high reed and the low reed may be tuned a different offset from the middle reed, eg you might have (in cents) -6, 0, +12 or various other combinations.  This give a more complex pattern of interference between the three pitches resulting in a richer set of harmonics.



Are the three reeds in a corso different octaves or are they the same?
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: Falseknight on February 06, 2009, 03:51:28 PM
Not tried a Corso, but a Club IIIM is two at pitch (tuned concert and sharp) and one an octave below, tuned at concert.

The problem with this arrangement is that the couplers switch out the bass reed or the sharp reed for octave two reeds or single reed.  That means that one of the high reeds (and of course the melody bass reed) has got to be in concert.
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: waltzman on February 06, 2009, 04:21:52 PM
Not tried a Corso, but a Club IIIM is two at pitch (tuned concert and sharp) and one an octave below, tuned at concert.

The problem with this arrangement is that the couplers switch out the bass reed or the sharp reed for octave two reeds or single reed.  That means that one of the high reeds (and of course the melody bass reed) has got to be in concert.

There has to be a good reason that accordions have been tuned concert and sharp and opposed to "dedic" tuning for the last hundred years.  Anyone care to venture a reason?
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: Dazbo on February 06, 2009, 04:26:40 PM
I think it was suggested on the other thread that if the instrument has the ability to switch reeds in and out (two tremelo reeds) then one of them needs to be at concert pitch so it became the standard way of doing it for all boxes.
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: IanD on February 06, 2009, 07:01:02 PM
I think it was suggested on the other thread that if the instrument has the ability to switch reeds in and out (two tremelo reeds) then one of them needs to be at concert pitch so it became the standard way of doing it for all boxes.

Precisely -- and also, before the availability of electronic tuners with programmable offset, it was easier to tune one set of reeds to concert pitch and then tune the other(s) offset from it.

As has been said, it only works for two-reed boxes without a stop, or three-reed ones where the only stop takes the low reed out.

Since these form the majority of melodeons nowadays it seems a shame to keep doing it "wrong"... :-)

Ian
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: waltzman on February 06, 2009, 10:13:16 PM
I think it was suggested on the other thread that if the instrument has the ability to switch reeds in and out (two tremelo reeds) then one of them needs to be at concert pitch so it became the standard way of doing it for all boxes.

Precisely -- and also, before the availability of electronic tuners with programmable offset, it was easier to tune one set of reeds to concert pitch and then tune the other(s) offset from it.

As has been said, it only works for two-reed boxes without a stop, or three-reed ones where the only stop takes the low reed out.

Since these form the majority of melodeons nowadays it seems a shame to keep doing it "wrong"... :-)

Ian


I wonder if there might not be more to it than that.  When a violin player does a vibrato it goes from the correct pitch to a slightly higher pitch and then back.  This sounds pleasant to the ear.  If you go below the correct pitch with vibrato it sounds terrible.  I think a slightly sharp tremolo would sound better to the ear than a flat tremolo.  Also, playing slightly sharp of other instruments makes that instrument stand out a bit although you wouldn't think the accordion would need much help in this regard.
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: IanD on February 06, 2009, 10:45:49 PM
I think it was suggested on the other thread that if the instrument has the ability to switch reeds in and out (two tremelo reeds) then one of them needs to be at concert pitch so it became the standard way of doing it for all boxes.

Precisely -- and also, before the availability of electronic tuners with programmable offset, it was easier to tune one set of reeds to concert pitch and then tune the other(s) offset from it.

As has been said, it only works for two-reed boxes without a stop, or three-reed ones where the only stop takes the low reed out.

Since these form the majority of melodeons nowadays it seems a shame to keep doing it "wrong"... :-)

Ian


I wonder if there might not be more to it than that.  When a violin player does a vibrato it goes from the correct pitch to a slightly higher pitch and then back.  This sounds pleasant to the ear.  If you go below the correct pitch with vibrato it sounds terrible.  I think a slightly sharp tremolo would sound better to the ear than a flat tremolo.  Also, playing slightly sharp of other instruments makes that instrument stand out a bit although you wouldn't think the accordion would need much help in this regard.

Given the choice of sounding sharp or flat the ear does seem to find sharp less offensive -- however it seems to find in tune preferable to either...

(violin players I know use vibrato above and below the true note, otherwise they sound sharp -- of course of they want to sound in tune with sharp-tuned melodeons thay don't have any choice)

You're right that melodeons playing sharp stand out, but I'd have to say that IMHO this isn't a good thing :-)

(again, the fiddle players I know *much* prefer playing with an in-tune melodeon to one that's sharp)

Ian
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: Lars on February 07, 2009, 01:12:08 AM
The standard for a number of melodeons / button accordions was actually to tune flat: A lot of the old GLOBE 4-stop melodeons was tuned LMMH with one M at 0 cents, and one slightly flat. A number of the Irish-american Baldoni-Bartoli and Walters boxes was also like this: E.g. an 8v with 4 middles, where two were in pitch, and two were slightly flat (but at the same amount flat - to give the impression of doubling-up the 4-stop tuning in an 8v box). I've also come across a LMMM baldoni where the three set of middle reeds were tuned low - one in pitch, one lower, and the last lower again. The L reed was in pitch. Not a bad sound at all!
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: old geezer on February 07, 2009, 10:45:39 AM

Three mid range reeds are almost always tuned with one at concert pitch, one above and one below. 

An additional possibility here is that the high reed and the low reed may be tuned a different offset from the middle reed, eg you might have (in cents) -6, 0, +12 or various other combinations.  This give a more complex pattern of interference between the three pitches resulting in a richer set of harmonics.



I'm going to go with Theo's suggestion and, request this tuning be applied to my Corso as this sounds an interesting tuning


Are the three reeds in a corso different octaves or are they the same?

I assume all Corso reed combinations have 3 reeds from the same octave

jack in OZ
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: Falseknight on February 07, 2009, 11:24:04 AM
Agree with IanD - Violinists (guitarists, mandolin players) all use tremolos above and below.  The only exceptions I can think of are the blues players who get a tremolo by bending the string sideways rather than rocking up and down the string (behind the fret).

The other issue is that a tremolo on a string (or wind) instrument is a periodic variation of pitch  This should strictly be called a vibrato.  The tremolo produced on a free reed instrument is the periodic variation of volume caused by the beating of a detuned reed pair.  The effects are not directly comparable.
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: waltzman on February 07, 2009, 12:22:22 PM
Agree with IanD - Violinists (guitarists, mandolin players) all use tremolos above and below.  The only exceptions I can think of are the blues players who get a tremolo by bending the string sideways rather than rocking up and down the string (behind the fret).

The other issue is that a tremolo on a string (or wind) instrument is a periodic variation of pitch  This should strictly be called a vibrato.  The tremolo produced on a free reed instrument is the periodic variation of volume caused by the beating of a detuned reed pair.  The effects are not directly comparable.

Yes, I know that the effects are not the same.  I was just searching for ideas.  I was not aware that there were (are) accordions that are deliberately tuned concert and flat with no sharp reeds.
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: Theo on February 07, 2009, 12:49:21 PM
Yes, I know that the effects are not the same.  I was just searching for ideas.  I was not aware that there were (are) accordions that are deliberately tuned concert and flat with no sharp reeds.

But there are many, especially Piano accordions which are deliberately tuned slightly sharp, eg A=441 or 442,
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: Lars on February 07, 2009, 01:13:26 PM

But there are many, especially Piano accordions which are deliberately tuned slightly sharp, eg A=441 or 442,

But aren't these to be played with OTHER instruments tuned slightly sharp (A=441-442) as well?

I know that in the 30's and 40's, a number of the New York and Boston melodeon players had their boxes tuned to A=445 to be played along with others tuned to 438 or 440. And then with a range of +/- 15-20 cents, you would be absolutely SURE to hear the melodeon, even with a number of saxophones doing the meloody as well.
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: IanD on February 07, 2009, 01:15:15 PM
Yes, I know that the effects are not the same.  I was just searching for ideas.  I was not aware that there were (are) accordions that are deliberately tuned concert and flat with no sharp reeds.

But there are many, especially Piano accordions which are deliberately tuned slightly sharp, eg A=441 or 442,

There is a theory that the added "bite" of playing lightly sharp -- at the expense of being in tune, of course -- is what lead to average concert pitch creeping upwards during the 19th and early 20th centuries, until it was reset to A440 to unify all the different pitches in use.

This could be one reason for some accordions being tuned sharp -- unless it's to play in tune with the melodeons which are already tuned sharp because of using concert/sharp reeds...

Ian
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: IanD on February 07, 2009, 01:17:39 PM

But there are many, especially Piano accordions which are deliberately tuned slightly sharp, eg A=441 or 442,

But aren't these to be played with OTHER instruments tuned slightly sharp (A=441-442) as well?

I know that in the 30's and 40's, a number of the New York and Boston melodeon players had their boxes tuned to A=445 to be played along with others tuned to 438 or 440. And then with a range of +/- 15-20 cents, you would be absolutely SURE to hear the melodeon, even with a number of saxophones doing the meloody as well.

I don't thing tuning deliberately sharp to be heard over other instruments in a band is a good thing -- if you really want to take this to it's logical extreme you could play a tune in D on an Eflat box, that would *really* make you stand out :-)

Ian
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: Accordion Dave on February 07, 2009, 03:16:32 PM
My Lombardi 2-row in the key of G-Sharp/C-Sharp (A-Flat/D-Flat) really "stands out" when I try to play along with a recording of one of my G/C boxes.

Obviously it sounds totally out of tune. However, using the pitch control on the tape recorder enables me to play a duet using these two boxes. 

I wonder why it was tuned a half tone sharp from the more common Hohner G/C boxes.
Title: Re: "dedic" tuning
Post by: Falseknight on February 08, 2009, 06:07:29 PM
There used to be a high-pitch tuning standard (A=450/455) if I remember correctly, which is coming close to a semitone sharp.  Lots of old Rudalll Carte orchestral flutes (Boem and 1867 system) are still doing the rounds, some with half inch "correction" sleeves.  Suggest you had a high pitch G/C.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal