Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: alaskairishbox on September 22, 2013, 06:35:14 PM

Title: b/c basses yet again
Post by: alaskairishbox on September 22, 2013, 06:35:14 PM
Folks, I have searched the archives and read a fair amount about this but am still unclear.

I have been slowly learning to throw in basses using the Burke system. My new box showed up with McComisky basses. I thought I would spend a few weeks with the McComisky system to see if it makes sense and then maybe convert.

I instantly found the awkwardness, but am less clear about the advantages. It seem really backward to switch buttons when the direction changes within a chord. For me it adds an extra layer I have to learn for each tune individually. Is the advantage of this system that often you can sort of getting away with the  "wrong" chord on the opposite direction. (That would be the "traffic jam"/traveller style of uilleann pipes.

Are there any advantage other than sometimes having the correct chord on the same button and sometimes having a wrong, but not so terrible chord. Doesn't this just lead to tolerating chord choices only the box player thinks are ok?
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: ButtonBox21 on September 23, 2013, 12:39:30 PM
I played BC with the Burke system a few years ago before changing to C#D and I wouldn't use any other system for BC. If you are used to the Burke system and find the McComisky system awkward then you should have it changed to the Burke system. I would recommend the Button Box as they converted my Paolo Soprani BC to the Burke system and did an outstanding job for a reasonable price.   :||:
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: Stiamh on September 23, 2013, 01:29:47 PM
The awkwardness is inherited from other systems where you spend more of your time playing on the row and where you can often conveniently keep your l/h fingers on the same bass/chord pair as the bellows direction changes.

This is, as you have noticed, not quite so convenient on the B/C where, being obliged to play across the rows to a far greater extent, you far less frequently play two notes on the same button. In my dabbling with B/C style playing I have never got as far as using the basses, so I can't say how often, if at all, the arrangement proves advantageous on that system. Over to Luke and others...
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: Bill Young on September 23, 2013, 02:44:51 PM
Referring to the common bass arrangements for B/C (http://squeezehead.com/keyboard-layouts/basses/LAYOUTS.html) boxes, I've always thought that the McComiskey system only makes sense if the box has been converted from the Paolo Soprani layout, as it's the easiest and cheapest way of getting a Push D. I had this done once, for precisely that reason. It makes no sense at all for boxes to be made this way from scratch; but this is now widely done, and it's referred to as the 'modern' bass layout. The Burke layout is much more sensible and preferable and avoids the awkwardness that Alaskairishbox is finding. I had a Paolo Soprani B/C converted to this system and it was better than the other two. All 8-button bass B/C boxes should be made with the Burke system from new. (But, hey, there's a whole history of technically superior systems losing out to inferior ones, for all sorts of reasons - Betamax vs VHS, OS2 vs Windows, Token Ring LAN vs Ethernet, etc.).

Nowadays I have moved beyond all of these systems to Stradella basses - 12 bass BC, 120 and 80 bass BCC#.
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: LDbosca on September 23, 2013, 09:30:34 PM
Nice to see such support for the Burke system instead of the POXY McComiskey system! I bought a box that had it once, by god did I hate it.
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: alaskairishbox on September 24, 2013, 10:25:30 PM
Ok, Looks like there isn't some major advantage of the McComisky basses that I am overlooking. I will convert the box over to the Burke system.
On an slightly different note. I find it interesting that the guy (Burke) who popularized the apparently more functional system spends so little time playing those basses.

Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: triskel on September 24, 2013, 10:40:42 PM
I find it interesting that the guy (Burke) who popularized the apparently more functional system spends so little time playing those basses.

Joe Burke would try to play more like a fiddler, but he's always "tipping away" gently on the basses - though you maybe wouldn't notice most of the time.
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: george garside on September 24, 2013, 11:24:02 PM
I have often thought that 8 (or better still 10 or 12) single bass notes ( same both ways  - a sort of free bass ) would  be the ideal BC  bass system  so chords could be built up using a combination of buttons and possibly a bit of ''bass melody'' could be used .  Um pa ing would also be available using  eg G  followed by GBD '

Maybe  for 8 bass  C C# D E F F# G A  and for 12  C  D E F F# G G# A B Bb Eb

has anybody done anything on those lines

george
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: Lars on September 24, 2013, 11:49:37 PM
I do prefer the McComiskey system.

I am mainly a C#/D player, but I started out on the B/C, and still have one around that I play on a weekly basis. To me, the advantage of the McC system is the relation to the 'old' system as Steve point out, keepin on the row. As a player of single row boxes as well as C#/D, it just makes good sense, especially when switching between different systems and boxes. I use the push D a lot, and I often find my fingers searching for it when playing boxes in the standard layout.

I do however see the benfits of the Burke layout, and if playing ONLY B/C, I would seriously consider it to be one of the best options for 8 basses. It should not be a difficult job to have it changed, so if you like that system I don't see why you should not go for it. Keeping the old reeds would make it easy to change back in case of sale, or change of heart.
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: Andy on September 28, 2013, 11:30:13 PM
Hi

Thought eight unisonoric chords would be handy.... but then I realised converting a note to a chord would be a whole lot more difficult than changing a chord for another chord or a note for another note. Anyone ever done this though? Particularly intrested if it has ever been done on a Double Ray Deluxe. - If you are unimpressed with the McComiskey system you should try the old Hohner system.

Andy
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: Bill Young on September 29, 2013, 10:16:13 PM
Hi

Thought eight unisonoric chords would be handy.... but then I realised converting a note to a chord would be a whole lot more difficult than changing a chord for another chord or a note for another note. Anyone ever done this though? Particularly intrested if it has ever been done on a Double Ray Deluxe. - If you are unimpressed with the McComiskey system you should try the old Hohner system.

Andy

The best bass modification I have seen for a Hohner Double Ray Deluxe is fitting a 48-bass end from a small Hohner PA, as made for Bruce Lindsay Jr by Bruce Snr (pic 1).  There have been at least two similar mods to Hohner Trichords; here's one I made earlier (pic 2).
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: george garside on September 30, 2013, 08:07:34 AM
I agree!

george
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: LDbosca on September 30, 2013, 12:20:34 PM
Probably quite good for Scottish music, but stradella's gonna sound awful for Irish music.
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: george garside on September 30, 2013, 12:58:31 PM
?? but many piano box players play irish trad music & they have stradella

george
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: LDbosca on October 02, 2013, 02:08:44 AM
?? but many piano box players play irish trad music & they have stradella

george

They almost all sound awful; the good ones seem to use the basses very little. As a percentage, I reckon quite few piano players play Irish trad.
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: Pat. on October 12, 2013, 06:15:01 AM
Have to agree with LDbosca that stradella bases on B/C/C#  do not work that well with Irish music apart from waltzes, and those that  play them seem to use them sparingly [although  there are always exceptions]where as with  playing Scottish music they seem essential to my ear.
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: george garside on October 12, 2013, 09:32:58 AM
I agree with Pat re sparing use of stradella for irish trad music ( of which I have little or no expertise so am commenting more as a ''listener'')   However I would still argue that for Irish trad on a 3 row  stradella is the way to go as  it is a much more useful system than push/pull bass however many are used.  Sradella gives the player , of Irish trad or owt else,  the choice of using the bass to 'ornement' the odd treble note here & there or to provide a comprehensive blend of  rhythm and harmony if required. 

I think it is the  over heavy and turgid use of stradella that is taken as the norm by many piano box players  that rightly puts others off the system.  ----but to be fair some can do heavy and turgid without any apparent effort on push pull basses!

george ;) >:E

Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 12, 2013, 10:00:33 AM
Not my area of experience either, but I can confess to having a CBA/Stradella tucked away in a corner, virtually unplayed. When I got it I took to the right end very readily, it's logical, essentially mathematical, and I'm well used to seeing invisible "scales" zig-zagging across box button arrays from my unusual approach to 3 rowing

Point wrt this thread is that it was the Stradella that put me off it. All those tiny little buttons, hard to hit accurately and comfortably (I'm size 8 gloves). Nor are the chords which Stradella offers … choice of maj/min triad, 7 :( and diminished :o really suited to Irish music as I understand it (I was trying jazz).

Dynamically, also a disaster, it sort of wants to play slushy legato! Very few (eg Becky Price, Steve from Southport) Stradella players get it "crisp". I think the weight of it doesn't help, and I wonder what it might do for the rapid bellows movement involved in B/C?

i'm not about to buy a B/C, but if Inwere I'd tend to go for mainly unisonoric bass chord pairs (with big buttons!) for pentatonic/diatonic melody led music. I see much celtic stuff in that genre, and there are loads of Youtubes now showing fantastic right end play, with left (presumably "standard"?) buttons hardly being touched.

Will drop back to listening mode, interesting thread, thanks
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: alaskairishbox on December 08, 2013, 02:35:38 AM
On a whim I decided to convert a B/C box from an 8 bass (Burke) to a John Williams 12 bass system last weekend. Or at least I think that's what Williams uses on his custom made box.
The process was not as straight forward as I expected it to be, but was facilitated by my having bits and pieces of a 12 bass PA left hand.
==================
==================
 B      b,  Gg, Aa
 C/F c/f,  Dd, Ee (push/pull)           (the E,A,B) have the thirds taped off)



I have to say Wow.... why on earth aren't B/C and C#/D boxes always made with 12 basses. I can hardly begin to describe how much more functional this system is than any of the 8 button versions. Playing the "cup of tea" for example gives one a completely new appreciation for the B chord.  Finally...no more odd fingerings to accommodate chords! No more bad words spoken about the complete lack of chords in certain directions. Now I just have to stop flinching when I am about to play a chord in what would have been the wrong direction on the 8 bass.

In an industrial process I can't imagine the extra 4 buttons and reeds would increase the price a whole lot. I am guessing the 8 bass is simply due to historical baggage, where the designers of these boxes didn't anticipate crossrow playing.

Draw backs? Haven't found any yet. I do think there is a good chance that folks used to listening to modern DADGAD guitar accompaniment won't be very pleased with what seems to lend itself to the 12 bass. So I think I will have to be careful not to overdo the basses in public :-)
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: JohnS on October 22, 2014, 05:46:55 AM
Maybe traffic jam in the sense of random honking?
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: alaskairishbox on October 23, 2014, 03:16:28 AM
There is a style of uilleann piping (Irish bagpipes) associated with folks like Finbar Furey etc. where the regulators are played in rythmic chord blasts, with much less attention given to harmonic support for the tune. To the non-uilleann piper this sounds a whole lot like a traffic jam. BTW The spouse approval rating for this style of playing is very low:)
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: deltasalmon on October 23, 2014, 03:36:01 AM
Rhythmic accompaniment like this: http://youtu.be/ZF8uHVu4Res ?
Title: Re: b/c basses yet again
Post by: alaskairishbox on October 24, 2014, 02:42:45 AM
Here is where that playing style originates from ...at least as far as recorded music is concerned.
Check out minute 6:30. It is Johnny Doran, the man himself.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=abrMpSjRu1Y
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal