Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => News and Events => Topic started by: Theo on September 24, 2013, 09:29:04 AM
-
The English Branch of the British Button Box Brigade BCC# inaugurated itself on the last Sunday of John Kirkpatrick’s accordion workshop at Gleanings in Shropshire 2013. One of the results is a new website set up by Mike Higgins and rejoicing in the title of the British Button Box Brigade (http://www.britishbuttonbox.org/)
-
This a very welcome development, as there is something special about the "British Button Box". As it's the declared English Branch I look forward to the info about the Great Jimmy Shand eventually being replaced by info about the Great John Kirkpatrick and other contemporary players ;) In this respect I do hope George in particular will continue to hang out here.
It's "The" Gleanings, incidentally, essentially a barn conversion on the Hart's smallholding, perfect for small weekend courses. On a brisk April weekend you get to feed the pet lambs; on a more mellow September … they feed you ;)
-
Thanks Theo & Chris - have signed up!. It will hopefully be provide a forum not only for existing BCC# enthusiasts but also for those who are genuinely curious about the one 'sook an blaw' box that eliminates the need to cart around several boxes in different keys!
george ;D
-
Good luck to them. They have chosen a very limiting title, and I imagine it will be, as they say, a very "rare company" indeed.
-
Rarified atmosphere. : )
I recall an interview with Jimmy Shand who said that if he had to do it all over again, he would have opted for the Continental Chromatic Button Accordeon. (CBA)
-
Good luck to them. They have chosen a very limiting title, and I imagine it will be, as they say, a very "rare company" indeed.
I agree Bill, but it can only be a good thing is it increases interest in the British Chromatic box down here. I do however hope that there will be some positive connections with the wider BCC# community!
george
-
I know I am slightly off thread but I wonder excactly how many people play the B/C/C# in the British Isles,a thousand at most maybe ?,I play but I do not no anybody else who plays one.and I know plenty of box players.
-
the chance of knowing the existence of other BCC# players (who may be local to each other) via various ''accordion/melodeon'' forums is not facilitated by the propensity of many to live in the mysterious land of ''nowhere!''
George from sunny anglesey >:E
-
I know I am slightly off thread but I wonder excactly how many people play the B/C/C# in the British Isles,a thousand at most maybe ?,I play but I do not no anybody else who plays one.and I know plenty of box players.
I'd be very surprised if it's anything like as many as that. I've thought that, in Scotland, the number might nudge into the low hundreds (2 or so?); and you probably wouldn't need many hands to count the number in England.
-
Bill may well be right, but I'm sure the difficulty in putting any sort of number on it is down to many lurking in the woodwork so perhaps , just perhaps, the new website will entice a few of the lurkers to go public!
I think the situation in Scotland is very different with more disciples of Sir Jimmy Shand and encouraged by a chain of thriving box and fiddle clubs.
I just hope that the new forum will help to increase knowledge of the 3 row box and that that may in turn encourage a few more to '' have a dabble with the fascinating and versatile instrument some of its detractors refer to as a ''diabolical contraption'' -- which it isn't!
george ;)
-
I know I am slightly off thread but I wonder excactly how many people play the B/C/C# in the British Isles,a thousand at most maybe ?,I play but I do not no anybody else who plays one.and I know plenty of box players.
I'd be very surprised if it's anything like as many as that. I've thought that, in Scotland, the number might nudge into the low hundreds (2 or so?); and you probably wouldn't need many hands to count the number in England.
Now if you're talking about "the British Isles" (a geographical description, which includes Ireland) rather than "Great Britain" (a political one, which doesn't), you shouldn't forget the Irish contingent - and I've actually had B/C/C# boxes made new for players here, in recent years.
Sir Jimmy was a big influence on Irish players back in the '50s, though "the big box" isn't so popular here now and you wouldn't see one too often in a session anymore, but there are still professional players who've been playing it for years (my friend Brendan Mulhaire springs immediately to mind, Donal Ring, Micheál Sexton amongst others, not forgetting Martin McMahon, a wonderful player who used to do 11 regular gigs a week around the London Irish circuit) and more recently Danny O'Mahoney has taken it up (though you'd more usually see him with his B/C), whist some B/C players might dabble on it a bit too.
There are a good-few Shand Morinos this side of the water, and other B/C/C# boxes.
-
Thanks Theo & Chris - have signed up!.
Just signed up, before I noticed it's full name "The British Button Box Brigade (English Section)". I'm sure they won't mind, but I can't quite see why they don't want to encourage Scots, Irish or Welsh players.
-
I think the perhaps longwinded name must have come from a desire to '' root out'' players in England and I am sure all BCCsharpists will be most welcome
george :D
-
It would seem that the British bit refers only to the type of box 8)
It says on their banner heading:
Anything of interest to BCC# players wherever you may live s
... I reckon that's pretty inclusive ;)
;D those who may have imagined that it was a precursor to devolution and the selling off of the colonies can relax now ;D
-
Graham,
I think there's a clue in the "English Section" part of the title. Seems pretty specific, and exclusive, to me.
-
I think the perhaps longwinded name must have come from a desire to '' root out'' players in England and I am sure all BCCsharpists will be most welcome
I'm sure you're correct and my post wasn't completely serious. There may be an element of wanting to encourage more than just Scottish dance music, which is the main BCC# home territory at the moment.
-
The only tutor book that I have come across for the instrument is the Hohner one by Capt. J. Reilly. Its full title is " Melodeon and Button-Key Accordion Tutor, for 1, 2 and 3 row instruments in British Chromatic Tuning " I think it's meant to read as 1 row Melodeon, 2 Row accordion and three row accordion in British Chromatic Tuning.
-
I had a copy of this years ago - from memory the BCC# stuff was very much an afterthought - plus ca change - "tutor" was a bit of an overstatement
-
I must admit I find the title '''' English section'' a bit odd, particularly as I am not aware of a Scottish , Chinese, American or whatever section.
I am totally in favour of a BCC# forum but if it were to be restricted to ''English'' music I feel that it is unlikely to thrive. I am English but play English, Scottish, American, French, Irish and anything else that takes my fancy including skiffle , church music, music hall stuff, brass band stuff etc etc. There is also considerable historic movement of tunes between nations so what is English, Scottish , or whatever can be sometimes difficult to establish.
Also the same tunes crop up for various dance genres, perhaps played at different speeds and with different phrasing etc etc but still the same tunes
Perhaps time and membership origins will dictate as to whether it continues as the ''English Section of '' or assumes a more generic title.
Lest anybody misunderstands me I have joined the new forum and would encourage others so to do --- It is brand new and will ultimately develop along the lines that the majority of members want it to
george
-
I ha
ve posted a post on the BCC# forum drawing attention to the comments made ( including my own ) on this forum, particulary in respect of the forum title sounding perhaps a bit non inclusive.
Mike Higgins the moderator has posted the following response which is both helpful and self explanatory
''The name is provisional so any better ideas are more than welcome.. If people feel excluded then the name has failed dismally. So encourage the mellnetters and anyone else who wants to to come up with something better and I will be delighted''
I also note that the 'english section'' bit of the title has been instantly removed!
george :D
-
Mike's a good bloke (:)
-
George - sorry for this intrusion in to otherwise uncharted territory - but do you think that the 'brigade' could include D/G/accidentals with stradella bass ... or is it purely for semitone between the rows. I fully intend to lurk over there as there could be some great advice to be had for left hand advice ... but then again I could also get that from piano box forums too.
I'm probably going to have to start my own forum with only me in it though as D/G based accordéon mixte system only seems to be present in my house at the moment!
-
Hi Sqeezy. the BCC# forum following an uncertain start now seems to be heading in the right direction with a clearly state aim to encourage all BCC# players and others with an interest in the system to become involved . It is very much in its early formative period and Mike Higgins is to be applauded for taking on board and promptly acting on constructive criticisms including those from me!
Being not much good at the 'computer stuff' I am not personally involved other than as a aforum member but would say that all are welcome to not only browse but to join and contribute as it is only by growing membership that a forum can thrive. From a personal view and taking into account that there are some BCC# boxes around with melodeon bass I would see ''interested parties'' with something similarly arse upards like your DG +acc with stradella bass to be welcome!
George
ps I would in many ways prefer a small 'stradella' set up on a 2 row DG and think it must be a considerable bonus on the almost chromatic quint boxes
-
the BCC# forum is in the process of being revamped on the basis of being a forum for all BCC sharpists wherever they live and whatever type of music they play. I understand that a Scottish BCC sharpist and member of this forum is assisting Mike Higgins in the process.
george
-
The BCC# forum now has a new web address BCC# http://buttonbox.org.uk/index and a much improved forum.
-
Indeed it is, nice 'blue' theme to it (:) looks like they have learned from Melnet without copying it.
They even have one for sale! (though I suspect an ad here might get more views at this early stage). All in all, a very sound rebuild.
-
Thanks, guys. Believe me, Chris, there is a considerable amount of copying involved. Having been part of this great forum since its inception and knowing how well it works, it wasn't difficult to choose the same forum software package and a similar format. We 'advance on the shoulders of giants', as I believe some scientist once said. The appearance is rather nice, and is just one of many 'themes' that the software offers. Having now dipped my toe in the water, my hat goes off to Theo and Clive for the amount of behind-the-scenes work they have done here over the years.
-
I'm pleased to say that one aspect of the Button Box Forum (http://www.buttonbox.org.uk) for BCC# accordions is developing very nicely. That is the Button Box Gallery (http://www.buttonbox.org.uk/Button%20Box%20Gallery/#) (viewable by visitors). The aim is to have a representative photo of as many makes and models of BCC# accordions as possible. It's certainly not complete yet. If any readers have photos of any make or model not yet represented, I'd be delighted to get copies; or to be pointed to any other on-line source.
-
Perhaps of interest to anyone contemplating trying the BCC# system or just plain curious the button box forum ( linked to here) now contains a section of 'notes for newcomers' . Whilst not intended as a course of 'tuition' these will be expanded to provide newcomers with a good knowledge of ''ins and outs'' (pun intended!) of this often misunderstood system.
Also a list of teachers and experienced players willing to help newcomers is being started
george