Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: kenakordeon on September 29, 2013, 05:11:10 PM

Title: case construction
Post by: kenakordeon on September 29, 2013, 05:11:10 PM
As for the case or body of the melodeon, does it make any practical and acoustic sense to build it of a multi-laminate plywood (7 - 9 plys) instead of a solid hardwood?  Would the strength and stability of the plywood offset any possible impairment or loss of the "warmth" of sound that a hardwood gives?  With mitred joints you might not even notice that the case had been constructed of plywood rather than a solid hardwood.  And, with careful staining and finishing it could look as attractive as a hardwood.

Or, is this already being done?

Ken
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: blafleur on September 29, 2013, 06:17:22 PM
There's been lots of arguments on the effect of the case material on sound.  I'm a firm believer it makes a difference, but may not make a lot of difference.  Regarding looks, plywood could be covered in any veneer. My only experience has been comparing hardwood like cocobolo, compared to soft wood like spruce or cypress.  I think there is a noticeable difference.  But differences in sound of an accordion is based on a pretty wide array of variables.

I haven't used plywood for the frames, but I know some builders who have, maybe they will join in.
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: Graham Spencer on September 29, 2013, 06:54:32 PM
My Serenellini Saltarelle is certainly made from veneered ply, as I suspect are many other French Italian boxes.

Graham
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: mory on September 29, 2013, 07:24:03 PM
Yes Graham, but only 3 ply with a thick inner core making a total of approx. 3 1/2mm. So basically a 2mm core+veneer+counter veneer. AtB mory
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: Rob2Hook on September 29, 2013, 09:59:26 PM
I'm pretty sure I've seen a plywood cased Oakwood...  Didn't Stormy Hyde build some from veneered foam?  Surely the only question is how thick a ply and how heavy would it make the finished casework? 

I think you'll have to build it to find out!

Rob.
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: IanD on September 30, 2013, 02:48:49 PM
I'm pretty sure I've seen a plywood cased Oakwood...  Didn't Stormy Hyde build some from veneered foam?  Surely the only question is how thick a ply and how heavy would it make the finished casework? 

I think you'll have to build it to find out!

Rob.
Certainly all the Oakwoods built around the same time as mine (or maybe all of them?) used panels of pre-veneered (birds-eye maple in my case) aircraft ply a few mm thick (very strong and light) set into a solid wood frame forming the corners. The result can be lighter than a case made from solid wood because it can be thinner, which more than makes up for the fact that ply is denser.
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: Graham Spencer on October 01, 2013, 07:14:52 AM
Yes Graham, but only 3 ply with a thick inner core making a total of approx. 3 1/2mm. So basically a 2mm core+veneer+counter veneer. AtB mory

Actually it's 4.5mm 4-ply with a walnut veneer. Just measured it - and incidentally discovered a couple of valves that need replacing!

Graham
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: mory on October 01, 2013, 11:32:20 AM
That's interesting Graham any chance of a snapshot you could post for me. I'd previously thought yours was the same structure as mine.
I'll try and take one of mine later (Got a better camera but not sorted out the tech bit yet)  AtB mory
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: Graham Spencer on October 01, 2013, 12:38:10 PM
Sure - might be tomorrow now as I'm a bit tied up at the moment.

Cheers
Graham
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: Graham Spencer on October 02, 2013, 12:08:57 PM
That's interesting Graham any chance of a snapshot you could post for me. I'd previously thought yours was the same structure as mine.
I'll try and take one of mine later (Got a better camera but not sorted out the tech bit yet)  AtB mory

A couple of shots - the close-up of the corner shows the witness lines where I glued it back together after it was dropped on to a tiled floor....
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: kenakordeon on October 02, 2013, 12:42:18 PM
Thanks for the interesting discussion.  I wonder why more builders don't use a high quality plywood.  As Bryan wrote, it can be covered with any type of veneer and it does solve any future problems with warping, shrinking, splitting, cracking.

Ken
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: mory on October 02, 2013, 01:25:06 PM
Thanks Graham here's the early Nuage with it's core and two veneers. AtB mory

Thanks Ken I think it's better for some boxes definitely. AtB mory
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: Graham Spencer on October 02, 2013, 06:43:34 PM
Several interesting differences there. What year is the Nuage? My Pastourelle is 1991 - and for the record I paid £825 (equivalent of £1500 now) for it brand spanking new (and then however much more - can't remember now - to Nils Nielson to make it playable, including some changes to the low end, and in tune!).

Graham
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: mory on October 02, 2013, 08:26:53 PM
Hi Graham,
well I got it second hand (£995) in early '97 (Jesus '97) but allegedly it had been languishing in the bottom of someone's wardrobe for about 10 years, but I have no proof of that and I had my doubts at the time. Certainly the tin badge was well under way by then I must have been drooling over them for at least a year or more.
Maybe somebody has info as to when the Gold Badge Saltarelles came in. Mairtin O'Connor's Perpetual Motion show's his window 2 1/2 row in 1990 and he plays the Nuage Gold Badge DD# on it, the window ones were around well before that I think.
It would be nice to get a time line sorted for Saltarelles with out opening up the usual run of comments that flood in when they get mentioned. I don't know if Rod is on here but I understand he was the first UK importer. AtB mory
 
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: rees on October 02, 2013, 08:48:17 PM
Ahem! I was the first UK importer (1988 - 1991). I then passed it on to Rod Stradling who developed the Saltarelle Stirling range in conjunction with George Roux.
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: mory on October 02, 2013, 09:48:33 PM
Apologies Rees,
so what can you tell us about the time line of the various types please. I know Sounds Interesting had the UK rep after Rod in '97, but when did the first Gold Badge get here? When did it become the tin badge model? What were the type you were bringing in? All the Best mory
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: rees on October 02, 2013, 11:52:11 PM
Mine were all pre Stirling range so no badges. They were all window models i.e.. Boube, Berry, Pastourelle plus a big black 3 row 4 voice called Morvan.
I lost touch with their development after that.
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: Graham Spencer on October 03, 2013, 05:17:07 AM
Mine's a window model (it's the one in my avatar); I confess I didn't buy it from Rees, but from another well-known dealer......
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: Graham Spencer on October 03, 2013, 07:00:46 AM
I imagine (though I have no proof!) that the different construction of Mory's and my old Saltarelles may be because they were built by different makers; it's well known that they are (or certainly were) actually only assembled in France from Italian-made components. I know mine is actually a rebadged Serenellini; who knows how many other makers are represented under the Saltarelle logo?

Graham
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: mory on October 03, 2013, 08:49:21 AM
Mine too Graham.
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: Owen Woods on October 07, 2013, 04:49:21 PM
The effect of the case is about density, stiffness and surface finish. The latter I think has the most effect (varnish or not varnish). There is probably a difference between plywood and hardwood cases, but I've never been quite convinced in my own mind that different species of wood make that much difference (apart from in extremes and for very thin walls).
Title: Re: case construction
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 07, 2013, 04:53:56 PM
it is a good idea to make them robust enough to sit on
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal