Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: pattcl22 on September 30, 2013, 08:45:21 PM
-
I'm sure this question has been asked before but why is there a B major chord on a D/G melodeon as it isn't native to the scales of D or G major?
-
I won't even attempt to explain it because my music theory isn't all that great but Chris talks about it here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9526.msg118276.html#msg118276)
-
I'll try to answer. Firstly - not all do - many come with B minor instead of B major.
The most convenient minor key to play on a D/G melodeon is E minor - and B major is the chord which goes with harmonic minor tunes.
However the chord you want with a lot of folky minor tunes is B minor that fits tunes in minor modes such as the dorian.
The reason that many players leave the B major chord unchanged is that you can 'fudge' a B minor 7th by playing the D chord with the B bass - and still have the major chord available for tunes that need it.
Alternatively many players will tape off the reed which makes the chord major (D#) leaving them with a neutral chord that can fit either major or minor harmony. Similarly if your instrument has a stop which removes all the thirds from the chords then this achieves the same thing.
Hope that makes sense,
Squeezy
-
Thanks Deltasalmon and Squeezy, my basic knowledge of music theory can just about cope with the explanations. I hadn't thought about the minor keys.
-
as above. Basically it's "about" the harmonic minor, with hangover effects from the transposition of the European G/C box into D/G "so that we could play with fiddles".
Em harmonic isn't a big part of our tradition, which is more about the dorian Em, conveniently based on our D row notes (starting second note up).
Having the minor dominant (V) chord as major makes a lot more sense in French, Baltic, Balkan or Klesmer traditions, which have big harmonic minor tune sets. If you want to play this stuff in Em you'll be happy as Larry.
For folkie dorian/simple minor tunes opinion here seems to be to make a Bm using D push on a B base, rather than tape out or retune the D#. That way you keep the best of both worlds.
-
Of course the way that 2 row D/G boxes tend to traditionally arrive from "the continent" - you wouldn't quite be happy as Larry not having the necessary D# to play with your B major as tradition seems to dictate that the "normal" way the accidentals should be arranged on the bottom two buttons of the instrument is with the D# on the pull!!!