Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Orma on October 04, 2013, 08:29:30 PM

Title: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Orma on October 04, 2013, 08:29:30 PM
Hello all,
I've spent several hours looking at threads about the pros and cons of the club system, very informative.
A  thought occurred to me whilst I was reading the various opinions about the system, most of whom were from box players of many years standing.
My question is: if you were fairly new to box playing (with less ingrained technique) would you embrace the club system or shun it.
Answers particularly in relation to music of a more "continental flavour" would be heartily welcome.
Thanks
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Cooper on October 04, 2013, 09:02:32 PM
Hello all,
I've spent several hours looking at threads about the pros and cons of the club system, very informative.
A  thought occurred to me whilst I was reading the various opinions about the system, most of whom were from box players of many years standing.
My question is: if you were fairly new to box playing (with less ingrained technique) would you embrace the club system or shun it.
Answers particularly in relation to music of a more "continental flavour" would be heartily welcome.
Thanks

 I would suggest chosing from 3 systems, not 2. Dutch inversion is best imo,
W
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Orma on October 04, 2013, 09:23:40 PM

 I would suggest chosing from 3 systems, not 2. Dutch inversion is best imo,
W
Is this a 5th button inversion on the inner row?  How does that effect the rest of the inner row keys and the 4th start buttons on "club type" Hohners. Also what are the benefits of this compared to "club".
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: pikey on October 04, 2013, 11:25:08 PM
Embrace.
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Orma on October 04, 2013, 11:55:16 PM
Embrace.
Would you care to elaborate?
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: squeezy on October 05, 2013, 12:18:14 AM
I can't explain the embrace thing ... But I would say that if you've never played any diatonic - the Dutch reversal system where the D and C button on the 3rd button from the start of the scale on a D/G has much to commend it for versatility.

If, however, you already play standard fingering melodeon then I would suggest keeping that part of the keyboard familiar as I'm not sure the re-learning required would outweigh the benefits.
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Orma on October 05, 2013, 12:55:03 AM
I can't explain the embrace thing ... But I would say that if you've never played any diatonic - the Dutch reversal system where the D and C button on the 3rd button from the start of the scale on a D/G has much to commend it for versatility.

If, however, you already play standard fingering melodeon then I would suggest keeping that part of the keyboard familiar as I'm not sure the re-learning required would outweigh the benefits.
Yes I do play standard fingering melodeon (in an okay fashion) learnt on a one row. I now have a Hohner Club system C/F and obviously have no experience of playing across the rows (or playing multi chord/basses), but I'd really like to. With this in mind I have the option to learn with the club system or de-club which might be easier initially. For all sorts of reasons (not all even musical) using the club system on a club box really appeals.
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Theo on October 05, 2013, 09:43:24 AM
For all sorts of reasons (not all even musical) using the club system on a club box really appeals.

Well in that case just give it a go.   Here is a nice precedent for you.  Bob Fox (http://www.bobfoxmusic.com), guitar player and singer, had to learn melodeon from scratch in 4 months to audition for the part of Songman in the National Theatre production of Warhorse.  He got the part (http://www.talkawhile.co.uk/yabbse/index.php?topic=39375.0) and is now in the touring version that opened in Plymouth last week.  He plays club system.
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Anahata on October 05, 2013, 09:54:47 AM
Yes I do play standard fingering melodeon (in an okay fashion) learnt on a one row. I now have a Hohner Club system C/F and obviously have no experience of playing across the rows (or playing multi chord/basses), but I'd really like to. With this in mind I have the option to learn with the club system or de-club which might be easier initially.

If you de-club now you'll never learn the club system!
The one row is quite a different instrument and you won't have any trouble playing both; anyway, the outer row of a club box is the same as a one row.

The only reason I haven't switched to 100% club is because I've spent so many years playing the other system
and switching would be hard. I have two C/F club boxes; I'm thinking of getting one of them retuned to D/G club so I can take it to sessions and get some practice in; I might yet make the full switch.
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Orma on October 05, 2013, 10:06:53 AM
For all sorts of reasons (not all even musical) using the club system on a club box really appeals.

Well in that case just give it a go.   Here is a nice precedent for you.  Bob Fox (http://www.bobfoxmusic.com), guitar player and singer, had to learn melodeon from scratch in 4 months to audition for the part of Songman in the National Theatre production of Warhorse.  He got the part (http://www.talkawhile.co.uk/yabbse/index.php?topic=39375.0) and is now in the touring version that opened in Plymouth last week.  He plays club system.
Thanks Theo,
I suppose it comes down to that sentence really. Just wanting to play a club box in the way it was initially designed to be played, not logical and perhaps decidedly odd considering it is already de-clubbed. I can't really put my finger on it though, it just seems to me "right".
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Orma on October 05, 2013, 10:10:43 AM
Yes I do play standard fingering melodeon (in an okay fashion) learnt on a one row. I now have a Hohner Club system C/F and obviously have no experience of playing across the rows (or playing multi chord/basses), but I'd really like to. With this in mind I have the option to learn with the club system or de-club which might be easier initially.

If you de-club now you'll never learn the club system
Thanks Anahata,
I'd posted my reply to Theo whilst you were sending  this.
Club it is then and the odd step of re-clubbing. Re-reading my post it does give the impression of having a clubbed box.....just the odd way I put down my thoughts.  ???
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Microbot on October 05, 2013, 10:34:55 AM
Hi Orma and all,

Encouraging words from Theo and I'd agree fully with Anahata.

... there's a point to add that (for me) backs up what Anahata is saying. When you are familiar with the conventional system and constantly playing it as your 'default' layout, and only using the Club layout as a 'try-out' venture, it can take some time to get used to the Club system. That is what I did....

....So for me, it's taken years to get familiar with the possibilities the Club layout opens up. I think the one thing I should have done (but didn't) is learn some new tunes on the Club system first ... tunes that I didn't already play on a conventional box, and tunes which really 'use' the Club potential. That would probably have got me there quicker!

... and remember ... the changes are reversible ... you can de-Club and re-Club! Replacement reeds for most Hohner models are readily available if required ... and the tuning work involved is not major ...

cheers

Mike
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 05, 2013, 10:44:02 AM
For all sorts of reasons (not all even musical) using the club system on a club box really appeals.

Well in that case just give it a go.   Here is a nice precedent for you.  Bob Fox (http://www.bobfoxmusic.com), guitar player and singer, had to learn melodeon from scratch in 4 months to audition for the part of Songman in the National Theatre production of Warhorse.  He got the part (http://www.talkawhile.co.uk/yabbse/index.php?topic=39375.0) and is now in the touring version that opened in Plymouth last week.  He plays club system.

.. though young Bob 'd been "playing the clubs" for nigh on 25 years now, Bonny Lad! :|glug

More seriously - utterly logical, and terribly difficult to relearn all your old repertoire and make the switch. I think I'd recommend Club to anyone starting up. In fact I am about to do just that ...
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: squeezy on October 05, 2013, 11:02:40 AM
May I just add the footnote that many non-club 2.5 row systems have the D pull that the club gives (I'm talking about an instrument in D/G by the way) very nearby on the half-row of the keyboard - they also often have the push C which the dutch reversal would give you too. 

This effectively gives an instrument which is just as versatile on the right hand - but with the added bonus that if you feel like picking up somebody else's standard 2 row then it won't feel unusual.  But if you feel that club is the way forward then it's a very good system too.
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Orma on October 05, 2013, 11:10:02 AM
Hi Orma and all,

Encouraging words from Theo and I'd agree fully with Anahata.

... there's a point to add that (for me) backs up what Anahata is saying. When you are familiar with the conventional system and constantly playing it as your 'default' layout, and only using the Club layout as a 'try-out' venture, it can take some time to get used to the Club system. That is what I did....

....So for me, it's taken years to get familiar with the possibilities the Club layout opens up. I think the one thing I should have done (but didn't) is learn some new tunes on the Club system first ... tunes that I didn't already play on a conventional box, and tunes which really 'use' the Club potential. That would probably have got me there quicker!

... and remember ... the changes are reversible ... you can de-Club and re-Club! Replacement reeds for most Hohner models are readily available if required ... and the tuning work involved is not major ...

cheers

Mike
Thanks Mike,
Interesting points, even though I been bothering tunes on a one row for a while, learning the club would be as a beginner with no "finger memory"
Chuff-ed (in Joke)
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Orma on October 05, 2013, 11:11:47 AM
For all sorts of reasons (not all even musical) using the club system on a club box really appeals.

Well in that case just give it a go.   Here is a nice precedent for you.  Bob Fox (http://www.bobfoxmusic.com), guitar player and singer, had to learn melodeon from scratch in 4 months to audition for the part of Songman in the National Theatre production of Warhorse.  He got the part (http://www.talkawhile.co.uk/yabbse/index.php?topic=39375.0) and is now in the touring version that opened in Plymouth last week.  He plays club system.

.. though young Bob 'd been "playing the clubs" for nigh on 25 years now, Bonny Lad! :|glug

More seriously - utterly logical, and terribly difficult to relearn all your old repertoire and make the switch. I think I'd recommend Club to anyone starting up. In fact I am about to do just that ...
Thanks Chris for your comments and suggestions, not just on this thread, but others I've posted.
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Orma on October 05, 2013, 11:15:40 AM
May I just add the footnote that many non-club 2.5 row systems have the D pull that the club gives (I'm talking about an instrument in D/G by the way) very nearby on the half-row of the keyboard - they also often have the push C which the dutch reversal would give you too. 

This effectively gives an instrument which is just as versatile on the right hand - but with the added bonus that if you feel like picking up somebody else's standard 2 row then it won't feel unusual.  But if you feel that club is the way forward then it's a very good system too.
Thanks Sqeezy,
Thanks for the advice, but I do think the club system is for me and not just for musical reasons.......odd I know, but it'll just feel "right". Can't really explain any better than that really!
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: squeezy on October 05, 2013, 11:16:19 AM
No - that makes perfect sense!
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: pikey on October 05, 2013, 01:17:30 PM
Embrace.

If you have a club box then embrace the system it provides!
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Ollie on October 05, 2013, 01:37:59 PM
May I just add the footnote that many non-club 2.5 row systems have the D pull that the club gives (I'm talking about an instrument in D/G by the way) very nearby on the half-row of the keyboard - they also often have the push C which the dutch reversal would give you too. 

This effectively gives an instrument which is just as versatile on the right hand - but with the added bonus that if you feel like picking up somebody else's standard 2 row then it won't feel unusual.  But if you feel that club is the way forward then it's a very good system too.

Surely the dutch reversal gives a push E, not a push C, on a D/G system? 
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Orma on October 05, 2013, 01:59:55 PM
Embrace.

If you have a club box then embrace the system it provides!
It's actually been de-clubbed, but I suppose that's why I want to return it to a club box. Embracing what it was designed to be, so to speak.
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: squeezy on October 05, 2013, 09:09:00 PM
Surely the dutch reversal gives a push E, not a push C, on a D/G system? 

Yes - of course it does ... my mistake
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Peter Savage on October 06, 2013, 06:35:43 AM
Is a "Dutch Reversal" usually just that one button flipped?  Or is it done in all octaves to effective create an Em row?
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Ollie on October 06, 2013, 09:23:32 AM
Is a "Dutch Reversal" usually just that one button flipped?  Or is it done in all octaves to effective create an Em row?

Just the one button. Flipping them all is wandering into the realms of Ukebert :P
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: waltzman on October 06, 2013, 06:05:02 PM
Given all this praise for the club system (which has been around a long time) any thoughts on why it isn't more popular than it is now?  Why hasn't it displaced the standard system in popularity?
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 06, 2013, 06:15:23 PM
Custom, practice, and dealer perception of what the English market wants? Had my original Hohner (a present) been a Club, I suspect I'd be playing one now.

The systems is theoretically sound and useful; it's the "unlearning" that is the problem
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: squeezy on October 06, 2013, 06:41:21 PM
I think it has something to do with players wanting to be able to switch from 1 row to 2 row to 3 rows without changing the core keyboard.

However, with the steriche systems with up to 4 rows, they've extended the gleichton idea further.
Title: Re: Club or Unclubbed
Post by: forrest on October 07, 2013, 08:54:55 PM
Further into the labyrinth here:http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3851.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3851.0.html) >:E
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal