Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: Bob7up on October 06, 2013, 01:46:30 AM
-
When playing a chromatic CBA in C griff (or B for that matter) are you supposed to run your fingers straight across the rows like on a diatonic melodeon or do you run them at an angle ??
-
I was interested as I angle my fingers on melodeon ;) I suspect there may be only one possible answer here compared to melodeonic on row playing. If you finger a row on a CBA don't you get diminished scale?
Hope an experienced CBAer wil pop along soon and explain
-
There is a well-known tutor by Ferrero backed at the time I think by Hohner (1940s?).
In there they trumpet the "modernisation" of their method with the move from diagonal to the one-true-way of same as a piano.
I don't really get why there is so much either/or talk.
If you look at melodeon/BCC# players you can see both ways used - tends to be straight on for on-the-row and angled to cross them
I don't think the answer is necessarily to look at top players on Youtbe - it may be that they are great players because they overcame the quirks of their tutors, unlike the rest of us who may well give up.
I feel the "natural" choice (C system) is straight across when you are basically using a chord but angling for runs in particular if using the 5rows.
On the other hand runs are quite comfortable "straight on" over 3 rows but in that case I reckon you need to be using the thumb.
In other words - it depends and that's part of the fun. I think melodeon players may have an advantage because you are so often looking at options - same with the CBA.
-
To answer Chris:
If you stick to a row you get a diminished chord - one per row * 4notes = full house.
Major, minor, Dom7th, 6th chords you form using 2 adjacent rows (rows>3) hence the "straight on" position.
-
I don't know what you're supposed to do (haven't had any lessons on the CBA yet), but I usually play straight across - using all 5 rows, and not following the chromatic layout. It's the most comfortable position and allows me to leave little finger & thumb in their natural positions.
However, I've only been playing CBA for 10 weeks, so what do I know...