I tend to keep out of these discussions on H&S grounds but would cautiously offer my own reaction, about 15 years old now. I've not come across Dermot at all, but did get to a Luke Daniels concert. I believe they said he had just won an all Ireland title.
His virtuosity in carrying a reel through all 12 keys was simply awesome; not a note out of place. However, when it came to what I would term "real music", well, it was sort of the same. I found it metronomically accurate, but his music failed (I'm afraid) to move my soul; and (contrary to assertions here) I do like listen to … particularly West Coast stuff. To be fair, his performance ticked all my "not speeding it up" boxes ;) perhaps too much?
But I recall feeling it was a bit like some of the computer generated stuff, prevalent at the time. Before I am shot down in flames, might I say that I felt the exactly same wrt an electronic rhythm box that Andy Cutting towed about for a season, around the same time.
NB there is no "wrong" way to play Irish (or any other) music
There is no "wrong" way for an individual to relate to it emotionally