Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: voyager on October 14, 2013, 12:33:59 PM
-
Can anybody explain why some mel have a flat keyboard and others have stepped is there any preference and why ? :||:
-
Well, my Saltarelle has a stepped keyboard because that's the way it came, and my Hohners all have flat keyboards because that's the way they came. I know some players have preferences for one or the other and have all kinds of arcane reasons for it, but personally I don't find it makes a scrap of difference. Just my opinion.......
Graham
-
That's a bit like asking why some people are tall while others are short - they're just the way they're made. They both do the job. Same with preferences - you'll find that often, one man's meat is another man's poison.
Personally, I play the lot - flat and stepped, open and closed. They all work fine for me.
-
Stepped keyboards look nice and traditional, and "stepped" whereas flat ones look nice and "flat" ;) I don't notice any difference in the playing, and just had to look to check the both mine are … flat ;D
-
"don't cares" would be more apposite?
[edit] correction, as my technique improves, even I am doing the odd "roll". OK, it is a bit easier than on my previous stepped kit. Though you could get close to it on the inner row. Outer row … not so easy ::)
-
Before the introduction of aluminum most treble levers consisted of a visible wooden and a hidden metallic part (still present in some less costly Castagnari models). With such a type of construction a stepped keyboard is almost a necessity, as there is hardly any other way to build it without the 2 rows interfering with each other. Whether this made the actual playing more comfortable or not was not a major concern.
-
I sometimes think the main reason for having stepped and flat keyboards is to give us something to disagree about and to force us to devise 'logical' explanations for our preference. Martin
-
... stepped keyboards are often said to be better for using the thumb.
That'd be on a Continental chromatic, not a melodeon.
I have noticed that some players actively avoid one or the other - perhaps one of them will respond?
Stepped keyboards are still "normal" on melodeons in many countries, and with the Italian accordion factories (where flat keyboards are often a "special order" and cost extra), but they are not generally considered suitable for Irish music - mainly because it seriously impedes the playing of the "roll" ornamentation. And before anybody says - yes, I know Sharon Shannon successfully plays a Castagnari "Tommy" (in fact I sold her first one to her, and a "Lilly") with a stepped keyboard, but a notable feature of her playing is that she doesn't play "rolls"...
-
There is another feature that has not yet been mentioned. There are two types of buttons in general use -1) mushroom shaped buttons which have a felt washer underneath that limits the downward travel of the button. Stepped keyboards use these, but there are also flat keyboards that have mushroom buttons. 2) the second type are those found only on flat keyboards where the button travel is stopped inside the keyboard by the lever or its mount meeting a felted surface.
-
I've read that about half of steirische harmonika players use their thumb. Found one fellow on YT who was doing such. I thought the big selling point for flat keyboards with Irish music was that you could slide a finger from the outside in, also. Never heard about the steps being a hindrance to gracing for rolls - presumably this is playing a note on the inside row and gracing with the outer one, usually to get a note a semitone lower. But why not just grace with the next note down on the row you're on? Not an expert by any means here, too, I just play the box for fun, I've never gotten the hang of 5 note rolls anyway, I just do the note-cut-silence-note type roll without a lower pitched grace in it in the first place. But am curious, do most able box players use the other row for the pat (lower pitched grace note)?
-
Past thread here: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,11598.msg143485.html#msg143485
Cheers
Steve
-
Many Thanks for all the info, the reason I posed the question was because of my arthritis I was interested if there was any ergonomic reason for having a stepped keyboard
but I will stick with my Polkawork and modify how I play.
Keep squeezing