Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: rees on October 18, 2013, 12:04:02 PM

Title: Tales from the workshop
Post by: rees on October 18, 2013, 12:04:02 PM
Yesterday I had a Corona III in for some spot tuning.
The front reed block would not come out.
Upon further examination I could see that someone had replaced one of the small grille screws with a big long nail.
This nail was so long that it had reached the reed block and neatly pushed a reed back into the slot.
I chopped the nail off and was then able to take the reed block out. Oddly enough, when I checked that reed it was perfectly in tune!
It's a jungle out there.  (:)
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: 911377brian on October 18, 2013, 12:55:40 PM
More of the same please Rees.. (:)
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Rob2Hook on October 18, 2013, 01:21:49 PM
Didn't early Coronas have nailed in reeds, anyway? ;D

Rob.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Theo on October 18, 2013, 02:14:18 PM
Don't get me started about silicone rubber. >:(
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: rees on October 18, 2013, 02:18:08 PM
Don't get me started about silicone rubber. >:(

Oh yes, great for sealing bellows frames - PERMANENTLY!!!

I've also seen it used instead of reed wax - NOOOOO!!!
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: martin p on October 18, 2013, 02:46:37 PM
Rawlplugs seems a bit industrial, but I did recently fix loose screws inside a box by pushing a shaved down matchstick into the over-sized screw hole. Trim off surplus on both ends and now screws up tight. I use this trick around the home also for loose door hinge screws etc, using suitable sized dowling.

 
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on October 18, 2013, 04:38:05 PM
OH! The wondrous world of the Chanson.
Super glue, putty, paste, car paint the odd log or two and... And...ah! Candle wax.  And a clothes peg or two  :o
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Etienne on October 18, 2013, 07:00:16 PM
and... And...ah! Candle wax.

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8520/8632206898_6ca135db22.jpg)
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: mory on October 18, 2013, 07:51:32 PM
Nearly as bad as the hot glue gun method  :o AtB mory
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Anahata on October 18, 2013, 08:03:23 PM
Hot glue is impossible to get off!
I guess the problem with candle wax is it's too brittle.
Reed wax is OK for attaching some pallets - those illustrated, for example, where there's a groove giving plenty of contact are between pallet and lever.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Owen Woods on October 18, 2013, 09:34:13 PM
Please post more of these (:)
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Theo on October 18, 2013, 11:12:42 PM
Home made valves, looking like shoe leather, on the high reeds where there should be none.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: malcolmbebb on October 18, 2013, 11:41:00 PM
Hmm, you'd expect shoe leather on the low reeds, I suppose.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on October 18, 2013, 11:55:35 PM
Hmm, you'd expect shoe leather on the low reeds, I suppose.

Yep, that's their sole purpose!  8)
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on October 18, 2013, 11:59:08 PM
Hmm, you'd expect shoe leather on the low reeds, I suppose.

Yep, that's their sole purpose!  8)

Or even found in a WELT Meister ?
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Rog on October 19, 2013, 12:25:10 AM
Hot glue is impossible to get off!
I guess the problem with candle wax is it's too brittle.
Reed wax is OK for attaching some pallets - those illustrated, for example, where there's a groove giving plenty of contact are between pallet and lever.

Actually, what *is* hot glue good for? I couldn't even get it to seal up a leaky water butt (twice), it sets almost instantaneously, is impossible to apply accurately etc..
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Anahata on October 19, 2013, 01:10:38 AM
Actually, what *is* hot glue good for?

We use it at work for gluing parts of electronic assemblies together, e.g. heavy components on boards, where the only other thing holding them on is two soldered wires that wouldn't last long under vibration conditions.
Similarly to stop connectors shaking apart.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: boxcall on October 19, 2013, 01:17:24 AM
Yesterday I had a Corona III in for some spot tuning.
The front reed block would not come out.
Upon further examination I could see that someone had replaced one of the small grille screws with a big long nail.
This nail was so long that it had reached the reed block and neatly pushed a reed back into the slot.
I chopped the nail off and was then able to take the reed block out. Oddly enough, when I checked that reed it was perfectly in tune!
It's a jungle out there.  (:)
This is bound to happen when everybody thinks bigger is better  >:E

Actually, what *is* hot glue good for? I couldn't even get it to seal up a leaky water butt (twice), it sets almost instantaneously, is impossible to apply accurately etc..
Crafts? or temporary repairs. I find it only has short term strength,  I use it in box (not melodeon) making to hold the top
to the sides then flush cut the top with router. It has enough tack for the job  but I can take it apart after with a thin blade.
Trouble is all the strands of glue everywhere
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Graham Collicutt on October 19, 2013, 07:17:24 AM


Actually, what *is* hot glue good for?

!5 years ago I replaced broken handle on garden fork with a suitable length of steel water piped and then re-attached plastic top part of old handle. This was glued with copious quantity of hot melt applying glue to heated steel pipe. It has never moved since but you could separate just by reheating.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Lester on October 19, 2013, 07:30:27 AM
Hot glue is impossible to get off!

No it isn't at least I can get it off quite successfully
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on October 19, 2013, 08:20:49 AM
Hot glue is impossible to get off!

No it isn't at least I can get it off quite successfully
[/quote

I agree with Lester, a hair dryer and a wood scraper should do the trick.
Don't confuse the hot glue gun with hot melt, two very different animals
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Anahata on October 19, 2013, 09:35:45 AM
Don't confuse the hot glue gun with hot melt, two very different animals

I probably was.  :|bl
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: pikey on October 19, 2013, 11:01:02 AM
Rawlplugs seems a bit industrial, but I did recently fix loose screws inside a box by pushing a shaved down matchstick into the over-sized screw hole. Trim off surplus on both ends and now screws up tight. I use this trick around the home also for loose door hinge screws etc, using suitable sized dowling.

 

Same here. Works every time. Just remember to strike the match first !
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 19, 2013, 11:05:16 AM
Ditto - done this a lot in household repairs. A single piece of match can move screws off centre though, and sometimes a sliver both sides is better. It's subtle stuff. Even repairing windows IME a single match has lasted all morning!
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Theo on October 19, 2013, 11:29:24 AM
Back to topic:
Repairs to cracks in woodwork where glue is plastered onto cracks and forced into cracks, but not clamped to close the crack.  Just had to discard a reed lock done like this because it was impossible to get all the old hard glue out to do a proper repair. 

Now if the folk who botch repairs could be persuaded to use scotch glue...
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: mory on October 19, 2013, 12:16:42 PM
it's the Scotch before the glue that does it Theo  ;) AtB mory
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Rob2Hook on October 19, 2013, 12:19:37 PM
Don't get me started about silicone rubber. >:(

I believe Theo is still having nightmares after rebuilding my Preciosa - a difficult box to work on at the best of times, but it had all the treble reeds "stuck" in with RTV.  It did make a strange sound!  Current project is to make a new reed pan as the reed wax doesn't stick properly to the contaminated surface...

Rob.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Christopher K. on October 19, 2013, 07:38:14 PM
I bought a Hohner on eBay described as a "project," no photos of the the reeds. When it arrived I found many signs of attempted repair including the reeds covered in rosin core solder. Mess!
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Theo on October 19, 2013, 10:01:11 PM
I've seen solder applied to the middle of reeds to lower the pitch. Disaster! Done by somebody on E Anglua apparently.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on October 20, 2013, 02:19:16 AM
I agree totally that the use of solder on the middle of the reeds is a disaster.

However, I'm sure that Theo or Christopher would not completely condemn the use of solder in tuning if done carefully, and only at the tips of reeds. I have successfully retuned a set of Preciosa treble reeds from CF to AD (3 semitones) using solder on EVERY reed. Little, if any, loss of response, and pretty easily reversible.

But I would stress the word "carefully"....and remember to clean off any solder or rosin that has run onto the back or edges of the reed.

I doubt that the amount of time the reed is subject to heat would much alter the temper of the steel, though I use a heat sink just in case. I would welcome comments on this aspect....



Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Theo on October 20, 2013, 09:02:32 AM
Conpletely agree Malcolm. Though if I wanted an AD Preciosa the Bb/Eb would have been a closer starting point!

Regarding heat drawing the temper of steel, it's not the length of time that is critical, it is the temperature, and typical soft soldering temperature is well below the level that will damage spring steel.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on October 20, 2013, 09:32:11 AM
Though if I wanted an AD Preciosa the Bb/Eb would have been a closer starting point!

It wasn't that I really, really, really wanted an A/D Preciosa.
It was more a matter of what to do with the impulse buy of a C/F that was surplus to requirements!

MAD remains endemic in these parts....
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Adam-T on October 21, 2013, 07:27:56 AM
A box I picked up had a reed missing from the chord section of the bass , I found it, someone had araldited it into a blank slot in one of the treble reedblocks ..

On an Italian B/C I bought to rebuild, someone had put all the bass end reeds back with builders mastic , the ones which actually sounded were in the wrong place..
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on October 21, 2013, 08:13:53 AM
Ceraphobia, I believe it's called. Fear of wax....
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Adam-T on October 21, 2013, 10:35:53 AM
I`ve seen candle wax before as well, less dramatic as it does no damage - well not if the reeds stay in place anyway..

Far worse was a recent Student-1 bass block had the large bass reeds Nailed in with those short galvanized roofing felt nails after being stuck in with Evostik upside down in the wrong place, I had a lot of clamping and hole filling (with cocktail sticks) to do to save that reedblock .

A known repairer (not of this forum I may add) who will remain nameless had lathered the front soundboard to frame edges and corners of a 4 stop I bought with reedwax to try and seal it, I couldn`t remove it to do a proper repair on the soundboard but managed to sort the corners after a hard time removing as much wax as possible.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Lester on October 21, 2013, 08:53:03 PM
Don't invite one of our illustrious moderators into your workshop then knock you mug of tea over all your tools  :o
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: rees on October 21, 2013, 09:31:59 PM
Don't invite one of our illustrious moderators into your workshop then knock you mug of tea over all your tools  :o

Snigger  ;)
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 21, 2013, 10:39:25 PM
My linota concertina had had an accident. The right end hexagon from had been damaged. Having bought it, I noticed that (judging from a string line) 1/3 of the hexagon had been glued back upside down,

Fast forward 20 years, got it to the Dippers "to put into playable state" … 2 years … oh, it's in one of the boxes. Boxes! Yes, bad previous repair, it'd have warped in another 20 or so years. Slow forward another 2 years and a bribe of a bottle of bordeaux. String line finally straight. Now sold and funded a nice melodeon.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Kimric Smythe on October 24, 2013, 04:01:29 AM
I currently have a old one row pokerwork that someone nailed the wood keyboard to the body. Had another one where someone had put wood glue all around the keyboard of a two row and glued it down (loads of fun getting that loose)
 Lots of audio tape used for valves (it works pretty well for awhile but it seems to curl after a bit from what I see). The one I was impressed by,as I would never think it would work ,was to cut off the tip of a reed and block the resulting gap with tape to get a higher note using an old bass side reed. The other is to lower pitch by adding nail polish or wax to reed tips (pain in the ass to tune later)
 The repairs in the second group are mostly from Mexico where there are few if any repair shops or available spares.

I have a Bandeoneon that Tom Waits purchased somewhere,it had been dropped or crushed, badly glued back together,then carefully  sanded and painted. You had to take it apart to figure out why it was leaking all over, it would be an insane repair job. Mr. Waits bought a newer AA that I had just rebuilt instead.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: pikey on October 24, 2013, 07:57:59 AM
THE Tom Waits, the one who's piano has been drinking ? Wow, awesome !

Btw I used white enamel paint on my pokerwork reeds to lower the pitch. It works, it's easy to scrap a bit off to bring the pitch back up a bit, and it's easy to remove totally if required using a blade and a dab of thinners.

It's the 'hobby' paint that's used on plastic models (used to be Humbrol paint in the UK)
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on October 24, 2013, 09:01:03 AM
THE Tom Waits, the one who's piano has been drinking ? Wow, awesome !

Hmmm. Who'd have thought Mr W was a closet bandoneonista.
Wonder if he plays other free reed boxes?

Any other repairers here with famous (and/or unlikely) customers?  A bit of workshop name-dropping perhaps? Or would it constitute a breach of confidence?



Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Howard Jones on October 24, 2013, 08:10:52 PM
Some of these bodged repairs sound fairly horrific.  But let's not forget that until recently, with the advent of the internet and this forum, it was very difficult for the ordinary player to find out any information about how to repair melodeons, or even how to contact someone who did.  It's hardly surprising that people tried to fix problems themselves, or that some of them made mistakes.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Theo on October 24, 2013, 08:27:08 PM

Any other repairers here with famous (and/or unlikely) customers?  A bit of workshop name-dropping perhaps? Or would it constitute a breach of confidence?

I have supplied boxes to Bob Fox which he played in the London Production of War Horse.  He is now in the touring version if the show.  Until a few weeks before audition Bob had never played melodeon, but he makes great use of them to accompany himself singing.
The boxes are a pair of Hohner Erikas with gleichton, one CF, one DG.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: pikey on October 24, 2013, 10:17:43 PM
The same Bob Fox of Bob Fox and Stu Luckley? That takes me back!  (:)
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Theo on October 24, 2013, 10:28:34 PM
The very same.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Christopher K. on October 25, 2013, 02:18:30 AM
Quote
I have a Bandeoneon that Tom Waits purchased somewhere,it had been dropped or crushed, badly glued back together,then carefully  sanded and painted. You had to take it apart to figure out why it was leaking all over, it would be an insane repair job. Mr. Waits bought a newer AA that I had just rebuilt instead.

That's funny, before I got to the very end of the post, I was going to ask if the broken bandoneon was something he used in Rain Dogs. Seems like it might fit in with all those sad characters and broken sounds.

And I guess it's a sufficiently common tendency among some part of our species. Because I, too, have a Hohner with a nailed-on wooden keyboard. It also has a nailed-on grille, nailed-on reed blocks, a prodigious crack in the fondo, and what looks like book tape used in lieu of bellows tape. Miraculously, the reeds weren't ever touched. It's as if the repairer thought there weren't enough nails stuck in this accordion, so he'd add a few more.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Theo on October 25, 2013, 07:25:37 AM
Bellows repaired with gaffa tape is one if my pet hates.  The stuff is so sticky that even of you can remove it without tearing off the decorative paper in the valleys, you still have a sticky residue to remove before you can do the job properly.
And then there are the bellows with layers and layers of Sellotape, masking tape, carpet tape, insulating tape and gaffa tape like geological strata - and the bellows still leak.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Adam-T on October 25, 2013, 08:34:35 AM
The saddest I heard of was on this forum a while back where someone a long time ago saw a destitute concertina player (in ireland if I remember rightly) who had dog-ends replacing missing buttons
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 25, 2013, 09:10:40 AM
Hmmm, I had a concertina with yellowed buttons once! ???
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Howard Jones on October 25, 2013, 09:50:40 AM
Bellows repaired with gaffa tape is one if my pet hates. 

I'm afraid I've been guilty of that, and also (as referred to in a previous post) using candle wax on reeds.  Both seemed to do the job.  This was many years ago when I had no idea how to get hold of the proper materials, or even where to start looking.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Theo on October 25, 2013, 09:58:53 AM
Bellows repaired with gaffa tape is one if my pet hates. 

I'm afraid I've been guilty of that, and also (as referred to in a previous post) using candle wax on reeds.  Both seemed to do the job.  This was many years ago when I had no idea how to get hold of the proper materials, or even where to start looking.

Don't worry Howard, you are not alone!  A least candle wax is easily removed, and does make a good repair if that is all that is available.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: triskel on October 25, 2013, 01:10:06 PM
The saddest I heard of was on this forum a while back where someone a long time ago saw a destitute concertina player (in ireland if I remember rightly) who had dog-ends replacing missing buttons

I don't know about dog-ends, but you'd hear tales of the old players of the German concertina, here in West Clare, replacing missing buttons with rolled-up cardboard glued onto the wooden levers - in fact I've got one, that's been left with me at the moment, with rolled-up gummed paper replacing a missing button. Maybe that's what they actually saw?

The other "classic" concertina/melodeon repair that you'd hear of would be using goose quills for springs, which might sound apocryphal but I've seen it/had to fix it several times. In fact I've got one of those in my workshop too - a yellow 20-key "Ceili Band" (Scholer) that originally belonged to "Baby" Crehan (mother of the renowned fiddle and concertina player "Junior" Crehan).

Still, (bringing us back to the fags) no worse than Oscar Woods' "fix" of a Woodbine's packet behind the spoon-bass keys of his Hohner 4-stopper...
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Kimric Smythe on October 25, 2013, 05:33:59 PM
Mr Waits purchased the bandeoneon about 6 years ago ,not sure if he has used it in a recording, he has a huge collection of instruments including a calliope. I never met him, but I talked to him on the phone and he really sounds like that.

On another note, I had a button box that had half of the missing buttons replaced by thumbtacks.
Title: Re: Tales from the workshop
Post by: Christopher K. on October 25, 2013, 09:31:50 PM
The saddest I heard of was on this forum a while back where someone a long time ago saw a destitute concertina player (in ireland if I remember rightly) who had dog-ends replacing missing buttons

I don't know about dog-ends, but you'd hear tales of the old players of the German concertina, here in West Clare, replacing missing buttons with rolled-up cardboard glued onto the wooden levers - in fact I've got one, that's been left with me at the moment, with rolled-up gummed paper replacing a missing button. Maybe that's what they actually saw?

The other "classic" concertina/melodeon repair that you'd hear of would be using goose quills for springs, which might sound apocryphal but I've seen it/had to fix it several times. In fact I've got one of those in my workshop too - a yellow 20-key "Ceili Band" (Scholer) that originally belonged to "Baby" Crehan (mother of the renowned fiddle and concertina player "Junior" Crehan).

Still, (bringing us back to the fags) no worse than Oscar Woods' "fix" of a Woodbine's packet behind the spoon-bass keys of his Hohner 4-stopper...

I remember reading that story about the cigarette ends for buttons. Was it on the Fiddler's Companion, under Cooley's Reel #1 (K:Emin
EBBA (B2 B)A|~B2 AB dBAG|FDAD BDAG|FDFA dAFD| ... )? Hard to forget such a great story, and can only wonder if it's true.

There are several stories circulating regarding the origins of this extremely popular session tune. According to David Taylor (1992) the reel was the composition of Co. Mayo and New York fiddler John McGrath (1900-1955). Philippe Varlet maintains it was the invention of accordion player Joe Mills of the Aughrim Slopes Céilí Band, who originally entitled it “Lutrell Pass.”  Charlie Piggott, writing in his book co-authored with Fintan Vallely, Blooming Meadows (1998), has yet another version, related to him by Joe’s brother Séamus.  Its origins date to the 1940’s when the teenaged brothers attended a house session in the neighboring county of Clare. There they listened to an old man with a battered concertina playing in front of an open fire (Séamus remembers some of the buttons had been replaced by cigarette ends!), and one tune in particular caught their attention.  On returning home the brothers tried their best to remember what the old man had played, staying up through the night working and worrying the remembered fragments until finally the reel took shape. Séamus credits Joe with the first part of their refashioned piece, while himself taking credit for the turn.

How about bottle caps for buttons? Never seen it in the flesh (in the wood? :o) but I saved a pic from an eBay auction on my old laptop. Rest in peace, my old Compaq friend.

Edit: Link to relevant entry in F.C. site here (http://www.ibiblio.org/fiddlers/COO_CORI.htm)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal