Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Clive Williams on November 05, 2013, 11:59:13 PM
-
Ok, I'm getting closer to coming up with a keyboard layout for the new 3 row. Attached is my first effort at designing the layout - are there any obvious issues or improvements that people can see? My thinking, to give some idea where I'm coming from:
- The bass layout is unisonoric and covers all chords (not shown on the diagram), so there's no need to worry about that, so the direction of the accidentals does not need to fit with certain chords in certain directions
- It's a D/G/Acc, whose main job is to do what a D/G box can - play in D, G, Bm, Em, Am using standard fingering, albeit transposed a button or two. The other keys/capabilities are nice, but fundamentally, this is a D/G session machine.
- I don't want to rewire my head by altering the D or G rows (accidentals apart), so gleichtons, dutch reversals, and Pignol's tweak of the repeated E note on the pull, great ideas though they are, out.
- I want the accidental row to, if possible, go upwards with each note in both the push and pull ranges - i.e. each button on the push is higher than the button to the left of it on the push, and likewise for on the pull - each button on the pull is higher than the button on the left of it on the pull. I used to have a box, for example, with a F natural on the push on accidental 3, and D natural on the push on accidental 4. It made sense on a note by note basis, but wasn't terribly aesthetically pleasing. I'm not sure how important this actually is for playability, but it seems to be a sensible thing to do.
- Each accidental should be properly spaced apart from its octave cousins - i.e. a space of 2 notes on the push, and a space of 3 notes on the pull, just like the D and G rows themselves.
- Each accidental should be as physically close as possible to notes that are similar - i.e. Eb should be physically close on the keyboard to D.
- I'd like to be able to play in Dm/Gm/A/C with a bit of practice. When I say Dm or Gm, I don't really know if I mean the normal or the harmonic minor. I probably mean both.
- I'd like to be able to play in more obscure keys too, with even more practice.
- Finally, all other things being equal and assuming it doesn't compromise the ability to play in certain keys, I'd prefer to have reversals of common notes in D and G (D, E, C, C#) than reversals of accidentals.
And that's it! Any thoughts anyone?
Cheers,
Clive
-
Clive,
You are an acknowledged guy, so that's a brave step, seeking comments on your new design direction, and I applaud it!
My own underlying design concept thoughts are similar, as expressed by your quote: fundamentally, this is a D/G session machine, though I may have gone in a different direction.
This is now going to get somewhat complicated:
First, I like your idea of avoiding 'counter-intuitive' directions of pitch changes within the accidental row - I have one on my 11/10/9 D/G/Acc layout, and it's the one thing about it that my fingers don't like!
Second, your end button accidental design is, I have to say, quite complex. I've always seen this two-row Hohner end-row accidental feature as a little bit of a fudge, when by going back to the earlier 2 1/2 row Club layouts, they could have designed a much better layout for the fingers. For example, your middle row F/F (5/5) button is a long way from nearby notes in the scale, and will involve a lot of hand-stretching to get to them, if you're going to want (as I do) to play in Dm and Gm.
That said, I like the concept of 'In and Out' F's, and I miss that on my layout. For example, I'd really like at the moment to play for one particular song a RH G7 chord arpeggio, but can't do that against a LH G chord, so have to fudge a D bass note. But why in your layout have that only in the middle octave?
I agree with your reversals comments.
Third, working within the Hohner LH layout has certain great advantages if you're playing in D or G, as you say you intend to do - as I've said before, it's brilliant if the bass third notes for the tonic, sub-dom and dom chords in D (ie F#, B and C#), are easily accessible to the fingers in the right bellows sense, because then you can get the lovely bass rolls beloved by boogie-woogie pianists as a normal part of accompaniment. I toyed with the idea of suggesting to you a 'nested 10-bass modified Hohner' LH layout, but I won't, because the implications are too complex!
Fourth point: Each accidental should be properly spaced apart from its octave cousins - i.e. a space of 2 notes on the push, and a space of 3 notes on the pull, just like the D and G rows themselves.
Like it!
Fifth: so there's no need to worry about that, so the direction of the accidentals does not need to fit with certain chords in certain directions
That comment has many implications, which I'm trying to understand! You have championed the unisonoric bass concept, I think with good reason, but I wonder whether there may be a logical clash between the RH basic 'two-row Hohner nest' concept, and unisonoric basses - if you want to design the RH like that, why not have a matching bass 8-button 'two-row nest', then add to it? To play a completely harmonic unisonoric bass and chord, you would presumably need 24 buttons, which is probably physically impossible without stradella.
The more I think about it, the more I think that the RH and LH design are going to have to be inseparable, even with 18 bass unisonoric basses - there's still choices to be made about which LH to pick, and those choices are going to have effects on LH and RH design.
I hope this helps - I have thought a lot about your design and playing concepts, though I think we have probably gone along different paths.
Sixth point: I really do not expect to understand the full implications of my keyboard layout within my own lifetime.
-
Sixth point: I really do not expect to understand the full implications of my keyboard layout within my own lifetime.
(:) I have that problem with the one-row ;)
-
(Rees, If there was a 'like' button, I'd have pressed it for that comment!)
-
Ok, I'm getting closer to coming up with a keyboard layout for the new 3 row. Attached is my first effort at designing the layout - are there any obvious issues or improvements that people can see?
Clive
This could be trialled on a Roland Fr-18, I would offer, but as Chris and Rees have said life is too short for the evaluation. As for the bass, Senor Stradella had this fantastic idea! (:) Good luck with it Clive
-
interesting as a DG plus layout but looks as if a fair amount of learning would be required to play in most 'other keys' which is why I will stick to the small BCC# (trichord) which has easy fingering for 12 keys and which only needs the learning of 5! ( for lightweight boxes I am more than happy with the ordinary 2 row Dg layout)
I would hnowevr be veryinterested in seeing the unisoric bass layout proposed
george ;)
-
Yes, I think I should add that IMO the DG+ concept can go a long way - It's extending the tried and tested Hohner DG concept into most of the frequently encountered neighbouring territories, and would allow the concept of 'transposing' instruments, to cover other keys.
-
Thanks folks - interesting stuff! The bass is indeed stradella, 12x4, so hence the confidence that I'm not really going to need to worry about chord direction. I'm comfortable with unisonoric bass systems of course, but the stradella layout is still going to need a little rewiring of the head - I've met it on my chromatic box on a much grander scale, so I'm hoping I can get my head around it, and it will even help my cba playing a little.
I've been thinking about Squeezy's layout discussed recently, the main difference being that whereas I've gone for ensuring I have C,C#,D,E in both directions, he's ensured he has Bb/G#/Eb/F in both directions. A *completely* different approach! So, question to the floor, what is the advantage of having the accidentals in both directions? It occurred to me that there's a distinct advantage in having a flattened note (e.g. Eb, rather than E) in the same direction as the note it's a flat version of, and the same for sharpened notes too. So, you'd want Eb on the pull to match with E on the pull, and D# (same note!) on the push to match with D on the push; hence you would want it in both directions.. Is that the thinking behind it?
The logic behind the 'row 1' buttons on my version, well, the Eb on the pull is for tunes like Jump at the Sun/Pterodactyl 2 Step, which just beg for it there. On a normal layout, I'd put G# on the push on the same button, but we've already got it on the pull, and it occurred to me that a C# reversal would be much more useful. F on the push is for tunes playing in C (Barroom Branle, for example, has the 2nd part in C), which means that the pull on that button would be Bb on the pull... but we've already got that. In fact, there's nothing terribly useful we could stick on that note that we haven't already got on the pull, so I thought go for the F unisonorically (which in itself is a duplication) in that it will mean I would be able to be less accurate with the F push playing and get away with it. Whether it's within reach of course, is a different question; guess we're not going to find out until it's built! It is quite a small box physically though, so my expectation is that it would be.
Cheers,
Clive
-
So, question to the floor, what is the advantage of having the accidentals in both directions?
For my layout, it would mainly and simply be to allow that note to be played with any given LH (or perhaps RH) chord, so yours is different issue - but with your stradella system, I imagine you would start from a different point in your design concept - I would assume you're going to be talking about making easy note runs, which is a completely different fish-kettle, and I wouldn't feel qualified to know without long experimentation - DaveW's suggestion is a good one, I think.
I think also I might try to look at it from a musical theory point of view, as opposed to a 'fits a particular tune' principle. And the type of music you want to play is also quite possibly a significant influence - if for example you wanted to play the blues or jazz, you might end up with a very different design, and build in the ability to play flat7, #9, or whatever, chords in a given bellows direction, say.
-
Sorry, another point occurred to me - your stradella bass end is likely to be heavier and more difficult to throw around, is it not? Which adds advantages to having more note reversals on your RH side, so that you can do more note runs on all pull or all push.
-
That said, I like the concept of 'In and Out' F's, and I miss that on my layout. For example, I'd really like at the moment to play for one particular song a RH G7 chord arpeggio, but can't do that against a LH G chord, so have to fudge a D bass note. But why in your layout have that only in the middle octave?
Sorry, I didn't read this bit thoroughly on my last read :-) I'll take that as a vote for F on the push; interesting - it wasn't a priority for me, and the F5 on the push in my layout is very much an after thought ('I've got a button left, what can I do with it!'). Because of the way the octaves work (repeat every 4 notes on the pull, repeat every 3 notes on the push), accidental space on the push is actually at a premium, and I've prioritised C, D, and Eb over it. Perhaps in hindsight I might change accidental 1 on the D row to F4/Eb4 (or maybe even F4/F4), and the rightmost accidental on the accidental row Eb7/F6 (Eb7 is never going to be used, is it?) to F6/F6?
-
Sorry, another point occurred to me - your stradella bass end is likely to be heavier and more difficult to throw around, is it not?
OK, I'll come clean. After a recentish little ebay victory, what I'm looking at is something like the one in this little video:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oQtg_jFWRt0
That chap seems to do ok, but I think I'll need a little practice ;D
-
Clive, what is your recently acquired stradella bass end off and what are its dimensions (to fit bellows) Am asking this as I would like to fit 12x2 to the trichord instead of the standard 6x2 but so far havnt found anything suitable
geroge
-
Clive, what is your recently acquired stradella bass end off and what are its dimensions (to fit bellows) Am asking this as I would like to fit 12x2 to the trichord instead of the standard 6x2 but so far havnt found anything suitable
geroge
It literally is a Hohner Lucia CBA, which will be converted to a D/G/Acc box just like Squeezy's (but with different accidentals). Don't know what the dimensions of the bass end are - sorry - don't have it in my hand at the moment as it's rebuilt, but I gather it's very compact. Perhaps Squeezy can measure his if he's about?
Cheers,
Clive
-
George - with an adapter plate an Imperial III would be pretty close.
-
Owen. there is an imperial 111 on ebay in americal and it looks much loner than a trichord - have you got the imperial bellwos dimensions?
george
-
There have been several versions I think - the one that I'm thinking of is the one with 48 12*4 bass. I thought that I had bellows dimensions for it but can't find them. Best bet is to ask the seller. I don't think that they are exactly right but I think that they are within a few cm, which is the closest out of any 12*4 that I've found. Another option would be one of the Reginas - the Regina V has 111 bass in a casing shorter and wider than a pokerwork! Perhaps an early Regina B (also 111 bass but a few more treble keys) might be a good match.
-
Alternative layout; (deep breath)
- have put G# on the push (better compatibility with my other boxes, easier in A i think),
- Eb on the pull (better for Gm, I think), which means that some of the notes have been shoved around to avoid breaking my 'ascending order' rule. I *think* that by happy coincidence this puts the F natural on the pull on the accidental row in the 'sweet spot' where you need it for mixolydian bits to work (Dark Girl dressed in blue in G, for example)... but need to test that.
- I've decided that if you want Dm and Gm to work, you need to have F natural on push *and* pull. So I've put in unisonoric F's in all octaves.
- The Eb on the pull I had on the D row button 1 was a mistake; I meant Bb, but that's on the accidental row on the pull anyway, so I've been able to reuse that.
- Repurposed right buttons at the end of G and accidental rows (which would have been useless) as out of sequence accidentals (notably to bring a F6 in both directions) and
- turned those C#/Eb accidentals into C#/G# (because Eb is now on the pull anyway).
Phew!
-
OK, here's the next iteration. It's been politely pointed out to me that having reeds too far apart on the push/pull is a *bad* idea from a tonality perspective. So here's a compromise solution that still keeps the 'always ascending order' and 'correct octave gaps' rules intact, without causing too much havoc with the 'reeds too far apart' rule. I'm still not entirely sure about where the 'sweet spot' for where the accidental row's 'F on the pull'; but this layout puts it as close to the adjacent notes as possible.
Interestingly, this layout looks different to anything else out there; I've since done quite a bit of analysis on the other 'standard' tunings offered by Castagnari etc. They all follow the ascending notes and correct octave gaps rules, but a different choice of push notes are chosen for the accidental row; I've chosen C, Eb and E. Is there any reason why I should have chosen any others? It's odd to me why you would *not* want a reversal of C, but no-one else seems to agree. Bb on the push is more popular, but I'm not sure I see the need for that at all, other than to match the chord. On the pull, because the pattern repeats every 4th button instead of every 3, you have much more space to include all the notes (you have to choose one to omit because of the repeated E note using an extra slot, unless you dutch reversal it).
For info, I'll add the D/G/Acc translations I've done of the various other layouts in other posts; makes an interesting comparison. I hadn't realised just how wacky Milleret Pignol is...
Cheers,
Clive
-
4 'off the shelf' layouts transposed to D/G/Acc from the usual Sol/Do/Acc layout documents; Heim No.1 has Dutch reversals (i.e. is a D/Em tuning)
-
... and a D/G/Acc version of Milleret/Pignol.
:o
-
PS Clive, I noticed you named your keyboard version CW-xx-xx-xx- maybe when you launch your lay out officially you might add your middle initial to make it a different abbreviation, because CW is also the Wim Claeys lay out and it may create confusion ;-)
-
Never knew that - thank you!
-
Just to bottom this thread off, here's the final note layout I've decided on. Replaced the C# on the push with Bb; a nod to the fact that most of the other standard tunings have a push Bb and it's going to be useful for minor key stuff. Also, having accidental pairs that sound good together (e.g Bb/Eb) is in general a good idea so that quick bellows reversals don't sound horrible if timed slightly wrong :-)
Cheers,
Clive
-
Against that, pairs like Ab/Bb will be better tuned to the resonance of the chamber, you may get tone change, that's what happens with my revC/Ab on the vdAa, but as they get used as passing notes it's OK
-
Clive, whilst I appreciate that your main intentions is for a DGplus box I am just curious as to how many different scale patterns would be required to play in the 12 major keys?
george
-
twelve? ::)
-
Clive, whilst I appreciate that your main intentions is for a DGplus box I am just curious as to how many different scale patterns would be required to play in the 12 major keys?
george
twelve? ::)
I'm guessing this is a B/C/C# reference. 5 patterns for B/C/C# vs 11 for the layout mentioned here. D and G having the same scale pattern. I don't see how any other two keys would share a pattern.
-
I was just curious ! But as d & g are dead easy on a BCC# and the others are far from difficult and 7 come free of charge it makes me wonder why more DG men (and women) wanting more than the simple 2 row don't give the BCC# a try. Perhaps its because they only think in terms of the shand morino 117 bass box when the 12x4 casali is much lighter at around 15 lbs and the trichord just the same as a corona.
George ( sorry for the intentional thread drift!)
-
So George, why do I only see you play a DG when I see you at Whitby?
-
It is a serious point. B/C/C# is a fine system and it is very quick to be able to play in any key. However, what it lacks is harmonic potential - the scope for RH harmony is much more limited on the B/C/C# than on a D/G. I still think that with the exception of the Loomes Chromatic, the B/C/C# is the best system for a diatonic player who wants to play in *every* key, but for a player who wants to play in *more* keys, a C#/D/G or a D/G/Acc would perhaps be a better choice, as you could design it to be good harmonically as well as melodically, at the expense of some of the more unusual keys.
-
So, at the risk of continuing the hijack of my own thread (which has run its course now, so that's fine), how does B/C/C# players play 12 keys exactly? Do you normally play rows 1 and 2, learn the fingering for those, and transpose to rows 2 and 3 to get a semitone up? I assumed most B/C/C# playing was done across all 3 rows...
Of course, if you want single key fingering for 12 keys, you want a 5 row CBA, a guilty pleasure of mine if ever there was one. This box isn't that of course, entirely different strengths.
-
Generally speaking, yes, you learn the B/C rows in the sharp keys and then learn the C/C# rows in the flat keys by reusing the same fingering. Once you have the basic scale for each key (of which there aren't very many), you can use the reversals very nicely. The big advantage of the B/C/C# is that flat keys are associated with the inner two rows, sharp keys with the outer two, which means that for the most part you are only playing on two rows. This makes the fingering much nicer. But as I said, if you are interested in harmony then some sort of quint plus system might well be better and yours is particularly nice!
Mind you, the Loomes layout is even nicer ;)
-
If you initialy learn the BCC# on the BC rows you can then do the same on the CC# rows and that automatically transposes stuff into the flat keys
Once reasonable familiarity with a few tunes is achieved using 2 rows ( with 2 alternative notes B & E) you can start to experiment using some of the alternative notes in the opposite direction on the inside row when playing on the sharp keys or on the outside row when playing in the flat keys. There is a misconception that 3 rows should be used to get long same direction runs which is not desirable as it can take the bellwos out to far with consequent difficulty controlling their return. What ;you can get is short runs in one direction followed by an run in the opposite direction bringing you back more or less to where you were without using the air button eg 4 notes out followed by 3 or 4 notes in.
the 5 scales are
C = b & C#
G = Ab & F#
D = Eb
A = Bb
E = F
The other advantage is stradella bass which means that the right hand does not have to be bellowed to suite the requiremnts of the left hand
for anyone who is not aware of it there is a link from here to the 'new button box forum( BCC# stuff) on which I will be doing a series of 'notes for newcomers' which may be of interest to those wishing to find out a bit about the system.
george
-
So George, why do I only see you play a DG when I see you at Whitby?
just a combination of ''horses for courses'' and angina. The former because my workshops are DG specific and the latter because the sessions I run require me to be on my feet playing for 2 hours so a relatively heavy box is out of the question.
george
-
Also, in my mind the best instrument in the world for playing in D and G only is the D/G melodeon. So if you are going to play mainly in D and G then why get a B/C/C#?
-
That's a fair point and one I agree with. The DG box is far better in my opinion than an 8 bass BC would as it enables rhythmic bass accompaniment and on the row bounce if desired. Also simple 2 row DG's are light enough to play by knackered old buggers like me for full evening English ceilidh stints
However for being able to play for song accompaniment in all the odd keys singers ask for and for playing along with a veriety of non folk instruments I love the BCC# and also prefer it just to play for my own enjoyment which includes the pleasure of sometimes playing a tune in a veriety of keys. Its just a question of horses for courses
I have however taken the precaution of buying a DG lilly and have a trichord to rebuild so that I should be able to continue with both systems for a long time!
george
-
Hang on a bit … this is worse than thread drift! George asked Clive about fingering patterns on DGaccs but then ends up answering his own question about fingering on a BCC#
Dear Marge, I am utterly confused, of Oxton, Wirral ???
-
not my question Clives question about normal BCC# playing involving all 3 rows
george
-
Cheers George - I've learned something today! (:)
-
Preserving the self-drift, I also agree with those that say that the D/G/Acc and the B/C/C# concepts are like different design branches, and you can't really say that one is superior to the other, they're just different. I still feel that for 8-bass D/G players, a more extensive 3-row and extended bass layout will give you lots of useful additional possibilities, and is well worth trying. The relatively light weight of such boxes is one result of the key limitations.
Equally, I see that the B/C/C# can give you more keys, and that is highly desirable. It may be at the expense of other things. Another issue must simply be the re-learning required to transfer, for D/G players. Knowing what I do now, I could perhaps have originally gone along the B/C/C# branch for my own particular style, but it's not at all clear it to me that it would have got me much further forward, and I certainly don't yet feel as if I'm 'stuck' with the D/G/Acc concept, except for the restriction on practical keys.
I actually feel that the unisonoric bass concept is like a different tree completely, and Garmoshka players might have useful comments to make here too. I hesitate to make any comment on your ideas, Clive, because it seems to me it could take decades to work through all the consequences.
-
Though that last comment certainly wasn't intended to sound at all discouraging!
-
Apologies for being extremely late to this thread due to being on the road with quite limited access to internet.
Firstly well done Clive on getting a Lucia! You will not be disappointed - but you will have some left hand practice to put in as I have spent the past 7 months or so doing ... it only messes with your head for the first 5 months or so :D
The Lucia is slightly smaller than a pokerwork both in length and width, but is very slightly deeper.
Regarding your proposed layout - I think that if it will achieve what you want it to then that is the right thing to do. There is no right and wrong in which notes are chosen because our needs are all different. The layout I have chosen for my Lucia is not specifically in order to have any note in both bellows directions because the unisonoric nature of the left hand kind of takes that pressure off the system. My reasoning was to allow the maximum number of major and minor triads to be playable on the right while maintaining a 7 note repeating pattern that allows the fingering to be the same in both octaves. I'm very happy with it.
But my goal was to also bite the bullet and try to play quite a way outside the comfortable keys for a D/G box - so far I have been getting to grips with tunes in E major, Bb major, F minor, C minor and Eb major and for the main part it is starting to feel less weird although you lose the safety net of D/G fingering that a misplaced note will sound OK!! That is the main reason that our accidental rows look remarkably different.
Anyway ... best of luck with it!
Squeezy
-
Regarding your proposed layout - I think that if it will achieve what you want it to then that is the right thing to do. There is no right and wrong in which notes are chosen because our needs are all different.
Very true,...yet for me it works also the other way around: given more possibilties, i will explore them, and will find use for stuff i would never have imagined i would go.
W
-
Thanks for that Squeezy - great to know. I was knocked out by how yours sounded on the Paris video - can't believe you can get so much flexibility into such a small package; I will have a little practice to do - can't wait!