Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Owen Woods on November 07, 2013, 12:07:33 PM

Title: Building a box help
Post by: Owen Woods on November 07, 2013, 12:07:33 PM
I have decided to give building a box a go in the New Year. I doubt that I will finish it, but I hope that I will at least start it! I am in the process of working out how to build one with the kit that I will have available, but am already thinking about reeds. I think that the reeds would have to be my first purchase, since they will impact on the design of the palletboard and the size of the instrument. So I have two questions. The first is what system I should go for and the second is what supplier I should use.

My thinking behind the box is that I wouldn't want another high box, like a D/G and neither do I want a very low box, like a G/C, F/Bb, E/A. What I would like is something in between, so either an A/D, Bb/Eb or B/E. I am currently contemplating the latter, because I like those keys and it would sound refreshingly different to my other boxes. Useless in sessions, but there we go. The other option is an A/A#, which is one of the more sensible semitone systems. I'd appreciate people's thoughts on this, because I am very undecided at the moment.

The second problem is which reeds to buy. I don't actually know much about reed suppliers and I don't even know how much a set of reeds would normally cost. I could probably afford around £150, on the basis that if it does all fall through I could always sell the reeds on. Is there a manufacturer who will make reasonable quality reeds for that kind of sum? And if not has anyone got any bright ideas for how to get hold of some?
Title: Re: Building a box help
Post by: Theo on November 07, 2013, 12:17:58 PM
Some (perhaps all) reed makers are not interested in supplying a single set if reeds.  The most likely are the smaller outfits like Binci or Ciccarelli, but they only make a mano reeds and are likely to be outside your budget.
Charlie Marshall is another possibility, though I think it is unlikely he will have B/E.

Italian reed plates are pretty much standard width and thickness, so you could design and build the majority of the box before you have the reeds to hand.  They do vary in length so building the reed blocks is best done for the specific set of reeds that you use.

Good luck with the project.
Title: Re: Building a box help
Post by: Lars on November 07, 2013, 12:26:54 PM
I'm currently waiting for reeds for my first homemade box, and I know the dilemma. You'd want nice quality, but 150 is not much if you want TaM or the like from a reputed maker. I'm making a 13 key 6 voice, and I paid around 350 euros for top notch Ciccarelli Bombarde.

Now, it depends on what you want. 2 voice 21 key? 3 voice 23 key? If you're making something in 'common' keys it should be fairly easy to find good reeds, perhaps used. Cagnoni reeds from CGM are nice for the price range, and old hohner reeds can sound great in the right box - I'm sure a lot of members here will have something to suit your purpose.

Many italian makers will take your order, even for a small quantity, and someone like Ciccarelli makes excellent 'basic' reeds - I have a box with his cheapest reeds, and they are quite nice. Downside is, that you must expect the usual delay. I've ordered from him twice, and the delivery time was doubled both times. Other makers might be faster, or have what you need in stock.

From what I gathered, the various makers will supply reeds for prices from around 1 pound to 3,50 pounds per reedplate, for treble reeds.
Title: Re: Building a box help
Post by: Owen Woods on November 07, 2013, 12:36:02 PM
Hmm, sadly more or less as I expected.

This will be a 21 key two voice (probably LM though). Nothing too complicated, will probably even have standard basses. I'd like to avoid Hohner reeds, just because I already have two very nice Hohner boxes and fancy the italian sound for this project.

Good to know that Ciccarelli makes good basic reeds. I've never tried Cagnoni but people say that they are OK. Perhaps I will talk to Charlie and see what he has.
Title: Re: Building a box help
Post by: diatonix on November 07, 2013, 03:45:49 PM
It should be noted that Ciccarelli reeds are basically Artigiana Voci reeds, because that's where he gets his semifinished goods from. The main difference between AV and Cagnoni is that the latter uses German steel while AV sticks to the (in the opinion of many, better) Swedish product.
Title: Re: Building a box help
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 07, 2013, 04:24:53 PM
I've never tried Cagnoni but people say that they are OK.
I have a 1930s vintage C/F Hohner Club I which has Hohner reeds in the LH end but which Rees fitted out with Cagnoni 'macchina' reeds in the treble end (I presume the original Hohner treble reeds were beyond salvation). The Cagnoni reeds are really quite nice and in this box sound and play pretty much like vintage Hohner reeds. I am pleasantly impressed with them.  (:)
Title: Re: Building a box help
Post by: Corinto on November 07, 2013, 08:09:06 PM
The second problem is which reeds to buy. I don't actually know much about reed suppliers and I don't even know how much a set of reeds would normally cost. I could probably afford around £150, on the basis that if it does all fall through I could always sell the reeds on. Is there a manufacturer who will make reasonable quality reeds for that kind of sum? And if not has anyone got any bright ideas for how to get hold of some?

Hi,

This link may be helpful, or may not, as it says "uni-sonore chromatique"
Look here = http://www.pianoabretelles.com/
Then go to = Ventes
And continue to = Pièces pour réparations
And scroll down till you see the reeds: Aluminium, Super Dural and TAM
Title: Re: Building a box help
Post by: Graham Spencer on November 08, 2013, 05:16:03 AM

This link may be helpful, or may not, as it says "uni-sonore chromatique"
Look here = http://www.pianoabretelles.com/
Then go to = Ventes
And continue to = Pièces pour réparations
And scroll down till you see the reeds: Aluminium, Super Dural and TAM

If you don't scroll down quite so far you'll find "bisonore diatonique" €4.96 apiece, listed as a mano.

Graham
Title: Re: Building a box help
Post by: bellowpin on November 08, 2013, 11:36:09 AM

This link may be helpful, or may not, as it says "uni-sonore chromatique"
Look here = http://www.pianoabretelles.com/
Then go to = Ventes
And continue to = Pièces pour réparations
And scroll down till you see the reeds: Aluminium, Super Dural and TAM

If you don't scroll down quite so far you'll find "bisonore diatonique" €4.96 apiece, listed as a mano.

Graham
interesting web site.   listing all manner of components and bits for melodeon building. did you spot the spare reed tongues?.    there must be hundreds of scrap reed plates around that need one replacement tongue. has any one tried this job.
 
Title: Re: Building a box help
Post by: bellowpin on November 08, 2013, 11:58:03 AM

This link may be helpful, or may not, as it says "uni-sonore chromatique"
Look here = http://www.pianoabretelles.com/
Then go to = Ventes
And continue to = Pièces pour réparations
And scroll down till you see the reeds: Aluminium, Super Dural and TAM

If you don't scroll down quite so far you'll find "bisonore diatonique" €4.96 apiece, listed as a mano.

Graham
   what a interesting selection of components and bits for making melodeons etc. i have never seen spare reed tongues offered before.  there must be hundreds of scrap reed plates around that need one replacement tongue. has anyone tried this job?
  theo used the phrase" thrift box" in another thread a few weeks ago. refering to homemade cheap DIY instrument.   a sort of super  "hero chanson" with nail heads showing ,i imagine.
finding suitable reeds at the right price is the only thing holding us back. oh ,and the bellows?   anyone with other ideas or low cunning out there,  could be a educational hobby.?        bellowpin.
Title: Re: Building a box help
Post by: Graham Spencer on November 08, 2013, 12:00:12 PM
No, I didn't see those - well spotted!

Incidentally on looking again I see the bisonoric reedplates are in fact listed as TAM.

Graham
Title: Re: Building a box help
Post by: Owen Woods on November 08, 2013, 01:06:16 PM
Wow, I don't even know what some of those things are!
Title: Re: Building a box help
Post by: oggiesnr on November 11, 2013, 09:22:48 AM
Have you thought about trawling the nether regions of fleabay or car boots etc for scrap Hohners and reclaiming the reeds?

Steve
Title: Re: Building a box help
Post by: Owen Woods on November 11, 2013, 05:37:02 PM
I have, but I would quite like to have the Italian sound on this box. Of course, if I do buy a set of reeds then I might be able to sell them on, or at least reuse them on a different box.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal