Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: boxer on November 11, 2013, 05:48:26 PM

Title: Reed response
Post by: boxer on November 11, 2013, 05:48:26 PM
Hi all.  A bit of advice, please, if you would.

I have in my collection a 1950s Hohner 2 row 3 voice (MMM) box.  It's in playable condition, the tuning's a bit uneven (as one might expect), but the reeds don't seem to breathe half as easily nor speak so readily as those of equivalent new MMM Hohner boxes I've had through my hands. 

Could this be due to a need for adjustment of the reeds or the valves, or might it be something else?  The bellows are ok and the levers and pallets have plenty of travel so I don't think they're the cause.  The box is has no significant leaks.  The reeds on the right hand side are the problem - the bass reeds work as well as they need to.

The box would be twice as much use to me if the problem could be sorted out.

Any advice welcome.
Title: Re: Reed response
Post by: rees on November 11, 2013, 05:55:46 PM
First port of call would be the valves. If they have fallen off or curled up then the reeds will be struggling.
Time to open her up.
Title: Re: Reed response
Post by: boxer on November 11, 2013, 10:35:11 PM
the valves are all present and correct.  The box is entirely playable, but nowhere near slick in its response as newer kit.  Do valves get stiffer with old age?  I can see how the height of the reed tips may change over time.  Could that influence response?
Title: Re: Reed response
Post by: Theo on November 11, 2013, 11:42:56 PM
Leather valves get stiff, plastic ones don't.  Hohners from the 50s and 60s are sometimes afflicted by plastic valves falling off because the adhesive fails, but this would be obvious.

Three voice Hohners can sometimes feel less responsive that two voice models, just because they are bigger and heavier.
Title: Re: Reed response
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 12, 2013, 12:51:46 AM
I can see how the height of the reed tips may change over time.  Could that influence response?
Definitely!

I would say that the order of checking/remediation of reeds which have not been adjusted or tuned for a long time is:

1. Valves - replace if curled, bent or missing.

2. Wax - old wax gets brittle and ceases to function properly. Remove reed plate, clean off old wax and re-wax into place with fresh wax, especially if renewing underneath (pull) reed valves.

3. Set reed tip height to optimum. Too high and the reed will be breathy and slow to respond; if too low it will either speak too easily but with obvious pitch variation with changing bellows pressure or else the reed may choke and not speak at all. There is a sweet Goldilocks spot which is just right.

4. Tune the reed.

Steps 3 and 4 are a reiterative process; changing the reed tip height will affect the pitch slightly and filing/scratching the belly of the reed may affect the reed tip height setting, especially if working on unsupported pull reed tongues through the reed plate slot.
Title: Re: Reed response
Post by: Theo on November 12, 2013, 08:16:32 AM
The symptoms of incorrect reed height are quite specific:

 Too high and you hear air going through before the reed gradually speaks.

 Too low and the reeds choke before starting suddenly, or not at all.

Before starting to make any changes establish the cause of the problem, it is very easy to make things much worse by adjusting reed height, so you don't want to start messing around bending reed tongues as your first approach.  Also bear in mind that if you have a three voice two row box you have over 120 reed tongues to adjust.

And  IMHO it is essential to have a good easy to use tuning bellows of you want to do this.  Of all the things Steve has listed above it is the most difficult to get right.

Title: Re: Reed response
Post by: diatonix on November 12, 2013, 08:44:54 AM
I've also come across cases where poor performance was caused by the holes in the reedblock not wholly covering their counterparts in the face plate (often in conjunction with half-loose blocks) This is usually easily remedied by repositioning the blocks and making sure they sit tight.
Older Hohners sometimes lack braces that connect the blocks. In cases where pins were used, they may simply have fallen off. This too can have a very noticeable negative effect.
Title: Re: Reed response
Post by: Theo on November 12, 2013, 08:59:50 AM
Good points Diatonix.

It is also true that not all Hohners were created equal, some of them just are better, or worse than others.
Title: Re: Reed response
Post by: Microbot on November 12, 2013, 10:24:45 AM
Hi Boxer, Theo and all,

it seems there's an abundance of good advice - all given with the customary Melnet generosity! All of it is 'sound comment' and might (or might not) be relevant - but there's a complete lack of info on what the instrument actually IS!!!

What model is it?

What valves are fitted?

The various Hohner models have different characteristics/weak-points/tendencies that could well be relevant...

the above info plus photos of the treble insides showing reeds and reedblocks -then the advice can be more specific and avoid fiddling with what may NOT be wrong!

cheers!

Mike R
Title: Re: Reed response
Post by: boxer on November 12, 2013, 04:30:40 PM
Thanks for all the advice everyone.

The box inquestion a Double Ray Deluxe in B/C (I don't think they were ever produced in any other tuning).  I'll work on the photos - I've very seldom uploaded pics so this may take a while.

As I said in my original post, I have experience with similar, brand new MMM Hohners (I'm thinking particularly of the Del Rey Compadre), so I'm not actually comparing the box to, for example, a well played-in Pokerwork or a 3 voice Castagnari.

The box had a quick tune-up when I procured it a couple of years ago.  The work only cost a few quid - it was not much more than a tweaking on a couple of reeds - but I would have thought the tuner would have advised me of any outstanding serious fault. 

While I often work on accordion key mechanisms - button and piano, melodeon and stradella basses - I've always left anything on the inside of a box that was more technical than pulling fluff out of reeds to professional tuners.  It's so easy to spoil reeds and valves.

Perhaps the best solution would be to send the blocks off to a different expert.

I'll work on the pictures - thanks again
Title: Re: Reed response
Post by: Theo on November 12, 2013, 05:20:19 PM
Just though of one other possible explanation.  Sometimes the base board can warp and leave enough space for air leaks underneath the reed blocks.  This is quite common on 1930s Hohner club boxes.  It is easy to diagnose.  Take out the reed blocks and look at the gasket on the base board, and/or reed block.  It should look smooth where the mating face has pressed into it.  If there is an area towards the middle of the block where the nap on the leather is still raised, and if there is blackening (caused by dust) in the same area then there is a poor joint caused by a warped base board or warped reed block, or both.
Title: Re: Reed response
Post by: Graham Spencer on November 12, 2013, 05:38:16 PM
Just though of one other possible explanation.  Sometimes the base board can warp and leave enough space for air leaks underneath the reed blocks.  This is quite common on 1930s Hohner club boxes.  It is easy to diagnose.  Take out the reed blocks and look at the gasket on the base board, and/or reed block.  It should look smooth where the mating face has pressed into it.  If there is an area towards the middle of the block where the nap on the leather is still raised, and if there is blackening (caused by dust) in the same area then there is a poor joint caused by a warped base board or warped reed block, or both.

That was exactly the case on my 1930s Club II; cured by gluing a shim of timber (lime in my case because I have plenty of it) to the bottoms of the reedblocks, opening out the holes to match the originals and then thicknessing dead flat on a belt sander. A new felt gasket, and job done. Mind you, my symptoms were uneven volume rather than overall weak or slow response.

Graham
Title: Re: Reed response
Post by: boxer on November 13, 2013, 04:43:46 PM
That sounds like a possible, although when I play the box, it doesn't feel as if air is bypassing the reeds, more that the reeds aren't letting much air through at all.  There's no excessive bellows movement.  If the base boards are warped I would have expected to have to move a lot of air to make a modest sound - rather like when a valve has failed.  It's not like that.

I'll have a look at the blocks anyway.  Thanks 
Title: Re: Reed response
Post by: blafleur on November 13, 2013, 06:03:10 PM
One thing I don't see mentioned regarding tip height is muting when too low.  If too low, it can choke off or not sound at all, but I've seen some that when adjusting, in between "too low" and the "sweet spot", there is a spot where the reed sounds and doesn't choke, but is slightly muted.  Anyone else experience this?  It's possible in that case that it would choke off with more pressure.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal