Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Happyhank on November 28, 2013, 02:29:07 PM
-
I'm curious about this Weltmeister on ebay.
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Rare-Vintage-Weltmeister-Wiener-W-21-Melodeon-D-G-Folk-Music-Accordian-Mint-/151176364105?pt=UK_MusicalInstr_Keyboard_RL&hash=item2332d04049
Would this be comparable to, better, worse than a similar vintage Hohner?
Also, I have seen this particular "Pokerwork" paint job -- that is, this specific design or pattern -- on other unidentified boxes. Can one assume that this design was proprietary to Weltmeister?
(http://farm3.staticflickr.com/2812/11101174335_6d802b0fb2_n.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/56081579@N06/11101174335/)
Weltmeister Wiener P851 (http://www.flickr.com/photos/56081579@N06/11101174335/) by hankins.greg (http://www.flickr.com/people/56081579@N06/), on Flickr
The asking price does seem a bit steep . . .
Thanks!
Greg
-
These model are very variable in quality, but even at their best they would not be as good as a Hohner. Reed quality is usually ok, but the keyboard and treble action is poor and if a spring breaks it is very difficult to repair. An the price is way way too high. The seller seems to be an antique dealer, so not surprising the price isn't right.
-
Looks like a 86W. Are there two different models or is it incorrectly labeled W21?
-
I think the design is intended basically as an imitation of the Pokerwork design (notionally, I believe, a decoration worked into the wood using a hot poker).
This particular guy is in Sherborne - they're a bit rural out there ;D
But worth watching out, if you're looking for a Pokerwork, that you're not looking at one of these.
-
Wow, the price is way, way too high. I've played a couple of these pokerworkalikes and both were distinctly inferior when compared with the Hohner boxes.
-
I was curious about the propriety nature of the design because I saw one with the same design for sale in Nashville, Tennessee, by a guy who thought it might be an old "Horner." (Amazing how many folks make that particular spelling mistake even when the photograph in there listing clearly shows "Hohner" on the top of the box.)
In any case, based on Theo's comment, it appears these would best be avoided at pretty much any price.
Greg
-
In any case, based on Theo's comment, it appears these would best be avoided at pretty much any price.
Greg
Absolutely - I've played several of these at one time or another, and personally I wouldn't pay 600 pence for one (well, maybe I would - 6 quid would be an OK price for some usable spares. No "sick squid" responses, please!).
Graham
-
Looks like a 86W. Are there two different models or is it incorrectly labeled W21?
The 86W is quite a decent box, but it has a different shaped keyboard, and has the Weltmeister name. I'm reasonably sure this is from the time of the DDR which is when the worst examples were made.
-
Having recently gone through the aggro of replacing keyboard springs on one of these I'd say don't touch it with a ten foot pole, not even at well under half of that price. They're horrible.
-
Not that hard to do the springs. You need to pop the button off, and slide out the key rod. I would be happier if the buttons were mounted in a removable manner , say screwed on buttons.
-
Thanks, I'd hoped there must be an easier way . . . BUT, on this particular specimen the key rod was absolutely immovable by any normal methods.
I eventually milled out the slot in the back of the keyboard a fraction to relieve the pressure on the rod in order to be able to slide it out, then replaced it with a fractionally bigger diameter axle that was a snug sliding fit so could be easily removed and replaced in future.
Rather than pop all the buttons off to get the keys out I machined the back out of the keyboard and made a flush fitted removable back panel.
It was a lot of work, but I had happily told the friend who owns it that the broken springs could easily be replaced without first having established quite what that would involve! A lesson learned, and I enjoy a challenge :)
-
Trying to pull out the rod to fix a broken spring is usually not a good idea. If it moves at all, you will most likely damage the keyboard itself. The springs are anchored in small holes in the wooden levers. They have a tendency to break at that exact point, leaving a small part in that very hole, which consequently has become useless. I always fix this problem by unscrewing the keyboard and drilling a new, virtually invisible hole (about 0.6 mm) through the bottom of the keyboard into the lever. This makes it much easier to place the new intact spring.
-
Never had a problem getting the rods out, but the technique with drilling the holes sounds interesting.