Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: WendyG on February 14, 2009, 12:09:45 PM
-
Hi, This is my first post and one of probably many questions. I received my Stephanelli D/G melodeon yesterday and the John Kirkpatrick DVD and so am trying to learn the Winster Processional march. The melodeon is a bit heavier than I expected but luckily it came with a strap which I have adjusted to its smallest setting (I am 5ft tall). After about 30-45 minutes of practicing I have noticed that my right-hand fingers are going tingly and numb, is this a factor of the way I am holding the instrument, or is it just tension and will go once I have relaxed into playing the instrument?
Thanks
Wendy
-
Are you playing standing up or sitting down?
Are you using one shoulder strap or two?
A possible cause of numbness in the right hand is that you may be pressing too hard with your thumb on the end of the finger board to keep the instrument steady. If so, then using two straps to steady the instrument or resting it on your knee if you play sitting down will take the weight more effectively and reduce the pressure on your thumb.
Another possibility is that you are being a little heavy-handed. Try to press the keys sharply but lightly. This will also help you to play tunes more crisply.
-
If you have not played melodeon or concertina before then you should build up your playing slowly over a number of weeks. There are all sorts of potential muscle strains and tendon injuries that you can trigger from over use. If your box is brand new the bellows action could also be quite stiff and this might ease over the coming months as well.
In my own view you are probably better practising three times per day for 10-15 minutes to start (with a good two hour rest in between each session), rather than 45 mins in one go.
For my own preservation I have also switched the hand and arm that I use to operate the mouse on the computer, to give my right arm a break.
The JK DVD is fantastic, but he takes no prisoners - don't expect to keep up with him!
all the best,
Peter
-
Hi Wendy & welcome to melodeon .net. I strongly reccomend the use of two straps whether playing standing or seated as this relieves the hand and thumb of responsibility for holding the box- the thumb should be resting LIGHTLY on the edge of the keyboard and is used to provide a sort of location point or anchor for the hand and therefore the fingers . Keep the fingers bent in a U shape so that finger tips are hitting the buttons. Have sent you a personal message.
george
-
....it came with a strap which I have adjusted to its smallest setting (I am 5ft tall).
Many prominent melodeon players seem to want to place the treble keyboard centerline somewhere close to the center line of the body. I've recently started with the 5-row accordion and the keyboard outer edge is adviced to be kept resting on the inside of the right leg. This again places the keyboard close to the body center. The right hand can move more freely this way. Don't know if this works for you but worth trying.
-
Many thanks for the suggestions. I have just ordered a second strap as I am having difficulties supporting the melodeon. I have just had a practice session (about 20 minutes, no numb fingers but they were starting to ache a bit) and noticed that I have the treble keyboard side almost in line with my right shoulder. This causes my arm to be in a rather cramped position with the elbow pointing backwards, possibly causing the numbness of the fingers? Tomorrow I will try with the keyboard nearer to the centre of my body and see how that goes.
Thanks
Wendy
-
Hi Wendy,
I hope you've ordered the correct strap, the right hand one is a fair bit longer than the left. This allows the centring of the melodeon in relation to your body. Many players who play seated have a very long right hand strap so that the right end rests on the left knee while playing.
As a newbie you need to keep practice times fairly short as has already been mentioned, I know you're keen but you must allow your body time to get used to this strange new activity!
-
I hope you've ordered the correct strap, the right hand one is a fair bit longer than the left.
I believe I have. The current strap is the Mally strap, which was miles too long even when adjusted to the shortest settings, I had to make several new holes!
I am trying to restrict my practice sessions, but as you say I am quite eager to learn. My target is to be able to play several Morris/English tunes well enough to be able to take the melodeon to a folk festival in August. Is this a realistic target? Or am I expecting too much of myself, (I am also trying to learn to play a 20 button Lachenal concertina that I recently restored).
Wendy
-
the 'mally' strap was designed for playing stting with box resting on left knee. It effeectively provided something to push against when steadying the edge of keyboard with right haand. However many people used it to play standing which meant assuming many strange postures, non of which were good for the anatomy! Mally himself reccomends 2 straps for playing stood up. Start adjustment with right strap slightly longer than left so that keyboard in roughly under your chin(when looking staight ahead). Set both straps so top of box is about a haandswidth bellow chin (again whilst looking staaight ahead). Then perhaps over a period of days spend time making small adjustments to the straps untill you get it feeling comfartable. With a small 2 row box their is no purpose served by resting it on knee with straps extended, particularly as this would mean readjusting straps for standing eg for playing for morris.Keep bellows 'tight ' and get into the habitof playing with elbows down at your sides rather than flapping them about as if in process of taking off!. Whatever stage you gt up to take the box to a afestival in august or whenever as you will have the chance to play to a greater or lesseer degree with others.
If you or anybody else are going to Whitby folk week I will be doing my usual 'crash course for beginners' (& those who have got stuck!) over 4 workshops mon - fri and probably an intermediate/advanced one on the friday. Will also be doing 2 led sessions 'well known tunes at a steady pace etc'
george
-
Whichever festival you go to in August, seek out other players, most of whom will be happy to give you a few tips. If it is Whitby Festival, I recommend strongly going to the sessions George Garside runs. They are ideal for people who are just starting out because he plays well-known session tunes at a steady pace.
If you are going to Sidmouth, come to the sessions we run every evening in the Sailing Club, where we also include a large number of 'session standards'. Introduce yourself and let us know what tunes you can play and we will be happy to start them if you are nervous of starting them yourself.
-
I had the same experience until I experimented with different hand positions.
Another question - are you using the thumb strap? If you are restraining your entire thumb too far inside the strap, or if your entire thumb is clasped tightly behind the keyboard, either way a bad hand posture is the result and it will strain your right hand until it goes numb. Lots of players ignore or remove the strap. Like George said, if you have two straps as an anchor then your hand can dance over the keyboard while exerting minimal pressure against it.
A small part of this might also be a strength/stamina issue, fresh hands take some conditioning. I see it all the time with my guitar students.
-
One thing that might help is to remember to raise your elbow so your forearm is almost horizontal. It makes playing a lot easier and reduces the strain on the wrist by keeping the hand and forearm in line.
-
And I can personally thoroughly recommend George's basics course at Whitby. The only thing is that I'm not up to the next level yet, but I keep trying!
-
Another question - are you using the thumb strap?
No I don't use the thumb strap as I found it quite restrictive (plus I have arthritis of the right thumb, and found it a bit painful). I am now shortening the length of my practice sessions to avoid muscle fatigue and strain, but still practice daily. When the second strap arrives I will set it up as suggested by George. I do prefer to stand up when I practice as it means I can walk around a bit, I find it helps concentration.
Wendy
-
Are you playing standing up or sitting down?
Are you using one shoulder strap or two?
A possible cause of numbness in the right hand is that you may be pressing too hard with your thumb on the end of the finger board to keep the instrument steady. If so, then using two straps to steady the instrument or resting it on your knee if you play sitting down will take the weight more effectively and reduce the pressure on your thumb.
Another possibility is that you are being a little heavy-handed. Try to press the keys sharply but lightly. This will also help you to play tunes more crisply.
Too much thumb pressure is a very likely cause -- when my wife started playing sopranino sax (which is supported by thumb rests with no strap) she had the same problem until she got used to it.
If you're playing with one strap (like I do) and having to press too hard with the thumb to keep the box steady it's likely that the strap is too short -- try lengthening it so the instrument sits further to the left and down, with the bellows hanging more downwards than sideways. This also straightens out your right arm, and means you use stronger muscles in your left arm than trying to keep the bellows high up.
Ian
-
You have to be carefull not to overdo it - like I apparently have. It seems I have 'Carpel Tunnel Syndrome' basically tendonitis of the wrists which causes slight swelling therby pressing on a nerve passing through this tunnel on the inside of the wrist. Symptoms are tingling and pain in the fingers especially in the morning , but , weirdest of all, only the thumb, first and middle finger, the others dont seem to be affected at all. It can be painful and sometimes stops practice - especially guitar. Comes from years of zqueezing, guitaring, building work and mouse manipulations !! Treatment is - using a brace at night (didnt do much), next Cortisone injections, finally surgery to relieve pressure. I'm waiting until it gets worse before succumbing to anything more invasive than a brace.
-
If the problem is "Carpel Tunnel" then it is the hand or fingers that are being starved of blood and hence you loose sensation in them.
A quick fix remedy is to massage the inside of the wrist starting about the area that your watch strap would be and using as much pressure as you can
muster push down to the palm. Do this repeat
I was shown this about 15 years ago and over that time there has been a remarkable improvement.
Can't play the Melodeon any better but that a different story!
Davied
-
I have now been using 2 straps, and keeping a check on elbow/arm, hand position for a week or so, and have not experienced the numbness since. I only practice for 20 minutes at a time (or until my fingers start to ache). My problem at the moment is trying to get the left and right hands to work independently, not very easy :(.
Wendy
-
I have now been using 2 straps, and keeping a check on elbow/arm, hand position for a week or so, and have not experienced the numbness since. I only practice for 20 minutes at a time (or until my fingers start to ache). My problem at the moment is trying to get the left and right hands to work independently, not very easy :(.
Wendy
It helps in the early stages of playing to only attempt to put bass to a tune that you can play on the right hand side without having to think about what you are doing - and preferably a slow tune so you have plenty of time to do things. Whilst continuous heavy um -pa ing or um- pa- pa ing can be both turgid & monotonous it is of considerable help in teh early stages. Concentrate on a steady um pa (march or 4/4) or um pa pa (3/4 or waltz) rhythm on just 2 buttons eg Gbass & G major & don't worry about moving to different bass buttons for harmony at this stage. Just treat the bass as percussion & try & keep a steady rhythm . Waltz tunes such as daisy daisy (daily bell) or oh dear what can the matter be with a steady um pa pa to the bar are good starters. Winster gallop played slowly & steaadily is a good introduction to a 4/4 rhythm.
There is much more that can be done with the bass as experience develops but the ability to beat out a steady (even at the beginning an over heavy) rhythm with the left hand whilst playing the tune on the other side helps to programme the brain into opperating each side seperately!
I also very strongly recommend keeping time with foot or even feet as the bass rhythm should be linked directly to the timekeeping foot & provides a built in metronome. i.e. for 4/4 foot down = bass note (UM) foot up = major chord (PA). For 3/4 again foot down = bass note (UM) foot up up (held up for 2 beats) =(PA PA)
george
-
When I started teaching myself the melodeon, I had great difficulty coordinating bass and melody (I didn't even know I was doing it wrong to start with!), but then somebody taught me the tune Speed the Plough. I found this a really easy one to fit the basses to, and it all clicked. I've recommended learning this tune to other beginners having problems with the basses, and it generally seems to work.
Good luck!
Pauline
-
When I started teaching myself the melodeon, I had great difficulty coordinating bass and melody (I didn't even know I was doing it wrong to start with!), but then somebody taught me the tune Speed the Plough. I found this a really easy one to fit the basses to, and it all clicked. I've recommended learning this tune to other beginners having problems with the basses, and it generally seems to work.
Good luck!
Pauline
presumably the 'English' version rather than the Irish or Scottish versions of Speed the Plough?
george :)
-
When I started teaching myself the melodeon, I had great difficulty coordinating bass and melody (I didn't even know I was doing it wrong to start with!), but then somebody taught me the tune Speed the Plough. I found this a really easy one to fit the basses to, and it all clicked. I've recommended learning this tune to other beginners having problems with the basses, and it generally seems to work.
Good luck!
Pauline
presumably the 'English' version rather than the Irish or Scottish versions of Speed the Plough?
george :)
Oh, yes, most definitely!!
Pauline
-
presumably the 'English' version rather than the Irish or Scottish versions of Speed the Plough?
I've been playing Speed The Plough (English) for more than 20 years - truly a great tune - but I had no idea it had Scottish and Irish cousins.
Are they also great tunes?
...and how do you differentiate? Speed McPlough / Speed O'Plough ?
(sorry!) ;D
-
Speed McPlough / Speed O'Plough ?
;D
http://www.rogermillington.com/steam/ploughs.mp3
Here's an Irish version played at a rather leisurely place by Jackie Daly et al., followed by what I would think of as a Scottish version, except I'd expect it to be in A and not G as here (played by Jean Carignan). Probably not much different from the English one... oder?
There's another Irish Speed the Plough, different tune altogether, which I would say is more popular than the other, and is what you would be most likely to get if you asked a modern Irish muso for Speed the Plough. It is tacked on the end of the clip (Tommy Peoples and Matt Molloy). Séamus Ennis referred to this tune as "O'Keeffe's Plough" so presumably it came from Padraig O'Keeffe.
Could someobdy post or point to an English version?