Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Nick Hudis on February 15, 2009, 06:13:26 PM
-
I got to thinking about this the other day. What is the ultimate melodeon? Of course everyone will have a different view, but here are three suggestions:
The 4stop 1 row. I once heard Ress describe this as the ultimate melodeon. Its the formula 1 racing car of boxes: stripped down to the bare essentials, loud, fast, brash even, and not too easy to control.
The "Pokerwork" or indeed any two row, two voice 5th or semitoned tuned. This is the ultimate melodeon in terms of sheer numbers. Think of this as the family saloon car of boxes. Simple, practical, adaptable, easy to play, go anywhere, affordable (maybe?), the bedrock of countless morris meets, ceilidhs and sessions.
The Big Box Here we are talking Castagnari Handry, Shand Morino etc. The Rolls Royce of boxes. multiple rows (I notice the Marc Perrone manages to get 4 rows on his Handry, and even from a wheelchair handles it as if it were a toy), seried ranks of basses, every possible combination of couplers and the finest reeds, the finest craftsmanship, unimaginable cost. A thing of beauty to be admired, but would you take it to do the weekly shop at Tescos?
So folks, whats your ultimate expression of the melodeon/diatonic accordion.
Just for the record, I'm a Big Box man.
-
one I can just pick up and play, oh yes and can afford as well. ;D ;D ;D
-
All the above
However I prefer unpretentious , simple boxes such as the Hohner 114 one row and poker work 2 rows.
-
My ultimate box would have more bass possibilities.. Specifically, I wish the old Club boxes were built with 12 basses along 2 rows, allowing the player to choose either more typical diatonic style play, or to play more along the lines of the 'Club method.'
Something else I think is nice: a 3-voice, 2-row box, with 23 treble and 12 basses (I think PS made these? Can't remember if they were 2 or 4 voice? Also the Saltarelle Atalante, I've never played one but 3 voices and 25/14 sounds like it would do the trick. Or a 3-voice, 3-row, 34 treble button box with Stradella bass. I think Hohner made something like this, but it's possible by switching ends. One of these days I'll just rewire and learn B/C/C#.
Having gone this far, I have to say it's refreshing to play along the G row on my G/C and accompany only with the G and D bass/chords. Gives the tunes a wholly different feel than when playing more 'melodic' bass to accompany the C row inside-out.
So how about a 6-voice, 1-row MMMMMM in three different keys? ;D Someone must have messed around with that idea. More trouble than it's worth?
-
I would love the one like I hear other people playing, you know the one that doesn't make all the mistakes.
-
My ultimate box would have more bass possibilities.. Specifically, I wish the old Club boxes were built with 12 basses along 2 rows, allowing the player to choose either more typical diatonic style play, or to play more along the lines of the 'Club method.'
Something else I think is nice: a 3-voice, 2-row box, with 23 treble and 12 basses (I think PS made these? Can't remember if they were 2 or 4 voice? Also the Saltarelle Atalante, I've never played one but 3 voices and 25/14 sounds like it would do the trick. Or a 3-voice, 3-row, 34 treble button box with Stradella bass. I think Hohner made something like this, but it's possible by switching ends. One of these days I'll just rewire and learn B/C/C#.
Having gone this far, I have to say it's refreshing to play along the G row on my G/C and accompany only with the G and D bass/chords. Gives the tunes a wholly different feel than when playing more 'melodic' bass to accompany the C row inside-out.
So how about a 6-voice, 1-row MMMMMM in three different keys? ;D Someone must have messed around with that idea. More trouble than it's worth?
How would you characterize the difference between typical diatonc style and 'club method' style.
-
My ultimate box would have more bass possibilities.. Specifically, I wish the old Club boxes were built with 12 basses along 2 rows, allowing the player to choose either more typical diatonic style play, or to play more along the lines of the 'Club method.'
Something else I think is nice: a 3-voice, 2-row box, with 23 treble and 12 basses (I think PS made these? Can't remember if they were 2 or 4 voice? Also the Saltarelle Atalante, I've never played one but 3 voices and 25/14 sounds like it would do the trick. Or a 3-voice, 3-row, 34 treble button box with Stradella bass. I think Hohner made something like this, but it's possible by switching ends. One of these days I'll just rewire and learn B/C/C#.
Having gone this far, I have to say it's refreshing to play along the G row on my G/C and accompany only with the G and D bass/chords. Gives the tunes a wholly different feel than when playing more 'melodic' bass to accompany the C row inside-out.
So how about a 6-voice, 1-row MMMMMM in three different keys? ;D Someone must have messed around with that idea. More trouble than it's worth?
How would you characterize the difference between typical diatonc style and 'club method' style.
Start with a 1 row Hohner in G, then a D/G Pokerwork, a C/F then for songs, one row 4 stop in C ,then a better 3 voice D/G ( great ). Friends play Klezma & Gypsy etc. so after long search a B,C,C# 60 bass then another with 48. The D/G's are short on reversal D&E's - B,C,C# has only G's push & D's & A's pull on the treble end, melodic bass is great fun. All the the different systems are great, just different. Such a large range with so few buttons. After a little while the apparent shortcomings seem to disappear, most of the time. By the way I didn't read George Garside's thread on the B,C,C# until sometime after I had started playing it, his experiences were exactly the same as mine. There is a DG Club with 48 bass and a BC also with 48 bass on Accordions of London's site. I've not seen a B,C,C# CLUB yet (treble chords ?)
-
sometimes I don't really have a clue what everyone is talking about although I probably should.
-
I think it could be the one my wife bought for me in Manchester on Valentine's day. I row, seven buttons and, er, pink.....
I had to lengthen the straps before I cold play it, mind, but it actually plays quite well for a melodeon made in China for kids! Inside it's actually made of wood and covered in pearloid (I's always assumed that they were just plastic) and even has removable reed blocks. I can feel some "tweaks" coming on.....
Mike
PS - for me, the real ultimate has to be an old 1-row 4-stop Hohner. I'm not bothered about expensive hand made Italian boxes, pretty as they are. An old 1-row just has a sort of credibility, and that 4-reed noise makes the hairs on the back of my kneck stand on end. Or would, if I still had any.......
-
My ultimate box would have more bass possibilities.. Specifically, I wish the old Club boxes were built with 12 basses along 2 rows, allowing the player to choose either more typical diatonic style play, or to play more along the lines of the 'Club method.'
Something else I think is nice: a 3-voice, 2-row box, with 23 treble and 12 basses (I think PS made these? Can't remember if they were 2 or 4 voice? Also the Saltarelle Atalante, I've never played one but 3 voices and 25/14 sounds like it would do the trick. Or a 3-voice, 3-row, 34 treble button box with Stradella bass. I think Hohner made something like this, but it's possible by switching ends. One of these days I'll just rewire and learn B/C/C#.
Having gone this far, I have to say it's refreshing to play along the G row on my G/C and accompany only with the G and D bass/chords. Gives the tunes a wholly different feel than when playing more 'melodic' bass to accompany the C row inside-out.
So how about a 6-voice, 1-row MMMMMM in three different keys? ;D Someone must have messed around with that idea. More trouble than it's worth?
How would you characterize the difference between typical diatonc style and 'club method' style.
By more 'typical diatonic' play (techinically, I know this is a lousy way to describe what I mean) I mean more like how you would play along the row on a single row box, or even a 2-row box with very limited crossing over, choosing lots of bellows reversals. Bass accompaniment would be limited to one or two sets of bass buttons, or melodic bass accompaniment with the extra 'melodeon basses.'
'Club method' I mean how a Club box was meant to be played, using the gleichton key on the inside row, playing in keys outside the home rows, inherently much more crossing over, using the half row, and using the original Club bass buttons. I don't understand how Hohner came up with such a brilliant system and didn't think that the player would need more basses. Seems that they put one foot in the direction of "chromasticity" (B-side to "Synchronicity?" ;D) and then had a sit down before finishing the job.
On the other hand, Club system is still alive and kicking with few modifications so this is probably all rubbish. But I thought I'd like the best of both worlds in a Club box.
-
A piano accordion with musette tuning on the treble side and deep helikon bass reeds on the Stradella bass side. In other words the ultimate would be a piano accordion that sounds like a Steirische Harmonika. I got to play one, custom-made by the Schmidt company in Austria.
-
Ultimate Box? Any one that will do all the work for me. A psychic box that will read my mind and play all the notes I intend to play, rather than the ones my fingers want to play!
-
I guess that when I started this thread the thought that was in my mind is that I am wavering about placing an order for a 3 row eighteen bass diatonic accordion. Despite the weight, such an instrument would suit the way my musical imagination works. Yet there is always the nagging doubt in my mind that maybe I'd be better off with a small CBA or PA. Saltarelle and Castagnari both sell such instruments.
But whenever I play a piano accordion it feels like cheating. Its so easy! You just squeeze the bellows and play the notes. PAs and CBAs compared to diatonics, are like powered ships compared to sailing ships. They are efficient but they lack soul and to some extend craftmanship. Just like a sailing ship, a diatonic requires skill and sensitivity to transcend its limitations. Working a complex tune with interesting harmonies on a diatonic has much of the same satisfaction for me as tacking a sailing boat through a narrow tidal water, or pushing a difficult route across a trackless mountain rather than following the footpath.
-
What a lovely post, which so neatly sums up my feelings.
I've been playing piano accordion for 25 years plus and do it well, although I say so myself. If find I get bored with tunes quickly and start mucking about with harmonies on the melody and hand and playing parts of the tune or a countermelody on the basses. I took up the concertina (english) some years ago and have reached the same point. There comes a time when you suddenly realise you've been playing a tune in G, then the same tune with an accompaiment in Eminor-ish, then dropped the whole thing into Gminor with a time signature change, just to keep yourself amused!
The melodeon, which I've been playing now for about six weeks, is an intellectual challenge and an opportunity to revisit harmonies and tune structures with the instrument's limitations. I've rediscovered the virtue of "simple" in some cases.
I think I'm actually going to have to buy one of my own before the thing comes out to play for the Morris, simply because I'm playing a borrowed Erica upside-down and struggling to reach the air button at times. I know modifications are possible but it's not my box.
-
I rather like suffolkboy's comparison too. But I think that an 18-bass 3-row diatonic is getting close to a ship with sails _and_ a steam engine.
My ideal is something about the size and weight of an Erica / Black Dot but with 12 basses and a more precise action, made by a craftsman I can talk to. Hoping the Gaillard I have ordered will do the trick. He lives down the road from my mother in law after all. I'd have liked an longer inside row (10/11) (not to mention a shorter wait) but reckon you can't have absolutely everything you want - or you'd never buy another box and that would be (in Lord Denning's words) an "appalling vista."
-
As an aside, why do they not make three-rows in DGC? For English players, that would give the whole scale of G in either direction.....
-
The C row would be very high and squeaky.
-
The C row would be very high and squeaky.
Multipurpose melodeon for frightening away stray dogs.. might also reduce my car insurance if I mounted it on the front bumper of the car! :D
Although a low D row is an interesting concept...
-
As an aside, why do they not make three-rows in DGC? For English players, that would give the whole scale of G in either direction.....
if you want the whole scal in G ( or whatever) in either direction you might just as well buy a piano or continental chromatic accordion - surely the whole point of a 'sook and blaw' box is that you have to do just that!
george
-
As an aside, why do they not make three-rows in DGC? For English players, that would give the whole scale of G in either direction.....
In my opinion, a better solution is to have a G/D box with a row of accidental that includes C, C#, D and E in the opposite direction plus a range of the most useful accidentals, such as F, Bb, Eb and G#. I converted a box to this system about three years ago and now have two such boxes - one of the best things I ever did!
-
if you want the whole scal in G ( or whatever) in either direction you might just as well buy a piano or continental chromatic accordion - surely the whole point of a 'sook and blaw' box is that you have to do just that!
george
I believe this too. It's the unique 'percussive' quality of the box that really grabs me.
cheers
Sandy
:)
-
As an aside, why do they not make three-rows in DGC? For English players, that would give the whole scale of G in either direction.....
In my opinion, a better solution is to have a G/D box with a row of accidental that includes C, C#, D and E in the opposite direction plus a range of the most useful accidentals, such as F, Bb, Eb and G#. I converted a box to this system about three years ago and now have two such boxes - one of the best things I ever did!
I've had one of these for a long time (in fact it's the prototype Castagnari Dony which I persuaded them to convert into a 3-row for me); the thing that makes it less than perfect is the size and weight.
Now if **** (name removed to protect the innocent) succeeds in building the 2.5 row 2-reed 8-bass we've been talking about (with ideas taken from my Oakwood/Tommy/Preciosa plus some of my own crazy ones) that *would* be my ideal melodeon...
Ian
-
Having the whole scale of G in either direction doesn't mean you have to play melody across the rows, it just annoys me that there are chords I want to use which I cannot make - D7 for example, which is only F#minor without the D.
I like the idea of having the relevant keys - and there aren't many, C, C#, D and E - on a half row.
-
if you want the whole scal in G ( or whatever) in either direction you might just as well buy a piano or continental chromatic accordion - surely the whole point of a 'sook and blaw' box is that you have to do just that!
This to me is the key issue ( no pun intended). Take a Handry 18, or a Loffet Pro (which is the box I'm most attracted to sound wise). Depending on exactly how it's set up, you've got a box that is a bit of a paradox. It is pretty nearly chromatic and has enough reversals to play across the rows with very little push or pull. You've got a box that approaches the flexibility of a PA or CBA, but grafted on to the basic melodeon push pull scale so you have to hunt around and pull all sorts of tricks to achieve this. Bandoneons and the bigger Anglos are similar in this respect.
Listening to and watching guys who play these big boxes, Riccardo Tesi, Marc Perrone etc they seem to be playing mainly across the rows, so the push pull concept has become a bit of an anachronism. There is nothing mushy about these players either. When they really crank it up there is every bit as much rhythmic vitality as say John Kirkpatrick pushing and pulling a Hohner. But maybe there is a point where you've got so far from the simple "melodeon," that you might as well play a CBA or PA and make life simple for yourself. Yet to my ear at least you could never be fooled into thinking that Perrone or Tesi are playing anything other than a diatonic accordion. Maybe its just ignorance on my part, but I've never heard a a PA or CBA which approaches that special diatonic accordion sound. (though they have fine qualities of their own) What is that sound? A little rawness, a little poignancy, a bit more like a voice and less like a fairground organ.... I don't know.
-
so you have to hunt around and pull all sorts of tricks to achieve this. Bandoneons and the bigger Anglos are similar in this respect.
. [/quote]
makes a BCC# sound very easy & logical in comparison as the relationship between notes on stays exactly the same whatever key you are playing in - no need to hunt around or pull all sorts of tricks!
I think the reason for the 'diatonic' sound is brought about by the fact that some notes are changed by using a different pair of buttons & some by changing bellows direction. Which occurs where is dictated by the needs of the tune and to some degree by the wishesof the driver. Therefore this subtly different way of changing notes is unevenly distributed according to the tune, the layout of the box and the way it is played. This applies to all diatonic boxes including those on which a whole scale can be played in one direction as you cant go on extending or pushing the bellows for ever. Piano & continental chromatic players also have to change bellow direction but most try to make the change at a phrasing point in a tune so as to minimise the effect of the bellows direction change that provides the diatonics with their subtly different sound.
For what its worth I think being able to play a scale in one direction is a very mixed blessing as it necesitates use of a lot of bellows which in turn reduces the all important control of the bellows for dynamics, rhythm etc etc. and certainly on larger boxes the furthur you let the bellows out the harder they are to get back (? uphill) whilst retaining any degree of finesse.
george
-
For what its worth I think being able to play a scale in one direction is a very mixed blessing as it necesitates use of a lot of bellows which in turn reduces the all important control of the bellows for dynamics, rhythm etc etc. and certainly on larger boxes the further you let the bellows out the harder they are to get back (? uphill) whilst retaining any degree of finesse.
For me the reason for having all the notes in D and G in both directions is not primarily so that I can play a scale in one direction. My reasons are:
- to give more choice in the use of basses. For instance, in a tune where a phrase is repeated, I might play it the first time mainly on the push using G basses and the second time mainly on the pull using Em basses.
- to make it easier to play triplets and cuts.
- to provide more flexibility in phrasing. For instance, I usually play jaunty polkas using lots of changes in bellows direction, but I might play whole phrases of a slow air in the same direction so that I can drone the basses.
So, by having all the notes in both directions, I am not trying to make the melodeon sound like a piano accordion (perish the thought!). I am simply seeking more flexibility and ways to make difficult bits easier to play.
-
Heresy I know, but my ultimate melodeon probably ends up looking a lot like and (more importantly) giving me the same musical options as a PA...however, I'm rather enjoying being diatonically challenged at the moment...though I often miss being able to play all scales in all directions...now there's a thought!
AL
-
For me the reason for having all the notes in D and G in both directions is not primarily so that I can play a scale in one direction. My reasons are:
- to give more choice in the use of basses. For instance, in a tune where a phrase is repeated, I might play it the first time mainly on the push using G basses and the second time mainly on the pull using Em basses.
- to make it easier to play triplets and cuts.
- to provide more flexibility in phrasing. For instance, I usually play jaunty polkas using lots of changes in bellows direction, but I might play whole phrases of a slow air in the same direction so that I can drone the basses.
So, by having all the notes in both directions, I am not trying to make the melodeon sound like a piano accordion (perish the thought!). I am simply seeking more flexibility and ways to make difficult bits easier to play.
[/quote]
just acting as devils aadvocate - doesn't it make more sense to alter the bass to fit the treble rather than altring the treble to fit the bass. Am thinking particularly of using some form of same both ways bass i.e. stradella or trixitica or even a mixture as used by some irish players (layouts on melnet). It is possible to accomodate 48 stradella on a 2 row double ray de lux as has been done very successfully by Bruce Lindsay in Scotland. Other possibilities include 12 stradella as on some double ray delux & trichord or 8 or 12 thirdless major chords which would provide reasonable harmony and reasonable rhythm for such a small number of buttons - you would in effect have the pa without the um!
george ;)
-
For what its worth I think being able to play a scale in one direction is a very mixed blessing as it necesitates use of a lot of bellows which in turn reduces the all important control of the bellows for dynamics, rhythm etc etc. and certainly on larger boxes the further you let the bellows out the harder they are to get back (? uphill) whilst retaining any degree of finesse.
For me the reason for having all the notes in D and G in both directions is not primarily so that I can play a scale in one direction. My reasons are:
- to give more choice in the use of basses. For instance, in a tune where a phrase is repeated, I might play it the first time mainly on the push using G basses and the second time mainly on the pull using Em basses.
- to make it easier to play triplets and cuts.
- to provide more flexibility in phrasing. For instance, I usually play jaunty polkas using lots of changes in bellows direction, but I might play whole phrases of a slow air in the same direction so that I can drone the basses.
So, by having all the notes in both directions, I am not trying to make the melodeon sound like a piano accordion (perish the thought!). I am simply seeking more flexibility and ways to make difficult bits easier to play.
The price for more notes in both directions is the same as the price for more reeds or more basses -- more size and weight, which makes it difficult to get that push-pull crispness and punch that you can with a lighter box.
To see this taken to its logical extreme have a look at this...
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=jDMhFTiBpC0&feature=related
Cheers
Ian
P.S. Yes a lot of it is fabulous fingerwork, but just look at what he does with the bellows :-)
P.P.S. My wife said "I bet he hasn't got a girlfriend..."
-
The price for more notes in both directions is the same as the price for more reeds or more basses -- more size and weight, which makes it difficult to get that push-pull crispness and punch that you can with a lighter box.
Yes, it can lead to extra weight, but I got round that by buying a new, improved model, Castagnari Benny. It is light and has the punch and push-pull crispness we all desire. It also has a great tone, especially since Castagnari have corrected the anaemic bass that let down the earlier (slightly smaller) Benny.
-
The price for more notes in both directions is the same as the price for more reeds or more basses -- more size and weight, which makes it difficult to get that push-pull crispness and punch that you can with a lighter box.
Yes, it can lead to extra weight, but I got round that by buying a new, improved model, Castagnari Benny. It is light and has the punch and push-pull crispness we all desire. It also has a great tone, especially since Castagnari have corrected the anaemic bass that let down the earlier (slightly smaller) Benny.
I'd be interested to know what they did to fix the basses, the Benny's used to be *really* weedy...
So how much does it weigh?
Ian
P.S. After doing some searching, I guess the answers are 1) added a third bass reed 2) 3.1kg
(I guess it's similar to a Tommy inside but with the 3 reed blocks being 1 per row (2 reeds) instead of 1 per row and 1 low one shared)
-
I'd be interested to know what they did to fix the basses, the Benny's used to be *really* weedy...
So how much does it weigh?
Ian
P.S. After doing some searching, I guess the answers are 1) added a third bass reed 2) 3.1kg
(I guess it's similar to a Tommy inside but with the 3 reed blocks being 1 per row (2 reeds) instead of 1 per row and 1 low one shared)
You are certainly correct about the weight and I think you are correct about the reed blocks, although I don't have time to check as I am just about to go away for a few days. They definitely made the Benny a bit larger than the earlier version in order to house the enlarged reed blocks in the bass end.
-
if you want the whole scal in G ( or whatever) in either direction you might just as well buy a piano or continental chromatic accordion - surely the whole point of a 'sook and blaw' box is that you have to do just that!
george
I believe this too. It's the unique 'percussive' quality of the box that really grabs me.
cheers
Sandy
:)
While the "percussive" qualities or "bellows dynamics" of push-pull boxes are often cited as a major advantage, I think it's also worth remembering the compactness or "efficiency" of the layout. You have a lot of notes over a wide range within reach under your hand. Come to traditional tunes from button box, whistle, or fiddle etc and start playing them on a "piano" keyboard (whatever sound generation device may be attached to it) and you suddenly realise that they cover quite a large range and your hand is having to fly around in big jumps across intervals that are hardly noticeable on the "traditional" instruments. Although that's routine technique to be learned by keyboard players, it's just not an issue on the more "traditional" instruments.
(There have been some typically forthright comments on this issue from resident MG over at thesession.org.)
Tom
-
So how about a 6-voice, 1-row MMMMMM in three different keys? ;D Someone must have messed around with that idea. More trouble than it's worth?
The problem is, by the time you add that much weight, you might as well have a three-row keyboard. At least you can access all of those notes!
-Andy
P.S. For me, the ultimate in "melodeonness" is a one-row box made in Quebec!
-
P.S. For me, the ultimate in "melodeonness" is a one-row box made in Quebec!
You bet! It's the quintessence of the melodeon!
-
The melodeon is starting to spoil me. My right hand doesn't need to travel as far to do the same runs on a button accordion as on a piano accordion. However, I do need to remember when to reverse the bellows.
-
I played a PA five years ago before coming to the melodeon.. The rhythmical accompaniment of the left hand on the PA is what attracted me to accordions in general, but the boring bellows use on the PA is what made me want to try the box. I put it off in favor of focusing on the concertina for too long. Maybe I never came to realize the PA's potential, or maybe it's the push/pull attitude I came to appreciate on the concertina, but I feel the box provides better sport, more opportunities for changing it up in any given tune. It's hard to become disinterested when there's so many tricks to be had and different ways to accomplish the same task. The box is a compact, loud, and spunky little thing, so devilishly simple but some people can really work wizardry with them. Don't know why I overlooked it for so long.
After rereading this thread, I'm still dying to have this one and that one, and would like to change this and that about another, but I'm also inclined to believe that any melodeon is the "ultimate" melodeon. It is truly an inspired invention.
-
how about a streb with 'predictive keyboard' like what mobile phones have. cock ups would be a thing of the pst - or would they
george
-
I am getting a bit off topic...
Learning to play the melodeon has actually improved my bellows technique on the piano accordion.
-
George - Where can I buy one?
-
how about a streb with 'predictive keyboard' like what mobile phones have. cock ups would be a thing of the pst - or would they
george
My melodeon already has a predictive layout - I can totally predict that it won't play what I want it too - or is there a language setting that needs to be changed???
AL
-
A box with a tap, now there's the pinnacle of design sophistication. It could be done with a lightweight box, like the Lily or Pokerwork. I'll gladly join the two-strap club to handle the extra weight. I wouldn't have to lose my seat to get a beer. ;D ;D ;D ;D
-
A box with a tap, now there's the pinnacle of design sophistication. It could be done with a lightweight box, like the Lily or Pokerwork. I'll gladly join the two-strap club to handle the extra weight. I wouldn't have to lose my seat to get a beer. ;D ;D ;D ;D
and how about a cup/glass holder on top - if nothing else this would promote ultra sensitive bellows movement
george ;D
-
And a Blackberry installed atop the cabinet, facing the player. Work from home, or the pub.
-
The Blackberry could be used to receive e-mails or text messages from people telling us which tune they want to hear.
-
For me the reason for having all the notes in D and G in both directions is not primarily so that I can play a scale in one direction. My reasons are:
to give more choice in the use of basses. For instance, in a tune where a phrase is repeated, I might play it the first time mainly on the push using G basses and the second time mainly on the pull using Em basses.
to make it easier to play triplets and cuts.
to provide more flexibility in phrasing. For instance, I usually play jaunty polkas using lots of changes in bellows direction, but I might play whole phrases of a slow air in the same direction so that I can drone the basses.
Agreed............it's having the choice I like, being able to choose how you phrase a passage. Some tunes sound great up and down the rows, some great across..........often it changes each time through the tune.
As someone said, on a 38 key anglo ( with a few reeds slid around) you can do the same thing.
Robin