Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: gettabettabox on February 20, 2014, 08:32:15 PM

Title: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: gettabettabox on February 20, 2014, 08:32:15 PM
this post is a genuine enquiry and certainly not intended to be provocative in any way other than to stimulate response and to learn.
why is it that most melodeon players of English traditional music are so fond of employing basses and chords, often constantly throughout the tune?
are traditional English tunes not capable of being just what they are?... it seems to me that some are very fine melodies,  do they always need accompaniment along the way?
also, can I ask, how does this impact in session playing, where 'ethereal' chords from stringed instruments are being played?
many thanks.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: EastAnglianTed on February 20, 2014, 09:01:23 PM
this post is a genuine enquiry and certainly not intended to be provocative in any way other than to stimulate response and to learn.
why is it that most melodeon players of English traditional music are so fond of employing basses and chords, often constantly throughout the tune?
    Hmm good question! Personally, and I do mean personally, I buy a melodeon as a bass end and a treble end, if I wanted half an instrument I would buy half  ;)
    I get your point though, and it's an interesting thought. I know some people who play just the one side, and it sounds just fine. Maybe, because I am not the best at right hand harmonies, I think that tunes (in the pants way I play  8)) sound a bit bland played only with the right hand, and the left hand can do alot to add rhythm and punch to even the most blandest of right hands.
    I suppose I was brought up learning to play both ends, and with just one it doesn't sound the way I want it to/the way I think it should.  (:)
    Personal opinions of course  :P
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on February 20, 2014, 09:06:25 PM
My own view, being a dartmoor style player, is that the om-pah acts more for percusion and to keep time for dances.
if you listen to mark bazely, he makes his bass note sound like a kick drum, and a short stabby staccatto chord sound like a snare ! I can see the benifits of playing bass and chords for dancing, keeping strict tempo ect. In a session, its so the bohdran player can keep time !
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Simon W on February 20, 2014, 09:28:21 PM
In answer to your question yes lots of the melodies can stand up for themselves without bass. I quite often only play the melody line, but there is something nice about playing both ends, otherwise you may as well just play a mouth organ or any other melody instrument. And as Tommy says the basses can adda real percussive element. But I also agree that sometimes the basses on a melodeon can obscure the harmonies suggested by other instruments in a session or band. The other thing I used to find playing for Cotswold morris is that the way some people bass style locks you into a very "four square" rhythm and I used to prefer playing fiddle or just the treble end which was a bit freer. Having said that some players are able to capture that type of fluidity really well using both ends.
I suspect that the real reason is that we spend so much time and mental effort learing how to play the two ends simultaneously to different rhythms that we're not going give up!

Simon
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 20, 2014, 11:09:42 PM
.
   "Light" left end is much better on the ear, but not always easy to achieve …
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on February 21, 2014, 12:36:33 AM
One of the reasons for using the bass end so much is that a lot of us play for dancers. Though I don't play my box very often in "dance mode", I find that dancers appreciate the basses being used to help emphasise the rhythm. I've probably put this very badly, but as a dancer myself, I find dancing to a box with bass is easier than without.  :Ph
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 21, 2014, 05:28:23 AM
If I'm playing in a band with a bass player or a keyboard player then I play only the right hand; in a session I generally play both ends regardless, but try to keep the left hand light as outlined above; playing for morris or for social dance where there is no bass instrument present I play both ends with much more emphasis on the bass; playing solo for, say, a clog dancer I use the bass to hold the time and regard the tune asa the decoration; playing for listening, such as in a folk club, I'll vary the approach so as to avoid the spot becoming too "samey"  - a wistful tune like "Bonny At Morn" will have no bass at all, a jaunty polka will have a jaunty bass, and for a "Playford" style tune I'll look for an interesting bass line. I think that about covers it for me.......

Graham
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Howard Jones on February 21, 2014, 09:07:18 AM
Firstly, that's clearly how the instrument was designed to be played, and how the majority of traditional players seem to have used it (although some seem to have used it more for percussion than harmony)

Broadly speaking, the English tradition seems to have had no fixed ideas about what instrumentation was appropriate or how they should be played.  People seem to have played whatever instruments were to hand, and if they allowed harmony there was no reason not to do so.  Contrast the Irish tradition, where there is a strong opinion that this should be melody-only and harmony is not appropriate.

I would be more inclined to question what role "ethereal' chords from stringed instruments have in traditional music.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: rees on February 21, 2014, 09:11:54 AM
On a visit to Kenmare way back when, I was in Crowley's Bar. Old Mrs Crowley played us a tune on her Double Ray. She played up and down the B row while hammering away on the C basses - interesting style.
I played some tunes on my D/G Pokerwork.
Later, Joe Burke and his mates came in. I swiftly hid my accordion.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Theo on February 21, 2014, 09:49:25 AM
There is a distinctly different style in northeast England.  Melodeons, in fact squeezeboxes of all kind are less common here, the predominant instrument is the fiddle.  Its an education to see how much rhythmic drive you can get with just melody instruments. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jWd0Xg8-sAs
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 21, 2014, 10:07:08 AM
on a discussion somewhere on here a while back, it was said that on a melodeon the drive comes from your right hand and the left accompanies it. That ties in with Theo's observations of the fiddlers in his locality who can drive a tune.
I used to play English concertina, and that illustrates it similarly. Leaving out those who chord behind the melody on an EC, some ( a lot ) play simple melodies as written with no emphasis at all, 'just play the dots' whereas others play with attack, light and dark etc and drive through a tune. It sounds like Theo's fiddlers are similar 'light and dark' players.
I came over to the Dark Side because I wanted to have a richer sound than with an EC so cherish the basses and chords on the left hand. I hope I'm not a slave to them though and do not just um-pah, I try and and mix in block chord/bass, runs and/or nothing as I feel I want to do in the tune.
Q
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: george garside on February 21, 2014, 10:16:52 AM
Indeed the rhythm must be incorporated/inherent  in the way the melody is played on a melodeon and no amount of whatever on the bass will cover lack of melodic tune playing.   

Having the ability to add anything from a strong um pa rhythm to lightly droned chords  is indeed handy but the bass does not have to be used just because it exists!  A free of charge and very effective ornamentation is to lay off the bass for some bits of a tune - a bar or two or perhaps just a couple of notes.   It can also be effective to play first time through without bass  for example in the tune  '' dark island''  then second time through adding a light gentle waltz rhythm  from the bass.

In other words the bass  can be  used or not used as the driver sees fit , and there are no right and wrongs about it

george
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 21, 2014, 10:32:28 AM
We seem to have moved to song? Went to the "monday afternoon, railway station" I kid you not, session this week and this month's Stalybridge station buffet was … hard to get into! They do songs, so i hazarded "Shotover River" which i do very lyrically (I hope). Mega chorus came in, very on the beat but I can cope with that, but with a whole extra bar in the middle! You don't fight such things, so I adapted melodeon music to fit in!

[plug] GPS mentioned a certain Northumbrian lullaby Here's how my family do it (https://soundcloud.com/dollymay/bonny-at-morn-by-dolly-may).

[radio guy] "That's a lovely song Dolly, how long have you known it"? …

            … "I can't remember ever not knowing it" ;) [/plug]
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on February 21, 2014, 10:51:09 AM
To be honest, the opening post is really begging the question.

Other traditions do use bass and rythmic accompaniment, including the Irish.

I know we're told so often that "the Irish this" and "the Irish that" as if they're all of one mind, following instructions from some folk music central authority ...

Well, someone ought to tell all those old Irish ceili and country dance bands that they were doing it all wrong, but you'd need a time machine for most of them.

Gallowglass Ceilidh Band:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HtgV9-0B3F4

Incidentally, looking up a few links for this post I searched for the Gallowglass Ceilidh Band on youtube and realised what that tuneful "humming" sound that is on all their old recording was. I often wondered when listening to now long worn out tapes of them (before the days of CDs), now I know is was a Saxophone. I never guessed that.

Of course you can find the same kind of thing in folk musics round the world, including those that have been heavily influenced by those in in different parts of these islands.

Now, I think (this is my opinion :-D ) that in these dance tunes that the most important thing is always the tune and how it interacts with the dance. We don't (English, Irish, Scottish, Welsh) "lay down a groove" and then warble an incidental tune over the top of it.

For dance music especially, in a way, it could be said that the melody instruments play the rhythm and the rhythm instruments play the melody.

See this wonderful example from the Geckoes:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Zcyk08xbFo

And that's the point. The rhythms played are a device to emphasise what the tune is doing for the dancers (oh, the piano and snaredrum so beloved by Scottish ceilidh bands).

Things to remember I think are that at the time that the Irish tradition had few or no guitars, nor did others (people often say there were no guitars in Irish folk music as if this was a unique thing). Small Jazz drum kits seem to have been making their way into English country dance bands at about the time that they were making their way into Irish ones. In all of them (in this islands again) smaller very local "bands" and individual musicians would have been the norm. Peasants (anywhere) don't tend to have relatively expensive instruments (both in terms of money and time spent). The days of lots of musicians, massed bands and big audiences were products of the industrial age and all traditions adapted accordingly.

There are no melodeons in either link above. As I noted elsewhere, melodeons/button accordions have had a great influence upon English, Irish and Scottish traditions, but they do not define them and the limited scope for playing bass end accompaniment on B/C boxes is not the defining feature of Irish dance music generally.

PS. Though the above does seem to be laying down the law or whatever, I know that this is just a contribution to a debate, so don't be reticent in coming forward and kicking the ideas around a bit and testing them out :-)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on February 21, 2014, 10:57:47 AM
There is a distinctly different style in northeast England.  Melodeons, in fact squeezeboxes of all kind are less common here, the predominant instrument is the fiddle.  Its an education to see how much rhythmic drive you can get with just melody instruments. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jWd0Xg8-sAs

Dead right! A super example.

Thrupenny Bit also comments that the drive for tunes really originates from the treble end on melodeons, something I've always held to.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 21, 2014, 11:13:17 AM
I'd go further. If your rhythm is "from the left end" you are probably playing it wrongly ( >:E ), though that is not to say that rhythm shouldn't come from the bellows

Put another way, your melody is the important bit; the left end chords are just there to "accompany" ::)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Clive Williams on February 21, 2014, 11:20:15 AM
Yes, I'd go with that - a lot of rhythm is actually, oddly, played on the right hand... the bass end is accompaniment and we use it... because we can. There are fairly few instruments that can easliy play melody and accompaniment at the same time, and the melodeon is one of them. It makes practice/playing much more enjoyable, because to get consistently good music with just a treble instrument is really very very difficult indeed. Lovely though the fiddle video is, and it is, there's 4 of them, and for me a lot of the beauty of their music lies in a couple of them doing rhythmic chordal pulses, while another is harmonising. Playing solo, and getting the same musical interest in it, is rather harder.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: gettabettabox on February 21, 2014, 11:31:10 AM
great replies, thanks to all.
I posted this question because to me, it is the melody and it's inherent rhythm, that is primary to my ears. we all know when we hear a skilled player, usually whatever the instrument and of whatever genre or tradition, because of the 'feel' they put into their expressive playing, seeking out the nuances, corners and the little secrets in tunes.
I delight in hearing the bare tune, then that same tune fully dressed! (see George garsides post) 
- but I do like good basses and chords, percussive or accompaniment wise, .. used as appropriate for the mood of the tune and the company.
in all honesty, I guess I know that English tunes can speak/sing for themselves, I just wanted to stimulate thought here and learn in the process. thanks again.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 21, 2014, 11:43:02 AM
thanks to you kind sir for bringing it up. It's always worth remembering and reflecting on what we do and why we do it.
Q
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 21, 2014, 11:43:55 AM
.

     fundamental, surely?
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 21, 2014, 12:44:09 PM
yes!
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: IanD on February 21, 2014, 05:39:28 PM
There is a distinctly different style in northeast England.  Melodeons, in fact squeezeboxes of all kind are less common here, the predominant instrument is the fiddle.  Its an education to see how much rhythmic drive you can get with just melody instruments. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jWd0Xg8-sAs
Indeed -- but of course they're not all playing the tune, one starts by playing pretty much what the off-beat left-hand chord on a box would be doing... ;-)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Matt (Kings Norton) on February 21, 2014, 08:01:10 PM

Now, I think (this is my opinion :-D ) that in these dance tunes that the most important thing is always the tune and how it interacts with the dance. We don't (English, Irish, Scottish, Welsh) "lay down a groove" and then warble an incidental tune over the top of it.

This seems like quite an important idea to me.  Very different from the music I grew up on, and for that reason it took me a long time to understand (or partly understand) why people were doing what they were doing  at music events (e.g. playing through tunes) and saying what they were saying on this forum.  I knew there must be a reason behind it and it turns out there is a good one.  All very interesting.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on February 21, 2014, 09:40:00 PM

Now, I think (this is my opinion :-D ) that in these dance tunes that the most important thing is always the tune and how it interacts with the dance. We don't (English, Irish, Scottish, Welsh) "lay down a groove" and then warble an incidental tune over the top of it.

This seems like quite an important idea to me.  Very different from the music I grew up on, and for that reason it took me a long time to understand (or partly understand) why people were doing what they were doing  at music events (e.g. playing through tunes) and saying what they were saying on this forum.  I knew there must be a reason behind it and it turns out there is a good one.  All very interesting.

Yes, though I shouldn't really have been quite so pejorative about it  :-\

"warble an incidental melody indeed"   ::)

Though to defend myself, it is an concept that has been quite difficult to get over to to some musicians (basically some bass players, rhythm guitarists and percusionists not from a folk background). It is, as you say, what you're used to.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Anahata on February 21, 2014, 10:40:41 PM
I fully agree that the rhythm should be in the tune. On a melodeon, though, that doesn't mean it's all done by the right hand. The left arm is providing the bellows action and that's the exact equivalent of the rhythmic drive that's coming from the bowing hands/arms of those fiddlers (trust me: I'm a string player too!). Don't underestimate its importance, just because the sound is coming from the right hand side of the box! It is worth getting used to playing without the basses to (a) check that your rhythm is accurate (not masked by the oom-pahs) and (b) make sure you're using you bellows for dynamics. It's not like the air-chest of a church organ, designed to supply air at constant pressure...

of course they're not all playing the tune, one starts by playing pretty much what the off-beat left-hand chord on a box would be doing... ;-)
Yes, I noticed that too  ;)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: gettabettabox on February 22, 2014, 12:13:22 AM
I fully agree that the rhythm should be in the tune. On a melodeon, though, that doesn't mean it's all done by the right hand. The left arm is providing the bellows action and that's the exact equivalent of the rhythmic drive that's coming from the bowing hands/arms of those fiddlers (trust me: I'm a string player too!). Don't underestimate its importance, just because the sound is coming from the right hand side of the box! It is worth getting used to playing without the basses to (a) check that your rhythm is accurate (not masked by the oom-pahs) and (b) make sure you're using you bellows for dynamics. It's not like the air-chest of a church organ, designed to supply air at constant pressure...

of course they're not all playing the tune, one starts by playing pretty much what the off-beat left-hand chord on a box would be doing... ;-)
Yes, I noticed that too  ;)

yes, it's true...it's very difficult to squeeze even a poor tune out of a melodeon unless you use the left hand. I have seen one played with a foot in the bass strap though! (that was a tune played without chords if I remember correctly, just a little bit of diminished on the right hand. (I fully agree about the dynamics afforded by bellow control, you can midi it or play it)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: oggiesnr on February 22, 2014, 07:37:02 AM
The converse is that I find it hard to imagine many of Andy Cutting's tunes (which seem to be going into the melodeon "tradition") without the left hand, and quite a precise one at that.  I suppose it's the difference between tunes played on the melodeon and tunes written for the melodeon.

Steve
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Anahata on February 22, 2014, 08:33:18 AM
The converse is that I find it hard to imagine many of Andy Cutting's tunes (which seem to be going into the melodeon "tradition") without the left hand, and quite a precise one at that.  I suppose it's the difference between tunes played on the melodeon and tunes written for the melodeon.

Steve

There's a certain English concertina player around here who doesn't have a high opinion of tunes like that. She has a point: it's not just that they are hard and unsatisfying to play on the EC, but a tune that doesn't stand on its purely melodic merits is less likely to get absorbed into the folk tradition. A tune built to last is usually one you can sing.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 22, 2014, 09:17:04 AM
I had a 'lightbulb' moment a few days back, whilst practicing one of Andy's tunes.
It's this only group of tunes I know where ( his exact ) bass/ chord lines are so highly integrated into the tune.
This makes them difficult for us ( me! ) to play as you need to get both hands right, as opposed to normally getting the right hand correct and the left hand ' more or less' right, or variable to your personal taste or ability.
I think of it as my old school art teacher had us do - colour wash the paper and paint the picture on top of it. That's how I think of his tunes.
Q
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 22, 2014, 09:17:35 AM
there are a stack of "favourite" EC tunes that are really awkward on melodeon! Generally 6/8 diddlers, nice tunes to, I think certain tunes suit certain instruments?

As for rhythm and accompanyment, we've explored the "left end line first" approach before, and commonly I still do it. That gets me going on a feasible "lay" of the melody on the rows. Thinking back to recent learning I then focus on right end … fiddly bits and variations within the rhythm.

While I've sort of pre-planned the left end, I actually add it once the tune is working. It's the only way I've found to keep it light. So that's something that works for me, and was what I meant by "accompany" on the left end.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Sage Herb on February 22, 2014, 09:23:37 AM

She has a point

She has indeed, lovely though these tunes are to listen to.
Best, Steve
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: IanD on February 22, 2014, 10:53:56 AM

She has a point

She has indeed, lovely though these tunes are to listen to.
Best, Steve
The mistake (IMHO) a lot of people writing tunes nowadays make is they seem to start with a chord sequence and then write a tune over it; this often results in what I call "noodling" tunes that go up and down without any direction or structure to them (there are of course many traditional tunes that do this too). To me the key of a really good tune is -- does it stick in your ear and you can not only remember it but find yourself humming it (and wanting to play it) afterwards?

A tune that *relies* on either the chords or fantastic playing to make it sound good (and you can't remember how the tune goes afterwards) isn't a good tune, it's a good arrangement of a not-so-good tune ;-)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Sage Herb on February 22, 2014, 11:59:34 AM

She has a point

She has indeed, lovely though these tunes are to listen to.
Best, Steve
The mistake (IMHO) a lot of people writing tunes nowadays make is they seem to start with a chord sequence and then write a tune over it;
I think that many songwriters proceed in a similar manner.
Cheers
Steve
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 22, 2014, 12:39:48 PM
That's a good observation Ian, I agree with that thought.
Q
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: ChrisP on February 22, 2014, 03:59:13 PM
Many of the English tunes now current were written for the stage, or for small bands, in the 18th and 19th centuries, and may have been originally conceived with more than a solo player in mind. They will not be damaged and may benefit from judicious harmonisation.
The other side of the coin is that many tunes were required by solo players; consequently many were either composed or evolved for that purpose. They usually diminish as more harmonies and noodles are added. Many hornpipes are strong enough to stand alone, and are diluted by too much chording along. I'm sure we can all think of people who are at fault in this regard.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: pikey on February 22, 2014, 04:02:55 PM

She has a point

She has indeed, lovely though these tunes are to listen to.
Best, Steve
The mistake (IMHO) a lot of people writing tunes nowadays make is they seem to start with a chord sequence and then write a tune over it; this often results in what I call "noodling" tunes that go up and down without any direction or structure to them (there are of course many traditional tunes that do this too). To me the key of a really good tune is -- does it stick in your ear and you can not only remember it but find yourself humming it (and wanting to play it) afterwards?

A tune that *relies* on either the chords or fantastic playing to make it sound good (and you can't remember how the tune goes afterwards) isn't a good tune, it's a good arrangement of a not-so-good tune ;-)

Agree. If you can't remember it after one hearing, it's not worth bothering with.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: ChrisP on February 22, 2014, 06:18:31 PM
Here's someone only using their right hand. Not realising the full potential of the instrument?

http://youtu.be/ONVjDpcouXc (http://youtu.be/ONVjDpcouXc)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 22, 2014, 07:38:03 PM
Yes Chris, but he's borrowed two other hands tht seem to be doing ok  ;D
Q
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: EastAnglianTed on February 22, 2014, 08:02:26 PM
Here's someone only using their right hand. Not realising the full potential of the instrument?
http://youtu.be/ONVjDpcouXc (http://youtu.be/ONVjDpcouXc)

    (:) I do love that video.
    Does he not play basses so as to not restrict himself to one or two keys?
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: ChrisP on February 22, 2014, 10:40:03 PM
Yes Chris, but he's borrowed two other hands tht seem to be doing ok  ;D
Q

Well it's probably a normal session and typically he's too polite to tell the other guy to shut up.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Anahata on February 22, 2014, 10:43:19 PM
    (:) I do love that video.
    Does he not play basses so as to not restrict himself to one or two keys?
One of the clever things about that video is the way he avoids accidentals by using different notes, but with such smoothness and panache you hardly notice anything's wrong. And when it came up before I think we all agreed that's a one-row box he's playing. It helps that Handel's original is remarkably consistent in staying in one key all the way through, but when the harmony strays from the home key it's all coming from the piano part. It's just like a Mozart Horn concerto : horn (natural horn with no valves) has an incredibly limited range of notes all in one key; orchestra weaves harmonies all around them; you don't notice the limitations.

Note also the expression and dynamics in that performance, which relates to my earlier posting about practising playing without basses and getting as much music out of the melody line as you can.

Oh, and aren't those bellows trills wonderful? Another "I didn't know you were allowed to do that" moment! (needs a good box!)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: IanD on February 22, 2014, 10:52:20 PM
    (:) I do love that video.
    Does he not play basses so as to not restrict himself to one or two keys?
One of the clever things about that video is the way he avoids accidentals by using different notes, but with such smoothness and panache you hardly notice anything's wrong. And when it came up before I think we all agreed that's a one-row box he's playing. It helps that Handel's original is remarkably consistent in staying in one key all the way through, but when the harmony strays from the home key it's all coming from the piano part. It's just like a Mozart Horn concerto : horn (natural horn with no valves) has an incredibly limited range of notes all in one key; orchestra weaves harmonies all around them; you don't notice the limitations.

Note also the expression and dynamics in that performance, which relates to my earlier posting about practising playing without basses and getting as much music out of the melody line as you can.

Oh, and aren't those bellows trills wonderful? Another "I didn't know you were allowed to do that" moment! (needs a good box!)

And his concealment of the notes that the box doesn't have is truly masterful ;-)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Gromit on February 22, 2014, 11:48:42 PM
Quote
Agree. If you can't remember it after one hearing, it's not worth bothering with.

Do you only play simple tunes then?
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 23, 2014, 09:10:35 AM
To me, it's not a question of simple tunes or complex tunes, it's the 'hook' in it that gives me an earworm.
Once through if it has 'something' in it that's catchy is all it takes........ and manages then to deviate and distract me off a chosen path of learning.
Q
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: IanD on February 23, 2014, 12:08:44 PM
Quote
Agree. If you can't remember it after one hearing, it's not worth bothering with.

Do you only play simple tunes then?
You don't have to be able to remember it note-for-note, maybe just a particularly catchy phrase sticks in your mind -- most people can't hum you the whole of "Also sprach Zarathustra" but they can all remember the signature bit.  But if none of it is memorable, it's not a good tune ;-)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 23, 2014, 12:34:11 PM
The mistake (IMHO) a lot of people writing tunes nowadays make is they seem to start with a chord sequence and then write a tune over it; this often results in what I call "noodling" tunes that go up and down without any direction or structure to them (there are of course many traditional tunes that do this too). To me the key of a really good tune is -- does it stick in your ear and you can not only remember it but find yourself humming it (and wanting to play it) afterwards?

A tune that *relies* on either the chords or fantastic playing to make it sound good (and you can't remember how the tune goes afterwards) isn't a good tune, it's a good arrangement of a not-so-good tune ;-)

Do we have here too the concept of tension/relaxation in music? Coming back into British sessioning in about 1998 I was struck that the melodeon tunes in particular so often seemed to sound "the same", that you could perhaps swap their AB parts in a modular way and … "hey guys, listen to my new tune"; I really suspected that was done!

All diatonic music expresses over an underlying chord "pavement"; melodeons do have severe restrictions in that department. But I concur with what I think may lie behind Ian's point, that we may play too much "in" the chord notes, "on" the beat? Whereas playing off beat (syncopate or swing) or "out" of chords carries more tension, thus more interest. In the latter I'm thinking of eg stressing say an F# against an Em chord, not the wilder blues stuff.

I sometimes wonder whether the "in chord" fashion might stem from the resurgence of one row play? Here it is all to easy to do that, albeit the better players seem to carry greater interest on the right hand, as discussed above.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: oggiesnr on February 23, 2014, 03:04:23 PM
I thing it's the other way.  Folks have got bigger and bigger boxes with more and more basses and more and more left hand cross chords and have gone "That's a cool chord" and written chord sequences and then tunes that can't really be played any other way and sound right.  This has now infected two row play and IMHO opinion we're in danger of losing the glorious simplicity of the instrument when it comes to writing new tunes.

Steve
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: rees on February 23, 2014, 03:56:29 PM
   This has now infected two row play and IMHO opinion we're in danger of losing the glorious simplicity of the instrument when it comes to writing new tunes.

Steve

My thoughts exactly.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 23, 2014, 05:02:58 PM
   This has now infected two row play and IMHO opinion we're in danger of losing the glorious simplicity of the instrument when it comes to writing new tunes.

Steve

My thoughts exactly.

Mine too. 
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 23, 2014, 05:23:35 PM
There seems to be a gathering swell of like minds.
Just reading JK's forward in his 2010 published 'jump at the Sun' tune book.
He has some typically forthright views,
 ' the melodies sustain interest perfectly adequately without some addled brain chucking in every oblique chord and syncopated rhythm available....  .... This isn't deeply sophisticated stuff on the whole and if you make chording too rich and lush you smother the natural strength of the melody....' Etc etc...
Quite John!
He expands it a bit more but I'll stop quoting there - go buy the book!
To my mind it's a breath of fresh air, and comes back to the original question at the start of the thread.

Also seems to be a vote too for a 2 row 8 bass box where it's limitations confine you to work within the simplicity of the melody and reduce the ability to overcomplicate things
Q
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: rees on February 23, 2014, 05:25:50 PM

Also seems to be a vote too for a 2 row 8 bass box where it's limitations confine you to work within the simplicity of the melody and reduce the ability to overcomplicate things
Q

My thoughts exactly - did I just say that?
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: george garside on February 23, 2014, 05:33:23 PM
seconded, thirded or  whatever!

george
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 23, 2014, 09:40:52 PM
Seem to be outvoted in this, but I think the concept of playing the notes of one of your rows (eg pull G row) against chords of another (that'd be Em) to create interest is still worth exploring. It's as valid on a 2-row 8-bass as on anything else.

"Mazurka Limousine" offered as a nice example of a tune that has "lasted". Or "Idbury Hill" ::)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: malcolmbebb on February 23, 2014, 09:54:57 PM
mmmm. Idbury Hill. A favourite. Must learn it. Why do so many insist on Morning Star?
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: oggiesnr on February 23, 2014, 09:56:55 PM
Chris, I think there's a difference between learning a tune, playing around with the chords and going "that sounds good" and playing around with the chords and then writing a tune that fits just that sequence of chords played in that way.

The latter also means that it's very hard to play the tune unless you're playing it on the same tuning of box it was written for or transpose keys.

Steve
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 23, 2014, 10:05:40 PM
I was replying to Ian's post suggesting that current melodeon repertoire has all got rather too chord based, and as such "noodling".

Clearly this is a popular genre on the instrument, as such entirely valid, of course.

But there are other ways to write tunes. Actually nothing in the posts above has answered my offered view that "they all tend to sound the same" … unless we count in those  … "my thoughts exactly" ;)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: squeezy on February 23, 2014, 10:12:17 PM
I thing it's the other way.  Folks have got bigger and bigger boxes with more and more basses and more and more left hand cross chords and have gone "That's a cool chord" and written chord sequences and then tunes that can't really be played any other way and sound right.  This has now infected two row play and IMHO opinion we're in danger of losing the glorious simplicity of the instrument when it comes to writing new tunes.

Steve

I can see there's a lot of support for this kind of thinking ... but firstly I should point out that a good tune is a good tune and should be transferable to other instruments too - the melodeon should never write the tune!

Secondly - simplicity is always the best way to get to the nuts and bolts of the tune and sometimes it's the perfect way to play it throughout with that traditional old school melodeon technique.  But there are jaw dropping examples of creative and playful uses of more unusual chords and left-hand accompaniment in my iTunes playlist where it lifts and changes the tune to positive effect.  Sometimes this allows a single simple trad tune to become a complete complex piece of music on one instrument.

Of course this kind of playing only works when carefully thought out and executed well otherwise it can easily sound like a mess - and even played brilliantly it rarely sits well in sessions where there may be many other chord and rhythmic ideas bubbling around on other instruments!

It seems a little unfair to use words like "infected" to describe people being a bit more adventurous on their left-hands ... it's not a disease, it's something which some people choose to do and others choose not to do.  I don't think we're in danger of losing anything myself - we only have more ideas and techniques on which to draw inspiration from.  There's absolutely nothing to stop any player today from trying to play like Bob Cann or Oscar Woods.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: IanD on February 23, 2014, 10:34:40 PM
I was in no way suggesting that chords detract from a tune, in fact exactly the opposite -- I can certainly think of tunes where the accompaniment helps make the tune something special, for example Shooting.

What I don't like is tunes where the chords seem to be the whole point where the tune is basically an unmemorable accompaniment to a chord sequence, and there are quite a lot of these, especially modern written tunes.

Which isn't saying that all modern written tunes are like this, there are some absolute crackers around -- some people seem to have the knack of writing earworms that sound like really good trad tunes (John K, Fred Paris, Mats Eden, Kjell-Erik Ericsson to quote a few I can think of immediately), but a lot don't...
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: EastAnglianTed on February 23, 2014, 10:35:12 PM
I thing it's the other way.  Folks have got bigger and bigger boxes with more and more basses and more and more left hand cross chords and have gone "That's a cool chord" and written chord sequences and then tunes that can't really be played any other way and sound right.  This has now infected two row play and IMHO opinion we're in danger of losing the glorious simplicity of the instrument when it comes to writing new tunes.

Steve

I can see there's a lot of support for this kind of thinking ... but firstly I should point out that a good tune is a good tune and should be transferable to other instruments too - the melodeon should never write the tune!

Secondly - simplicity is always the best way to get to the nuts and bolts of the tune and sometimes it's the perfect way to play it throughout with that traditional old school melodeon technique.  But there are jaw dropping examples of creative and playful uses of more unusual chords and left-hand accompaniment in my iTunes playlist where it lifts and changes the tune to positive effect.  Sometimes this allows a single simple trad tune to become a complete complex piece of music on one instrument.

Of course this kind of playing only works when carefully thought out and executed well otherwise it can easily sound like a mess - and even played brilliantly it rarely sits well in sessions where there may be many other chord and rhythmic ideas bubbling around on other instruments!

It seems a little unfair to use words like "infected" to describe people being a bit more adventurous on their left-hands ... it's not a disease, it's something which some people choose to do and others choose not to do.  I don't think we're in danger of losing anything myself - we only have more ideas and techniques on which to draw inspiration from.  There's absolutely nothing to stop any player today from trying to play like Bob Cann or Oscar Woods.
    +1 well said.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: squeezy on February 23, 2014, 11:05:54 PM
What I don't like is tunes where the chords seem to be the whole point where the tune is basically an unmemorable accompaniment to a chord sequence, and there are quite a lot of these, especially modern written tunes.

Which isn't saying that all modern written tunes are like this, there are some absolute crackers around -- some people seem to have the knack of writing earworms that sound like really good trad tunes (John K, Fred Paris, Mats Eden, Kjell-Erik Ericsson to quote a few I can think of immediately), but a lot don't...

I agree Ian - within the English tradition at least (and I'm sure many others), the focus has always been on the strong melodies - and tunes which are obviously derived from riffing on a desired chord sequence sound weaker for it.  That is not to say that there are many valid traditions out there globally, some of which use a squeezebox, that are primarily based on riffing or noodling around set chords.

But I felt that the the conversation (which I had deliberately avoided until now) was veering towards a lot of knowing head-nodding against "fancy modern ways" which is always disturbing ... especially if you consider that the core English repertoire of germanic sounding polkas and schottisches was at least as new and foreign sounding to Scan Tester's and Bob Cann's grandparents as some jazzier chords and syncopations being implemented by today's box players.

Rubbish tunes will always be forgotten eventually ... fantastic tunes have a fighting chance of living to be played by another generation ... parents will always tell their children that modern music is tosh ... I have absolute faith in the "folk process" even in this modern era of instant global communication.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: EastAnglianTed on February 23, 2014, 11:15:15 PM
    Fair play, when I listen to stuff JK plays, which I had previously dismissed as "not so good songs" it breathes a new lease of life into it and makes me want to revise it. E.G. Siberian Stomp!
    *Ducks for cover*  :D
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: squeezy on February 23, 2014, 11:50:04 PM
Just reading JK's forward in his 2010 published 'jump at the Sun' tune book.
He has some typically forthright views,
 ' the melodies sustain interest perfectly adequately without some addled brain chucking in every oblique chord and syncopated rhythm available....  .... This isn't deeply sophisticated stuff on the whole and if you make chording too rich and lush you smother the natural strength of the melody....' Etc etc...
Quite John!

Reading this, written by John Kirkpatrick, and then watching this performed by John Kirkpatrick, http://youtu.be/Y8zXspR4qJk?t=6m50s

... confuses me somewhat!

My vote is for the latter with a lot of incredibly intricate, clever, surprising and tasteful left hand ... maybe he just has very strong opinions about certain chords he didn't play there - but the accompaniment is certainly rich and lush to my ear!
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Anahata on February 24, 2014, 12:07:10 AM
Quote from: squeezy
maybe he just has very strong opinions about certain chords he didn't play there - but the accompaniment is certainly rich and lush to my ear!
I think you are spot on about 'certain chords' - all of his harmonies fit perfectly and they are not like those employed by many younger melodeon players now.
(Do I get my official grumpy old git badge now?)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: squeezy on February 24, 2014, 12:20:24 AM
You do get the grumpy old git badge Anahata!  Signed by Oscar Woods' grandad too!

I chose that clip because John has deliberately chosen to flashily play the tune on the left hand staggered with his right by half a bar - leading to some massively fruity clashes (which I happen to think sound wonderful) ... but I don't see any difference between that and the kind of jazzy major sevenths and suspensions/substitutions which are often employed by "younger" melodeon players now.  They simply draw on different non-folk influences.

The acid test is whether you can pull it off or not, and it's clear that he can.  But let's not pretend that JK really believes that the melody is all-important if he's pulling off amazing stunts of those proportions!  You can't have it both ways.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: oggiesnr on February 24, 2014, 08:27:50 AM

Reading this, written by John Kirkpatrick, and then watching this performed by John Kirkpatrick, http://youtu.be/Y8zXspR4qJk?t=6m50s

... confuses me somewhat!


On the other hand it is possible to play Jump at the Sun with four chords and for it sound perfectly fine.  You don't need the super complex left hand top make it work which is just as well as most of us don't have a stradella bass end  (:)

As far as my use of "infect" is concerned in an earlier post, it may be a bit strong but it appears to have got the point I was making across.  If I've offended anyone I apologise, that was not my intention.

Steve
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 24, 2014, 09:22:48 AM
Rubbish tunes will always be forgotten eventually ... fantastic tunes have a fighting chance of living to be played by another generation ... parents will always tell their children that modern music is tosh ... I have absolute faith in the "folk process" even in this modern era of instant global communication.

Making one litmus test of a "good tune" that your grandchildren play it? Not terribly useful in drawing up a set for a gig, but about right in the wider scheme of things?
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Anahata on February 24, 2014, 09:24:58 AM
I don't see any difference between that and the kind of jazzy major sevenths and suspensions/substitutions which are often employed by "younger" melodeon players now.  They simply draw on different non-folk influences.
Point well made and understood. I still don't feel comfortable with the way it's done sometimes which leads us to...

Quote
The acid test is whether you can pull it off or not

When I hear jazz musicians playing major 7ths, substitution chords and suspensions, I am in awe of how the chords clash with the tune and yet follow some sort of logic that I don't fully understand but can hear is working. Thelonious Monk is a master of that craft, and in my teenage years I attempted to learn some of Dave Brubeck's pieces, many of which have dense and complex harmonies.

It's not that I don't like that kind of music, but I've heard very few melodeon players pull that kind of trick off in a way that convinces me.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: IanD on February 24, 2014, 08:53:15 PM
You do get the grumpy old git badge Anahata!  Signed by Oscar Woods' grandad too!

I chose that clip because John has deliberately chosen to flashily play the tune on the left hand staggered with his right by half a bar - leading to some massively fruity clashes (which I happen to think sound wonderful) ... but I don't see any difference between that and the kind of jazzy major sevenths and suspensions/substitutions which are often employed by "younger" melodeon players now.  They simply draw on different non-folk influences.

The acid test is whether you can pull it off or not, and it's clear that he can.  But let's not pretend that JK really believes that the melody is all-important if he's pulling off amazing stunts of those proportions!  You can't have it both ways.
And it all works because Jump at the Sun is a *great* tune even if you don't play a single chord ;-)
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 24, 2014, 09:29:03 PM
Isn't that where we started?

Incidentally it's "harmonically" mostly in harmonic minor modes, though with considerable latitude with respect to some notes eg A/A# in its 'A' ;) music. Nevertheless a bit alien to our diatonic instrument. It's "correct" chords "should" vary accordingly, which underpins Ian's comment about keeping its bass simple, (he implies … nil)! [ed] guess I'm saying that playing it against 4 standard trichords isn't "perfectly" fine to my ear

First thing I did back in 1972 when I became St Lawrence FC secretary was to book John, whom I knew from folk camping; we all got a wild card choice. He turned up and blasted (inter alia) that 3 tune set offered by Steve. Can still visualise it. We were quite swept away. Jump@Sun is now a circassian circle "standard" across Europe.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: IanD on February 24, 2014, 11:08:35 PM
Isn't that where we started?

Incidentally it's "harmonically" mostly in harmonic minor modes, though with considerable latitude with respect to some notes eg A/A# in its 'A' ;) music. Nevertheless a bit alien to our diatonic instrument. It's "correct" chords "should" vary accordingly, which underpins Ian's comment about keeping its bass simple, (he implies … nil)! [ed] guess I'm saying that playing it against 4 standard trichords isn't "perfectly" fine to my ear

First thing I did back in 1972 when I became St Lawrence FC secretary was to book John, whom I knew from folk camping; we all got a wild card choice. He turned up and blasted (inter alia) that 3 tune set offered by Steve. Can still visualise it. We were quite swept away. Jump@Sun is now a circassian circle "standard" across Europe.
I certainly don't play JATS without chords -- in fact exactly the opposite, there's a load you can do with it ranging from very simple to the kind of thing John does (instrument permitting, obviously). What I meant was that it's a strong distinctive instantly recognisable tune with just the melody, which is one thing that makes it a great modern tune.
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Lyn on March 10, 2014, 08:59:39 AM
I did choke rather on my cornflakes on reading the 'infected' comment - and am a bit uncomfortable about it even now it has been 'amended' somewhat. Guilty as charged - I love music with interesting chords and chord sequences;my frustration as a not very good fiddle player was that I could only play melody and longed to learn how to accompany, and do that wonderful weaving in and out and harmonising which better fiddlers could achieve. It was learning La Marianne on fiddle and being disappointed and frustrated by how 'thin' it sounded when I played it, that led me to youtube, finding Squeezy Joan (Sandy) playing it on meloedeon and falling in love with the melodeon.

I'm still relatively new. I love the broad appeal of the instrument, that it can accompany dancers in the Morris tradition as well as Breton, Swedish, and umpteen other traditions - all on a 2-row DG. You choose the style for the tradition and it is fine for that use, but that does not make it superior to any other style which may be used for other traditions.

I'm not explaining myself very well here. Suffice it to say I can thoroughly enjoy Jump at the Sun, Three Piece Suite, any of Squeezy's playing on any of the Spiers and Boden/Bellowhead cds, but my heart turns over when listening to say, Naragonia Les Deux Freres, Pignol's British Swing, and almost anything Andy Cutting plays because the tunes are wonderful, the rhythm is addictive and the chords/basses hold the whole thing together - without them the listening experience would be wholly diminished.

As I say, I am relatively new to melodeon playing, and have no style/tradition axe to grind; I do detect a bias in this thread which deny it as you might, chaps, is there. It's a bit like passive/'aggressive behaviour: you say something then hastily retract part of it should someone challenge it - but the spirit of what you have said remains.Or perhaps I have misread the enitre thread. (see what I did there? >:E )
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 10, 2014, 10:25:42 AM
If you like Norbert Pignol, I did quite a lot of video of him last week on mobile phone. Worked amazingly well but did fill the memory quite quickly

It's on my facebook page https://www.facebook.com/chris.ryall.104
Title: Re: can traditional english folk tunes/melodies sing out for themselves?
Post by: Earbrass on March 10, 2014, 02:45:49 PM
I do detect a bias in this thread which deny it as you might, chaps, is there. It's a bit like passive/'aggressive behaviour: you say something then hastily retract part of it should someone challenge it - but the spirit of what you have said remains.Or perhaps I have misread the enitre thread. (see what I did there? >:E )

I would take any comments about any style or method of playing being "wrong" with a small mineful of salt. I recall my Bert Weedon "Play In A Day" guitar book asserting that if using an electric guitar, one should be careful not to set the gain on the amplifier so high that it distorts. So go to the back of the class, please, Mr. Hendrix.   :D 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal