Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: wimpole on March 03, 2014, 01:57:38 PM

Title: 3-row tuning
Post by: wimpole on March 03, 2014, 01:57:38 PM
I have two melodeons (Bertrand Gaillard) which I lug around to sessions: G/C and D/G. Would there be any disadvantages to having one instrument tuned D/G/C? I guess if I had a preference, the G row would be in the same pitch as the G row on my G/C. Would this make the outside D row very low in pitch?
I'd be glad of any thoughts anyone has.
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: Phil B on March 03, 2014, 03:37:08 PM
 Re 3 row tuning
I know at present that you have to carry two boxes but it does mean you always have a spare with you so in the event of something going wrong with one the whole session is not lost to you
Phil B
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: squeezy on March 03, 2014, 03:49:50 PM
I have never seen a D/G/C and that is probably because either the D row would be tuned very deep indeed (an octave below the D row on a D/G which is in the middle of most melodeon row ranges) - or if it were an octave higher then the C row would be very squeaky indeed!
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: george garside on March 03, 2014, 06:00:42 PM
I have two melodeons (Bertrand Gaillard) which I lug around to sessions: G/C and D/G. Would there be any disadvantages to having one instrument tuned D/G/C? 

Why not go for a trichord  which is dead easy to play in CG&D  but can also be played in the other 7 major keys without much difficulty  and all in one compact little box!

george
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: OrchardAshley90 on March 03, 2014, 06:54:57 PM
Have a 2 a half row with f naturals and b flats put in c is quite easy on the Grow but then you gotta re learn tunes in c...
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: Theo on March 03, 2014, 07:31:33 PM
One three row box instead of two two-rows?   Good,  only one box to transport but disadvantage is that while playing you have the extra weight and bulk of a three row instead of a two row.  It can be quite a big difference.  You will also have to re-learn a good part of your fingering.  There are no perfect answers with diatonic boxes.  If you have gone to the time and trouble of acquiring two Gaillards then my advice would be to stick with them.  Consider getting wheels on the instrument cases!
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 03, 2014, 07:35:24 PM
Retuning a Gaillard is not trivial as the chambers are all tuned to resonance. I think this is something you'd do with a pokerwork, but don't let that stop you ;)

I carry a 3-row. Which … depends on the session, but having fun here in SE France with the C#GG
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: Ollie on March 03, 2014, 08:19:19 PM
I have two melodeons (Bertrand Gaillard) which I lug around to sessions: G/C and D/G. Would there be any disadvantages to having one instrument tuned D/G/C? 

Why not go for a trichord  which is dead easy to play in CG&D  but can also be played in the other 7 major keys without much difficulty  and all in one compact little box!

george

It's only dead easy once you've learnt how to play a B/C/C# though. The sound and playability of a Trichord is a million miles from a Galliard too. Getting a B/C/C# is not always the answer, George!
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: Lester on March 03, 2014, 08:23:34 PM
Getting a B/C/C# is not always the answer, George!

 (:)
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: Christopher K. on March 04, 2014, 02:29:43 AM
For the same reasons stated above, I agree that DGC isn't really the most feasible option for putting two accordions into one. As Theo said, there are no perfect solutions for diatonic accordions. Anyway, the DGC system would be at the highest end (or lowest, as mentioned in the OP) of possibility in that realm. Other three-row systems with the trable rows a fourth apart are commonly available in 31/12 or 34/12 configurations like Hohner Corona (GCF, ADG, EAD, etc.).

It could be a good exercise for you to find a Corona or similar at a music store, and try some of your two-row tunes with the same fingerings. When I tried this, I found that my imagination played a terrible joke because the dynamics and control of the Corona were nothing like the various Hohner two-row Vienna accordions I had been playing. Given, some players get along with it just fine (Bob Cann comes to mind, although going from a Club III to a Corona is far less jarring than going from an Erica or Pokerwork to a Corona or even Club III), and with practice fluency on both accordions is within reach. But it takes a bit of getting used to and if you like how your tow-rows by B.G. handle, it might not be something worth giving up.
 
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: JD on March 04, 2014, 01:02:34 PM
I have done something that Squeezy hasn't, there's a first for everything. I have not only seen a DGC box but played it too. It was a 11/10/9 18-bass Loffet Pro that had been commissioned for the purpose of replacing a pair of DG and GC boxes.

The C-row was a fourth up from the G-row so the bottom octave was at the same pitch as the top octave of a conventional GC G-row. For me it was a marvellous box to play in A minor (on the lower octave of the G and C-rows). It would probably drive a conventional "top-octave" GC player mad.

The box had a bass layout with the eight "DG" basses at the knee end. I might have gone for a more "Corona-ish" layout had it been my choice.
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: Rog on March 04, 2014, 09:01:39 PM
How about a DG and a one row in C? This would be less weight if you happened to get a Hohner 114C (they are v light and compact) and you'd have all the fun of a Cajun box too. Or not (:)
I've owned a couple of Coronas, one in ADG and one in GCF, both nice boxes but have to say I rarely used the outside row (the low row) except occasionally to pull some bluesy riffs across the rows, once, on the ADG during a guitar heavy session. Maybe you should think about a DG with an accidental row (like Squeezy's ....what does he call it...Mixte system ) or a 2.5 row.
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: rees on March 04, 2014, 10:00:16 PM
I have converted three row boxes for one particular player to C/D/G and that works fine but he never ever crosses the rows - strictly up and down.
As has been said, D/G/C is either too low or too high.
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: TomBom on March 04, 2014, 11:58:49 PM
Why not go for a trichord  which is dead easy to play in CG&D  but can also be played in the other 7 major keys without much difficulty  and all in one compact little box!

george
BTW, what is a trichord?

How about a DG and a one row in C? This would be less weight if you happened to get a Hohner 114C (they are v light and compact) and you'd have all the fun of a Cajun box too. Or not (:)
Or a G/C and a one row in D ...
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: Christopher K. on March 05, 2014, 12:09:25 AM
A Trichord is an accordion made by Hohner in BCC# tuning. Trichord II has two sets of treble reeds, Trichord III (shown) has three. It's physically similar to the Corona, but it has a different tuning and 12 stradella basses. They are no longer in production.

This one's red, you also see them in black:

(http://www.buttonbox.org.uk/Button%20Box%20Gallery/slides/Trichord-III.jpg)
Title: Re: 3-row tuning
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on March 05, 2014, 12:47:36 AM
I made up a D/G/C from a B/C/C# Trichord shell some years back. Effectively a G/C with a low D row outside, and cross-row friendly. Lots of chiseling of the reed chambers involved!!! Worked well and its subsequent owner still plays it regularly around Sydney.

Wish I'd kept it.....  :-\

I believe Peter Hyde offers a DGC option with his 3 row range.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal