Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Rog on March 04, 2014, 09:39:22 PM
-
I've got a broken bass button on my Modell 2 project, the remaining buttons are yellow with age and the replacement button from Charlie is all new and white, which is not ideal.
I managed to get the broken button off, by heating the end of the pushrod, but I am sure I'd end up destroying the other buttons if I tried to get them off.
On another thread it seems that the way to get the bass mechanism off is to take out the pins for the button push rods and thread them though the casing hole, leaving the buttons in situ on the end of the rods. Is this the best way to do it?
But in any case I'm going to end up with 7 ages buttons and one new white one, so maybe I should replace them all?
What does the panel think?
-
Leave the new button to soak overnight in cold tea!
-
Leave the new button to soak overnight in cold tea!
Really? OK I'll try that. Thanks. I'll let you know if it works.
-
Sorry Roger, just spoofing! Most plastics are pretty impervious to such tactics in my experience whereas old bone buttons would discolour nicely in an hour or two and then turn brilliantly white again after being soaked overnight in Sterident. That said, tannin will discolour the glaze on some pottery very quickly, perhaps it will do the same for certain plastics!
-
Roger, assuming we're talking about "mushroom" type buttons, I'm sure that most melodeon repairers will have a box full of old discoloured buttons salvaged from boxes where all 8 have been replaced with nice shiny new white ones. I know that I have dozens, and they have been handy to find a match where only one or two broken ones have needed replacing.
I suggest you try your "local" repairer, but if you get stuck, post or pm a decent photo and I'd be happy to try and find you a match for the cost of postage....
-
Sorry Roger, just spoofing! Most plastics are pretty impervious to such tactics in my experience whereas old bone buttons would discolour nicely in an hour or two and then turn brilliantly white again after being soaked overnight in Sterident. That said, tannin will discolour the glaze on some pottery very quickly, perhaps it will do the same for certain plastics!
Haha. Yes I thought the advice might have been of the 'left handed screw driver/tin of striped paint' variety, but I didn't want to suggest this in case it was genuine advice. Ah...the old tricks are the best. Shows you can still get caught out on't Internet with the old 'go to the stores and get me..' joke.
-
Roger, assuming we're talking about "mushroom" type buttons, I'm sure that most melodeon repairers will have a box full of old discoloured buttons salvaged from boxes where all 8 have been replaced with nice shiny new white ones. I know that I have dozens, and they have been handy to find a match where only one or two broken ones have needed replacing.
I suggest you try your "local" repairer, but if you get stuck, post or pm a decent photo and I'd be happy to try and find you a match for the cost of postage....
Hi - thanks. Yes a wanted notice might do it. Is there a best way to get old buttons of without breaking them?
-
Depends on what glue was initially used to put them on.
A good soak in hot water over night might do the trick. Animal glue etc.
I despair for future bookbinders who are going to have to deal with our PVA technology. At least today restorations are reversible :'(
-
Haha. Yes I thought the advice might have been of the 'left handed screw driver/tin of striped paint' variety...
Strangely enough, many cheap pianos used to be painted with striped paint. Quite simply, the can contained an oil based paint and a water based paint of slightly dissimilar tone, so that after vigorous stirring it gave a grained appearance along the brush strokes which remained on drying as the two paints were immiscable.
Rob.
-
I think the buttons are jammed onto the end of the push rods. I removed the pins from these rods and threaded them through the holes, leaving the buttons in situ. I can now put on new felt washers.
-
Haha. Yes I thought the advice might have been of the 'left handed screw driver/tin of striped paint' variety...
Strangely enough, many cheap pianos used to be painted with striped paint. Quite simply, the can contained an oil based paint and a water based paint of slightly dissimilar tone, so that after vigorous stirring it gave a grained appearance along the brush strokes which remained on drying as the two paints were immiscable.
Rob.
Wasn't that called scumballing? A Victorian method of making cheap pine etc. Look like Oak and other expensive woods. Sure I'll get shot for the spelling but it sounded something like that. ;)
-
More recently that that Nick. When we moved into our current house (built 1963), the internal doors were painted that way.
-
It's graining, with scumble glaze. Often using a comb to help get a better effect. You can still get the combs.
In skilled hands you can get a very realistic wood effect. Our house built 1939 had it everywhere !!
-
You can get the old buttons off without damaging them by removing the bass plate so you can see the rod under the button. Apply a soldering iron (25 watt or greater) to the rod directly under the button. Pull upon the button while doing his , as soon as the rod gets hot (200-300deg F) the button will come right off with no damage.
You can salvage the old buttons by sanding the top to get off the rough yellowed surface, you can then paint the sanded top with white nail polish. Nail polish is basically dissolved celluloid. Do a couple of layers several hours apart, and let dry for a day. You can re apply the buttons using the solder iron method , or drill them out a bit and apply with glue.
-
Thanks for the info on reviving the buttons. I did try a soldering iron but I didn't get it hot enough, I think. I dismantled the bass mechanism to get the buttons and push rods off. I will try the nail varnish trick. (:)
-
hi I have removed the old buttons on a pokerwork, by laying the accordion face down, and using a small amount of acetone painted on the rod ,to soak down into the button it softens the glue and makes it easy to remove the button
-
Strangely enough, many cheap pianos used to be painted with striped paint.
And lots of old German melodeons (usually Vienna accordions) and concertinas too.