Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Andy Next Tune on March 15, 2014, 06:42:02 PM
-
I'm attending the one row melodeon makers workshop in October (finally!!!), so it's form filling time...
....And as well as deciding upon ipmy chosen key, I need to make a decision on the first button notes, and one of the suggested options is to use it for accidentals.
For example on a D box, to have G#/C to assist playing in G and A.
I realise the purists will view this as the start of the slippery slope to hell.
Equally at the moment, I can't remember the last time I used that first button on my traditionally tuned one rows.
So I would appreciate any thoughts on this arrangement as having one row accidentals was not an option I'd ever considered or even heard of.
Cheers, Andy
-
When playing English choons, I hardly ever touch that button but for Cajun/Zydeco I'm on it all the time.
So, no accidental for me.
-
Just had a little play to think about it, and I since I'm often changing octaves and playing runs/bits of melody/counter melody (need a technical term here ::) ) an octave down on a one-row, that button actually gets a surprising amount of use of use in its "standard" state (E/G on a C one-row).
The equivalent on a C one-row would be I suppose an F♯ and a B♠to "play in G and F".
Neatly dodging the "purist" label, I think it could be a little perverse to try to set up a one-row 4 stop to habitually do something it's not naturally inclined to do (I'm talking mostly about music from the British Isles here of course). There are some tunes which work very well in G or F on a C one-row and of course there is a large store of tunes that don't have a G♯ for playing in A on a D one-row. I think the thing is to find them and play to the strengths of the instrument.
One of the glories of one-row playing is skipping up and down the keyboard, putting in all those one-row tricks, playing the octaves and chords that it loves. Using accidentals (with a long stretch from the centre of the keyboard) I fear would tend to break that flow, something that playing outside its "natural" keys can have a tendency to do anyway if you're not careful (again, I'm not referring to Cajuns playing in G on a C one-row, which should be classed as pretty "natural" really).
Of course I've nowt against someone having a go, with skill I could well be proven wrong, but I think I'll leave all that sort of thing to the playing of 2 row and above boxes and leave my one-row in its "pure" state.
Anyway, my box has those notes already. You want to know where they are? Look, over there! Oh dear, they were just here, did you miss them? :P
-
If you are building one, then why don't you just add an extra button on the top for your accidentals and keep the rest as normal? So you got 11 buttons instead of 10.
So you got your normal Cajun box but also when your feeling like playing something funky you got that extra button.
-
In common with previous postings, I make frequent use of the repeat note in the lower octave. At it's most basic it is a useful root for the final chord when playing in G (on a C one row). It is a also a useful pedal point for both G7 and C harmonies.
That said, I have considered the possibilities introduced through inserting additional notes. my own choice would be a C one row with Ab pull and F# push. This would give neat options for Fm, D7 and E7 harmonies. Which would give some useful progressions for playing in Am, G and C.
>:E Playing Devils Advocate I would point out that the instrument already has two built in accidentals - when playing in F on a C one row there is a very useful augmented fourth (tritone or Diabolus in Musica) >:E and a flat seven when playing in G.
On reflection I can't help noting that I have managed without accidentals for the past 35 years, I guess that would suggest that I don't need them. If it aint broke, don't try to fix it.
-
I agree with mike . The 10 button 4stop is what it is and if accidentals were to be gone in for two of each would be needed , one for each octave etc etc
Where would it stop. first of all a couple of acidentals on the first button, then an extra button top or bottom or both! then a little helper row starting with 2 buttons, but why not have a few more so it becomes a one and a half row , before you know it its a full row so why not just go for say a CC#! or a GC or a CF or a DG or whatever, ah but that's not enough the newly grown 2nd row will then need a little helper row etc etc etc!
george ;)
-
I'm with Mike and co. The glory of the one row is its diatonic scale. If you want a lydian scale play the C instrument in F, or in G for mixolydian feel (and the other four)
One of my great gestalts about 'Cajun play was Mike's intimation here that they play it simply, mainly simple pentatonic … yet our ear hears an augmented 4th … that doesn't exist ;)
-
Thanks guys. You nicely worried this question for me applying your years of experience, as opposed to me with gut feel and years of inexperience!!