Melodeon.net Forums
Forum and website admin => Wish lists => Topic started by: KLR on March 25, 2014, 12:19:20 AM
-
Different boards for Irish, Scottish, Norteno, or various types of Continental musics would be a good thing. Having TOTM for each would be great, and bring in all sorts of new members, too. Most discussions boards on these really aren't up to snuff, I recently tried to dig up some talk on the Conjunto etc traditions over at the reyesforum, and found almost nothing whatsoever. Noe Garza (https://www.youtube.com/user/alkanzeboy/videos?view=0&flow=grid) has outstanding videos on YouTube so that fills the gap, but it would be great to be able to chat about it all too.
Also there's the problem of having a board that's not specific to any type of diatonic accordion leading to a lot of quite random advice being dispensed. Irish box playing gets discussed here a bit, and over at thesession.org, but in a rather haphazard manner - there only seem to be a handful of people here who specialize in that particular music, and a recent thread on Cut/Grace Note (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,14400.0.html)s was started by someone wanting advice on playing a tune in a specifically Irish manner; all sorts of advice was thrown in, much of it from perspectives decidedly outside that tradition, leading to the latest of many trips to the top of the soapbox (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,14400.msg177819.html#msg177819) for poor Steve Jones. (http://deephousepage.com/smilies/pullhair.gif) Not that it isn't great that so many people want to help out, of course; but perhaps this does more harm than good, and, again, I doubt many take an interest in this board as it doesn't cater to their specific interests.
-
I rather doubt it would have the desired effect Kevin. I can't imagine that because a topic like the one you referred to was in a subforum labelled "Irish" that people who don't specialize in that tradition or know much about it would refrain from giving advice of doubtful relevance, saying they don't like what very capable Irish players are doing, or giving their opinions on how Irish music is played in English sessions etc. etc.
Anyway, these forums are run by and overwhelmingly frequented by players in the various English traditions. Let's not have ghettos. Or: "we must educate our masters" ;) (now who said that?)
I think it is best kept as one big generally happy family - we can all let the digs and uninformed/non-pertinent/impertinent comments wash over us. (I'm sure there are plenty of those in topics about English music.) As for trips to the soapbox, I don't mind. Hey, I'm getting better... look I didn't even contribute to the recent thread about using the r/h little finger!
-
Having recently returned to this forum after about five years away I like the general "pub-like" atmosphere as much now as I did then, and think fragmentation into too many categories would be a pity.
I'd also be reluctant to suggest anything that adds works for our hosts and moderators.
The only thing that comes to mind is a formal or informal method of tagging discussions (and possibly posts) according to the musical tradition and/or instrument system they relate to....
TomBR
-
Hey, I'm getting better... look I didn't even contribute to the recent thread about using the r/h little finger!
Do you pinky swear ?? ;D
-
Tags, that might work. Thing is, I stumbled across some new forum for the BCC#, just by looking around for 'accordion forum' or something. Labels really do draw attention to these things. I don't think this is tantamount to ghettoizing, just keeping things on track a bit. Imagine a discussion forum for anything trad windblown - whistles, fifes, flutes from every nation. That'd be a complete mess.
But yeah, I kinda doubt much more of a populace is out there in the first place. Was reading some violin forum and who do I see among the contributors but Trevor Jennings, who you see over at thesession.org most every day for 12 years now. The number of people who bother with these online forums is probably pretty finite.
-
I'm all in favour of maintaining the status quo. What I find interesting is different people's perception of the content here. KLR says of Irish-related discussions "there only seem to be a handful of people here who specialize in that particular music", while my impression is that there's a very substantial amount of space devoted to that genre (in which, I confess, I have no more than a very casual passing interest). I don't think either of us is wrong - it's just another manifestation of the "glass half empty or half full" syndrome. In the light of that, I think melnet has probably got it just about right.
It's all music - just play it and enjoy!
Graham
-
Let's not have ghettos.
I agree with that, and would add: let's not build fences either.
-
I totally agree with those who would prefer to keep the forum 'as is'. It is nice to pick up info about different genres of melodeonism which I doubt if I would do it the were sub sections for irish, French, Chinese or whatever.
Restricting a forum to one type of box or one genre of music narrowsits interest and viability whereas it is the open nature and inclusivity of this forum that has enabled it to thrive in a friendly manner - and long may this continue
george
-
I'm not a regular contributor to ToTM but enjoy popping in and out. I've learnt French and Estonian tunes, and never would have looked at them if they were in their own sub group.
I find the same thing happens with other things across general forum, sometimes curiosity leads me to read thread outside of my normal interest - and often learning something and enjoying the journey.
Totally agree about keeping it 'as is'.
Q
( edited to counteract bizarre spellchecker. " gathering " forum ?? How about 'general' forum! )
-
I find the same thing happens with other things across gathering forum, sometimes curiosity leads me to read thread outside of my normal interest - and often learning something and enjoying the journey.
Absolutely - couldn't agree more. (http://)
-
Another vote for the status quo from me. Bob
-
I like hearing and learning about traditions I'm not part of :P
-
Me too! It's been fun and interesting to learn morris , french or other tunes .
good music and advise all around IMO.
-
Imagine a discussion forum for anything trad windblown - whistles, fifes, flutes from every nation. That'd be a complete mess.
ahem
http://forums.chiffandfipple.com/ (http://forums.chiffandfipple.com/)
Although there is some organisation ... I see they're letting in free reeds now, so it's probably downhill all the way (they already have a chanson thread)
-
Gosh, interesting place! Clive and Theo .. any chance of an Azumi Flute subforum here? ::)
-
Thank you Chris for a very 'interesting' suggestion, but let's not do that. :D
-
Chiff and Fipple have subforums for whistles, flutes, uilleann pipes, free reeds, trad music per se; have had them for ages. Imagine one forum to rule them all, in the darkness bind them, etc. >:E You'd scan past pages of posts about taking a knife to your mouthpiece and Nicholson vs Pratten to find info on why your back D is breaking. ??? That was complete greek to you guys, right? It would be like one big forum for this site, a complete mess. You'd have to scan past block acoustics and ads for CFs for sale to get to advice on getting the left hand working.
I'd better state once more that a big plus would be that the compartmentalizing would attract interest from new members. Could the tagging feature be implemented? Like I said, hadn't thought of that approach. Not sure if it would lead people here, but might help find relevant past posts.
My thing is mostly Irish music, true, but I love hearing accordions played in all kinds of genres, too.
-
We already attract a regular stream of new members, a few new members most days, total membership is in four figures. That doesn't sound like a struggling forum than needs to find new ways to attract members.
-
I'd better state once more that a big plus would be that the compartmentalizing would attract interest from new members.
And a big minus would be that it would drive an awful lot of regulars away. It ain't broke, so...........what. fix it until it is?
Graham
-
We already attract a regular stream of new members, a few new members most days, total membership is in four figures. That doesn't sound like a struggling forum than needs to find new ways to attract members.
Then could we have a subforum about clarinets, please? Please Theo! It would attract all manner of woodwind players. Who knows we might even tempt GbH back. Oh, go on. We all want to talk about clarinets ::) don't we?
-
I suppose we could all
1. be a bit clearer what we are after (eg technical input from a specific perspective)
2. lrn2reed, as the young have it, and not proffer unsought opinions not that related to the question
3. be more diplomatic when expressing opinions ("I hate it", rather than "that is awful") - after all we are allowed opinions and to hate stuff others love
4. lrn2reed as in "he hates it, poor sod, but that's his personal problem" rather than "he thinks it is crap and somehow that matters"
5. grow a pair *coff* I mean, grow a thicker skin (those few that don't already have ones like rhinoceros hide)
6. Kittenz :-*
No coding required
-
I like hearing and learning about traditions I'm not part of :P
What he said.
I know my playing preferences are narrow (on purpose!), but I find all box-things fascinating.
-
My reading to posting ratio is probably about 100:1 and I think the balance of the forum is just fine. I learn a great deal about styles and genres, techniques and workarounds that have no direct impact on the way I play music but they are of great interest to me nonetheless. A eclectic mix of information about all things related to the diatonic button accordion is what melodeon.net has always been about, long may it remain so.
I have nothing against tagging posts if it helps members search for specific information but I'm not sure it's possible with the existing forum software and wouldn't want to add to the mods workload in any case.
-
Just been to a session at Whitby where there were at least five melodeons. The tunes played came from England, Ireland, Scotland, Canada, USA, France, Sweden, Portugal that I know of. That broad interest seems to reflect the discussion here.
If we did have sub forums for each genre then I can just imagine the "discussions" about which genre tune X belongs to. And beating in mind that at present some members seem to have difficulty deciding between the existing forum headings then I think we just stick with the present structure. If it ain't broke don't fix it.
-
I'd prefer to keep it the way it is. I play only Irish, but love to hear about other traditions. If our posting membership were say 20 times bigger, I might feel different. As always well thought out subject lines help.
Dan