Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: LeoBenHan on March 28, 2014, 03:07:34 PM

Title: Reed Tuning on Hohner 1040
Post by: LeoBenHan on March 28, 2014, 03:07:34 PM
About a month or so ago, I bought a Hohner 1040 in G for £200 in a music shop (I think it's an old one, possibly 60 years old; I read somewhere on here that one can tell by the button-board design). Anyway, the second G note reeds (6th button) were so badly out of tune that they made a rasping noise when sounded. I filed them so that they were in-tune, and it was fine. Well... so I thought!

One of the push reeds for the 8th button was completely broken off when I bought it, but I replaced the reed, and that pair is now in-tune. After this, the button next to that, the push on the 7th button, mysteriously went out of tune. I tuned it, but one of the reeds wouldn't sound at all. After a few days of soaking the reeds in acetone and dowsing them with boiling water to get rid of any glue or wax blocking the throat (and generally tearing my hair out), I realised that one of the push reeds was bent inward slightly, which I remedied with a tweak. Great! They now both work. HOWEVER, the pull note (I think an F#) for the 6th button is now out of tune, which has remained so since it developed. And now, since that happened, the push note, the very first one I tuned is now too in-tune, and is no longer 'wet-tuned'.

Why, oh why, is this happening? Does tuning one set of reeds effect neighbouring reeds, or am I doing something terribly wrong? Or is the melodeon having some fun with me...
Title: Re: Reed Tuning on Hohner 1040
Post by: rees on March 28, 2014, 04:18:51 PM
Well, it sounds as if you know what you're doing so I reckon it's having some fun with you. They do that sometimes  ;)

So, reading through your post am I right in thinking that you did the various tuning jobs then removed the reeds for cleaning and finally replaced and re-waxed the reeds hopefully with new valves.
If that is the case then another tune-up would be necessary as cleaning and replacing valves will alter the tuning slightly.
Title: Re: Reed Tuning on Hohner 1040
Post by: boxcall on March 28, 2014, 04:26:23 PM
Hi Leo,
What do the leather / valves look like?
If curled and not sitting flat over the reed this could effect the tuning, but I assume you know this since your doing your own tuning (:)
and you won't be able to see the valve on the underside of the reed with out removing.
I'm sure one of the more experienced in this will be along shortly with the answer.


Rees you beat me to it  (:)

edited :to say with better advise of course!
Title: Re: Reed Tuning on Hohner 1040
Post by: LeoBenHan on March 28, 2014, 09:12:59 PM
It certainly feels like it's having some fun with me! Then again, it's my first time owning and playing a melodeon, so maybe it's part and parcel that I have yet to get used to :')

I only cleaned the one set of reeds, that was the pair that needed a tweak. They're in tune...for now. I'm not entiiirely sure the cleaning did anything at all, but if it did I can't tell. Either way they've been tuned since cleaning.

You might be onto something with the valves though! I tuned the reeds, then took the valves off (which were very curled indeed), flattened them and reattached them. That could well account for it! This of course means I'm going to have to remove all of the reeds, replace all the valves, then tune them... I really don't fancy cleaning all 20 of the reeds; its a messy, waxy job. The rust probably adds character anyway haha.

If it sounds like I know what I'm doing, I certainly don't feel like I do! :')

Thanks for the advice!
Title: Re: Reed Tuning on Hohner 1040
Post by: Theo on March 28, 2014, 09:18:29 PM
Old wax could also be contributing to the problem.  When wax gets old it starts to loose its adhesion to the reed plate which can make it sound seriously out of tune. Valve changes usually result in much smaller shifts of pitch.  In the long run it may best to re-wax all the reeds
Title: Re: Reed Tuning on Hohner 1040
Post by: LeoBenHan on March 28, 2014, 09:27:26 PM
Ahh that'd explain it too; I way have been a bit liberal when waxing in the reeds back in place. Hmmm yes a complete re-waxing is probably in order. I'll give it a thorough going over and clean off any excess wax from the reed plates I put on last time. Thanks!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal