Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: LDbosca on April 03, 2014, 06:33:20 PM

Title: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: LDbosca on April 03, 2014, 06:33:20 PM
Hi all,
As some of you may know, I've been working on a duet with my good friend flute player Christina Dolphin. It's all box/flute (and sometimes voice) with no other accompaniment. We're hoping to record a 15-track album soon but for the moment we've five demo tracks uploaded to soundcloud, go check it out :) There's three sets of dance tunes, a song and a slow air.

https://soundcloud.com/christinaandluke

Luke.
Title: Re: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: Graham Spencer on April 03, 2014, 06:53:33 PM
I really enjoyed those, Luke; thank you for posting.  I'm always intrigued by that Irish practice of everyone playing in absolute note-for-note unison, while the English approach (or at least my approach) is to look for variations, fills and countermelodies. You have a lovely mellow blend of sounds there; I look forward to the full-fledged album.

Graham
Title: Re: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: richard.fleming on April 03, 2014, 07:14:10 PM
GPS - was that patronising Irish traditional music with faint praise, or am I being oversensitive...?
Title: Re: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: Graham Spencer on April 03, 2014, 07:32:29 PM
GPS - was that patronising Irish traditional music with faint praise?

It was absolutely not; I am genuinely intrigued by the two quite different but equally valid approaches to traditional music, each of which contributes to its own national character. I am somewhat taken aback - not to say put out - that anyone could interpret my observation in any pejorative sense.
Title: Re: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: LDbosca on April 03, 2014, 07:42:31 PM
I really enjoyed those, Luke; thank you for posting.  I'm always intrigued by that Irish practice of everyone playing in absolute note-for-note unison, while the English approach (or at least my approach) is to look for variations, fills and countermelodies. You have a lovely mellow blend of sounds there; I look forward to the full-fledged album.

Graham

Well we've a lot of variations -  it's just that we do all of the exact same ones at the exact same time! There's a few harmonies on some items that we haven't recorded yet, but only for a few bars at a time. I know that other players take a freer approach to duet playing, which can be great, but can sometimes sound very sloppy on a studio recording. More than one way to skin a cat! :||:

Glad you liked it anyway (:)
Title: Re: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: Graham Spencer on April 03, 2014, 07:54:12 PM
I really enjoyed those, Luke; thank you for posting.  I'm always intrigued by that Irish practice of everyone playing in absolute note-for-note unison, while the English approach (or at least my approach) is to look for variations, fills and countermelodies. You have a lovely mellow blend of sounds there; I look forward to the full-fledged album.

Graham

Well we've a lot of variations -  it's just that we do all of the exact same ones at the exact same time! There's a few harmonies on some items that we haven't recorded yet, but only for a few bars at a time. I know that other players take a freer approach to duet playing, which can be great, but can sometimes sound very sloppy on a studio recording. More than one way to skin a cat! :||:


That was exactly my point, Luke; one of the characteristics of Irish playing is that tight unison. I'm intrigued by it because it is so alien to the way I play (which is why my infrequent attempts to play Irish tunes are rubbish!), and I admire the ability to do it. I apologise if you see my observation as a criticism - it was intended to be quite the reverse. In the light of responses, I should obviously have phrased my comments differently or kept my virtual mouth shut. I really did like the tracks very much - no reservations.

Graham
Title: Re: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: boxcall on April 03, 2014, 08:27:18 PM
I really enjoyed those, Luke; thank you for posting.  I'm always intrigued by that Irish practice of everyone playing in absolute note-for-note unison, while the English approach (or at least my approach) is to look for variations, fills and countermelodies. You have a lovely mellow blend of sounds there; I look forward to the full-fledged album.

Graham
I see a lot of praise in what you wrote GPS four times in fact, I can't see how anyone could be offended.


Really nice playing there Luke and as GPS said looking forward to the album!!
I like the barn dance!! It sounds a little like the old blackguard or maybe it's just my lack of tune knowledge.
Title: Re: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: mory on April 03, 2014, 08:53:14 PM
Hi Luke. Loved the combination, playing and tune choices, a real joy after a long and hard emotional day, so pleased for you both it's coming together so nicely and definitely well worth the wait ;)
1st in line for hard copy when your done mate. All the very Best. mory
Title: Re: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: gettabettabox on April 03, 2014, 09:20:14 PM
listened to that with mucho healthy volume through a ''sound system'' whilst cooking! great playing, thank you both. a treat for sure.
lovely pulse in the reels, driving box, punchy flute! (sounds like northern flute style?...anyways/anywheres, great lift )
spot on with the box voicing in the polkas and and for me, a 'not heard before' slan le maigh. (was that in c?)

very much enjoyed, thank you.
Title: Re: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: gettabettabox on April 03, 2014, 09:36:53 PM
oops...Dublin.  (:)
Title: Re: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: LDbosca on April 03, 2014, 11:08:18 PM
Thanks everyone  (:)

Graham, I didn't take the slightest bit of offence, as far as I'm concerned your comments were highly complimentary  (:)

Now, touch wood we get funding to record :||:
Title: Re: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: rees on April 03, 2014, 11:36:39 PM
Fabulous Irish music, bring on the full album.
Is that a B/C box?
Title: Re: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: LDbosca on April 04, 2014, 01:07:38 AM
Fabulous Irish music, bring on the full album.
Is that a B/C box?

It certainly is
Title: Re: Luke Deaton (me) & Christina Dolphin Soundcloud
Post by: Graham Spencer on April 04, 2014, 07:58:10 AM
I really enjoyed those, Luke; thank you for posting.  I'm always intrigued by that Irish practice of everyone playing in absolute note-for-note unison, while the English approach (or at least my approach) is to look for variations, fills and countermelodies. You have a lovely mellow blend of sounds there; I look forward to the full-fledged album.

Graham
I see a lot of praise in what you wrote GPS four times in fact, I can't see how anyone could be offended.

Thanks - I was wondering whether it was me! And thanks Luke for your reassurance that you weren't offended. Funny how different people read things differently - but that's been said here many times. Anyway, water under the bridge now  - and I still really like the tunes!

Graham
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal