Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: IvanM on April 04, 2014, 04:22:20 PM
-
Rambling through the forum I've run into this
You could try a 3 row CBA, 48 bass, or 72 bass, or more. But I don't know how suitable this type of accordion is for Scottish music.
Didn't Jimmy Shand Junior play a CBA? Tell me if I'm mistaken.
Steve
There are umpteen players using CBA for Scottish music, though mostly full size ones. Yes, Jimmy Shand Jnr plays (not past tense) a CBA. Other frequently heard players include Gordon Shand (no relation), Johnny Duncan, Ian Holmes. The late Bobby MacLeod moved to CBA, and you can't get more Scottish than his music.
I wonder if the scourge of BC and BCC# is the bad left keyboard and CBA have the much greatest and full Stradella one, why don't simply switch to CBA? Does the bisonoric treble side of BC(C#) have some (if any) advantages over the unisonoric CBA one?
-
I think most BCC# players opt for the boxes with a stradella layout.
As for the BC players, I think they tend to play a different style. From my personal experience, I play mostly Irish music and originally wanted to play fiddle but after getting one was discouraged on how difficult it was to even play just a simple tune (e.g. Mary Had a Little Lamb). I later tried the melodeon and loved how well I got on with it right from the start. That being said I have a load of musical idols right now that play the accordion but I have equally as many that play fiddle. With the fiddle you have no bass/chords, you play the melody with occasional double stops and droning and a B/C can do both of those fairly well (I don't play B/C but I started on it and now play the similar C#/D).
The stradella bass offers a lot you can add to the music but the question is whether you want to or not. The answer usually depends on the style or genre that you want to play. Some Irish players make a lot of use of it, some don't make much use of the left side at all. With the English style probably most would make a lot of use of the left hand but as mentioned in other threads, players of the Norteño style will even remove the reed blocks from the left side to make it lighter since they don't use them at all.
-
[I wonder if the scourge of BC and BCC# is the bad left keyboard and CBA have the much greatest and full Stradella one, why don't simply switch to CBA?]
ha, that is precisely what i did...
[Does the bisonoric treble side of BC(C#) have some (if any) advantages over the unisonoric CBA one?]
no. well...depends on your taste orientation. if you want the "one-row melodoen" push-pull sound, then the bc(c#) treble side does have an advantage....that is, when you're playing "on the row," old-school push-pull style, in one of the b/c(c#)'s "on the row" keys....
but for my money, if you're gonna play b/c mostly in its "across the row" keys which are smooth and fluid....cba and all its advantages then beckons......
-
probably 90+% of BCC# boxes from the 12 bass trichord up to the 117 bass Shand Morino have stradella bass in just the same way as do the continental chromatics so a desire for stradella bass is fully met by the BCC#!
This discussion is/should be about the BCC# v the continental chromatic rather than comparing the merits of the 8 bass 2 row BC , although to complicate matters there have been some 2 row BC boxes with 12x3 or 12x4 stradella which in my opinion transforms them.
So to the BCC# (with stradella) v the continental chromatic -----
possible reasons for going BCC
- those with well honed push/pull skills are already halfway there and can adapt fairly easily
- It offers a lifelong challenge as there are always alternative ways of playing a tune to be discovered
- it offers a choice of changing a note by bellows movement or by changing button which can have a unique effect on the sound
- the compulsory notes i.e DGABb in one direction only give a sort of random bounce that cannot be imitated on a unisoric box
- there is considerable satisfaction to be had from playing with a just few inches of bellows open
- the layout facilitates very fast fingering
- it is a very close descendent of the first 10 key push pulla ccordion of around 1829 and is a fully paid up member of the melodeon family!
Possible reasons for going Continental---------------------
- the keyboard layout is entirely logical
- it is ideal for those who have never quite got the hang of the push pull systems
- Its rhythmic qualities are more akin to a piano box than to a large 'diatonic'
- It is entirely suitable for a very wide range of music including complicated classical stuff
- It is much more compact than the equivalent piano box
- one scale can be used to play all major keys ( on 5 row) but learning 3 is preferable. ( the BCC# needs the learning of 5 scales)
- the fingering is very compact compared to a piano keyboard
- for anybody wanting to ditch push pull or who can't get the hang of the push pull systems it is the sensible choice.
Speaking from a purely personal point of view , (and as one who plays both bcc# and continental ) the continental wins on most counts but is somehow bland and maybe too easy and as a result does not give the same intangible 'satisfaction' that is to be had from getting a decent tune out of the BCC#
george
-
Ultimately, and with great respect to all those who enjoy playing them, and make wonderful music on them, ;D unisonoric boxes, CBA, PA, and English concertina are highly efficient machines, but for me, there is just something dull and unappealing about them.
At the far end of the bisonoric boxes you have the one row 10 button melodeon. Loads of character and severe limitations.
At the other end of bisonoric spectrum you have the three-row button accordions (inc b/c/c#) that prompt the question, why not go unisonoric? The reasons why not are not entirely logical, but they somehow carry over into the music that's made, and a fascination in playing them that just isn't there with one-button-one-note.
(A very nice and fair reply from George as a double-half-step enthusiast, by the way! ;D )
-
Yes, unless you are an unusually skilful PA player something carries. I think it is a reluctance to use the bellows, not helped by an often physically (i shall say no more!) heavy left end. Somehow the music then lacks "breath" and in that has less life.
All common sense would have me on CBA for the music I like, but I still prefer diatonic. BCC# would seem an excellent compromise, but it's too late for me. I was introduced to it by JK when I was a teenager, a real lost life opportunity … I'm now 61 :|glug
-
… I'm now 61 :|glug
I wish I was!
george
-
.
You'll get there George, be patient ::)
-
Chris - only if I engage reverse!
george
-
I seem to recall an interview where Jimmy Shand said if he had to do it all over, he would play a CBA, not a B/C/C#.
-
Well I'm 73 and have no doubt that I could learn CBA if I had one. It's true my fingers aren't fast but then a lifetime as a marine machinist will mess up anyone's hands. I prefer the small bellows movement of the two row BC and it's good for Irish, Russian or French music. What's not to love?
-
I prefer the small bellows movement of the two row BC and it's good for Irish, Russian or French music.
Interesting. What Russian music did you play with BC melodeon?
-
The bellows movement on a larger BCC# is smaller than on a 'small' BC (if the field is levelled by using no or minimal bass) This of course being because the larger the bellows the more air is moved per inch of bellows movement.
george
-
I prefer the small bellows movement of the two row BC and it's good for Irish, Russian or French music.
Interesting. What Russian music did you play with BC melodeon?
I suspect this may be a cypher for "harmonic minor" which tends to have a central European feel to the British ear, weaned and raised on dorian minor melody. Britfolk has the odd "modal" minor, meaning the simple Neapolitan/relative, but major 7th played in a minor tune tends to raise eyebrows in sessions here.
-
Unfortunately, silly me, all this harmonic stuff is some magic for me. I still do not understand what is difference in minor/major (e.g. A minor/C major) if they are made of the same notes.
-
Unfortunately, silly me, all this harmonic stuff is some magic for me. I still do not understand what is difference in minor/major (e.g. A minor/C major) if they are made of the same notes.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tonality
The notes are only the raw material. As a pile of bricks isn’t a house, a pile of notes is no tune. ;)
A minor and C major differ, because they have different tonal centres. All other notes are defined through their proportion to the tonal centre. An 'E' in an A minor tune has different characteristics form an 'E' in a C major tune.
-
Unfortunately, silly me, all this harmonic stuff is some magic for me. I still do not understand what is difference in minor/major (e.g. A minor/C major) if they are made of the same notes.
you don't have to understand to experience music. Just play it out: C scale start on C, major; start on A, minor; start on D, different minor. They are "scales" not sets on notes and you don't have go start with C ;)
Start on A, substitute G# for G, Harmonic minor.
… or are you saying that you don't choose to understand it? ::)
-
I'm not a musical person. I'm too technically (or prosaically) minded too understand such abstract things. I'm not sure at all if music is my thing and I should go on in this direction. I became interested in accordions and melodeons and came here only by accident. But all this is a little off-topic.
-
I'm not a musical person. I'm too technically (or prosaically) minded too understand such abstract things.
Ah, than it may be easier, as music is mathematics.
To construct a major scale, take a tone with frequency x. This will be your base note.
The octave above has the frequency 2x. The octave below has the frequency x/2. The human brain understands tones in octave distance as of identical quality: When you hear two notes in octave distance simultanly, the brain doesn’t perceive them as different notes.
The space of every octave is filled with six notes, so that a complete scale consists of seven distinguishable notes.
How to find the frequencies of these notes?
To find the frequency y of the octave above the base note with frequency x: y = 2/1 * x
To find the frequency y of the fifth note above the base note with frequency x: y = 3/2 * x
Frequency of the forth note: y = 4/3 * x
Frequency of the major third: y = 5/4 * x
Frequency of the minor third: y = 6/5 * x
and so on, you see the pattern?
If you choose x = 262 Hz:
Base note (tonal centre): 262 Hz
Octave: 2/1 * 262 Hz = 524 Hz
Fifth: 3/2 * 262 Hz = 393 Hz
Forth: 4/3 * 262 Hz = 349,3 Hz
Major third: 5/4 * 262 Hz = 327,5 Hz
Minor third: 6/5 * 262 Hz = 314,4 Hz
A major third + a minor third ~= a fifth. That is: If you construct a minor third above x = 327,5 Hz you should end at 393 Hz. Let’s try:
6/5 * 327,5 Hz = 393 Hz <= exact match! (:)
-
can't we just get on with playing it !
george
-
The ear should be king, George, I agree. As for the maths, new to me, I thought those frequencies were a log pattern but happy to defer to Sebastian and any tuners in the forum.
Musically speaking, although the "major scale" is quite big in occidental music it is only a start in one's journey. You can start it on any of 7 notes "the modes", of which 5 are used in folk music, 2 in jazz. Plenty to explore …
Further, many aspects of music bear no relation to the "major scale". In terms of intervals it runs {t=tone} t.t.½.t.t.t.½. There are also seven "harmonic minor" t.½.t.t.½.t½.½ based scales; and seven "melodic minor" t.½.t.t.t.t.½ ones (rare in folk, common in jazz). Because of the unique 3 semitone interval in harmonic, and that t.t.t.t whole tone block in melodic these scales cannot be mapped to each other. Plenty to explore …
Then the simper ones: pentatonic, the derived blues and bebop scales, the symmetrics (dim/ wholetone), and various exotica. Honestly, the "major" diatonic scale is just a start. We can (on a chromatic instrument) sequence music in so many ways.
If you like "major", do start with its 7 modes, eg play "C" starting on each note in turn, against a drone of that note. Each has a completely different feel? The tonic sets context and the interval pattern defines the scale. As these all derive from the major diatonic scale its all doable on a one row melodeon. Both BCC# and (especially) CBA allow you to explore further
-
A general thought on uni v bi sonoric that came to mind yesterday eve,
"With a chromatic you have to go and find all the notes, with a diatonic the notes come to you!"
8)
-
So true! But that is also to (generally) play "in" the notes of the present chord?
-
Thanks, Chris! I've read something similar, but I like your explanation.
Nevertheless, actual tunes are not made of straightforward scales, but of the notes arranged in different ways (and exactly the arrangement differs one tune from another, as I think). Then how do we know if the definite tune is in major or minor?
And how can we say that some instruments better fit "minor" East European music if any diatonic accordion (including garmon) can freely play both major and minor?
-
The notes of a melodeon are placed in totally bizarre places, unless you want to play along with the craftily arranged push pull chords on its left end. For that it's frankly magical and I'd argue that 2-row quint music is essentially left-end driven. That's what gives to intrinsic rhythm, harmony and bounce.
To address your specifics, the characteristic note of minorness in a scale is a flattened third note, eg DEF rather than DEF#. You can extend the concept further http://chrisryall.net/modes (near the bottom), but outside blues and some eastern scales that is always true.
The top end of minor scales has considerable variation, especially notes six and seven. viz 6b,7b:simple minor 6nat,7b:dorian. These are diatonic scales and lie naturally, in various places on a melodeon. Seek them out, very useful!
6b,7nat:harmonic 6nat,7nat:melodic minors. Because of the tone/semitone runs alluded to above, these cannot be mapped to diatonic row scales. They will always involve use of "accidentals", though that's "on purpose" ;) on our instrument. Whereas a CBA or piano player can sharpen/flatten a note at will, simply by shifting a finger.
-
Then how do we know if the definite tune is in major or minor?
By analysing the underlieing harmonic progression.
Normally your brain does this automatically, but you can make it explicit. (I won’t do it here, because we should "just get on with playing it".)
-
.
… the "just play it" approach works very well for dorian minor, Sebastian, but then people post here wondering why it's C rather then C#, or hit a wall when their nice Em tune suddenly asserts a B major chord? More posts here …
But your mention of harmonic progression suggests you know this pretty well ;)
-
… quick cross link to another thread "major/minor"
The klezmer tune "Die Mame ist Gegangen" - A and B parts in G misheberekh (i.e. B flat and C sharp, dorian mode with a sharpened fourth) and the C part in G major.
dorian #4 (there's that that destinctive 1½ interval again, Bb to C#) is 4th mode of harmonic minor, aka Rumanian, aka Ukranian, aka what Jack said (a new one on me)
-
Is it worth to play BCC# instead of CBA? Has anybody experienced playing both?
George's explanation is very thorough but as I can see (=hear) the main sound difference is the "hopping" character of BCC# (as of any push-pull), which (probably) better suits Scottish (and/or Irish) music. Though I think it is a sort of stereotype, before push-pull accordions became the standard nobody would consider that. Anyway, are BCC# played outside Scotland as an alternative to CBA? Do BCC# players play something except Scottish traditional?
-
I'm not sure if it's mentioned anywhere in this thread, but isn't weight a factor? Am i wrong in saying the BCC# is a lighter machine because each reed plate gives you two notes, whereas the CBA/PA gives you only one, so you end up having twice the number (?) of reeds for the same range of notes (leaving aside number of voices etc). E.g. I recently had cause to examine a Weltmeister 41 key/120 bass and I could barely lift the blimmin thing off the ground.
-
I'm not sure if it's mentioned anywhere in this thread, but isn't weight a factor? Am i wrong in saying the BCC# is a lighter machine because each reed plate gives you two notes, whereas the CBA/PA gives you only one, so you end up having twice the number (?) of reeds for the same range of notes (leaving aside number of voices etc). E.g. I recently had cause to examine a Weltmeister 41 key/120 bass and I could barely lift the blimmin thing off the ground.
There's not a great difference in the number of reed plates, because the bcc# has lots of notes in both directions. 10 plates per octave instead of 12?
Do BCC# players play something except Scottish traditional?
John Kirkpatrick is a well known English example.
Apply logic and you nearly always end up unisonoric, but music and playing enjoyment are not all about logic.
A quint box (D/G or C/F etc) with a full set of accidentals doesn't save that many buttons and reeds over a CBA layout, but try persuading melodeon players to change!
With all push/pull instruments, for those that take to the system, there's something extremely satisfying about the way the music lies under your hand, that going to a different button or key for each note can't match.
Even though they may be slightly illogical push/pull instruments do very well in certain areas of music that they are well suited to. They are not expected to play all styles of music. Most players are amateurs who have not had formal training, but in these areas of music I'd suggest that for a certain level of expertise push/pull players can often play music to a higher standard than they could on a unisonoric system.
-
I'm not sure if it's mentioned anywhere in this thread, but isn't weight a factor? Am i wrong in saying the BCC# is a lighter machine because each reed plate gives you two notes, whereas the CBA/PA gives you only one, so you end up having twice the number (?) of reeds for the same range of notes (leaving aside number of voices etc). E.g. I recently had cause to examine a Weltmeister 41 key/120 bass and I could barely lift the blimmin thing off the ground.
I think, it depends on the instrument. "Half-CBA" (or "half-bayans" as I like to call them) may have just two reeds on the right and the same range if not slightly more than BCC# (that is 2½ or 3 octaves). And their weight is usually the same 4-5 kg. But it has all needed 60 (or 48) bass buttons, and can even has 4 or 5 rows and additional reeds. Though all these options (additional reeds, registers, rows) increase the weight. The unisonoric nature of CBA may theoretically increase the weight per se, but BCC# has one "superfluous" row for accidentals. That compensates the difference. They both have three reedblocks, as I suppose. While much of the weight falls on the left side. BCC# with 60 basses would weigh the same as half-CBA if not more, while half-CBA with 12 basses (if such exist, I'm not sure)* would weigh the sames as a Trichord.
Of course, the full instruments like Weltmeister mentioned by you are much heavier. But I think it is unfair to compare simple 31*12 Trichord-likes with full "academic" 5-row 90*120 CBA with many reeds and registers.
*Well, I remembered I've seen such a CBA (http://omsk.avizinfo.ru/content/files/russia/201204/f_cam_0006_20121204233743.jpg) (:)
-
]
Do BCC# players play something except Scottish traditional?
John Kirkpatrick is a well known English example.
many you tube vids of John doing his various stuff but 3 of him playing the BCC# are 'john kirkpatick at otley black sheep festival 2011'', jk at Cheltenham folk festival 2008 and jk at Loughborough folk festival ?2008 ----- and definitely not a Scottish or Irish note passes over his reeds!
george
-
Anyway, are BCC# played outside Scotland as an alternative to CBA? Do BCC# players play something except Scottish traditional?
They enjoyed quite a bit of popularity in Ireland in the 1950s-1960s (I am guessing here) but nowadays very few players who concentrate on traditional Irish music play one, and practically nobody playing purely traditional Irish music is taking up the BCC#. The players who still use them in Ireland are not young and tend to be on the country-popular-sentimental-folk ballad end of the spectrum.
See this recent thread. http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=13507.10
I would guess they were taken up as an augmented B/C and not instead of CBA.
-
Pete Arrowsmith was the musician with Lincoln Morris Men back in the seventies and played a Paolo Soprani 80 bass. He also played with the local dance band (Redwing). He started on a B/C but wanted the extra basses so he could play the correct chords.
Steve
-
its not just the extra (or more to the point the stradella) bass that gives most BCC# boxes more scope than 2 rows but also the extra treble row which far from complicating matters does in fact greatly simplifies the proceedings.
I agree with Ivan M that most BCCsharpists went for that system as a sort of augmented Bc rather than as an alternative to a continental chromatic. That is exactly what I did because I did not want to go up the piano box route and when I went BCC# I had never even heard of a continental chromatic. Maybe if I had I would have gone up that route -or maybe not!
george
-
In my search for something more than the DG I went for a CBA and found it to be easy to play allsorts of flash things, although I had to do it right handed as they don't work upside down, but it was all a bit flat and boring. I considered BCC#, tried BC, CC#, and C#D but settled for DC# in the end, I may stretch it to D#DC# one day if a suitable box comes along for conversion. if anyone comes across a three row with a mirror image stradella (to be played with the right hand as I play left handed) please let me know. For me DC# has the right level of bounce in the main keys I regularly play and the hand position fits left handed playing well. The best system is the one that you enjoy playing, forget all the logic.