Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: blunderbox on April 11, 2014, 05:20:26 PM
-
On the two row b/c box, there are a bajillion ways to get from an F# to an A along the G scale, here is one of them, where the finger in indicated above the staff and the row (i=inside, o=outside) is indicated below the staff.
(http://i655.photobucket.com/albums/uu277/josephquigley/Gscale.png)
I am interested in this exact run on the b/c box. Do other b/c players have a preferred fingering for this run? (or maybe C#/D players for the same run in the key of A?)
-
Speaking as a C#/D player who plays in A and likes to learn tunes in B/C style as well. I would most probably do that whole run with fingers 1 and 2 and land on the top note (your A) with my 2nd finger.
Like this:
1 2121 212 1 2
F# GABc def#g a
If the run stopped at g, I would play g with 3.
I find running up the keyboard with 1 and 2 like this very fast and efficient, and since I dislike running out of fingers, it keeps your 3rd and (crosses himself) 4th fingers in reserve to reach for higher notes at the end of the run.
-
and either to add to the confusion or make the point that there is no right or wrong way of doing it my version is
(thumb not included in numbering so 1st finger =1)
F#2 outside
g 1 inside
a 1 ''
b 2 ''
c 2 ''
d 3 ''
e 3 ''
f# 4 outside
g 1 inside or 3 if going no further
that's 3 ways so far -- any more bright ideas out there?
george
-
Thanks folks, specifically, this is the part of Hunter's House that I am looking for fingering suggestions on, the bit between the arrows.
(http://i655.photobucket.com/albums/uu277/josephquigley/HuntersHouse.png)
-
Too many finger changes can become confusing. I think George's way probably sensible but depends on the tune you are playing. The only reservation I would have on George's version is the use of the 4th (little) finger to play the F#. The jump to the first finger for the G is too cumbersome. I would probably use the first finger for the F# leaving my second finger ready for the following G. The use of the little (4th) finger can be useful, but not in this case I feel. The bottom line is whatever you feel comfortable with.
-
I really think (with apologies to Sartre) that "l'enfer, c'est le doigté des autres" (hell is other people's fingering), so Tom's bottom line obviously applies here. But Wayne did ask.
Having looked at the passage again in the context of that great tune, I wouldn't end on the high a with finger 2, but with 3 or - why not - 4, since you only have to come down after it, and it's not a note that is crying out (to me anyway) for a grace note.