Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Owen Woods on March 12, 2009, 02:08:08 AM
-
This is a really very idle question; I have lots of quite uninteresting work to do that I am profoundly uninspired to complete.
I currently play a "standard" D/G melodeon with 8 bass. The lack of more bass (especially an F#) really irritates me and it strikes me that it may be easier if the bass was not bisonoric. I have no real interest in having a massive 3 row box that would be impossible to cart around - I regularly walk for up to 45 minutes at a time with my box in my hand so weight is an issue. This (apart from the pain of having to get to grips with a new system) is what puts me off the B/C/C# boxes that George and Kirkpatrick play. I was wondering whether there is such a thing as a 2.5 row with the half as accidentals but with cut down accordion bass, i.e. unisonoric with all 12 bass and associated major chords. With a careful layout minor 7ths should be fairly easy to produce and with automatic couplers minors could be obtained by taking out the third.
Does such a thing exist?
-
I have seen a three-row ADG box married to the basses from a 48-bass accordion. Where chords are not required (Bb and Eb rows, diminished chords), the buttons, and associated metalwork inside, had been removed to save weight. The bass end still offered root and major third, plus major chord, minor chord and seventh for EADGC and F. This also means you can play a full diatonic scale on the bass notes in the root keys and have neat tricks like a C on the push, which doesn't exist on the melody hand.
The guy in question had the bellows made specially, since the two donor instruments were different dimensions. Whoever did this was something special, the way they smoothly taper, almost imperceptibly, between the narrow-tall melodeon end and the fat-short accordion end is remarkable. :||:
-
Quite do-able with a bit of ingenuity and it would be fun! The bass end from a 12x4 48 bass pianobox would seem a good place to start. Fair few pass through Ebay, though they tend to be 8x6.
Worth bearing in mind that with Stradella bass ends a 48 bass and a 120 bass can have the same number of pallets and reeds. The difference is all in the number of buttons that actuate combinations of those same reeds. The saving in fewer buttons is therefore in manufacture and therefore cost, the weight difference is not that great.
Tom
-
The saving in fewer buttons is therefore in manufacture and therefore cost, the weight difference is not that great.
Tom
Excellent point Tom and one not a lot folk are aware of. If I were minded to go down such a route I'd want as many bass on the Stradella end as is reasonable and compatible with the treble side - just to make all the effort worthwhile! :o
AL
-
If it's just the F# bass that you feel that you are missing, could you not re-tune the pulled D bass note to F#, but leave the chord as is? This would still give you D major in both directions, but you would also gain F#min7, by combining the F# bass note with the Amaj chord.
Equally, I've got a C/F Club box that has been de-clubbed but still has the club bass configuration with Eb on the push instead of having Bb available in both directions.
If you were to do this on a DG box you could get the following bass notes: D E F F# G A B C.
Taking out the thirds from the chords could give you even more possibilities
Any thoughts?
-
If it's just the F# bass that you feel that you are missing, could you not re-tune the pulled D bass note to F#, but leave the chord as is? This would still give you D major in both directions, but you would also gain F#min7, by combining the F# bass note with the Amaj chord.
Equally, I've got a C/F Club box that has been de-clubbed but still has the club bass configuration with Eb on the push instead of having Bb available in both directions.
If you were to do this on a DG box you could get the following bass notes: D E F F# G A B C.
Taking out the thirds from the chords could give you even more possibilities
Any thoughts?
Well I would like to have the full chromatic range, but the F# is the one that I feel most in need of. That isn't actually a bad idea, retuning the pull D to an F#. It would mean adjusting the way I play bass, but probably not significantly. I wonder how much it would cost to retune in that fashion.
Quite do-able with a bit of ingenuity and it would be fun! The bass end from a 12x4 48 bass pianobox would seem a good place to start. Fair few pass through Ebay, though they tend to be 8x6.
Worth bearing in mind that with Stradella bass ends a 48 bass and a 120 bass can have the same number of pallets and reeds. The difference is all in the number of buttons that actuate combinations of those same reeds. The saving in fewer buttons is therefore in manufacture and therefore cost, the weight difference is not that great.
Tom
Ah that's interesting. I didn't actually realise that, although it does make sense now that I think about it. As mentioned, the bellows would be a nightmare going from the large bass to the smaller treble. Ah well, yet another one for the list of projects...
-
It might not look pretty (depending on how it was done) but one could make up an "adaptor" plate quite easily to test the concept. As simple as a ply rim with flanges either side to match up to the bellows and treble or bass end as convenient, plus gasketing and bellows pin holes etc.
Tom
-
We talked about 2-row boxes with extended basses a short while ago:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1300.msg11645.html#msg11645
-
It might not look pretty (depending on how it was done) but one could make up an "adaptor" plate quite easily to test the concept. As simple as a ply rim with flanges either side to match up to the bellows and treble or bass end as convenient, plus gasketing and bellows pin holes etc.
Tom
That doesn't sound pretty, no! It would probably work though. If only I had the time and skill :(
-
Daniel Denecheau plays what l think is a 4th tuned box with a stradella bass. Haven't heard his playing, but he's composed some nice tunes in the Fench style.
http://denecheau.free.fr/IMG/jpg/la_Villette_2006bis.jpg (http://denecheau.free.fr/IMG/jpg/la_Villette_2006bis.jpg)
I've thought about this as an option, but having heard what guys like Riccardo Tesi can do on an 18 bass G/C+, I think its a good option if you want an extended capability diatonic box.
-
The lack of more bass (especially an F#) really irritates me and it strikes me that it may be easier if the bass was not bisonoric.
I guess the real issue might be: which kind of music do you want to play?
If you find that a standard 2-row 8 bass or 3-row 12-bass is not right for the music you want to play, then perhaps another instrument might be a solution, like a chromatic accordion.
One feature of a standard melodeon is its compactness and light weight, adding extended or stradella bass notes kind of defeats these features. I play a lot on a 1-row, tell me about bass limitations! But when playing with an ensemble we rarely use the bass notes and only use the treble side anyways.
It's like the three choices you have in marriage: live it and love it, live it and hate it, or leave the relationship ::)
-
Daniel Denecheau plays what l think is a 4th tuned box with a stradella bass. Haven't heard his playing, but he's composed some nice tunes in the Fench style. (snip)
Are you sure it's 4th tuned? Some French players play "chromatic" boxes with only three rows and they look very similar to this. The Stradella is also very typical of the French chromatic. The idea of 4- and 5-row chromatics is that they "repeat" rows that are already there so that you can change keys "across" the rows and have the buttons you need there. But a 3-row chromatic has all the notes that you need - having a 4- or 5-row doesn't give you more notes, it just repeats notes so that they're more convenient in some circumstances.
I've seen a few ADG's with Stradella bass. Unfortunately, (IMO) that often encourages somebody's playing style to change so that tunes come out sounding like a p*&#o a^^I&*%@n and completely loses the melodeon sound.
BH NC USA
-
It's like the three choices you have in marriage: live it and love it, live it and hate it, or leave the relationship ::)
Well . . . many of us here seem to have found a fourth option, at least in the melodeon department.
Get many "spouses"!
-
I did see Daniel Denecheau playing live in France abot 12 years ago.
I believe he was then playing a quint tuned GCF with 12 basses. I may be wrong. it could have been a GC+.
-
I guess the real issue might be: which kind of music do you want to play?
If you find that a standard 2-row 8 bass or 3-row 12-bass is not right for the music you want to play, then perhaps another instrument might be a solution, like a chromatic accordion.
One feature of a standard melodeon is its compactness and light weight, adding extended or stradella bass notes kind of defeats these features. I play a lot on a 1-row, tell me about bass limitations! But when playing with an ensemble we rarely use the bass notes and only use the treble side anyways.
It's like the three choices you have in marriage: live it and love it, live it and hate it, or leave the relationship ::)
I play in a ceilidh band, which comprises most of my melodeon playing. I also play in sessions and for Morris (extremely badly).
I agree about the compactness and light weight thing, something that has put me off a three-row in the past. Lugging around a two row is bad enough, especially when the gig is 45 minutes walk away. Tonight it's only around 25 minutes, thank the lord. I wonder whether a reduced accordion bass system would add significantly to the size of the instrument. With a clever mechanism as above there wouldn't be that many new reeds to install. Obviously it would increase the size somewhat however.
I love playing the melodeon, over all of my other instruments bar the Piano. As a piano player for many years the bass of the melodeon is frustrating, as the piano bass is complete and you don't have to worry about whether you are playing on the push or the pull in order to use it... The other thing is that I play a lot of pieces where it would be exceptionally difficult to cross rows such that the bass would work. Having a unisonoric bass would be a lot easier in this regard.
One day I will get a 2 1/2 row 12 bass melodeon, which would probably be as good as I'm going to get. But I do think that such an instrument as described as above would be an interesting one to play.
And please don't tar me with the same brush as the accordion players ;)
-
Yep, this is what they use in the folk traditions of the north Argentina/Brazilian borderlands - this particular subspecies of halfbreed box is called the 'Gaita Pontos'... it's a D/G, usually with a unisonoric half row, coupled to a 40 Stradella bass end (rather than 48, to save on weight I'd guess).
Google/Youtube Renato Borghetti to find out more... here's one to be going on with... (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMFhgqIZUSc)
As you'll see, it's quite a small format box (and handy to go gadding about the stage with). I've got a R/H note layout stuffed away somewhere... I'll see if I can find it...
Daniel Denecheau plays what l think is a 4th tuned box with a stradella bass.
Daniel Denecheau often uses what the French call an 'Accordéon Mixte'... which is a three row combo of semitone and fourth apart systems - one example being G/C/B - stuck to a Stradella bass end. Kind of a second cousin to the B/C/C# British Chromatic, but developed/evolved separately - and 40 odd years earlier (The more recent emergence of C#/D/G instruments - albeit usually with bisonoric bass - is semi-related too).
Ed J
-
Gaita ponto just means button accordion.
-
Gaita ponto just means button accordion.
Well indeed, but doesn't Gaita refer to several types of bagpipes too? I'd guess the word is referring to the bellows part...? :-\
I'm wondering as to the origins of this Gaucho diatonic... wondering if it originally came out of a localised 'cut and shut' of various bits, and the subsequent development of instruments were specified from the manufacturers... I'm aware there used to be a volume accordion manufacturer in Brazil (Todeschini), so I guess they must have made a fair few...
I remember now... the note layout I found was from a dealer in Brazil who sold Scandalli - he also sold some massive 100 odd bass version too... something akin to the bulk of the Shand Morino and no doubt as many reedbanks...
Ed J
-
Gaita is in Spain and Portugal a bagpipe, maybe you are right if the bellows are meant. Otherwise an accordion is called sanfona.
-
Gaita in Brasil is also a harmonica
-
Yep, this is what they use in the folk traditions of the north Argentina/Brazilian borderlands - this particular subspecies of halfbreed box is called the 'Gaita Pontos'... it's a D/G, usually with a unisonoric half row, coupled to a 40 Stradella bass end (rather than 48, to save on weight I'd guess).
Google/Youtube Renato Borghetti to find out more... here's one to be going on with... (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMFhgqIZUSc)
As you'll see, it's quite a small format box (and handy to go gadding about the stage with). I've got a R/H note layout stuffed away somewhere... I'll see if I can find it...
Daniel Denecheau plays what l think is a 4th tuned box with a stradella bass.
Daniel Denecheau often uses what the French call an 'Accordéon Mixte'... which is a three row combo of semitone and fourth apart systems - one example being G/C/B - stuck to a Stradella bass end. Kind of a second cousin to the B/C/C# British Chromatic, but developed/evolved separately - and 40 odd years earlier (The more recent emergence of C#/D/G instruments - albeit usually with bisonoric bass - is semi-related too).
Ed J
That was exactly what I had in mind, thank you :) I'd be very interested in more information if you are able to furnish me with some, but in the meantime I'll go a-googling.
I have been considering a C#/D/G, but I think that I would probably either a) stick with D/G and only make use of the C# row to cross in for the odd accidental, which wouldn't be an efficient use of space or b) become enamoured with chromatic systems and hardly use the G row at all, in which case the basses would be much more difficult to use. I suppose I should try the British Chromatic, but the size and weight of the thing puts me off. Plus I probably wouldn't be able to afford it.
-
That was exactly what I had in mind, thank you :) I'd be very interested in more information if you are able to furnish me with some, but in the meantime I'll go a-googling.
One nice link I found was Casa da Gaita Ponto (http://www.casadagaitaponto.com.br/) - regardless of one's understanding of Portuguese, it seems to gives a basic idea of the instruments used/available... and past/present manufacturers...
Ed J
-
The Castagnari Dony does exactly what you ask for. It's 2 1/2 row, has the standard 8 buttons to suit the key of the box, mine is D/G plus four other chords, F, F#, Bb and Eb. I didn't like the physical arrangement when I bought mine so I changed it to order of descending flats (ala Stradella). I love it. You can do runs or even play the melody. You don't have to lash out Castagnari bucks for one either. Try the Hohner Gallaad.
If you want two row with Stradella base try the Finnish melodeon. Here's one http://www.giustozzi.it/Catalogo/vetrina/scheda_eng.asp?IdC=C0030&PCat=;0;C0035;C0030;&IdP=115/A
Please let us know what you settle on and maybe a tune on youtube if music is still allowed. (current news articles claim music is to be banned on youtube)
Martin
-
I certainly will, thank you! I've been meaning to put up a youtube vid or too for ages, unfortunately the nearest digital camcorder is a few hours away. I might once I get home.