Just wondering what peoples thoughts are regarding his comment, is there any truth to it? Hmmm...
...And now good morning, I have had my rant, in response to yours.
I find that I easily tire of hearing dry tuned melodeons everywhere I look these days.That's probably because of all those people that are tired of hearing wet tuned boxes ;-)
Bad mouthing Ms Shannon in this seems a bit weird. I have only heard her play penny whistle (session in Galway) and that she does .. pretty well.Oh Chris - where have you been all this time... ;)
She plays melodeon as well?!! :o
But do I detect that there is only one bass button or is it one White one and the others black?Well spotted, Nick. I hadn't noticed until you mentioned it. If you freeze the YT video at 0:28 you can indeed see that there is only one bass button. The others have all been removed. There also seems to be a fair amount of black gaffer tape on the LH end. :o
I have twice tried to reply to Young Ray's completely undeserved misrepresentation of what I said in my post.Both times there has been a red warning at the top about more replies ahead of mine and neither have posted.
If there is a more beautiful melodeon tone in ITM than this, I'd be hard-pressed to come up with it ...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pe1EjTMPl0Q
If there is a more beautiful melodeon tone in ITM than this, I'd be hard-pressed to come up with it ...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pe1EjTMPl0Q
The Saltarelles MOCO plays aren't the same as the ones they flog to the plebs
The Saltarelles MOCO plays aren't the same as the ones they flog to the plebs
Having played Jackie Daly's one (which would have been made by Dino Baffetti) I can say I was seriously not impressed - in fact I've politely declined when he's offered me a tune on it since...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CGzJdoMeoQY (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CGzJdoMeoQY)
She plays melodeon as well?!! :o
It wasn't that long ago when Seán Ó Riada was saying accordions didn't belong ion traditional music at all.
And I would NEVER assume anything about anyone's ability to pay more for a box, I did NOT bring up the topic at all, and I most certainly don't believe and never said, that expensive boxes are beyond criticism or that pricier is always better, where on earth on my post can you extrapolate that from??
It wasn't that long ago when Seán Ó Riada was saying accordions didn't belong ion traditional music at all. Time only flows in open direction and the thing that hurts traditional music the most is close-mindedness.
You need a classic, expensive box to play? Tell that to Lemmie Brazil, or this guy.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CoeG2-ZKLBQ
Blaming Sharon Shannon for anything seems just stupid.
But speaking as a newcomer with no background baggage, I'd say there is a smattering of what you call brand snobbery - usually of the inverted kind., even from some of the very nicest venerable chaps on here.
Blaming Sharon Shannon for anything seems just stupid.OK, I confess, mea culpa, it's all my fault - I'm the one who's done massive damage to [Irish] traditional music (which is what this is all supposed to be about, isn't it?), by selling Castagnaris in Ireland 20-odd years ago, and introducing Sharon to them - just don't tell the guy on YT
squirm as you might....it's very clear from your own admissions...that you are fully implicated in this whole, sad process.
trying to make them sound like concertinas... ?...I think not sir.
Where can I get a sponge? Clearly that's also a thing I should have - is there a Guinness branded one yet?
This is "when the rot set in" - the moment that Irish box players discovered there were other accordion makers in the world, apart from Hohner and Paolo Soprani:
But I remember the first time I ever heard Sharon Shannon was in London, when she was visiting as the new teenage "whizz-kid" on the box, and she was playing a 2-coupler Paolo Soprani back in those days, with all but one set of reeds taped off
QuoteBut I remember the first time I ever heard Sharon Shannon was in London, when she was visiting as the new teenage "whizz-kid" on the box, and she was playing a 2-coupler Paolo Soprani back in those days, with all but one set of reeds taped offIt's a fascinating process - how "taste" changes over time. What prompted Sharon to tape off the reeds in the Soprani (surely the worst of all possible worlds in terms of efficiency)?
But I remember the first time I ever heard Sharon Shannon was in London, when she was visiting as the new teenage "whizz-kid" on the box, and she was playing a 2-coupler Paolo Soprani back in those days, with all but one set of reeds taped off - so maybe the buck passes back to herself again... :D
... on those Joe Cooley tapes you hear him playing a pretty dry tuned C#/D off and on, for the stepdancer for instance. Maybe he used couplers to get that sound.