Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Roland Carson on April 28, 2014, 01:15:10 PM
-
Hi,
I have a Castagnari Evo which has a Pignol/Milleret layout keyboard. The layout has lots of benefits but it requires me to re-learn anything I already know on the standard layout.
I would like to consider putting the F row back to something more compatible with my other boxes whilst retaining some of the useful things.
I think that I can achieve what I want with the minimum change but I would like to have opinions.
I will attach two layout diagrams: One is the existing and the other is my proposed changes.
Thank you for any help. I don't read music so please don't confuse me (:)
Roland
-
I completely agree with the goal of having your different boxes allow for some transference. Even the differences between my three row quint and my 2.5 row (with accs) sometimes forces me to relearn a fingering.
What are the benefits of the current layout that you would like to retain?
-
Those 2 C#'s are very stange indeed, you already have those somewhere else. Must be the wrong reeds put in or something ;-)
About your right hand side: i have a similar board, but chose to only retain the push-C on the highest octave, for the middle octave i chose the push D. I am very happy with it, and i dont have any trouble switching betwen octaves. So it is probbably just a matter of getting used to, as would your layout be. And indeed i have this on all my boxes.
W