Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: melodona on May 23, 2014, 07:58:09 PM
-
A have this cajun box with weak copper rods (see picture). The "wrists" of the rods are all weaken and the valves all have stronger pressure at the bottom than at the top. Bending every time it's starts leaking will lead to breakage. How would you solidify the wrists? With soldering, epoxy or some other way?
Thank you
Melodona
-
I think you have a problem. Not a suitable metal, heating it makes it more bendy. You can "work harden". But if you want to do that, it might be easier to replace with a more suitable alloy.
-
solidifying rods ---- the mind boggles --- ? a job for little blue pills!
george
-
Where exactly is the bending happening?
-
My understanding is the pallets do not land flat on the faceplate. Could you correct the angle of the pallets by bending/unbending the rods at the bend half-way to the keyboard (to avoid weakening the 'wrist')? If the rods prove too weak to keep their shape, it may be best to replace them (last resort).
-
Hi, thanks for the answers.
Yes, like I said, all the pallets gradually bend up so the pressure is stronger at the bottom than at the top. The weak point where it's bending is what I call "the wrist" (see new picture attached). Bending them back (event at a different point on the rod), will hold for a little while, but then the wrists gradually bend back bringing the pallets out of tightness again.
Which is why I'm thinking nothing will work until those wrists are solidified and wondering if it's worth it.
Thanks again
Melodona
-
How old is the box?
Did you buy it new? Was it from a shop?
In Britain, if it was bought from a shop or a trader, then you may have redress under the sale of goods act (depending up circumstances, this could even be several years down the line) as it is evidently not of satisfactory quality. I don't know what the law is in Canada, but I wouldn't be surprised to find a similar type of legislation.
-
It's not mine. It's a client's box, custom made.
-
Back to the maker? ???
-
I think the problem may not be just the levers. The levers attach to the centre if the pallet, so if the lever just pushes down then the pallet must lie flat. I believe that the problem might be solved by slightly slackening the screws that attach the lever to the pallet. This will prevent the lever from applying twisting forces to the pallet, and will allow the pallet to lie flat even if there is some flexing of the lever.
-
I think I know the maker by the crimp at the end of the rod flat. He makes a lot of accordions, and I've never heard of that. Are they all bending, or just one? That part of the rod, where the round turns to flat, is the weak spot, and where breakage usually occurs, when it does. And when the accordion is first built, there is some bending to get the valves to sit flat. But if they're continuing to cock up, especially if it's more than one, there is another issue at play.
-
I was wondering if the user did the bending before the box came in for repair? The only box I've ever seen this on was a very old German Vienna style with metal rods that terminated in wire-frame pallet at a solder joint.
-
Some of the US made boxes use copper for the rods, and this fails sometimes. I usually replace the rod with Aluminium and then give it a clear coat of copper colored varnish to make it match. Copper looks nice but does make for good arms. The usually snap/ weaken at the screw closest to the key arm.
Brass would be better.
-
Brass is notoriously brittle! Did you mean bronze?
-
Brass is notoriously brittle! Did you mean bronze?
I don't think that is particularly helpful.
There are 100s of alloys that go under the name of brass, many of them quite durable. It also depends on what degree of hardness they have which can be affected by cold working and heat treatment. Nearly all Wheatstone and Lachenal concertinas use brass action and they are noted for their longevity.
-
Sorry, Theo. Yes alloys are very, very complicated (as The Comet discovered). I was passing on honest advice of son Fred, who works with metal (steel mostly) in a forge surrounded by massive bronze warship propellers.
But it's horses for courses. It may be fair to observe that concertina action is rather lighter. If brass is up to the relatively mild stress of a squeezebox action, fine. At least we've learned that unalloyed copper … isn't?