Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: The Blues Viking on May 27, 2014, 01:08:00 PM

Title: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: The Blues Viking on May 27, 2014, 01:08:00 PM
I posted a link to something like this last year; that was a 6 stop/6 reed C & D Cajun from (I think) Junior Martin. Thus one's a 4 stop/6 reed Gibbanelli (Texas) box that I thought someone here might find interesting. No relationship with the seller.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Gabbanelli-King-Cajun-2-key-accordion-accordian-/111364494360?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item19edd75418

TBV

EDIT: Upon reflection (and triskel's post) I think that the link I posted last year was for a Randy Falcon box being sold by Junior Martin. My memory is a bit fuzzy and I cannot find the previous post. Not that I looked all that hard. - TBV
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: pgroff on May 27, 2014, 02:11:43 PM
That is interesting!  I noticed the box but did not realize it had more sets of reeds than it has stops.

Some folks like 6 voice boxes that are all in one key . . .


Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: triskel on May 27, 2014, 04:48:48 PM
Some folks like 6 voice boxes that are all in one key . . .

Can't imagine who Paul! ;)

Actually, I have wondered what Randy Falcon would make of it if I asked him to make me one of his patented 6-stopper key-changing "Melodeons" in only ONE key - I think he might be a little taken-aback...  ???
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: blafleur on May 28, 2014, 01:25:56 PM
I'm a bit skeptical the accordion in the picture has 6 rows of reeds.  Not only does it have only 4 stops, the valves seem really short for 6 rows, but perfect size for 4. 
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: blafleur on May 28, 2014, 01:28:27 PM
Well, just noticed the tags on the frame edges that say "C" and "D".  Would love to see the inside of this box.  Well, I guess I always want to dissect every box.
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: pgroff on May 28, 2014, 01:50:11 PM
Hi Bryan,

Well, it could be a mistake in the listing.

But I think there would be room for 6 voices, if all the reedblocks are upright types (like you'd have in a Hohner HA-113 or HA-114). In the Gabbanelli 2-key Cajun King listed in the link above, you might *possibly* have:

1) 4 upright reedblocks -- 2 that are doublesided and 2 that are one-sided  (this would be "twice the kind and number in a HA-113").

or

2) 3 upright reedblocks, with the middle one having 2 separate sliders (this would be "one additional block of the kind in a HA-114").


Either way you could have a 6 voice box with 2 keys, for example:

LMH in C plus LMH in D

or

LMM in C plus LMM in D

Just speculating.  I agree it would be fun to look inside. 
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: blafleur on May 28, 2014, 02:02:43 PM
I know there's room in the box, but the valve size is what has me puzzled.  Even the my 5 voice I made, I had to make longer than normal valves.

The listing shows the configuration as LMM.
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: pgroff on May 28, 2014, 02:51:07 PM
I know there's room in the box, but the valve size is what has me puzzled.  Even the my 5 voice I made, I had to make longer than normal valves.

The listing shows the configuration as LMM.

Yes, but you weren't trusting that listing  ;)

I'm a bit skeptical the accordion in the picture has 6 rows of reeds.  Not only does it have only 4 stops, the valves seem really short for 6 rows, but perfect size for 4.

I'm not sure what's in there . . . 4 voices or 6, and what the voicing is.  But there look to be 4 airways and 4 stops, with two labeled C and two labeled D.  So if the listing is correct, I suppose you might have one airway for D L reeds, one airway for D MM reeds, one airway for C L reeds, and one airway for C MM reeds.  In that case we might wonder if those airways for the MM reeds are big enough. 

Proof would be in the playing and listening I guess.

PG
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: melodeon on May 28, 2014, 03:26:11 PM
Note:
The seller is from Sugarland,Texas.

Gabbanelli is known to sell direct.


The stops appear to be on or off.. D or C.   ???  but why 4. ?

I would like to see inside.
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: triskel on May 28, 2014, 06:17:49 PM
... it would be fun to look inside.

I can't help with what the Gabbanelli one looks like inside, but this is the interior of a Randy Falcon one: https://www.facebook.com/FalconAccordions/photos/pcb.583374355089044/583374075089072/?type=1&theater (https://www.facebook.com/FalconAccordions/photos/pcb.583374355089044/583374075089072/?type=1&theater)
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: reelkidmusic on May 29, 2014, 07:17:46 AM
Must take on the 4 stops would be as follows;  By pulling up the "D" stop, you would engage the D reeds, and you us the middle two stops to vary between your LMM setup.  Likewise when you push down "D" stop and pull up "C" stop, you engage the C reeds and again use the middle two stops. This is the only solution I can come up with and can't imagine how that mechanism would work either!
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: oggiesnr on May 29, 2014, 08:01:48 AM
The C/D stops operate master slides that engage the three rows for that key, the other one (in each key) takes the L reed in or out.  At least that's what I've seen before.
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: triskel on May 29, 2014, 11:21:37 AM
Randy Falcon's 1992 Patent for a "Dual pitched melodeon" (US 5111726 A), with three sheets of drawings, can be seen online here (http://www.google.com/patents/US5111726) if you want more information about his design, but it will have expired - so anybody can make them now.

Only, looking at it I'm rather surprised to see that Anthony Faas' 1854 "Construction of accordions" (US 11062 A) Patent (http://www.google.com/patents/US11062) (the first U.S. accordion patent) isn't listed in the Citations, seeing that that instrument had a key-changing inside row (from C/F to C/B systems).
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: Mike Averill on May 31, 2014, 07:28:34 AM
Just received this description of the reeds and blocks from the seller:
reeds are cagnoni dural heavy duty, reed blocks are 2 laying down on top of 2 facing up, unique "block" system
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: blafleur on May 31, 2014, 01:26:08 PM
Just received this description of the reeds and blocks from the seller:
reeds are cagnoni dural heavy duty, reed blocks are 2 laying down on top of 2 facing up, unique "block" system

Wow, now I'm REALLY wanting to see the inside.
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: The Blues Viking on May 31, 2014, 02:30:25 PM
...and before anyone else mentions it, yes I am aware that I misspelled "Gabbanelli"...

TBV
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: triskel on May 31, 2014, 03:02:39 PM
...and before anyone else mentions it, yes I am aware that I misspelled "Gabbanelli"...

You can correct it in the Topic title if you edit your first post...
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: syale on May 31, 2014, 03:27:01 PM
Note:
The seller is from Sugarland,Texas.

Gabbanelli is known to sell direct.


About 20 miles from me...wish I had the readies!

Stephen
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: The Blues Viking on June 01, 2014, 12:16:22 AM
You can correct it in the Topic title if you edit your first post...

Oh, I'm not afraid of the damage a misspelling will do to my reputation. Much.

TBV
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: melodeon on June 01, 2014, 02:23:04 AM


"Randy Falcon's 1992 Patent for a "Dual pitched melodeon" (US 5111726 A), with three sheets of drawings, can be seen online here if you want more information about his design, but it will have expired - so anybody can make them now.

Only, looking at it I'm rather surprised to see that Anthony Faas' 1854 "Construction of accordions" (US 11062 A) Patent (the first U.S. accordion patent) isn't listed in the Citations, seeing that that instrument had a key-changing inside row (from C/F to C/B systems)."

I called the Patent Office when Falcon ( And the LA University) got the patent on the key switcher. I was able to talk to 1 of the two gentlemen that approved and issued the patent.
I did this on behalf of a request from Cajun accordion maker(s) as they did not want a backlash.. they know Falcon personally.

I brought to their attention FAAS 11026A, and the fact that there were Italian accordion makers who were already making switchers.
His response.

We are not required to search internationally, not required to use anything except "current" documentation". I asked him what current documentation meant. He had no answer. The other examiner that approved the patent had retired and was not available for comment.
He also said that if he had known about FAAS the patent would not have been granted.  He also said that for $2355 a protest/dispute would be entertained and likely the patent would be over turned.  The person(s) who asked me to do this "favor" decided against crossing ( their words) the all powerful, wealthy Falcon and the university.

The examiner also informed me that the patent, the way it was written, also patented the 1 row ,diatonic, bisonric, bellows driven aerophone.

Mr. Falcon, the university, and their attornies, were very passionate enforcing the patent.




Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: triskel on June 01, 2014, 10:10:58 PM
Randy Falcon's 1992 Patent for a "Dual pitched melodeon" (US 5111726 A), with three sheets of drawings, can be seen online here (http://www.google.com/patents/US5111726) if you want more information about his design, but it will have expired - so anybody can make them now.

Only, looking at it I'm rather surprised to see that Anthony Faas' 1854 "Construction of accordions" (US 11062 A) Patent (http://www.google.com/patents/US11062) (the first U.S. accordion patent) isn't listed in the Citations, seeing that that instrument had a key-changing inside row (from C/F to C/B systems).

I called the Patent Office when Falcon ( And the LA University) got the patent on the key switcher. I was able to talk to 1 of the two gentlemen that approved and issued the patent.
I did this on behalf of a request from Cajun accordion maker(s) as they did not want a backlash.. they know Falcon personally. ...

He ... said that if he had known about FAAS the patent would not have been granted.

That would explain a lot...

Mr. Falcon, the university, and their attornies, were very passionate enforcing the patent.

Getting them to bring a "test case" against somebody could have been very interesting, if it came to court. I could have brought my 1850's Faas along as "evidence"...

Here are some pictures you won't see every day, of the "works" of a Faas key-changer:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/001-12.jpg)
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/002-13.jpg)
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/003-14.jpg)
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: The Blues Viking on June 02, 2014, 10:24:49 PM
No bids at $1,000.00, apparently. I guess no one found it a grand's worth of interesting.

TBV
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: Theo on June 02, 2014, 10:57:08 PM
All admirably ingenious but I don't get it.  Why not just put two rows of buttons and you can change keys by swapping rows?  You could even change key in the course of one set which would be difficult with one stop to pull and one to push.  It seems to work for Eric Martin (http://www.accordeonsericmartin.com/).
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: triskel on June 03, 2014, 01:46:45 AM
All admirably ingenious but I don't get it.  Why not just put two rows of buttons and you can change keys by swapping rows?  You could even change key in the course of one set which would be difficult with one stop to pull and one to push.  It seems to work for Eric Martin (http://www.accordeonsericmartin.com/).

Never got it myself either Theo. (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Smileys/dontknow.gif)

It's not as if it's a simple flip of a switch, like on the Faas, to change key, and you've sacrified the "edge" that the piccolo reed gives you, so you might just as well have one of those 2-row Eric Martin boxes. Only (much as I want one of the latter myself, especially after Katie let me "have a go" on the green 'un) they don't sound "Cajun" to my ears - though maybe if Eric tuned the two rows that way? But you still wouldn't have that "edge"...

Much better to have two ten-key four stoppers if you ask me!
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: reelkidmusic on June 03, 2014, 10:14:11 PM
It has been relisted with a massive reduction in the starting bid.  A steal at $995   ;D ;D
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: squeezy on June 03, 2014, 10:51:33 PM
Wow - that takes some brass neck to try and patent a one-row melodeon in the 1990's!!!!

From what I've heard here, this Mr. Falcon sounds like an complete bottom-orifice.
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: The Blues Viking on June 12, 2014, 06:23:58 PM
Re-listed again at $995 after no bids? I don't think this is going anywhere for a while.

TBV
Title: Re: Interesting Cajun box, 1 row/4 stop/6 reeds/C & D, Gibbanelli, US Ebay
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on June 12, 2014, 08:13:41 PM
Re-listed again at $995 after no bids? I don't think this is going anywhere for a while.

TBV

I suspect it will continue to be difficult to shift as long as the description is so confused, well maybe not so confused, but not really clear. It needs some pictures and a demonstration.

In the end, I suspect that there is also a very small market for such an instrument. I wouldn't see the point. If I want that style of accordion then I'd want all four voices. If just three (LMM), then a two row 3 voice box is surely a better buy.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal