Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: shalomjj on June 12, 2014, 10:26:02 PM
-
Hey all,
I am really enjoying my Hohner Erica C/F. I just got back from a cabin/camping trip and spent a lot of time around the fire or on the porch learning new melodies. One area I struggle with is in the 2nd row when playing in different octaves some of the notes are configured different. This must be for chords? Anyways, how does one learn to play these best? When playing a song on the low octave and then switching to the higher I struggle because you have to play differently to get the same notes. Thanks!!
-
the only way to get the hang of it is to practice scales in both octaves i.e start with the lower octave and play right through to the end of the higher octave. There are no short cuts!
george ;)
-
Hey all,
I am really enjoying my Hohner Erica C/F. I just got back from a cabin/camping trip and spent a lot of time around the fire or on the porch learning new melodies. One area I struggle with is in the 2nd row when playing in different octaves some of the notes are configured different. This must be for chords?
No, it's because an octave on a push-pull box has 3 push notes (CEG on the outside row of your C/F box) but 4 pull notes (DFAB). Hence the layout must change for the higher octave. This could be avoided by duplicating the C notes (so CCEG push and DFAB pull), which is how a chromatic harmonica is laid out, though I've never heard of a box like that. Hope this helps with the logic, if not with the actual playing (for which George's advice is sound).
Cheers
Steve
-
I learned initially by practicing 2+ octave scales, but quickly moved on to the more interesting way of forcing myself to play familiar tunes in both octaves. Andy Cutting's Flatworld/Continental Mood is great, as it was written for upper octave fingering. After several tunes something clicks and your fingers "know" both fingerings intuitively.
This is totally natural on GC, it's meant to play that way. I've found both DG and CF rather squeaky up there. My present DG is LMM and provided the L reeds are switched in the two octaves feel "linked through"
-
Exactly the same thing happens when I attempt to play on a 1-row in the upper octave a tune which I usually play on a 2-row in the lower register. No problem t'other way round except it can get a bit dogs-and-dolphins on a D/G. As everyone says, though - no shortcuts, you just have to learn to do it; learn the tune twice, in effect, and then remember which version you're supposed to be playing. Sometimes works........ ::)
Graham
-
Not sure I agree, Graham. My brain would burst if I had to remember 2 fingerings for each such tune!
I think Shalomjj should look more to educating his fingers, and treating the instrument as having 2 octaves rather than one. Like any other instrument, dare I add? :|glug
[ed] re David below: I've tried that too. John K recommends it as a practice methods and "interesting effect". I've never managed to keep it up for more than a couple of bars ::) One is (IMHO) better investing time in playing "in chords" than "on octaves" ... but as ever ... depends what you play.
I'd add that MADding onto L+M voiced instuments was one of the best moves I ever did. Opens things up so much!
-
Just for fun, I sometimes play tunes in both octaves simultaneously, playing octaves with my first finger and ring finger. 'The Rose Tree' works rather well on a DG melodeon, providing you have low notes available on the melodeon. It feels very strange because the fingers move independently, but it does have the advantage that I can pretend to be playing a 4-reed LLMM melodeon! Otherwise, I just make sure to practice plenty of tunes in both registers, and endure the squeaking in practice for the day when I can get a more salubrious instrument. I should think the same logic would apply to a CF..
-
I think Shalomjj should look more to educating his fingers, and treating the instrument as having 2 octaves rather than one. Like any other instrument, dare I add? :|glug
I think that's pretty much what I was saying Chris, but probably not sufficiently clearly. :D
Graham
-
a couple of thoughts
- playing the same tune in both octaves is a very good idea once you have got the hang of the 'full box scale' . It is useful playing one part of the same tune an octave higher if you are devoid of low notes so to do eg B part of golden slippers. Doing that even if you don't have to can provide a bit of added colour to a tune.
- It is worth remembering that (on the row) the scale for the upper octave has exactly the same suck & blow sequence as the lower octave. i.e. blow/suck, blow/suck. blow /SUCK. SUCK blow. The only difference being that in the higher octave you blow on one button and suck on another!
george
-
I think Shalomjj should look more to educating his fingers, and treating the instrument as having 2 octaves rather than one. Like any other instrument, dare I add? :|glug
I think that's pretty much what I was saying Chris, but probably not sufficiently clearly. :D
Graham
Chris and Graham,
I totally agree. Playing reasonably fluently (or better!) in the upper octave on a D/G or C/F box is definitely something everyone should aspire to. After all, you've paid for those buttons, so you might as well use them. Yes - the fingering is out of step with the lower octave and that feels strange at first, but it's worth persevering and getting it to be as second-nature as playing in the lower octave.
The upper octave can be used to great effect especially on a two-voice MM box by combining it with the lower octave - i.e. playing in unison octave chords. Suddenly there is a new dimension to the tune and it makes people sit up and take notice. But upper octave playing really comes into its own on a 3-voice LMM box. The effect of suddenly switching a tune up to there is very powerful. It's especially worth doing with repetitive tunes when playing for dancing: alternating between lower octave MM and upper octave LMM brings an extra dimension to the whole performance.
G/C players will, of course, wonder what all the fuss is about... ;)
-
Only in the last couple of years have I got to the place where I feel able to play most tunes in either the "normal" low or high register.
Consequently i often switch between registers (mostly when in D) during tunes. This helps me to strengthen the ability and also helps with the ability to make long accurate moves at speed up and down the keyboard.
It also can make it a bit more interesting for the unsuspecting public (perhaps?).
Due to low notes and a 4th key start (accidentals on the .5 row) I also have a complete octave below the 4th key keynote. This means I can often play the tune under anyone else, also adding to the colour of the performance. However the "order" down there is quite scrambled, but seems to have embedded itself in my brain.
So, to summarise, there must be some tunes, played in D for which I can play in either of 3 octaves! I'll look out for one..
-
I can, and do, play Donkey Riding (used for one of Aldbury Morris' dances) in 4 octaves on my Erica. As it has the G Scale layout I can play it in 3 on the treble and due to the lack of any F#s I also play it on the bass end.
G Scale (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20D_G%20-%20G%20Scale%20with%20accidentals.jpg)
-
Just for fun, I sometimes play tunes in both octaves simultaneously, playing octaves with my first finger and ring finger.
Yes, that's fun and sometimes sounds nice (at least to my ears) as a variatio. (:)
-
As others have said, it is sometimes nice to alternate between the upper and lower octave and, like Brian, there are also times when I like to play a tune in the octave below the keynote. It is also a useful way of emphasising certain notes to play the lower note with the index finger and the note an octave above with the ring or little finger, either simultaneously or alternately. Cajun tutorials sometimes advocate playing whole tunes like that as a practice technique.
However, these are things that are easier to do after familiarity with the upper octave has been achieved. I would advocate beginning by playing scales (but not too much, because it is boring!) and learning tunes exclusively in the upper octave, i.e. not playing those tunes in the lower octave at the initial stage - save that until you are comfortable playing them in the upper octave. A few tunes that come to mind that I tend to play in the upper octave for preference are Kit White's Square Eight, The Self (a variant of The Oyster Girl) and The Wells Waltz.
-
Thanks for all the ideas. In the music you mentioned I am working on the Flatworld. Where do most of you get your music? I am mainly just learning by ear after watching youtube videos. But, if there are some good sources for music that some of you use I would appreciate the input :D
-
I learned it by ear off the vanilla album, my first real foray up to the squeaky end. The key to it is to play a chord sequence on the left, then play across that, cross-fingering.
In Em its Em, C, Am (all pull), D push
Em, C. D/B, Em
then Em, C pull, Dpush, B
Em C D Em
Experiment with chords other way, most of the tune cross fingers both directions. On my kit it also plays low end. Ideally with a low C, or "steal" it from the bass ;) working out how to finger it is the learning exercise - but it's brilliantly fluent.
-
I'm playing Da Slockit Light at the moment which means working properly at the squeaky end. :||: :-*