Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: malcolmbebb on June 20, 2014, 11:50:46 PM
-
I have been asked about the Compadre as a beginner's box? No knowledge myself.
Competitively priced at present - any views?
Cheers
Malcolm
-
They are excellent value for money - if you want a three row.
-
Thanks Theo. I understand that the D&G rows are the same as a normal D/G, so presumably it's just a bigger & slightly heavier box. And a Spiderman image.
-
I just bought one yesterday as a second box! When I'm out with the morris and the weather's a bit dodgy I get really nervous of taking my Dino Baffetti Oakwood Super out so I thought it was time to get a "cheapie". Everything I read about the Compadre was positive, it was a couple of hundred quid cheaper than a Pokerwork, plus I fancied messing about with a 3 row after seeing Daddy Long Les' videos.
For the money it's great. I'm still breaking it in and I think it's going to take sometime to loosen up but it sounds great. Being a 3 row it's a bit bigger than what I'm used to and it's not a lightweight at 4kg but it's not so heavy as to be uncomfortable. Compared to a lot of other cheapie 'beginners boxes' it plays fantastically and I don't think you'll be looking to replace it after a couple of months as it seems like it's a quality bit of kit. How the aesthetics will stand up to use, I'll have to wait and see. I really like the 'Spiderman' grill and think it looks much better than say the Pokerwork grill.
The basses seem a bit on the quiet side but, then again, I'm used to a Dino who's basses can be a bit too strident if you're not careful! In general, I would say the basses are actually pretty well balanced against the treble but to my ear could be a smidgeon louder. They also come with Hohner's usual built in percussion accompaniment ;D.
Personally, I would have no doubts in recommending the Hohner Compadre to a beginner provided they don't mind starting with a larger box. I also think in this day and age of a decent Italian box starting at around £1.5k, this Chinese made Hohner is fantastic value for money at £456 new (including bag and decent straps).
-
Thanks Theo. I understand that the D&G rows are the same as a normal D/G, so presumably it's just a bigger & slightly heavier box. And a Spiderman image.
Yes.
You can compare the layout yourself, the layout charts are on the Hohner website: Compadre (PDF) (http://de.playhohner.com/fileadmin/hohner_group/hohner/09_documents/fingering_charts/3_row/fingering_charts_compadre_reyvallenato_hohner_3_row_button_diagrams.pdf) and Pokerwork (PDF) (http://de.playhohner.com/fileadmin/hohner_group/hohner/09_documents/fingering_charts/2_row/fingering_charts_erica_corso_hohner_2_row_button_diagrams.pdf). On both accordions the third button is g'=G4 on the G-row and d'=D4 on the D-row.
-
Thanks.
We are going around a number of options at present. Maybe developing a short list to to try at Sidmouth.
-
I think everyone is best to start on a 2 row (be that 4th apart or half tone) and branch out from there. Think I see this as a second instrument. For some reason my brain'd make an exception for a BCC#, which is sort of a "complete system"?
-
I agree. I'd advise new learner to start with a two row and get used to that, and play across the rows a bit, then try a three row, where (in my opinion) their power lies in playing across the rows, and the diamond shaped and L shaped sequences you find on e two row work across the three rows.
Have to say I spent a lot of time looking at the Compadre but in the end managed to lay my hands on a really nice Corona.
-
I think everyone is best to start on a 2 row (be that 4th apart or half tone) and branch out from there. Think I see this as a second instrument. For some reason my brain'd make an exception for a BCC#, which is sort of a "complete system"?
May I ask, why?
Okay, the majority of us tend to start out with 2 rows because they are in the majority and because they tend to be cheaper than 2.5 or 3 rows but they all play the same way. If you forget the A row and upper 4 basses you've basically got a DG box albeit slightly bigger than a 2 row. There's nothing more complicated about a 3 row and cross rowing can come later the same way as on a 2 row.
It might also depend on what you want to play. If you tell someone wanting to learn TexMex to start with a 2 row I think you might be doing them a disservice as they seem to need to be able to play chords all over the place for their style of music.
I don't mean to start an argument, but I think you're suggesting starting on a 2 row just because that's how it's generally done, not because of any weird layout or extra accidentals (like on a 2.5 row) that might be confusing; and even then if you just forget about the 1/2 row you've got a normal box. Granted, if you just play a 3 row as you would a 2 row later on, the third row is a little bit wasted as being able to cross row seems to be the biggest advantage of that system; but again that depends on what you want to play because you don't really want to cross row for morris for example. And yes, I agree, you don't want to start out cross rowing when you're wanting to learn English folk tunes but on the continent they are always cross rowing so I'd bet they learned this from the off and didn't learn to play like we do, i.e. like two single row instruments!
I will stand by what I said that if you are on a budget, and want a decent quality instrument that comes in cheaper than some of the other better quality 2 row starter boxes then the Compadre is a good box if you don't mind the extra size and weight. It plays just the same way as a DG box but has an extra A row that you can forget about to start with, if you want.
What I would think is more important to discuss than whether or not a beginner should start with a 2 or 3 row box is whether they should get a standard 23 button box with accidentals or low notes or a 21 button instrument? Should it have a 3rd or 4th button start, etc? For example my Dino Baffetti is a small, 21 button box, which by your standards would be ideal for a beginner to learn on. But it's missing low notes and for some stuff, other than morris, I kick myself for not having them as it can be very restricting in what I can play.
-
It's a feeling, influenced by my own journey (as for everyone), and I don't need to square up about it either. I think it's because we all get going in some way that suits our local circumstances, in my case being in a Morris team, and then move on from there in directions unknown.
I'd see a 3-row as a fairly expensive commitment for a *beginner* and one that might be in a wrong direction. As such … advice would be as above. But with a recent lottery win, or retirement lump sum, maybe a different calculation?
It's taken me 25 years and about 5 boxes to get to where I am now, which feels like where I need to be. I started with a pokerwork, still don't regret that.
-
But a Compadre is not an expensive commitment. Its a cheap box, and better quality than any 2 row I can think of for that price.
-
I've read a couple of times on this forum that a 3 row is absolutely required for "Tex-mex", or rather for Conjunto Tejano.
But, that doesn't seem to be the case. For instance, one of my favourite vinyl records features Santiago Jiménez who plays a 2-row box throughout. Maybe this is the older style or something, but his brother is very often to be seen on a 2-row as well.
OK, maybe it's the majority choice to play 3-rows, not living in the area I wouldn't really know. Maybe you can do stuff on a 3 row that you can't do on a 2-row ... well that's pretty much certain. However, the characterisation that you cannot play the music on a 2-row appears to be incorrect.
Andrew ... happy to be corrected (:)
-
I think you're suggesting starting on a 2 row just because that's how it's generally done
Yes. I’m afraid this is the essential factor. But what’s wrong with that? What’s wrong with following the tradition, at least in the beginning? I tend to think it is an advantage for a beginner that he can follow a well established path and is discharged from the need to solve questions he isn’t already in a state to solve.
I think it’s a myth that a musician has to stick to his first and only instrument. Every player I know – and not only melodeon players – got on to a second and third violin, saxophon, zither, trumpet, … So why not start on a two row and than, after you achieved a state of proficiency and can make a qualified decision, change to a Club or three row or whatever, if you think it is more fitted to the music you want to play?
Of course there may be exceptions, for example if you already know that you want to play only Texmex or only Alpine music. But the normal starter instrument seems to be a two row box (with accidentals).
-
Sebastian, there is nothing whatsoever "wrong" with sticking with tried and tested methods but, dare I say, I think you're missing the point.
The OP's question was asking whether or not a Hohner Compadre was suitable for a beginner. Although it has a third A row, it can be played exactly the same way as a 2 row DG box. The only disadvantage is it's a bit bigger and heavier than an Erica or Pokerwork but if you think weight and size might be a disadvantage, look at some of the kids on You Tube who play boxes almost the same size as they are, LOL! Other than that, it plays and sounds great and as Theo says, it's considerably cheaper than either of the above mentioned instruments.
You don't have to learn cross rowing in the beginning (unless you want to), and you're not duty bound to keep this as your first and only box, but price wise, for a new box, I don't think anything in the same price bracket can touch it! And there's nothing about it that would disadvantage a beginner - just leave the A row alone and you're learning on a 2 row box for a couple of hundred quid less than the next best Hohner 2 row. :D
When I first started playing I bought a 'new' Primo (from fleabay) that was, quite honestly a piece of crap! Within a month I'd splashed out on a secondhand Excelsior Chiltern. So basically, "to learn" cost me the best part of £900. If the Compadre had been my 'learner box' would have cost me half that and, more importantly, I'd have had a really decent instrument to learn on in the first place and something that would have lasted me a great deal longer than a month!!! And, personally, I'd have seen the 3rd row as a bonus for later, not a hinderance.
-
I have owned and played a Compadre ADG for over five years and can confirm that they are very good value for money, I can forsee no problems as a beginners box
-
I've read a couple of times on this forum that a 3 row is absolutely required for "Tex-mex", or rather for Conjunto Tejano.
But, that doesn't seem to be the case. For instance, one of my favourite vinyl records features Santiago Jiménez who plays a 2-row box throughout. Maybe this is the older style or something, but his brother is very often to be seen on a 2-row as well.
OK, maybe it's the majority choice to play 3-rows, not living in the area I wouldn't really know. Maybe you can do stuff on a 3 row that you can't do on a 2-row ... well that's pretty much certain. However, the characterisation that you cannot play the music on a 2-row appears to be incorrect.
Andrew ... happy to be corrected (:)
I used to play bass guitar (for my sins) and you can play virtually everything you need on a 4 string bass. But, add a 5th string and it opens a new world of possibilities and your fingers aren't dancing up and down the fretboard as the required note is often within easy reach because of this extra string. But the neck is slightly wider on the 5 string and it does take a little more learning but not a great deal more. But a 4 string is more than adequate for most needs and that is why they still are the most popular bass. But....................
Things change, styles change, fashions change, and I dare say Santiago Jiménez would have started on a 3 row had he been starting out today.
My view is play whatever works for you, if it's a one row and it does what you want, go for it! Likewise, if your thing is a 5 row CBA equally, go for it!
One of my favourite boxes is a little Castagnari Mignon which I had converted by Pete Grassby to play like the bottom end of the G row. On the accidentals I had him put in a low C and E on one button and a C and C# on the other which means I can play heaps of morris tunes, not all by a long chalk, but enough to have lots of fun! In the hands of an expert I don't doubt it could do even more but for most morris a 2 row is essential. Likewise, although Tex Mex might be able to be played on a 2 row by an expert, for most mortals it's got to be a 3 row. And a lot of Mexicans don't have a lot of money to spend on an instrument but, guess what, they can afford a Compadre!
-
Although it has a third A row, it can be played exactly the same way as a 2 row DG box.
I tend to differ on that. The bass layout is different, there is a different playing position for the right hand, the bellow diameter is bigger. And to be honest, I would have to make a conscious effort to confine myself to the inner and middle row.
Please don’t get me wrong: I don’t think a three row (and the Compadre specifically) isn’t a suitable instrument for beginners. The Compadre is certainly great fun and the price makes it definitely even more attractive.
The only disadvantage is it's a bit bigger and heavier than an Erica or Pokerwork but if you think weight and size might be a disadvantage
Yes, I definitely think so.
The red Club you see in my avatar is a 2.5 row I really love (cost for instrument + complet retuning, revalving, rewaxing is still less than a new Compadre), but I play it rarely just because of the additional size and weight. It is clumsy compared to a simple two row and it has to be played differently just because of the additional size and weight, which slow down bellow movement. It’s just not so alert as a normal two row.
You don't have to learn cross rowing in the beginning (unless you want to), and you're not duty bound to keep this as your first and only box, but price wise, for a new box, I don't think anything in the same price bracket can touch it!
Yes. But if it’s the price, than I would consider a used and restored instrument. What concernes playability they are at least level with new instruments. (It’s different on chromatic accordions.) When I look at where I live, I see for example a reworked Erica for 420 € (http://fraton-accordions.com/EN/second-hand/) in the next town.
And, personally, I'd have seen the 3rd row as a bonus for later, not a hinderance.
Maybe that is the real point where my opinion differs. I consider the third row as a nuisance. (:) Musically the third row adds very little in contrast to the second row (with accidentals). The second row opens up the musical universe; the third row is – grosso modo boring ballast.
Maybe personal background influences me. My main instrument for years and years was the organ. It’s a phantastic instrument and you can make fabulous noise (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pr6w8QzAwPE) with it! I have (nearly) every muscial possibility with it. But what draws me to the melodeon is its (apparent) simplicity. That is its trump. But you weaken it with a third, fourth or fifth row.
When the beginner could acquire a Compadre as a special offer or from a friend who gives it away: Of course, take it and play it!
But when he would want to buy a Compadre because he thinks the third row would offer more possibilities: No, take a two row.
Mattias Nyström (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TswEieKkynM) on two-rows: "I think that the trick when it comes to melodeon is that one should never underestimate it's possibilities. There are ways to play everything just keep trying and don't ever think you can't learn more."
-
Sebastian, it is clear to me that you have never really experimented with an ADG because you are mistaken about the bass layout. Everything that is played on an a standard D/G can be played with exactly the same fingering on the ADG. The bass layout on an ADG contains within it the same bass layout as a D/G. And as to the third row being boring ballast I'd like to point out that it adds G#'s in two octaves plus Eb and F in the low octave adding up to all the accidentals available in a standard 2.5 row D/G except one. In addition it offers numerous reversals facilitating the smooth playing of waltzes and mazurkas with the appropriate chords. It allows playing on the row in A. It facilitates the tex-mex style of playing melodies in 3rds and sixths. In short many advantages for substantally less money than the price of a two row D/G simply due to the economics of scale since the three row is so popular. The added weight is something that I and many others have gotten used to and find it negligible.
-
Sebastian, it is clear to me that you have never really experimented with an ADG because you are mistaken about the bass layout. Everything that is played on an a standard D/G can be played with exactly the same fingering on the ADG.
Maybe my formulation wasn't clear. The bass side has four additional buttons towards the chin end. To me playing it and position of the left hand feels different, I don't like it.
I think, the points are made clear. You pay a prize for the added possibilities of the third row in weight and size and playing style. For me and my playing this prize is higher than the benefit.
Maybe I should have underlined this phrase in my earlier posting: "I don’t think a three row (and the Compadre specifically) isn’t a suitable instrument for beginners. The Compadre is certainly great fun and the price makes it definitely even more attractive."
-
I have been having a lot of problems with Hohner boxes in the last couple of years. Mostly it seems that they have never received a final tuning. This is pretty universal, from the Bravo series ,to a Flaco Jimenez 3 row special.
You can run the instrument on a tuner and the notes will vary about 3-5 cents +- all the way across the block.
Not such a great deal when you have to pay 150-350$ for a final aftermarket tuning.
-
I think that's always been the case.
-
Been tuning for upward of 17 yrs ,and the general tuning on Hohners has gotten suddenly a lot worse in the last few years. It is not all of them ,but it is about 50% at least. I pretty much stopped carrying them in my store , as the profit margin is not enough to cover tuning brand new instruments.(was hardly worth it even before)
I finished a Bravo 48 bass for a walk in customer (he bought it on line) and he paid me to set it up for him. It was about $145 with tuning. It even had a card with a stamp on it verifying it had been tuned and inspected.
The gapping on the reeds was all over the place too.
-
Early days on my Compadre yet. But I find it to be a good morris box, even though it is a bit mellow. But after playing the excelsior everything is mellow. As a learner box, I don't think I would recommend it. I had the use of a pokerwork and a corona when I trying to learn years ago, I preferred the pokerwork.
Thinking back though, if I was playing to the dots back then, perhaps I would have used the corona more, but by ear I found the two row more agile.
-
Bought my ADG Compadre sh for just over £200. Bargain! It's a great box - sweet tone, light to hold and the bass and treble are perfectly balanced. Loads of videos on my You Tube channel
(greenplectrumfilms) if you want to hear it in action.
-
At that price even I see it as a beginner's box! Only glitch is that it won't encourage one to cross the rows; others here would see that as a virtue, though :|glug
-
Only glitch is that it won't encourage one to cross the rows
I don't understand that. Playing smoothly across the rows is one of the great advantages of the ADG...especially in the key of D where you have two full octaves in both directions.
-
Yes, I didn't understand that comment either. Three row quint boxes are made for playing across the rows.
-
Pleased to hear that. I only have (knowing) experience of 2 players, one a local morris player, another a fella I met in New Zealand. Both played almost universally up and down A row in A, G row in G, D row in D. Yes, there are other (I daren't say "better") ways …
I did say "not encourage" ::) As you know I'd encourage any neophyte to cross rows. I've been urged not to encourage rows on Melodeon.net; after last time ;)
-
perhaps an advantage of the BCC# compadre is that the choice of row crossing or not doesn't come into it, unless you wish to play in only B.C or C#!. Pity Hohner didn't have the decency to fit 12 or better still 40 stradella bass as bisonoric and BCC#ing don't go well together
george
-
Pleased to hear that. I only have (knowing) experience of 2 players, one a local morris player, another a fella I met in New Zealand. Both played almost universally up and down A row in A, G row in G, D row in D. Yes, there are other (I daren't say "better") ways …
I did say "not encourage" ::) As you know I'd encourage any neophyte to cross rows. I've been urged not to encourage rows on Melodeon.net; after last time ;)
You said it - "morris player". Of course you play up and down the rows when you play for morris! It's what gives the tunes the "bounce" and is what sometimes lacks when an accordion is played for morris dancing. You don't want to cross row for morris so if you have a 3 row box, you're going to play up and down the rows, aren't you? When I use my Compadre for morris, this is exactly what I'll be doing because the style of music demands it.
Just because someone plays one way for one style of music, it doesn't mean that they're not going to play other styles at sometime and this might include row crossing, and a 3 row might be advantageous. I'm just learning row crossing and what I find most difficult is fitting in the basses, does anyone have any advice please?
-
I'm just learning row crossing and what I find most difficult is fitting in the basses, does anyone have any advice please?
If you're having trouble with the basses, I'm wondering why and how you're doing "row crossing" at all.
One major reason for using buttons on a different row from the one in your home key is precisely so that you can get more of the right chords and basses. Where you have the right basses and chords on the home row, stay on that row!
-
I'm just learning row crossing and what I find most difficult is fitting in the basses, does anyone have any advice please?
Learn the simple ones first, push G/A/B, pull C/B/A etc and get used to them so it becomes automatic and gradually extend your repertoire. The trick is not to fight the tune and force row crossing when the chords or tune don't need it.
Steve
-
The three row Norteno style is really a different style from euro style playing. They never use the left row (it is sometimes used in cumbia) , and often take the reed blocks out.
The technique is a bit like Argentinian Bandeoneon playing in that most of the song is played on the pull with a lot of chords , the bass buttons are usually used like the huge air valve on a bandeoneon on the push ,to quickly return for the next phrase.
Kimric
-
I play three row and two row boxes. To be honest the two row is always my first "port of call" as I prefer the feel of the bellows movement on this type of instrument i.e. lots of changing of direction. Somehow it feels more organic, natural. The three row is great if you really don't have the notes or basses you need for a particular piece but sometimes it can feel a a little sterile to me anyway! Taking this a stage further, I have been teaching myself the Chromatic Button Accordion (B system). This has a stradella bass system where the notes are the same on the pull and push and a right hand which also is unisonoric. I'm really enjoying it but I think it says something when I constantly return to my DG melodeons and instantly start to smile and feel good as I play. This instrument feels like it's part of me. I hope this makes some kind of sense. Check out Anahata's videos as I think he demonstrates admirably what I've been trying to say here.
-
Check out Anahata's videos as I think he demonstrates admirably what I've been trying to say here.
Not the bit about smiling...
-
Hmm, see http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,14992.msg184828.html#msg184828 Very timely ;) Even if it's not quite the same model.