Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: melodeon on March 24, 2009, 03:28:52 PM
-
As a follow up tp the D/G question
Who is playing A/D
Long ago a famous Breton player told me that he plays G/C only when he must; much preferring the A/D
I have not heard of too many A/d players... more specifically I can't think of but 1 or 2 A/D 2 1/2 row players
Any comments here ??
-
I have an A/D Erica sitting in the cupboard, which I bought very cheap on ebay so I would have a box to play easily in A! I rarely take it out, as I already carry 2 boxes around with me. Obviously a D/G plays in D & Em, and I don't have much call to play in Bm.
Having said that, since I started playing G/C I've been meaning to get it out and have a go at playing it in the top octave, as your Breton player no doubt does. It is actually a nice pitch, being just a bit higher than a G/C.
Pauline
-
It's pretty popular in Newfoundland. I'm having a 21/8 box retuned A/D with accidentals, right now. I'm excited.
-
The A row comes in handy on my A/D/G box for many canadian tunes.
It is also a helper row for the D and G tunes to reduce bellows movements.
-
i beleive they are somewhat popular in canada as finnhorse said, though there are far more 3 row and 1 row players, then 2 row players here. But the tunes i play (mostly fiddle tunes popular in quebec/canada) are more often in A then G, so an a/d would be more useful then a d/g for me.
-
Emmanuel Pariselle plays A/D , I believe.
-
Emmanuel Pariselle plays A/D , I believe.
He does.
I use an A/D box all the time in my Zydeco band. It's perfect for playing the blues in E, so the guitarist loves it.
-
I have an old A/D Pokerwork, although its very battered, and sounds it in spite of Theo's ministrations, it just seems a lovely tuning.So if anyone knows of an A/D Corso going!!
-
I started on a cheap east-German A/D.It took me awhile to get accustomed to the higher toned G row on my A/D/G.A lot of Canadian and Scottish fiddle tunes are in A and those that are in G often need the low notes that a D/G doesn't have.The middle C that those G tunes often need is absent on the D/G and is a real annoyance for me.More than half the G tunes I encounter prefer a G/C box,though the basses aren't as handy.
I've since inadvertently happened upon two more A/D boxes which shows that it was once a common tuning.I think it's much more practical than a D/G box in that you're not wasting 4 buttons on the G row on high tones that you would hardly ever play.
If I only played two row instruments I'd choose an A/D well before I'd choose a D/G.But I like my A/D/G,it answers many dilemas.
Chris
-
Thanks for the replies
Rees what brand and model A/D for the Zydeco/Blues ???
-
Thanks for the replies
Rees what brand and model A/D for the Zydeco/Blues ???
I use a 20 year old Dino Baffetti Carnival, 3 voice LMM with stacks of tremolo. It sounds a bit like a Hammond organ when it's miked up. I painted it black for that sexy Zydeco look. I also have an old Guerrini in A/D that I am restoring. It may replace the Baffetti one day.
-
The middle C that those G tunes often need is absent on the D/G and is a real annoyance for me.
I got so fed up with not having a low C on my D/G box that I replaced the low A on the bottom button of the D row with a C.
I now play a tune which needs that low A so I have to fudge it, but I wouldn't swap back!
Pauline
-
Hmm, not a bad idea. I suppose I could have a push C instead of the push A on the D row, or perhaps more sensibly have it on the pull A... except I don't particularly want to lose that as it can be very useful. Ah choices.
-
Hmm, not a bad idea. I suppose I could have a push C instead of the push A on the D row, or perhaps more sensibly have it on the pull A... except I don't particularly want to lose that as it can be very useful. Ah choices.
This is what I have done to get the low C on my box. (The A on the PULL made way for the C)
-
Isn't the CARNIVAL now the base for the Music Room's new "BINCI" box ?
-
Thanks for the replies
Rees what brand and model A/D for the Zydeco/Blues ???
I use a 20 year old Dino Baffetti Carnival, 3 voice LMM with stacks of tremolo. It sounds a bit like a Hammond organ when it's miked up. I painted it black for that sexy Zydeco look. I also have an old Guerrini in A/D that I am restoring. It may replace the Baffetti one day.
The Guerrini isn't this box, is it? I let it get away, regretted it ever since.
-
No, the Guerrini is an old 1950s model in green and cream with flowers painted on!
Sorry no photo at the moment.