Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: arty on July 07, 2014, 10:44:39 PM

Title: Changing Castagnari Tommy to 4th button start
Post by: arty on July 07, 2014, 10:44:39 PM
As I have to send my Castagnari Tommy back to the suppliers to get some work done on it, ( a reed setting problem), I am thinking of asking them to change the layout to a fourth button start at the same time. I am thinking this way, simply because it would seem more useful to me, in the future, to have two extra buttons at the low end rather than the very high squeaky ones at the top.

I have only been playing for a couple of years, so I don't have the experience yet to decide if this is an entirely good thing to do and indeed what new notes I should have on the newly available buttons. However, reading through some old posts about the subject, I have come across a layout that goes like this:

D Row: (push/pull)  G#/Bb, F#/A, A/C#, D/E etc.....
G Row: (push/pull)  F/Eb, B/D, D/F#, G/A etc.....

I would be grateful for other peoples opinions and especially to hear from other Tommy owners who may have fourth button start instruments. Many thanks.





Title: Re: Changing Castagnari Tommy to 4th button start
Post by: Anahata on July 07, 2014, 11:02:06 PM
That's a very standard layout.
Rather predictably I'm going to suggest this variation:

D Row: (push/pull)  G#/Bb, G/A, A/C#, D/E etc.....
G Row: (push/pull)  Eb/F, B/C, D/F#, G/A etc.....

Alterations shown in red.

Two quite independent changes here:
(1) swapping the accidentals gives you a D# in the same direction as the B Bass. You won't be able to do a G7 chord: take your pick...
(2)The other two changes give you a complete G major scale (1st two notes on the D row) gaining two new notes (by dropping some duplicates) and losing an F# you rarely need.

Also linked from the melnet "keyboard layouts" page to this full chart (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20D_G%20-%20G%20Scale%20with%20accidentals.jpg) and discussed in this thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=14991.0) and even more in this one (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7727.0.html) amongst others...

There's nothing specific about the Tommy in this: it works for any D/G melodeon.
Title: Re: Changing Castagnari Tommy to 4th button start
Post by: arty on July 07, 2014, 11:25:10 PM
Thank you very much Anahata - I'll go with your suggestion I think.
Title: Re: Changing Castagnari Tommy to 4th button start
Post by: Theo on July 07, 2014, 11:30:24 PM
One other thought.

For a two voice DG box there is no question 4th button start is best.  With a three voice like your Tommy the third button start has more going for it because the low reed makes all the higher range very useful.  If you loose the top button on each row you will restrict the use if the top octave. 
Title: Re: Changing Castagnari Tommy to 4th button start
Post by: ozbhoy on July 08, 2014, 03:34:14 AM
I purchased a new Tommy D/G approx. 10months back. I went for Anahat-as, G scale with accidentals, except on the G row I started with F/F#.
 It has been great for the type of music I am playing Folk,English,Irish & Australian bush. The low G note allows me to play with fiddle players, I have not missed the high squeaky end as I try to stay away from there?
One other thought.

For a two voice DG box there is no question 4th button start is best.  With a three voice like your Tommy the third button start has more going for it because the low reed makes all the higher range very useful.  If you loose the top button on each row you will restrict the use if the top octave. 
[/quote
One other thought.

 Theo is right the Tommy having a low reed make the squeaky end pleasant its what suits you best.
 I find the fingering up/down or cross row very easy that...

I want to convert my Lilly to a 4th Button start to match my Tommy, ( is there anyone in  Australia who can do this) if not would it be worth sending it overseas to do?
Title: Re: Changing Castagnari Tommy to 4th button start
Post by: arty on July 08, 2014, 08:43:42 AM
One other thought.

For a two voice DG box there is no question 4th button start is best.  With a three voice like your Tommy the third button start has more going for it because the low reed makes all the higher range very useful.  If you loose the top button on each row you will restrict the use if the top octave.

Thanks for your thought Theo. The thing is, I play mostly by myself or just with a whistle playing friend and I tend to play most of the time with the low reed taken out. While I have learnt quite a few Morris tunes in the process of learning the instrument, I have no ambition to play for Morris dancing or in regular sessions. This, added to the fact that I live in a small flat, means that I don't often want the extra volume produced when the low reed is engaged. Having said that, I do really enjoy the full sound when playing with other musicians.

What do I do? I had virtually made up my mind to go for Anahata's layout and then...Theo has given me more to think about!  ???
Title: Re: Changing Castagnari Tommy to 4th button start
Post by: Theo on July 08, 2014, 09:14:54 AM
Ask yourself "are things that I want to play now that you can't play because I don't have the low notes?".   If the answer is "no" then you don't need any change at the moment.   If the answer is "yes" then take a little time to explore playing those tunes an octave higher with the low reed engaged.  You will find the fingering is a bit different, but you will have all the low notes you need.  It does take some learning time, but is well worth the effort because you get a much different sound between using MM in the low range than LMM in the high range.
Title: Re: Changing Castagnari Tommy to 4th button start
Post by: Anahata on July 08, 2014, 09:18:29 AM
I do really enjoy the full sound when playing with other musicians.

We'll, if that's the only important reason for wanting the low reeds, you should be fine.

I actually have 4th button start even on a 19 key box, and the missing top notes are rarely a problem. It only goes up to D, and many fiddle players consider that note off limits. That's a two-voice MM box though, so the argument about low reeds and playing in the higher octave doesn't apply.
Title: Re: Changing Castagnari Tommy to 4th button start
Post by: Clive Williams on July 08, 2014, 10:23:01 AM
I'd drop the top buttons myself. On a D/G you lose 4 notes, E and A on the D row and B and F# is on the G row. The E is repeated on the G row in the same direction, so isn't a problem. The F# is repeated, albeit in the other direction on the D row, which means you have to adjust a little fingering to get round it, but generally it's not too tough to do. That gives the full run up to G in both keys of D and G. I can't say I've even noticed the loss of A or B if I'm honest... but I'll frequently notice the loss of a low B or low C.

Your experience may differ of course!

Cheers,

Clive

Title: Re: Changing Castagnari Tommy to 4th button start
Post by: george garside on July 08, 2014, 11:00:08 AM
on my DG lilly I have 4th button start  and  have gone for the 'traditional' layout with notes repeating on push every 4 buttons and on pull on every 5.  I prefer this layout because it follows thee same layout on the row as the semitone boxes which I also play and therefore avoids nasty accidents!. For me it works fine but for anybody not brought up on the semitone layout the anahata set up is well worth considering.

I think the thing to be avoided if having a box altered is to choose the 'new' 2nd buttonsworth of notes   to enable the playing of one particular tune  and then finding you have  not improved it for the bulk of tunes.  All 2 row melodeons require a adegree of compromise as far as the lower notes are concerned and also with regard to whether or not to 'sacrifice' high notes  in return for low notes.  Those unwilling /unhappy with such compromises may well be better off  with a continental chromatic!

george
Title: Re: Changing Castagnari Tommy to 4th button start
Post by: Anahata on July 08, 2014, 11:18:28 AM
I think the thing to be avoided if having a box altered is to choose the 'new' 2nd buttonsworth of notes   to enable the playing of one particular tune  and then finding you have  not improved it for the bulk of tunes.

That's good advice generally, but I don't recall ever finding a tune that my layout can't cope with and a sensible alternative could have done.

The limitations are specifically:
- no D on pull (but everything you might use that for can be done with the push D)
- no low F# (very rarely needed)

There are lots of tunes that can use a C natural and/or a low G.
Title: Re: Changing Castagnari Tommy to 4th button start
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 08, 2014, 11:22:50 AM
One other thought.

For a two voice DG box there is no question 4th button start is best.  With a three voice like your Tommy the third button start has more going for it because the low reed makes all the higher range very useful.  If you loose the top button on each row you will restrict the use if the top octave.
I'm not sure I totally agree with Theo on this one. On a three-voice D/G box I think it depends on how many buttons you have to start with.

I like to play in the upper octave a lot on a 3-voice box using the LMM setting. My Castagnari Hascy is 21 buttons (11+10) and is a 4th button start. Although I've 'lost' the two top-most buttons which are present on a 3rd button start box, it still gives me a very useful range at the top (knee end) of the keyboard and I've never found myself running out of notes. So on a Tommy which is 11+10, you should be OK.

However, in my opinion, anything less than 21 buttons - e.g. 19 buttons (10+9) with a 4th button start will leave you with insufficient range at the top of the box to play properly in the upper octave.

If you have a 4th-button start on a 23 (12+11) button box, e.g. a Saltarelle Nuage, you have the best of all worlds.
Title: Re: Changing Castagnari Tommy to 4th button start
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 08, 2014, 01:50:19 PM
I have a Tommy and have had it changed to exactly the layout Anahata describes.
I hadn't been playing that long before taking the plunge as it simply made sense. His layout drops to low G and there are several common tunes that drops to low G as it was the lowest note on a fiddle. You often find these tunes played an octave up, cos the old 3rd button start means you have to improvise to play the tune by putting up an octave.

Both my Castagnari's have accidentals like this:-
G Row: Push Eb pull F
D Row: Push Bb Pull G#

which I find useful, as I can play Eb ( D# ) and push a B bass/chord with it in current tunes I'm learning where I'm using accidentals.

My only annoyance is when trying to play some of JK's tunes where he uses a Pokerwork and the accidentals are reversed, so it lies to his fingers and plays hell with mine as sometimes the notes no longer don't fall easy!
Q
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal