Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Steelarts on July 12, 2014, 10:55:29 AM

Title: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: Steelarts on July 12, 2014, 10:55:29 AM
I've been playing the DG box for a while now and love it.  I play guitar at an Irish session I go to and was wondering how difficult it would be to learn the BC box as well as the DG?  Any advice, even "don't bother", will be very gratefully accepted.
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: Stiamh on July 12, 2014, 11:21:07 AM
Initially I think you would probably find it a little confusing and frustrating. I say this based on my experience of trying to master B/C fingerings coming from a C#/D, which is a far less dissimilar system than a D/G. Certainly in the initial stages I think you would have to abandon the idea of bass accompaniment and concentrate on the right hand.

I also think it will be a little like giving up smoking: you really have to want to do it, otherwise you'll abandon the attempt. But if you stick at it of course you can learn two systems. There are people on this forum who regularly play both D/G and B/C, notably George Garside, who will have more a informed assessment than mine.

Others will doubtless also ask this question: why do you feel the need to make the change? If it's because you really want to emulate the style of B/C players you know, fair enough. But as will surely be pointed out, you can play a very large chunk of the Irish session repertoire on a D/G.

Have you considered C#/D? That will give you all the accidentals you don't have on a D/G and also allow you to adopt certain stylistic devices used by B/C players, and would involve, I think, a less daunting learning curve. The main differences between B/C and C#/D initially have to do with smoother style vs choppier style and compact fingerings vs spread-out fingerings, but a little further down the road it's a question of which keys are easier on which system.

Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: Stiamh on July 12, 2014, 12:20:50 PM
PS: some advice in this earlier thread (don't stop at the first post!): http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=9273.0
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: george garside on July 12, 2014, 05:23:37 PM
simplest way for a DG player to 'test'  the BC system is to play a few tunes in A on the D row of the DG.  It is more or less the same as playing in G on a BC particularly if tunes without a G# are used.  Tunes to try  could include cock of the north, 100 pipers, westering home which are G#less.  If you have a G# accidental on the Dg box you can use that to play a wider range of tunes in A

The same fingering  and bellows movements on the C row of a BC would come out in G and the required accidental (F#) is on the D row exactly where it is needed i.e. next to the E on the C row or on the 'back' of the E on the B row.

If you can knock out some tunes as above you should be ok playing both systems  albeit with less useful bass on the BC

george
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: gettabettabox on July 12, 2014, 05:50:06 PM
simplest way for a DG player to 'test'  the BC system is to play a few tunes in A on the D row of the DG.  It is more or less the same as playing in G on a BC particularly if tunes without a G# are used.  Tunes to try  could include cock of the north, 100 pipers, westering home which are G#less.  If you have a G# accidental on the Dg box you can use that to play a wider range of tunes in A

The same fingering  and bellows movements on the C row of a BC would come out in G and the required accidental (F#) is on the D row exactly where it is needed i.e. next to the E on the C row or on the 'back' of the E on the B row.

If you can knock out some tunes as above you should be ok playing both systems  albeit with less useful bass on the BC

george

doesn't work at this end? do you just mean playing off a single row?...no options on standard D/G's to replicate pseudo C+ or F+
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: george garside on July 12, 2014, 06:06:37 PM
yes! keep on the D row  .  Try the scale in A   which will start on 5th button push A  .  ABCDEF#   will be ok but the G# will have to   omitted (or played using chin end accidental).

The tunes I mentioned, and many others, in A do not have a G# so can be played  completely on the D row.

i.e. pretend the D row on the Dg is the C row on a BC

This only works if playing by ear rather than from the dots!

george
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: gettabettabox on July 12, 2014, 06:10:56 PM
yes, but how would that help anyone who wished to try B/C fingering?!

Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: george garside on July 12, 2014, 06:13:56 PM
because that is exactly the same as the tunes I  suggested would be fingered on a BC!  in key of G

g
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: gettabettabox on July 12, 2014, 06:25:37 PM
playing using just one row, wherever you pitch the tune, will not give much of an idea of what is required to embark upon playing a semitone system in session friendly keys.
(I know that you teach and play all systems!)
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: Theo on July 12, 2014, 07:08:21 PM
Ok put it this way then.  If you find yourself all at sea when playing in A on a D row then you will find it similarly difficult to play in G on a C row(on a BC). It's just a way if getting a quick idea of what it's like.
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: gettabettabox on July 12, 2014, 07:30:29 PM
sorry, playing tunes that sit on a single row hardly touches the essence of playing the B/C,
and I know tunes that do sit nicely on a C row.
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: gettabettabox on July 12, 2014, 07:32:57 PM
I would say to the topic poster "go for it." - always useful even if you change direction later.
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: ButtonBox21 on July 14, 2014, 12:28:27 PM
Before you decide to try BC, check out Kathy Cook's videos on YouTube. She plays a Castignari DG and her Irish tunes are excellent. You can play a lot of Irish tunes on DG and you will find the basses are easier to use than they would be on a BC or C#D. If you do decide to learn BC, please go to an instructor as BC requires intricate fingering techniques which are best learned with an instructor.  :||: :|||:
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: Stiamh on July 14, 2014, 01:32:53 PM
It's Cathy Cook, actually. I can't imagine a style more diametrically opposed to B/C than hers, with the constantly huffing basses.

Steelarts, a few years ago, in response to a similar query on here, I made a clip to try to illustrate some of the differences in fingering between C#/D and B/C systems using a tune in D as an example. It's a bit lame (I was nursing a broken leg at the time (:) ) and I've got a little better at B/C since then, but it might give you some insights into the kind of mental leap|brain transplant facing you if you change from a box with a D row to a B/C. http://youtu.be/enAPM5Okr0U
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: Myndmusic on July 14, 2014, 01:53:10 PM
In response to the original question, I did the switch from D/G to B/C almost a year ago. It was a steep learning curve at the start but I am now much happier with the B/C albeit there's an awful long way to go yet. Lots of D/G players kept asking 'what about the basses?' but to be honest the last thing I would want to do is oompah my way through some Irish reels or slides. The Irish bass technique of many great players is a great deal more subtle than applying a constant beat behind the melody. I haven't got much left-hand technique yet but it will come, some day.

Of course you can play the same tunes on a D/G, most of the time all the notes will be there ... but it is not quite the same. Tim Edey may be able to do it, but then he is Tim Edey.

If you can loan a B/C then that might be an option, but you do need to play around with it for a while. At my very modest level of ability I went almost back to square one, so it's not much use just playing around with a box for a couple of days, it will take several weeks before you know if it's for you. I bought a cheap, new B/C from the Music Room at Sidmouth which has been very good, although the bellows are still very stiff so I am obviously still not playing it enough! I have promised myself an upgrade to an Italian box when my skill level justifies it and funds allow.

I had originally thought about C#/D, following the excellent advice of Steve Jones and others, but was persuaded that teachers might be easier to find on a B/C. Unfortunately I have yet to find one close enough to me in Shropshire and am still on the hunt ...

Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: Johnf on November 04, 2014, 11:38:05 PM
I had played a single row for many years (Cajun music) and not long ago acquired a B/C (actually a 21+4). My learning curve has been basically to learn to play in G first, then progess to D, then A...learning use the appropriate sharps on the B row as needed. Did the same thing with the keys of F, Bb, E.  The extra half row above helps provide certain notes in an alternate direction: they are F/F#, A/G/D/C. F/F#. 
The usual learning path for B/C seems to be learning the D scale, then the G scale, etc. That is great for someone new to it, but I found my method better since I was already well versed in C.
Having played Cajun music also gave me a good understanding of the two finger chord possibilities. 3rds and 5ths can give a nice added tone to things.

A method to learn bellows air control:  leave one of the bellows straps attached and play with only the small amount of bellows movement available. That is a tip from the famous Cajun accordion player/builder Marc Savoy.
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: Rog on December 06, 2014, 11:03:26 AM
Here's an exercise you can do on any diatonic accordion to get the hang of the different push/pull pattern on the BC accordion, which is the equivalent buttons/bellows control for playing in G on the C row of a BC, with the exception of the F#.
The A part of 'Ship in Full Sail' and much of the B part uses no F# (of the version I have, in G, which is taken from the 'Timber Flute Tutor' but it's a common enough tune).
On a D/G melodeon:
On the G row, play the tune in the key of D, or, using exactly the same fingering/bellows control, play the same tune on the D row (which will give you that tune in A). If you can do that smoothly, then play the same tune on the C row of a BC box, you will be playing it in G.
BTW I can't do it just yet... (:)
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: Stiamh on December 06, 2014, 09:58:21 PM
Here's an exercise you can do on any diatonic accordion to get the hang of the different push/pull pattern on the BC accordion...

Well that's part of the hang you need to get Roger - back-to-front bellows movements. I would have thought the fingering of non pentatonic tunes would be a greater challenge...

Yes that is basically a pentatonic tune apart from the odd F# as you say. The useful thing to know about pentatonic tunes is that they can be played in 3 different positions on a single row - on a D row, you could play that tune, and many others like it, in D, G or A.

In a sense what you are describing is as much one-row technique as B/C technique. I try to get my box students to take a simple pentatonic tune and learn it in all three positions on one row, something I see as very beneficial, but few seem to want to get to grips with it!  (:)
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: george garside on December 06, 2014, 10:47:37 PM
...
 
In a sense what you are describing is as much one-row technique as B/C technique. I try to get my box students to take a simple pentatonic tune and learn it in all three positions on one row, something I see as very beneficial, but few seem to want to get to grips with it!  (:)

Seconded!

george
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: Rog on December 07, 2014, 07:31:22 AM
'as very beneficial, but few seem to want to get to grips with it'...

I need to have a go at that (I play the one row too).  It takes a lot of practice to do what you describe but I can see how it would be very beneficial. You guys are the experts... I'm happy to mod my post if you think it's confusing. R
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: Stiamh on December 07, 2014, 01:09:20 PM
More of a relentless dabbler in my case, Roger  ;)

However I do think you're on the right track in that (leaving aside C major and D dorian) G is probably the easiest of the common keys to get under your belt on B/C. You've only got one note from the outer row (F#) that you cannot avoid using - and it's as well to get used to what might appear to be a maverick note (the only one in the D maj arpeggio on the push) as early as possible.

Soon you'll discover the delights of the e-f#-g "triangle" and (in tunes with 2 sharps) its immediate neighbour, the b-c#-d pull triangle, and before you know it you'll be hooked on the possibilities of the B/C system  (:)

My next suggestion would be to start tackling D tunes, particularly ones bit arpeggios of D in them, because once you've got those figures tamed, with the characteristic B/C little shove on the F#, the rest will fall into place.

Don't forget to use the "magic notes" of B and E on either row whenever it makes things easier, and keep your hand moving...
Title: Re: DG player wants to learn BC
Post by: Rog on December 07, 2014, 09:42:16 PM
Thanks. I've got to that point in my button accordion playing career where I feel I ought to master the BC. Folk tunes use arpeggios with abandon and on a DG they are easy, but it's a different kettle of fish on the BC (:)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal