Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: thegeneral431 on August 06, 2014, 02:45:29 PM
-
Hi
Sorry if this is not the correct place to be asking this question but after my various questions on google this site keeps popping up. I am hoping someone can help me with some advice. approx. 30 years ago my aunt passed away and left me an accordion. This has sat at my parents house for a number of years until I opened it recently, It is a Baldoni Bartoli accordion with the Irish/American flags.
Whilst I think its a very impressive and beautiful machine I have no real need for it and would like to sell it and fund some other adventures. Could anyone point me in the right direction of a good /shop sales outlet for this is the UK (I'm based in Manchester). I didn't think ebay would be the best solution as I really do not have any idea on the value.
It seems to be in very good condition and has been sat in its box for over 30 years. The name on the front is a family name linked to ours hailing from Galway. Apologies for the quality of the pics I will try to get some better ones if reqd.
Sorry again for the intrusion but any help would be appreciated.
Regards
Jon
-
Hi Jon,
Welcome to Melnet - even if it's just a fleeting visit.
You are broadly in the right place for such a box, and I'm sure others will be along with comments, but I think it will be hard to find what you want to know.
It is a lovely box indeed. However, it is likely to be quite a specialist interest and my first thought is that a dealer would equally have difficulties with a valuation, and might not obtain a very wide exposure to potential buyers.
So hang in here for a while and see what others think, but good luck with it.
-
Gosh, what a lovely box. I'm sure someone on this forum, will advise, or even make you an offer. I'd love it myself, but the MAD kitty is empty, till I sell a couple of boxes.
John
-
Thanks for the replies and help much appreciated. I'm more than happy to take as much advice and direction from anyone on her and have duly noted the donation page on the site for you all helping.
thanks again.
-
What a beautiful box! It looks like it would suit a lady. I'm sure it will be snapped up!
-
Hi Jon, I might chip in a little:
The Instrument:
It's a Baldoni-Bartoli, as you say. They were a New York-based company that imported, sold, and repaired instruments - wheather they actually made instruments is debated (search this forum for Baldoni, and you'll find a lot of info). By the time yours was made, it's beyond doubt that the instruments were made in Italy, and then finished and decorated in the U.S.
I'd say this is late 40's, or 50's. It's a quite 'simple' type of instrument, with 10 treble and 2 bass buttons - but for that category, this is among the absolute Rolls Royce of its age. It will likely have either 4 or 6 sets of reeds, and the two switches ('High' and 'Low') will give you two different combinations for two different sounds. It's hard to say if it has 4 or 6 sets of reeds from the outside.
They were made for the Irish-American market, and from the 30's and up until the late 50's/early 60's, most accordion players around the big cities (New York, Boston, Chicago etc.) filled dancehall after dancehall playing traditional Irish dance music mixed with popular hits - and many of the top players used instruments from Baldoni-Bartoli.
The condition:
It sure looks pretty. 30 odd years in a case will not do much to it, and it looks like even before that, it was well kept. The thing about accordions is, that most of what goes on is on the inside - the reeds which make the sound are held in place by a wax, and the valves that open/close depending on the direction of the bellows are leather. Both living materials, and both affected by humidity, dryness, temperatures and 'old age'. It's impossible for me to base anything on the outside, but you could either have a ready-to-pick-up instrument, or you could have one that will need a full overhaul - and anything in between. If the instrument is to be played much (and I hope it will!), it could be a good idea to let someone with a bit of expertise have a look at it.
The value:
Prices for these old instruments have gone up and down, just like anything else. They're not the cheapest instruments out there (based on the open market such as eBay), but certainly not the most expensive. The best would naturally be to keep it in the family if someone plays, or have it looked at by a tech, and 'try the waters'. I'm not going to write numbers here, as the true 'value' is more about who is going to be playing it, and what condition it is in, from a players perspective. It's only worth as much as someone is willing to pay, and on the other hand, you can't put a price on a great piece of history like that.
Feel free to ask any questions - there's a lot other Baldoni-Bartoli fans on this forum, and I'm sure people will be glad to help you out with finding out more about this box.
/Lars
-
P.M sent. :||:
-
Hi
Sorry if this is not the correct place to be asking this question
Regards
Jon
As well as here if you "do" Facebook the One Row Melodeon page has plenty of enthusiasts for this type of box who would be more than willing to add to your knowledege. Whereabouts in Manchester are you? Although I'm no expert on these type of boxes we could meet up and I might be able to advise on anything that needs doing...
-
thank you Lar's that's some great info!
I have played it a little and to my ear it sounds good but that's like saying I tinkle a few keys on the piano and it sounds ok I've no idea if its in tune or not! I know a little of the history and it was brought back from America as a present to Ireland. My Aunt was actually nun who enjoyed music but couldn't play anything, I can only assume she was given this at some point but never learnt to play it.
If any of you know any techs in the North West area I would be happy to go and see them and at least get it checked out to make sure I'm not trying to sell a duffer!
thanks again for your help, I will get a few more better pics uploaded tonight showing the rest of it and box.
-
I've just read the advice given to thegeneral431 and am once again moved by the kindness shown by the more experienced Melnetters those seeking help. It's something I have experienced personally many times. Mind you, it would be difficult not to respond helpfully to such a mannerly request. Melnet seems to bring out the best in it's contributors.... (:)
-
Jon, you may be interested to read this earlier thread about a somewhat similar family heirloom: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=10508.0
Cheers
S
-
... and I'm sure Paul Groff will be along soon to add his voice. He is very knowledgeable about this make and about Irish-American boxes in general.
-
Hi all
thanks again for all your notes and advice. Baz I am based in Heaton Moor south Manchester and would be happy to meet up if your willing I will send you a pm.
I look forward to hearing more about the item if anyone knows more it really is a great piece of history. I will have to try and dig out some more info when I'm with my father to see if anymore light can be shed on its origins.
cheers Jon
-
not too far at all...I'm in Mobberley...more than happy to meet in a convenient half way house if needed...
-
Hi Jon,
Thanks very much for sharing the photos and information of your beautiful and historic family instrument with us.
I agree with the advice you've had so far! Lars in particular sketched out many of the important issues.
I agree with him that it's hard to put a market value on this instrument. It looks great. It's only a "1-row box" (10 melody keys in one row) which limits the market somewhat. As Lars mentioned, from this time period a nearly unplayed box might or might not need an expensive overhaul. It might have 4 - 8 sets of reeds. Hedging bets and based on incomplete information, I would expect it to sell as-is somewhere between 500 - 2000 GBP, depending on (currently unknown) details of the instrument's construction and condition, and on the circumstances of the sale (including buyer confidence in its condition and the seller), and on how many potential buyers can raise the funds to make a good offer during the time in which it's for sale. No matter how fancy it turns out to be "inside," if you try for a fast as-is sale, for example on ebay, it might sell at the lower end of that range, and it would probably be pretty slow to sell in today's economy at the higher end of that range unless it had just had a top-quality full overhaul. Those are just my educated guesses, but may be helpful since you may not want to ship it to me in the USA for a full appraisal!
We can share more of the general history of this type of instrument if you are interested (for example by referring you to some links to articles, websites, and forum discussions). Some photos of the insides would tell us more about the accordion, if you (or some one possibly more knowledgeable) can carefully open it up. We can tell you how to do this.
But if you are mainly interested in passing the instrument along to someone who will play it, you may not need all that discussion.
In that case, I think you'll soon be fielding offers to inspect it and to purchase it. :-) You could probably sell it locally through an ad on this forum, through ebay, through consignment with a respected expert , etc. All those approaches have their own, different, advantages and disadvantages.
Congratulations and tell us how best we can help. Many of us love to discuss these old machines here if you would like to learn more.
Paul Groff
-
PM sent
-
PM sent
-
Hi again Jon,
A little more on your Baldoni.
I agree with Lars that it probably dates from the 1950s, so is around 60 years old. I think that at any one date there would have been accordions with different features for sale, and sometimes I think the accordions may not have sold until some time after they were made. So even if you find a dated catalog photograph that matches, or a date inside the accordion, that does not always pin down the manufacturing date. But several features of style and construction of this accordion "fit" for the 1950s, including the shape of the leaves on the Shamrocks and the asymmetric harp (rather than the symmetrical lyre)
Compare some of these Irish-American instruments:
http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Baldoni_-_1940s_+.html
http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Baldoni_-_More_1940s_+.html
For convenience, I'm going to re-post a couple of my own comments and links taken from another discussion here on melnet. That topic was about the evolution of the D/C# accordions. Your accordion is a 1-row accordion (probably in the key of D, but have you established that?), so it has a "simpler and older" complement of notes, but its construction and stylistic features are similar to the D/C# accordions that were being made and sold in the 1950s, so part of this discussion is relevant:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,14971.msg184593.html#msg184593
"many Irish and Irish emigrants learned to play a few tunes on the one-row melodeon in the late 1800s through early 1900s, and some of them got amazingly good. Some became professional musicians especially in the US in the early twentieth century and there was demand for very high-quality, responsive, loud (and often showy) instruments. They could be very expensive but pro players need the best they can get. So you had the situation of very deluxe instruments with 4 - 8 sets of reeds and super quality, but only 10 buttons to accommodate the styles that had been developed out of the young but popular melodeon tradition. Example: the one-row Baldoni and Walters boxes played by P.J. Conlon and others in the late 1920s to early 1930s."
Your 1950s(?) box is a later example of such a multi-reed, high quality, and decorative Irish-American 1-row accordion. These were usually in the key of D (especially for amateur players who only had one instrument), but examples are known to have been made in the keys of C, G, Bb, etc. Ann "Ma" McNulty had several 1-row boxes in different keys and was continuing to have these made in the 1940s and 1950s, long after most professional performers who played the D accordion had transitioned to the 2 row D/C# system:
http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Mas_Baldoni.html
http://www.tedmcgraw.com/SuperiorStory.html
http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Walters_McNulty.html
Keeping that in mind, the additional links below will open the door to a wealth of history and photographs about the Irish-American Accordions:
Ferrel, F. and J. Cowan 1995. Joe Derrane: the C & S interview. Concertina & Squeezebox 32: 12 - 28.
Liner notes by Charlie Harris on this essential recording:
http://www.oldtimerecords.com/peterconlon.html
One of Ted McGraw's publications:
http://www.nyfolklore.org/pubs/voic36-3-4/accordion.html
Review and info about one of Hugh O'Rourke's publications:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,11164
And some more discussion threads that are relevant:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,768
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1564.0.html
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9187.0.html
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12985
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,13549
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,11144
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,11281
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,11879
PG
-
Hi again Jon,
I see that Ted McGraw's vintage Baldoni-Bartoli catalog has now been published publicly on his website, www.tedmcgraw.com. What a great resource, generously provided by Ted. He dates the catalog to 1962 or earlier, but Baldoni was known to include photos of earlier date in their catalogs. So it's safest to say that the models illustrated in that catolog were available beginning "pre 1962." Of course, some of these same models may still have been available for sale in 1962 or later as well.
Your accordion seems to be listed and illustrated as Model 734, professional 1-row accordion with 6 sets of reeds, and the list price ca. 1962 was $195 (US). It is however possible that yours might turn out to have 4 sets or 8 sets of reeds inside.
http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Baldoni_Ads.html
PG
-
Good Day,
This is a beautiful instrument. I am very interested in it and would love an opportunity to discuss purchasing it. My great grandfather played one of these and I am looking at continuing the tradition.
If it is available, please pm me.
Regards.
-
First of all a big thank you to all the public and private messages you have all helped enormously. pgroff that's a wealth of info to work my way through superb help thanks.
Just for info to everyone who has asked on pm's regarding a price etc, I really have no idea yet and my first concern is that I get the item checked out to make sure what condition it's in and make sure I'm giving people a correct condition for the correct price.
I have to say originally I was thinking something like eBay was the way to go but the obvious passion and knowledge shown on her makes me want to try and make sure someone from off here or as a result from here becomes the owner. Genuinely overwhelmed with the help. I will get some proper pics and a sound clip uploaded tomorrow if poss.
Thanks
Jon
-
Hi Folks
I have managed to get some more pictures, including the box and a short sound clip uploaded. Please ignore my obvious shocking skills it was just to show it works!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9_yARdox1-Q&feature=youtu.be
I have sent a message to a couple of different shops to go and get checked out so hopefully can get you a recording of it being played properly this week then I will advise everyone of the condition/price for all those that have asked.
Have a good weekend.
Jon
-
Few more
-
few more
-
few more, 19 shows some small scratches on the back from the buckle. I tried to take a couple of shots in the open position to show inbetween.
-
last ones, thanks for looking.
Jon
-
Looks like you need to get your own "sealed bid" in fast, mate! What a nice thing to see a classic box going off to be played again :D
-
Hi Jon,
Thanks for sharing the extra pictures. It really is a very pretty example of such a box, and pristine condition on the outside it seems!
There's a few things you would want to know before putting it up for sale, since it would be the things most interesting for a potential buyer to know:
Number of reeds - how many reeds does it have per note? You can see this by opening up the box - it is a simple procedure, takes a couple of minutes, and we could easily tell you how to do this: Along the edge of the bellows there are a number of 'pins' or 'nails' that hold the bellows to the body. Pulling these out (not forcing or breaking, but a direct PULL) all the way around one edge will allow the body to be lifted from the bellow-frame. It might creak a bit after so many years. On the inside you will see the reeds. On the side with the 10 buttons, there are some long wooden 'blocks' holding the reeds, with reeds on both side of each block. 2 blocks means it's a '4 voice' accordion, 3 blocks means '6 voice', and 4 blocks means '8 voice'. Or, post a picture, and I'm sure the forum will comment accordingly. The, put it back on the frame (make sure you don't put it on backwards;)), and push the 'pins' back in place. Don't hammer them in, but push straight in.
Voicing - how are the reeds arranged? There's a number of different variations available for the voices - what octave are they in, how many in what octave etc., etc. If you go to a technician, he/she should be able to tell you this fairly quickly from a look inside.
What sort of pallet-lifting mechanism does it have? This a bit nerdy, but Baldoni-Bartoli did make a couple of different systems. It does not effect the sound, but one of the systems does need a bit more work after being 'worn' for a long time. This is visible under the 'hood', the plate covering the front, where the two 'couplers' are attached. Unscrew the screws, lift carefully, and it's all visible there. You will need to pay good attention when putting it back on, as the couplers can be a bit tricky getting back in place right. A technician could also help you with this.
What's the condition of the wax and the valves? This has to do with what I wrote in my first reply to you - how much work is needed to get the full potential out of the box, if any work is needed at all? A good tech should answer this, and might even give you an estimate of what he or she thinks is needed.
Now, the above is just the sort of questions I personally would like to know the answer to if I were to purchase a used box. The price should reflect the above, and especially the number of voices would be interesting. But like Pgroff said, there are SO many other things to consider when negotiating a price.
If you're not comfortable with tools, or feel it might not be a good idea to noodle around with the above things, I think it's a good idea that you have someone look it over, and give you the answers. Personally, I think the number of voices, and the configuration (how many in each octave) is important, but there's different opinions out there, and the different answers might spark interest in different potential buyers. Like the forum moderators has stated in the buy-and-sell section, the more information you can share about an instrument for sale, the better! And as they also say, this forum can't exactly tell you what the exact value is, but it can point you towards the right direction.
-
The important thing is that you have there a beautiful box that will be a superb instrument when restored. So it will make somebody very happy!
-
PM sent
-
Good afternoon
I hope you will all be pleased to know that I finally was able to get my Baldoni checked out and it is now for sale via Hobgoblin in Manchester if any of you are interested. The box was opened and found to be in great condition with the reeds still looking brand new. the gents who inspected it advised that it is a little out of tune but that should be rectified fairly easily.
I have attached a couple of pics from the inside and also the link to the page with the sale.
Please note 10% of the sale will go towards The Christie hospital in Manchester as part of my fund raising challenges you can find more about this at www.the7challenges.com
Thank you again to everyone for there help and information and i will make a donation to this sites upkeep once the sale is complete.
Best regards
Jon
-
Link to sale
http://www.hobgoblin.com/local/products/SHMAsadd2/Baldoni-Bartoli-One-Row-Accordion-in-D-Model-734-made-circa-1962-slight-tuning-issue-Call-for-more-info/