Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: butimba on August 19, 2014, 11:32:05 AM
-
Hi all,
I’m looking to upgrade from my beginner’s box and have spent the past couple of weeks reading lots of threads on melnet and looking up makers and generally getting confused. Reading through this forum has already been a huge help, but any further advice on a couple of questions I’ve got would be much appreciated!
My main question is: D/G or G/C? (NB Ideally I’m after a 3 row with accidentals.) I’m not certain about this, but I think that on the whole French/Breton/Scandinavian repertoire probably interests me more than English (if I had to choose one or the other, although I really like being able to play a bit of everything). So in terms of repertoire, I wonder if a G/C would be better, but then I don’t want to make it really difficult to e.g. go to workshops/maybe join a ceilidh band/play with other musicians in England. Would a G/C make this a lot harder? (Basically, is it better to focus on the type of repertoire you want to play, or who you want to play it with?)
My second question: how long would I have to wait for someone to make me a D/G/acc box? (I’ve got the impression that Bernard Loffet is pretty quick, but other makers might take from 6 months up to a year or more, is that right?) And is this basically the only way to get a D/G/acc box (as second-hand ones appear to be rare, and they’re not stocked by places like Musicroom)?
Part of my interest in getting a G/C/acc is impatience (because it seems to be easier to get hold of them), which I know isn’t a good reason, but I’ve just had enough of playing my Delicia Popular and don’t really want to be stuck with it for the next 6 months or more. However, I also don’t want to rush into getting a box made for me (particularly before I really know what I want), so I wonder if I should just get a 2.5 row D/G now and try to be content with it. Even though I can see myself getting annoyed that it doesn’t have more notes!
-
I'm guessing that you're looking at many years ahead to play? If so, I'd say go for something that gives you a leap in terms of playability, if you can afford it - yes, look at 3 rows, but also consider the bass end discussions here. You'll want 12 bass at least IMO, but I'd suggest more. Scour the 'for sale' forums, not necessarily in this country. I say all this because it may take you many years to explore the possibilities a box like this will give you.
I also think you're right to think long and hard about what types of music you want to play. In England, D/G/Acc would definitely give you more chums, but it depends on whether that's the musical direction you want to follow - that one has got to be your decision.
-
G/C/accs is a different mindset if you're playing the standard English repertoire.
I play the dusty end which actually equates pitch wise to the lower end of a normal G/D box. On mine I've sacrificed the B major pull chord for a C major so as to balance out pushes and pulls a bit more, it also reduces some of the cross rowing. D major is a pull chord only so you end up diving into the C row for the pull D, likewise Em is push so the same applies. Given the other instruments I play I find it isn't a problem but it is a learning curve going from a D/G.
The one thing I've found that helps (this comes from playing double bass) is that I formalise my hand shifts a lot more and plan them out. In this I'm aided by the fact that the A/B button is dimpled so if I'm heading for a pull D I want my little finger on there, a push D means my ring finger. It also helps if you cultivate a four finger right hand hand, it gets very complicated if you only use your little finger for diving for notes.
On the negative side, almost all the classes at Melodeons at Witney use a D/G :(
Have fun
Steve
-
Thanks both for the replies! Sorry, more questions...
I'm guessing that you're looking at many years ahead to play? If so, I'd say go for something that gives you a leap in terms of playability, if you can afford it - yes, look at 3 rows, but also consider the bass end discussions here. You'll want 12 bass at least IMO, but I'd suggest more. Scour the 'for sale' forums, not necessarily in this country. I say all this because it may take you many years to explore the possibilities a box like this will give you.
Yes, I’d really like a box I can grow into. 18 basses sounds good to me, but then I’d also like the option to have thirds in the chords, and both of those together I imagine will make a beast of a box. So maybe I need to compromise on something just to keep down the weight a bit, although I don’t know if it’s better to compromise with 12 basses or no thirds…
I also think you're right to think long and hard about what types of music you want to play. In England, D/G/Acc would definitely give you more chums, but it depends on whether that's the musical direction you want to follow - that one has got to be your decision.
In your opinion are chums more important or musical direction? ;) (I realise that’s probably one of those ‘how long is a piece of string' questions, but I’m guessing maybe chums, because actually the whole key issue comes down to who you want to play with? So: getting a D/G would make it easier to play with other people, and I could play any French tune on a D/G, it would just come out at a different pitch. If I got a G/C, French tunes would come out at the ‘right’ pitch, but it would be harder to play English tunes in sessions etc… is that basically what the choice comes down to?)
oggiesnr: what made you decide to switch from D/G to G/C (sounds like you started on D/G from your post)? With something like Witney, would you go along anyway with a G/C or not even attempt it?
-
So: getting a D/G would make it easier to play with other people, and I could play any French tune on a D/G, it would just come out at a different pitch. If I got a G/C, French tunes would come out at the ‘right’ pitch, but it would be harder to play English tunes in sessions etc… is that basically what the choice comes down to?)
That sums it up for me, yes. And once you are there and it doesnt matter which you choose, you just choose which pitch you like the best.
To me DG is way too high, and a waste of a good part of your buttons. I like the MM tone on a GC, but if you want to go for a LM or LMM, GC is rather low.
So,...
-
I had a 2.5 row D/G Mory in front of me at Sidmouth.
It's owner, an extremely good player who posts on here, completely blew me away by demonstrating the number of keys possible using the layout. From my limited knowledge of the beast, it'd allow you to play with your D/G mates at a typical English session, yet still explore exotic keys for a future foray into pastures new. A certain Mr. Cutting adopts this policy to great effect, though a touch of genius helps him though ;D
Of course, there are other nice similar boxes out there. I have played a couple of Loffet Po's and they are nice things and a lot less than a Mory. Check out layouts of 2.5 and 3 rows as shown off the Home page of this website.
Good luck with your choice.
Q
-
In your opinion are chums more important or musical direction?
Aha, that's your choice! Mind you, I'm certainly not saying G/C/Acc is a 'Billy No-mates' option, it's just you may find yourself travelling a bit more to find your new chums! ;)
-
I think Chris got a point there, but on the other hand, you could get yourself a really good G/C/acc box and keep a lesser D/G for playing with other D/G players or joining in on a English session (BTW. aren't a lot of English tunes in G?).
Anyway, I live in Sweden and play mainly Swedish tunes on my C#/D, D/G an C/G concertina. I play mostly with string or wood wind instruments, but also manage to join in with other Swedish melodeon players who mostly play G/C or A/D. But I do also keep a nice (dripping wet) G/C poker work ready to bring for rare occasions where I know it's a only G/C event.
So I would claim that to play a Scandinavian repertoire (thinking Swedish tunes) you would do just great with a D/G/acc, especially if you plan to play with fiddlers, but if planning to join Swedish G/C players a G/C/acc would of course be a better choice...
-
oggiesnr: what made you decide to switch from D/G to G/C (sounds like you started on D/G from your post)? With something like Witney, would you go along anyway with a G/C or not even attempt it?
One of my other instruments is Bandoneon and the right hand G fingering (and A if you regard it as a transposing instrument) has a lot in common with a G/C melodoen as I play it in the dusty end (honest). I also play a lot of non-English repertoire which fits better on my G/C.
As I see it the problem with Witney is that the classes that are based round the D/G box are looking at techniques on that box in the class situation. Whilst the knowledge is transferable it isn't so in an immediate, play along sense so last year when I had the chance to go I didn't bother.
-
FWIW I've recently came to a decision over a similar dilemma. Until recently my repertoire (playing on my own) was perhaps 50/50 french/english and I was looking for an upgrade to my G/C and D/G Hohners. I feel pretty satisfied with a two row/8 bass box as things stand and am not (yet) looking for more rows and basses.
I felt the G/C gave me twice as much melodeon as the top octave is so much more playable, and if I'm playing on my own, it doesn't matter what key I play in.
However, I didn't really know what sort of box I wanted and it's pretty hard to find a good selection of G/Cs to try out in this country - places like the Music Room and festivals etc. have an incredible choice of boxes but they're almost all D/G. When I finally got a chance to try a number of boxes, I was surprised at how some just felt so wrong as soon as I picked them up.
As it happens I've been playing english with others more often in the last couple of months and so that and the availability finally swung me towards a 3voice Baffetti Super D/G, which improves the top octave a little, and gives better coverage down low with the 4th button start.
Being only a couple of years in, I can't really imagine trying to play in D or G with the wrong box amongst a group of D/Ger's i.e in a workshop or group.
However the upgrade was well worth it - the keyboard and response of the Dino feels as if it's improved my playing already.
Steve
-
Based on what your are describing, I would go for a GC/Acc. Most English tunes sound good (with the same fingering) on a GC anyway, so when you're playing alone you could continue to play the English repertoire on the GC, & I would keep a simple 2 row DG for playing with your English chums.
-
A comment regarding the suggestion of having a main box in 3 rows and a smaller 2 or 2.5row for other keys - I know this works for many people, and I thought it would for me too many years ago, but it didn't work out that way. I have a C/F Club, but hardly ever play it, and am going to sell it. The thing is, you get used to the different fingerings available for all sorts of runs on a three row, and you just don't want to go back. So for example I've been trying out a few Scandinavian tunes recently, reading from chorded scores in reasonably friendly keys for D/G/acc. I'm not a fluent reader, but I have learned to see patterns of notes that are often best played in a certain direction against certain chords using the note reversal opportunities available, and to be honest, I would miss that opportunity too much.
Another point is that if you don't mind going electronic, you could always buy a good value Roland FR 18 and these issues go out of the window - you've got pretty much all the notes you would want, and you can play in any old key you like!
-
Someone turned up and sang against an electronic box at a Whitby session yesterday. Probably an early streb. It was quite awful. No dynamics whatsoever and reminded me of the sound of the less expensive 60's Hammond organs. Sorry :-\
-
First off, accept that you will never be satisfied with what you've got. A simple fact of life.
My first, and supposedly last, purchase was a G/C/Acc (12/11/10 keys) with 12 bass/chord, and I love it. The trouble is I would now like 18 basses, would like F's, F#'s and A's on the push, I would like to have another voice, etc. I could go on, but you cut your coat according to the cloth you have available, so, for the time being, I will settle for what I've got and work around it.
I recently joined a Morris side, and am now playing English tunes (something I would not have envisaged when I started), I'm not brilliant but I'm getting there, and enjoying the process. There is not an issue playing with D/G'ers, they are generally pushing when you're pulling, the bass/chord layout is different but with a bit of cross fingering and using more basses than chords it's do-able. If you're playing by ear, then their "A" is the same as yours, and unless they are playing in the dusty end, you can be in the same octave, or down, whatever you prefer. If they are playing in Dmaj then you have the required C# in you accidentals; you will be dancing around the keys a little but that's why you have 3-rows, is it not ? The same situation occurs if you are reading the "dots". If it's tablature you're reading from, then you will need to re-write the finger, no hardship there. What I have discovered is that each new tune I learn generally goes through a number of fingering variations before I finally settle on one that works for the style/chords/feel of the piece, and it certainly helps if you are a cross row player. I had considered buying a D/G specifically for the Morris work, but came to the conclusion that it was not necessary, I just needed to put in a little more effort.
Nobody can advise you on what instrument to buy, that is down to you, but my experience is that a G/C/Acc does work in a D/G environment, so you have no reason to feel at odds with your chums.
Someone turned up and sang against an electronic box at a Whitby session yesterday. Probably an early streb. It was quite awful. No dynamics whatsoever and reminded me of the sound of the less expensive 60's Hammond organs. Sorry :-\
I would suggest Chris, that perhaps that says more about the performer than the instrument.
-
The newer electronic designs are not that bad, Chris, and don't deserve to be rejected out of hand. They certainly have dynamics, and a lot of tone variations available, and many other musically liberating features. Yes, it is true that they still sound electronic - they are not the same as acoustic instruments.
-
What is the reason a GC box is often preferred for French? Is it just that G, C, and Am are the main keys (like D, G, Em for English) or is it something more subtle?
Thanks,
Tony
-
The reason we have D/G boxes are historical.
In the early 50's a collector of tunes returned from the north of England and as most tunes were in D or G ordered a batch of melodeons in D/G to allow the tunes to be played.
( search for a thread by Inventor who documents this properly )
The same is true for our friends in France. Their melodeons are designed to play their tunes in whatever keys they are found in. I believe the German melodeons reflect the fact that a lot of their tunes are brass band based. Essentially the melodeon, often restricted to 2 or 3 keys, allows you to play your tunes in your keys.
Q
-
What is the reason a GC box is often preferred for French? Is it just that G, C, and Am are the main keys (like D, G, Em for English) or is it something more subtle? Thanks, Tony
There is no "French" in this sense as their folk culture (also cuisine!) is more regional than ours. In the Allier valley, where the Paris family live, D gurdies, and bazooka like long D bagpipes rule supreme and a GC is not altogether useful. The Bretons often base a bagad around bombardes and tiny, tiny pipes; my friend Pierre plays entirely happily on "to die for" Bb, and Bb/Eb Martins.
The original Parisian "salon" culture that fostered the (to be honest, Germanic) new accordéon in the 19th century seemed to go for G/C, but I'm off base and can't check that out. Basques (ie those I've met) also seem to play that setup. Pignol-Milleret (Savois) layout is also GC "based", but they rarely seem to base melodies on that, I'd say Cm, F or Gm would be most common. Chambre Blue is in F#m, (using D notes, phrygian) ::)
-
Just to say thanks all so much for your replies, very interesting and useful for me. Have been mulling it over all week and I think I'm leaning towards G/C (particularly in light of Idelone's post), but once I've made a purchase will let you all know what I've gone with and why (just in case it helps anyone in the future trying to make a similar decision).
-
What is the reason a GC box is often preferred for French?
To add to Chris's obviously well researched answer, there are popular bagpipes from some regions with a G drone and chanter that plays a G or C scale. (I think they have fingerings for F both natural and sharp: my Swayne pipes certainly do).
-
As someone else has pointed out, you're always going to want to try something else. I currently have five playable boxes and others in various stages of 'project'. There are so many variations in make, tuning, sound etc that in some respects it's not worth spending too much time umming and arring about it. As soon as you think you've got the right box, you'll probably start hankering after something else to try. Or at least that's been my experience.
-
Wot Roger said. :D
-
As someone else has pointed out, you're always going to want to try something else.
Based on my own experience, I would have to say that that's definitely true! :-\
But beyond the question of tuning, or layout, or repertoire, there is the simple fact that different boxes SOUND different. Having a variety of boxes is enjoyable for that reason alone. Going to a vintage Hohner in (say) GC, after playing a modern Castagnari in (say) DG makes the same tune sound completely new & fresh. There is no "perfect" box - each instrument brings something different to the table.
-
This being a fairly common, recurring topic. Is this unique to box playing?
Never have seen much searching for the "single, perfect" banjo, guitar, uke, concertina, mandolin or some of the other instruments I have played….
Usually there is recognition that one need several tools in the tool box, if one can afford them….
As always circled back to, it's just not possible, especially for beginners, to pick out the single, best most perfect box…that will always protect against needing other boxes….
Now, I understand the threads that lean "I only have USD800" or whatever, and those make sense. Just enough to buy one, decent used box and not a fancy one at that.
So my question is: where does the fantasy come from that one can buy the perfect, fairly expensive, only, first and last, box, especially when one does not have a years and years of playing experience?
And the second question, has it ever been done?
-
When you start it takes some time to fully understand that it is a limited instrument and can't do everything, musically speaking. All other instruments have their limitations too of course, but the melodeon has the capacity to be extended almost without limit. Extra rows, extra basses, extra voices being the main ones. I can't think of another portable acoustic instrument with quite as much capacity for expansion. So it is all too easy to go down the path of adding more and more, and it takes done time to realise that for every addition there is a penalty of extra weight and bulk and therefor the instrument needs more effort to play dynamically. The trick is to find ones own balance point where there is enough capability to meet your needs, and at a size and weight that you find manageable. It's a classic design trade-off.
-
Wot Theo said. They are endlessly fascinating instruments.
-
it takes time to realise that for every addition there is a penalty of extra weight and bulk and therefore the instrument needs more effort to play dynamically.
This is really the key point with melodeons. A PA or CBA can have massive numbers of RH notes and basses, limited only by what you can afford, because the extra weight (up to a point) doesn't matter while you are playing, whereas on a melodeon it really does.
-
Thanks for the insight.
I had been missing the "capacity to be extended" idea, but you are right, it can make one crazy (or at least confused)
There really are an almost infinite number of choices between a one row/two basses and a three row/18 bass, plus the key, accidental, basses and reversal issues…. :Ph