Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: WestOz on September 14, 2014, 06:15:48 AM
-
I have recently succumbed to another episode of MAD, and acquired a lovely Preciosa in gold celluloid with blue trim round the edges. In due course it will be delivered to an expert in UK to retune to D/G. It came with the original box, which has a sticker on it advertising the vessel Vulcania, of the Cosulich Line, which plied between Italy and USA (where I bought it). Wikapedia advises that the Vulcania was sold to Italia Line in 1936, implying that this Preciosa made the journey in the early/mid '30's. Picture attached.
I have another grey marbled Preciosa, which I think are more common, however my question is how common (or rare) are the gold Preciosas?
-
Ooh, that's a nice sticker on the box; I love art from the 20s/30s. I know Guy has one of these too, as I got a chance to play on it (and it's a really fun little box). I was under the assumption that you have to own a spangly gold suit to go with it though, so I haven't bought one myself yet ;D
-
I have one of those too, but not in such nice condition.
Can I make a plea for keeping the original tuning? CF and BbEb have many uses too, and the instruments always sound better in these lower pitches than in DG. If you already have a DG you don't have to have this in DG too. Variety is the spice of life, vive la différence!
-
Wot Theo said ! Those lower pitches are much nicer.
-
'er in doors has 3 liliputs, 1=Bb/Eb,2= C/F, and 3 is one I (:) changed from C/F to D/G, and her order of preference, 1.2.3. I would go for original tuning
-
Another vote for lower pitches. I have 2 Preciosas in BbEb (but not, alas, a golden one like yours), and 2 Liliputs, one of which is a superb DG conversion and the other still in BbEb.
Much as I like the DG, the BbEb boxes are far more beguiling to my (tin) ear.
-
These seem to come up on E-Bay reasonably regularly, I'm after one myself but only if its in Bb/Eb. I can see the merits of keeping these lovely boxes in their original keys but conversions but equally don't regret getting my C/F Liliput converted to D/G. I wanted it for morris tours, weekends away and festivals so that I could carry it around all day and
annoy more people get more opportunities to play. This has worked really well and from Chippenham to Swanage via numerous festivals, weekends away and days of dance I've had a lot more opportunities to play and much less shoulder ache.
There is a Bb/Eb shaped hole in my melodeon collection and I'd like one of these gold Preciosas to fit it though :|||:
-
Has anyone seen one of these boxes tuned B/C? How would they sound?
-
Can I make a plea for keeping the original tuning?
Including the club tuning - it's worth learning the wonders of the Club system.
If you really can't get on with it after giving it your best shot it's still a simple job to de-club it.
-
A certain mr E Presley had a gold lamé suit, that would go well with this box. It may be available, as I hear he has no further use for it, since he's left the building.
John
-
I can't comment on how common the gold finish is on Preciosas. I do have a Club III (MMM) with the same gold sparkle and blue piping as your box. I have never seen another one. I once played Anniversary Waltz on it for a Golden Wedding ceilidh.
The last time I was there Martyn White had a couple of piano accordians (possible Student 1 models) with this finish.
I am afraid I will be another voice suggesting you keep the original tuning.
-
Congrats on your new acquisition, Terry. Looks just like mine apart from slightly different name decals.
-
Thanks to all who responded to my original post. I feel I should bow to the inexorable pressure, and retain the original Bb/Eb tuning, although my other Preciosa is also Bb/Eb. How about if it was "sharpened" to A/D? This would only require a semitone adjustment, and mean that it could be used in sessions which are predominantly in D/G.
Two other Melnetters indicated they have Gold Preciosas - there must be more out there - how often do Repairers/Fettlers/Tuners see them?
-
Similar quandary here. :-\ :-\
Both my grey one and my gold one are in C/F, though both re-valved and tuned up to A:440 pitch from the original A:435-ish. I don't need both, but while I love the look of the gold model, the grey tends to sound just that bit sweeter and responds marginally faster; the reeds being a noticeably better fit to the plates.
Do you notice much difference between your two, Terry? The cynic in me wonders whether the gold models had inferior reeds and were marketed/promoted on their bling factor rather than their musicality...
Incidentally. I've only seen one other gold Preciosa, about 40 years ago in Plymouth, Devon. Until I got mine about 5 years back, I thought his was unique!
-
Hi Malcolm, The gold Preciosa requires rewaxing, revalving and tuning, and as such is not in a playable condition to be able to compare with the grey one, which was "Microbotted" a couple of years ago, and plays superbly. I do note that the action on the grey one is faster, perhaps because the buttons do not stick up as much (due to repadding with felt-backed leather?).
The grey one has a full wooden thumb groove, whereas the gold one has a half- see picture.