Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: HallelujahAl on April 03, 2009, 09:32:53 AM
-
Hi, I know that this is off-forum really, but I thought I'd ask the question anyway - does anybody have any experience with playing a continental C system button accordion? I'm being offered one by a PA playing friend. I play PA myself but would like some other perspectives. I'm wondering how easy it would be to cross over from PA to that kind of system. The bass end is 120 button Stradella/Free bass converter which I must admit I find quite fascinating.
AL
-
should not be a problem playing both. Advantages of C system are less hand stretch required, more right hand chords readily available (in reach). It is also poosible to use the same fingering for all keys if its a 5 row.
In many ways its the most sensible system but does not give any great satisfaction or sense of achievement which is why after about 3 years of C system I was happy to revert to the BCC# which is just an overgrown melodeon.
george
-
My husband bought one some years ago, but didn't get on with it (he's since decided to stick to wind instruments). I had a go on it and learnt Speed the Plough, but I didn't really like playing it very much...too much like a PA, and too big! I would think it would be fine for anyone who already plays both PA and melodeon, though.
I actually advertised it for sale on this forum a few months ago, but I've had no takers.
Pauline
-
Yup, I got one for all those accidentals, same pattern no matter the key etc., but it is nowhere near expectations. It definitely lacks something against a melodeon. On the positive side, the PA players I know who have moved over are really good at it but it does loan itself to million mile per hour playing.
-
This one Pauline?
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,976.0.html
...could be the credit crunch...
-
Well, not playing the PA but I can say the treble side is very logical. Last Christmas I started with the 5-row and I'm sure you won't have any trouble to get into it quickly with PA background. I still would recommend a good tutor book to get the most out of the system and to learn the 3 main fingerings.
Btw. you can get the punchy melodeon feel by just using the bellows more in the melodeon style.
-
This one Pauline?
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,976.0.html
...could be the credit crunch...
Yep, that's the one. Any sensible offers considered.....maybe even stupid ones.
-
You may find the following references useful:
http://www.accordionpage.com/diskant.html
http://www.thecipher.com/chromatic-accordion-cipher.html
I was talking recently to two ex-PA players who had made the transition from PA to C-system CBA. They both said that at first they couldn't make head nor tail of it, but once they realised scales were played in-and-out across the rows, rather than up and down as on a PA, all became clear and they got on well. I believe they were learning "by ear", rather than from a teacher or tuition book.
-
You may find the following references useful:
http://www.accordionpage.com/diskant.html
http://www.thecipher.com/chromatic-accordion-cipher.html
I was talking recently to two ex-PA players who had made the transition from PA to C-system CBA. They both said that at first they couldn't make head nor tail of it, but once they realised scales were played in-and-out across the rows, rather than up and down as on a PA, all became clear and they got on well. I believe they were learning "by ear", rather than from a teacher or tuition book.
Thanks Bill - two really useful and informative websites there - I've already discovered much I didn't know (not difficult).
AL