Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on September 19, 2014, 05:10:55 PM
-
I am getting absolutely nowhere with my Casali Verona. I just cannot make the bass side work for me. I can't keep my hand in the right position, without either missing the button, my hand slipping, or hitting the air button. When I do hit the right button, it doesn't sound right to me.
I've only been learning melodeon for 2 years, and I now realise that I have taken on too much, in trying to learn a different bass system, when I haven't really got 8 bass buttons mastered.
I will give it another week, and after that, I'm afraid it will be up for sale.
John
-
I know just how you feel ... it's excruciating!
I have got on top of the stradella thing - but only by playing it in a far more melodeon-like way than any of the accordion tutors suggest. For playing in any given key (for example G major to illustrate) I use the G,C and D bass buttons and major chords for the obvious 1,4,5 chords - but when using the Am, Em and Bm relative minor chords you sometimes need for that key - I don't go linearly down the bass row - instead using the counter basses above the F,C and G basses. To get a "fudged" minor I then play the A counterbass with the C major, E counter bass with the G major and B counter bass with the D major ... this has the advantage of keeping your hand much more in one position (because all those basses are in close proximity) ... it also sounds more like melodeon playing to my ear.
Good Luck!
Squeezy
-
Well there's another reason why I'm struggling. I don't read music, so it's all by ear, in my case.
John
-
John, don't give up! Stradella is actually very easy to play reasonable harmony and rhythm by ear and without any knowledge whatsoever of music theory whatsoever
As its easier to demonstrate than to describe I will try to do a you tube vid of the basics in the next day or two - just laptop camera and no fancy enhancing or editing as I havn't the tackle or knowledge to do that.
george
-
George's stradella tips are very practical and I think well worth a try as I reckon half the battle is to get your fingers moving, take some of the conscious thought out of it. As for learning by ear reading stradella from notes is a bit of a bugger anyway, but I find writing out chord symbols in a row does help to push me in the right direction. Once the fingers are moving, it's suddenly not too hard to branch out a little bit. If you want to.
-
John,
You don't need to read music, but you do need to know where the bass notes and chords are. Consider going to a piano accordion teacher for a few lessons on the basics of the Stradella bass - 2 or 3 should do it.
-
Going for a starter lesson on Wednesday. Watch this space.
I may be an advert for the sale of a box, or, it may not!
John
-
Well then, I've just been to my first lesson, and I am learning a tune in D, to get me into row crossing. Nothing about the bass side at all, yet.
Going back next Tuesday.
John
-
Who are you going to for lessons?
[Ad alert!]
Consider posting about your experiences on http://buttonbox.org.uk/index.php/board,4.0.html, which is dedicated to BCC# with Stradella bass.
[/Ad alert!]
-
Sorry, George/Bill et al, but I have given up on learning the Casali. I'm still learning straightforward melodeon, and I'm really only just discovering the capabilities of my Beltuna Alex III. I didn't really know it is capable of playing 4 more scales, not just D and G. So I have decided to explore that, and not to try, at 72, to learn a another instrument.
Sorry guys, but it's now up for sale.
John :(
-
Well John, you lasted longer than some (:)
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=9273.0
-
Best of luck john!
If anyone is after a nice small BCC# the casali is among the best so Johns may be worth looking at. I can't comment on the particular box as I havn't seen or played it.
george