Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: richard.fleming on September 26, 2014, 11:39:46 AM

Title: Irish press and draw style
Post by: richard.fleming on September 26, 2014, 11:39:46 AM
I get puzzled by refs. to the above. Clearly there is more press and draw action with the bellows on a single row melodeon or if playing Csharp/D (especially tunes in D) than if playing a B/C box. Is there any more to it than that?
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: deltasalmon on September 26, 2014, 03:16:02 PM
As far as I know "press and draw style" is synonymous with playing a C#/D box (perhaps more accurately using C#/D fingering). I've heard people refer to B/C as "on the draw" or "cross row" style of playing but neither of those really make sense to me. If someone is playing a C#/D without crossrowing they're either wasting half the keyboard or playing in a lot of C# sessions. B/C also has more "draw" notes but certainly has a fair share of "press" notes also.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Gromit on September 26, 2014, 04:43:38 PM
I play B/C - my understanding is that there is less in / out bellows action with B/C than C#/D.

If I play the scale of D maj I'm going - pull, press,press, press, pull, pull, pull, pull whereas playing the scale of C maj (which is the same as Dmaj on a C#/D box) I'm going - press, pull, press, pull, press, pull, pull, press.

I think B/C  is smoother where C#/D is punchy.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: richard.fleming on September 26, 2014, 05:33:43 PM
I agree with all you say, Gromit - I've played both B/C and Csharp/D for nearly fifty years, currently the latter - but I hear references to 'the old push-and-draw style' which seem to have a flavour of something else..
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Anahata on September 26, 2014, 05:51:51 PM
I tried a Google search, and there seems to have been some detailed research in to this.
Three-line summary:
In the early 20th century Irish players had single row melodeons which forced a particular style of playing and ornamentation.
In the 1950s the different style of playing evolved based on two row semitone boxes that were then widely available.
Then it seems Jackie Daly led a movement back to an elaborated version of the old style, still using two row boxes.

See http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/41699846?uid=3738032&uid=2&uid=4&sid=21104228556611
and
http://buttonbox.ru/books/graeme_smith.pdf

for example.


Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: richard.fleming on September 26, 2014, 07:31:54 PM
Interesting stuff, Anahata; thanks for posting those links. So when people talk about press and draw, they are talking about the politics of traditional music as well as just personal preference.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Vector on September 27, 2014, 12:08:00 AM
From my observations while sitting next to beginner/intermediate C#/D players in sessions, the B/C is a more smooth, flowing style, while the C#/D box players seem to struggle much more with chucking the box quickly in and out on fast tunes -

Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: boxcall on September 27, 2014, 01:14:39 AM
 Once you develop bellows control in the C#/D OR D#/C  melodeon style of playing it becomes less of a struggle and can be as smooth and flowing with the added bonus of lift for free. My teacher Jack Conroy playing some reels, some times you can hardly notice bellow movement and it flows nicely IMO.  Jack plays D/C# and D melodeon
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EOqj5v2VbwY
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Pat. on September 27, 2014, 07:13:26 AM
The push and draw is to my understanding is one row  original style  and is not complicated with over ornamentation due to the limitations of the notes available ,but in skilled hands it has great rhythm and honesty about it.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Stiamh on September 27, 2014, 09:17:00 AM
I think B/C  is smoother where C#/D is punchy.

This is true but IMO greatly exaggerated in people's minds. The scale of D major is one thing. What about an arpeggio of D major? First bar of Father O'Flynn - six notes (dAF DFA): five bellows movements on B/C, one on C#/D.

There are plenty of tunes in the Irish repertoire where you will have to do more work with the bellows on B/C. They are after all the same instrument separated by a tone. It's all down to the keys you play in.

Getting back to the original question: I don't know. I would contend that in the paper mentioned above Graeme Smith makes the whole question political for academic purposes.

I would also report that on Jackie Daly's 60th birthday an article in the Irish Times referred to him as playing in the "depress and draw" style, which seems far more politically loaded.  ;)
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: richard.fleming on September 27, 2014, 09:41:38 AM
"political for academic purposes"

Of course. But music often has a political loading, in the sense that, for example, I doubt that Morris dancing is done for the beauty of the tunes or the dances but rather because the participants have views about things like Englishness and tradition and a vanished rural way of life. In the context of Irish history it would be very odd if a music seen as national did not have political significance.
Please, Morris dancers, don't come down on me like a ton of bricks. I didn't say the songs and dances weren't beautiful, merely that that may not be the attraction.. I've done Morris dancing myself in the past.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 27, 2014, 10:50:05 AM
I have to admit I'm always slightly bemused by rules about how music 'must' be played to be acceptable.

One of the things I find delightfully liberating about playing English traditional music on the melodeon, whether in sessions, for dancing or for solo performance, is that there are no rules. You can play in whatever style/fingering you like and, so long as it sounds good, no-one cares whether you are playing along the row or in cross-row style or combinations of the two. There are no fingering/bellows police who are going to jump on you and tell you that you are doing it wrong and that it is counter to the tradition, etc.

Within reason, it doesn't really matter what notes you play either, so long as the tune is generally recognisable. It is true that some contemporary composers prefer their tunes to be played using the notes which they originally wrote, which is fair enough. And I also remember the anecdote of William Kimber (the great concertina player from Headington Morris who was championed by Cecil Sharp). William's father told him "these are the notes you play, and you play no others!" But that was in the late 19th century and William was playing a specific set of tunes for a specific morris side who wanted the music to be just so.

But in general, I think we have a healthy, relaxed attitude to our tunes and our tradition. Just my observation from the middle of England...  ;)
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Matt (Kings Norton) on September 27, 2014, 11:29:23 AM
I'm not involved in English music but looking in from the outside there seem to be some strong feelings about the right way to do it.  (E.g. Pushing and pulling is A Good Thing, fast music is not musical.).  Which seems OK to me, it's a tradition after all.  Sometimes this might even spill over into a view on the right way for other people to play their music.  By the same token I think it's fine for other traditions to take a view on these things and argue about it, it's not as if everyone comes out sounding the same, far from it.  Anyway I'm committing thread drift, the question was about Irish technique and traditions and I think it's a pretty interesting subject.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: george garside on September 27, 2014, 11:54:44 AM
what Steve said!

george
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Stiamh on September 27, 2014, 01:33:13 PM
I have to admit I'm always slightly bemused by rules about how music 'must' be played to be acceptable.

(...) There are no fingering/bellows police who are going to jump on you and tell you that you are doing it wrong and that it is counter to the tradition, etc.

(...) I think we have a healthy, relaxed attitude to our tunes and our tradition. Just my observation from the middle of England...  ;)

I'm slightly bemused, too, by the above, because in this discussion I see nobody talking about rules or how music should be played - far less about a "fingering/bellows police" (!). Just a question about a certain style, or rather what a certain label that people use might mean.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 27, 2014, 03:15:48 PM
Perhaps you are right, Steve and Aradru; maybe I am being a bit oversensitive or have misinterpreted things, in which case I apologise. However, the very thread title itself seems to suggest there are Irish styles of playing which don't apply elsewhere. Then a few posts ago there was the hinting at the politics of the Irish style(s). I have also encountered Noel Hill's concertina fingering methodology for Irish traditional music where he insists that his students adopt only his style and woe betide you if you don't.

I still maintain that certain traditions can be rather proscriptive when it comes to style: for example, how rolls should be played in order to be authentic. It's not just Irish music; the Scottish 'pibroch' bagpiping competitions insist on particular notes and gracing, otherwise you are doomed to ignominious failure. To a lesser extent this happens in the Northumbrian tradition too, as I have personally encountered in years gone by, although I get the feeling that things are more relaxed these days.

But the emphasis of my post was more about the relaxed approach we seem to have for English traditional music and how pretty much all styles of playing are OK. If you want to play with different notes, twiddles and grace notes, that's fine, if you don't that's fine too. I like that. We don't get our knickers in a twist.  (:)
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: richard.fleming on September 27, 2014, 03:49:57 PM
I used the title 'Irish press and draw style' because you only hear 'press and draw' used as a description of a style of playing in the context of Irish music.

I'm reminded of an old debate about grammar - should grammar prescribe what it is correct to say or describe what native speakers actually say. The same must apply to a musical tradition - you can prescribe or you can describe. Either way the native speaker of Irish music knows that both Jacky Daly and Joe Burke are both completely authentic, even if they typify different attitudes to the tradition.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: mory on September 27, 2014, 04:28:57 PM
I think this may best describe the attempts to DRAW this discussion away from it's topic so let's just PRESS on.
http://dubsism.files.wordpress.com/2012/02/laughing-hysterically.gif
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 27, 2014, 05:11:37 PM
I would have to take issue with you here. Noel is a personal friend of mine and also happens to be my son's tutor.
He is an excellent teacher and of course he is recognized internationally as being one of the foremost concertina players.
He is a perfectionist and I wouldn't want it any other way as far as my son is concerned.
The Noel Hill you describe above is not the Noel that I know.
Oh dear, I'm in hot water again! I apologise if I have caused offense.  :-[
My experience was via someone whom I was trying to help understand the harmonic (aka 'English') style of playing and who had previously learned Noel Hill's method and had apparently been led to assume that any other method was 'wrong'. There is clearly a big difference between the Irish style of anglo playing and the harmonic style. Both are valid, of course, and to claim one is right and the other wrong is nonsense. But we are thread-drifting here, so perhaps it's best to say no more.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Gromit on September 27, 2014, 07:40:23 PM
I'd like to learn to play the Uilleann pipes but in a relaxed laid back English (free)style cos I can't be arsed with all those twiddly bits - any ideas would it sound any good?
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: boxcall on September 27, 2014, 10:51:25 PM
well I guess you would PRESS the bag to DRAW out some notes (:)
Just trying to keep this on topic and I,m not sure if the air sack is called a bag?
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Stiamh on September 28, 2014, 10:09:09 AM
Then a few posts ago there was the hinting at the politics of the Irish style(s).

To understand the hints you'd have to have read Graeme Smith's paper. It has a lot of good stuff in it but he sets up a dichotomy between the espousal of the B/C style by working-class Irishmen and criticism of it by people from another layer of the social spectrum (e.g. Ó Riada). An issue of no interest to the average box player, I think, and not a very solid peg to hang preconceived notions about attitudes in any particular musical community on, even if you had understood the reference. (:)
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: richard.fleming on September 28, 2014, 11:33:29 AM

I personally have always not been sure what I think of the B/C style as played, for example, by Joe Burke. He is obviously a giant in Irish music and a very fine player, but the amount and the predictability of the ornamentation, and the way many players who, (perhaps less so more recently),  reproduce it pretty well note for note, can seem too predictable or even a bit mechanical. Maybe the definition of an  Irish gentleman, to parody the old joke, is a button accordion player who knows how to stuff a tune with 5-note rolls but doesn't.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Pat. on September 28, 2014, 11:48:20 AM

I personally have always not been sure what I think of the B/C style as played, for example, by Joe Burke. He is obviously a giant in Irish music and a very fine player, but the amount and the predictability of the ornamentation, and the way many players who, (perhaps less so more recently),  reproduce it pretty well note for note, can seem too predictable or even a bit mechanical. Maybe the definition of an  Irish gentleman, to parody the old joke, is a button accordion player who knows how to stuff a tune with 5-note rolls but doesn't.
[/quote
     Well composed.]
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: OrchardAshley90 on September 28, 2014, 12:34:14 PM
This is an interesting thread, but to me, isn't all music played on a diatonic box a 'press and draw' and not just Irish? from say a one row all the way through to a BCC#, they are all diatonic and got to press and draw to get the correct notes.

Having said that i can tell the difference between them while being played. after spending the last 3-4 years learning ITM from all kinds of different players. i usually prefer the style of a B/C player than a C#/D. Joe Burke is a very 'clean' player although mechanical he is the best one to learn a tune from if playing by ear, as well as Jimmy Shand both very clean in their playing.
But i don't really care much for jackie dalys style, don't get me wrong another fantastic player just don't like the style. but Joe Derrane a D/C# player has a good style very different to Jackie Daly.

I think a lot of this is down to the style of the individual and not the system, Although i play an A/D/G i try and play in the more 'Clean' style.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: richard.fleming on September 28, 2014, 12:49:43 PM
It's just that the phrase 'press and draw' seems to have a particular meaning when used in the context of Irish traditional music, and it is this I'm trying to tease out.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: mory on September 28, 2014, 01:58:02 PM
I've always felt it referred to the ornamentation aspect i.e. the available notes and methods .  A melodeon style of playing transferred to a C#D is the way I'd understood it when referring to Jackie and also on a BnC if playing in C up and down the row or on the B row (Rose Murphy style) exploiting and exploring the limitations, and developing alternatives to the musical choices.
All the Best mory
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: boxer on September 28, 2014, 03:07:03 PM
There are as many B/C playing styles as there are B/C players.  Style is a means to an end.  Everyone's arms hands and fingers work a bit differently.  Physical imitation of another player's style doesn't guarantee that you'll sound much like him or her.

"press and draw" sounds like a non-box player's attempt to describe playing tunes up and down a single row.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Pat. on September 28, 2014, 03:54:52 PM
Press and draw IS up and down the one row  no political conotations and is a well known term among Irish old style box players,I know because I have known a lot of them for over the last  thirty years.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: KLR on September 28, 2014, 08:35:08 PM
In piping "tight" = staccato, "loose" = legato.  Box players are just adapting piping terminology, out of envy since buttons accordions can only be a pale imitation of the pipes.   ;)

I sometimes play with a B/C boxer, whose music is as choppy as all get out.  LMM Cardin he plays, even without the L going he's louder than hell, too.  Would that this system were some royal road to smooth playing, it just doesn't work that way.  You have to just keep working at it, if smooth is your ultimate goal anyway. 

You should keep in mind that the other musicians have no idea about these niggling little niceties, and in almost all cases aren't interested in them.  You could bring one of those 2 row Russian unisonoric mini bayans to a session and probably hear a chorus of "Hey, love the new box!"

Joe Burke is one of the greats, instantly recognizable, full of lift/heart.  Could listen to him all day, have never understood why he has any detractors, people are finicky, or jealous.  Would you rather he weren't around?
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: richard.fleming on September 30, 2014, 07:45:40 AM
There's still a lot of dismissiveness about, I think, Aradru. I was talking to a brilliant young Connemara B/C player not so long ago about getting a Csharp/D box and the reply was  'You might as well get a melodeon'.
I'm glad to get your reply. Pretty well sorts it out. All we need now is Triskel's take on it and we're done. I think.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Stiamh on September 30, 2014, 01:50:08 PM
The more I think about it, the more it seems obvious that the term "press and draw" could only have been coined (doubtless with the disparaging intent that aradru highlights) after the B/C became popular. Prior to that it was all press-and-draw (and still is, as Ashley said), so what would be the point of the term?

Regarding the political aspects, when I made my comments I hadn't realised that Graeme Smith had written another paper (the one Anahata linked to on Jstor). I was referring to the other one. I have now read the second one, which covers a lot of the same ground, but with less emphasis on the working-class / middle-class dichotomy. [Which I always thought was a bit artificial - you could hardly get more working-class than Joe Cooley (a builder, wasn't he?) and Jackie Daly (a pipe-fitter before he turned professional).] I also think that Graeme oversimplifies the resurgence of the new press-and-draw style. Anyone from outside the tradition reading the paper might assume that B/C has been sidelined by C#/D since the 1970s, which is hardly the case.

As a footnote, I'd say that the admiration of Joe Burke for Jackie Daly's playing is entirely reciprocated, from what I gather, and the two of them enjoy a long-standing tradition of mercilessly slagging each other off as a mark of their mutual affection.

Oh, and I have changed the spelling of my first name to avoid future confusion between Steves. An old joke I share with a friend's daughter called Niamh.  (:)
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Pat. on September 30, 2014, 06:03:43 PM
Well Aradru I, think your post summed it up pretty well
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Theo on October 01, 2014, 08:07:33 AM
I mention this because I always felt that whether you choose to play 'press and draw' or B/C, has less to do with ability and talent
and more to do with character type.

Very interesting!   I think there is a parallel between people who choose to play a push/pull box of any type and those who choose a piano accordion.  The former tend to be happy go lucky, jump in and give it a go types, wheras the piano accordionist is much more likely to be a planner and a follower of a more formal learning path.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on October 01, 2014, 08:29:42 AM
I think you've hit the nail on the head there Theo.
 That certainly sums me up. ;D
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: malcolmbebb on October 01, 2014, 08:55:20 AM
I mention this because I always felt that whether you choose to play 'press and draw' or B/C, has less to do with ability and talent
and more to do with character type.

Very interesting!   I think there is a parallel between people who choose to play a push/pull box of any type and those who choose a piano accordion.  The former tend to be happy go lucky, jump in and give it a go types, wheras the piano accordionist is much more likely to be a planner and a follower of a more formal learning path.

Interesting - I was having a conversation and similar thoughts of players of Anglo vs English concertinas quite recently.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Anahata on October 01, 2014, 09:39:47 AM
Also PA player = music reader, melodeon = play by ear.

Not always, obviously, but that's the tendency.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: george garside on October 01, 2014, 09:54:15 AM
and piano ( & continental) players ''improvise'' when they are feeling a bit naughty,  whereas  push/pull people  just play it 'on the hoof' the way they want it to sound!

george ;)
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: gettabettabox on October 01, 2014, 11:07:30 AM
Here is another angle.. not entirely unrelated to the OP I hope.
It's been a long-held belief of mine that a 'press and draw' player will have some distinct character traits.
As opposed to a B/C player that is.
I believe that a person displaying those traits is almost predestined to play C#/D system (given of course that they play box of any description).
I think it's possible to predict a person's character without having met them, just by knowing what system they play.
Your typical C#/D player will be contemplative, introvert, introspective, sensitive.
The music, or rather the individual piece or tune is at the centre of their focus and is more important than the peformance.
A B/C player is .. well, more outgoing? A more natural and comfortable performer?

I discussed this with Charlie Harris the other day (briefly, as we were too busy talking boxes. Charlie is a C#/D, D/D# player)
and I think he agreed with me. At least he didn't say that he disagreed!

I mention this because I always felt that whether you choose to play 'press and draw' or B/C, has less to do with ability and talent
and more to do with character type.




a great angle on things. 
meanwhile, those that have self-directed towards the ''push and draw'' style, probably did so in pursuit of that driving pulse? (the pulse that is difficult to define, yet you know it when you hear it.... and lucky you.. if you're able to generate it.)


how about the irish/American lads and their D/C+ boxes?...
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: richard.fleming on October 01, 2014, 11:53:56 AM
Aradru quote: 'I started playing B/C and I never had a difficulty with it. I still play that system fairly regularly.'

I started B/C because I bought a Double Ray in a Dublin pawn shop. I moved to Csharp/D because I thought it might help me to play a crisper more staccato style. I don't think either is more suited to my personality, though I agree that PA players may well be different from us.  I'm full of admiration for people like Aradru who can play both B/C and Csharp/D. I've switched back and forth a bit, and it seems to be either/or for me, though I'd like to play both, and have one of each here. ..
Any tips, please, on how someone who plays by ear can play both?
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: george garside on October 01, 2014, 12:20:34 PM
?play the same tunes on both  using same fingering.  G on bc = A on c#D , D = E , F = G etc.   

 learn scales on the BC  to the point where the fingering is automatic (cgdae)  I is then easy to play same  tunes in same key on either box      using  the appropriate scale.  This applies whether dot reading or playing by ear

george
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Stiamh on October 01, 2014, 12:54:29 PM
Part of the C#/D personality profile, is there is such a thing, must be a willingness to swim against the tide, the still near-total dominance of the B/C system in Irish music. Taking up C#/D you need to accept that teachers, courses and tutor books/DVDs are more difficult to find, and be prepared to plough a lonelier furrow and teach yourself. D/C# even more so, I think, unless you are under the wing of an established player.

Should press-and-draw ever become dominant again, perhaps those with a maverick turn of mind will be drawn (haha) to the B 'n' C?

I have to say though that aradru's idea of character traits is a new one for me. When the yen for a box took me I borrowed a B/C and tried out both B/C and C#/D fingerings. I thought I made my choice based on logic and on how mapping the tunes out on the D row corresponded more closely with my mental map of the tunes based on decades of playing other instruments, where the D string of the fiddle or the bell note of the whistle act as natural reference points. Now I have to allow that the choice might have been dictated by being an awkward so-and-so.  :D

Maybe being one of the many who never really liked the accordion in Irish music until they heard Jackie D might have had something to do with it too!
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: waltzman on October 01, 2014, 01:29:26 PM
Another interesting thing about these two tunings is that they are not really different 'systems' at all.  The differences in technique are entirely key dependent.  That is to say that if you play a C#/D in the key of E you could use precisely the same fingering and technique as playing in D on the B/C. Is that not the case?
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: george garside on October 01, 2014, 01:37:48 PM
indeed
g
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Stiamh on October 01, 2014, 02:50:58 PM
That is to say that if you play a C#/D in the key of E you could use precisely the same fingering and technique as playing in D on the B/C. Is that not the case?

It is indeed. To appreciate the difference I think you need to try learning a few tunes in D on the B/C  (:)
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: TomB-R on October 01, 2014, 04:32:25 PM
Have the best of both worlds in one tuning - D/D#  ;D

[edit] No, on second thoughts, don't. It's an awful system you wouldn't like it at all. Don't go looking for D/D# boxes on Ebay.  >:E
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: boxcall on October 01, 2014, 05:07:11 PM




how about the irish/American lads and their D/C+ boxes?...
I would think we have similar traits to the C/D# players, but we are on the outside looking in. (pun intended)
And when there's a fork in the road we don't take it, we bushwhack.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Pat. on October 01, 2014, 08:36:05 PM
Well I play B/C for the keys available ,and the ornaments you can express yourself with,but I also like the Push and draw style because of the rhythm/pulse ,so that is why I have a B/C and a D/G. I cannot find the perfect box  so this is the next best thing,what this all means as regard to my personality is anyones guess.  ;D
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: mory on October 01, 2014, 09:21:03 PM
Not sure Brendan would be cool you using his image without permission  ;) AtB mory
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: KLR on October 02, 2014, 06:18:01 PM
There are 3 excellent box players where I live, all Irish fellows, 1 C#/D and 2 B/C; one of the latter has the closest thing to a career with tours CDs etc so I guess he's the most "outgoing," but personality-wise he's much more reserved than the other two, really.  His playing is a lot more mo-dern as well. 

The C#/D player is more than a bit intimidating musically, and before he gave up drink he used to be a bit of a terror to be around on a bad night too, I always thought he scared people off the button accordion by dint of personality - he also used to be the publican in the only venues in town with a session going in the first place.  So these roles seem to be reversed around where I live, to an extent anyway.  But really there aren't too many box players period.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: sticky fingers on October 02, 2014, 08:25:38 PM
Has nobody mentioned the D/G system in the Irish press and draw style? sf
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: rees on October 02, 2014, 08:54:16 PM
Has nobody mentioned the D/G system in the Irish press and draw style? sf

a la Dave Mallinson and Jeff Bainbridge.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: gettabettabox on October 03, 2014, 01:58:02 AM
The push and draw is to my understanding is one row  original style  and is not complicated with over ornamentation due to the limitations of the notes available ,but in skilled hands it has great rhythm and honesty about it.

this is my understanding as well.
the two row boxes (employing a D row in today's musical key sensitivities,) can mimic it, but also easily dilute it by playing across the rows and incorporating the extra basses.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: richard.fleming on October 03, 2014, 09:43:55 AM
What Gettabettabox says above raises a question.
I can't play many of the tunes, even those in the key of D, on my Csharp/D, without playing across the rows to find notes on the Csharp row that are really important to the tune. If I were NOT to do this, as Gettabettabox seems to suggest, in order to replicate the press and draw style, I might as well play a D/G box.
I know one or two people who try to play Irish on the D/G box, I personally don't like the effect  much.
I prefer to describe the Csharp/D as being an instrument that is technically just as good as the B/C, that produces  music that is as good as that produced on the B/C and that gives the Irish button accordion tradition an interestingly wider range of sounds and styles. I can't see how trying to play on the D row is doing anything except limiting the instrument's and the player's potential.
If you want to do that, why not get a melodeon?
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: mory on October 03, 2014, 09:50:08 AM
That's what I was referring to here Richard
I've always felt it referred to the ornamentation aspect i.e. the available notes and methods .  A melodeon style of playing transferred to a C#D is the way I'd understood it when referring to Jackie and also on a BnC if playing in C up and down the row or on the B row (Rose Murphy style) exploiting and exploring the limitations, and developing alternatives to the musical choices.
All the Best mory

Have a listen to Johnny Connolly, John O'Halloran, Cuz Tehan and many others if you've not done so already. AtB mory
Notice you've altered your post but Johnny is a master at playing tunes with the missing notes replaced in numerous different ways.

Just reading through your earlier posts Richard. I guess it's always about choices, I know I've certainly been drawn here there and every where over the years. Picked up a BC (Paddy Clancy) again a while back simply because it was such a beautiful sounding and playing box but it's probably going to go again as it doesn't fill that place I've settled in C#D, DD#, DC#, D, C and Concertina (home is where the heart is I guess) AtB mory
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: smiley on October 04, 2014, 12:02:44 AM
Has nobody mentioned the D/G system in the Irish press and draw style? sf

a la Dave Mallinson and Jeff Bainbridge.

Simon Melia played Irish tunes on the D/G but somehow it sounded 'smoother' that most 'press and draw' style box players that I've heard.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sj4Yb8RvebQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=30iVm5U0gvg
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: gettabettabox on October 04, 2014, 12:41:32 AM
methinks ''stiamh'' on here knew this guy, so perhaps will elaborate upon his style?
but i recall, that this was a two voice pokerwork? and possibly swept along by the good company he was in?
sounds pretty punchy to me. I recall from stiamh's  post that he lifted tunes up from d to g, suggesting more of a 'row playing' style? (but not necessarily so.)
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Stiamh on October 04, 2014, 01:48:44 AM
Ian (Smiley) has put his finger on an aspect that I almost posted about - that although the D/G can be played up and down either row, the reversals, if used to the full, ought (theoretically at least) to allow a smoother style with less pressing and drawing than even the B&C.

At the time I knew Simon I cared little for the technical aspects of boxes and the differences between systems. To me he was just a very exciting musician to play fiddle with. Someone who knows more about his approach, and I believe they worked on adapting D/G to Irish music together, is Geoff L (pushpullefty) but he hasn't looked in here for the past three years. The thing that amazes me at this distance, listening to Simon's playing now with some experience of playing box, is the extent and inventiveness of his variations. All this from a self-taught lad with no musical background who'd been at the box for only about 5 years when we first played together.

He did jack some tunes up a fourth, but not that many. Apart from Maid behind the Bar the only tune I can state with certainty that he did this on was Musical Priest, which sounded absolutely electric at a fast clip in high E minor instead of the usual B.

Edit: correction - he also jacked up Ask My Father from D to G. https://soundcloud.com/jonesbach/ask-my-father-green-grow-the
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Pat. on October 04, 2014, 06:52:21 AM
When a lot of people play  ITM on a D/G box it often sounds not very Irish,.I think if you play B/C or C#/D THEN play D/G it can work well ,the I think the trick is not to play it like a D/G style  treat it as a one row with extra base options but use the base purely for rhythm  not for clever effects.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: TomB-R on October 04, 2014, 09:31:14 AM
If you're either in an Irish music community, family etc, or just decide you want to play the music on box what does everyone tell you to do? Get a B/C or C#/D. 

If you're in a different musical environment, there's a very good chance the advice will be in favour of a quint box, D/G in England etc.  Once you're a bit fluent on that, and go to mixed sessions, you may decide you "want to play a bit of Irish." So you play the notes on your D/G and you can keep up in your local session, but do you seriously rebuild your playing style?

Irish music enthusiasts are fond of saying it takes a couple of years of obsessive dedication to start playing the music properly.

There are hundreds of fiddlers out there, many with some classical background, who can knock out an Irish tune in a session, but they don't actually play the style.

Same with flute. If you want to play Irish flute, you get a simple system flute. There are loads of silver Boehm flute players (classical background) happily playing along in sessions. Joanie Madden is the one proof that the music can be played to a high level on Boehm flute.

It's not the instrument, it's the player, but the whole cultural environment, and the work involved, means that when people get serious, they want the version of the instrument that's within the tradition.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: OrchardAshley90 on October 04, 2014, 12:10:07 PM
http://youtu.be/f4_2mugHPW0

there is a video of me playing some ITM although it is an A/D/G I'm not using the a row at all. any good?
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: KLR on October 04, 2014, 02:56:55 PM
 
.....
The C#/D player is more than a bit intimidating musically, and before he gave up drink he used to be a bit of a terror to be around on a bad night too, I always thought he scared people off the button accordion by dint of personality -....

I am having difficulty getting my head around this.
I can see how others might not want to be in his company, but people being scared off the accordion by his personality??
How does that work?

Well, there seems to be this unspoken rule that more than one box/banjo/pipes is a bit much, for one thing.  Also this fellow is very good and it would be more than a bit daunting to try and keep up with him, is all I'm saying.  Here's some video:  Irish Trad - YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4xc_6_OiJcI) 

Also there's been more than a fair bit of trad music played around where I live in the last 30 years and there are innumerable students of Kevin Burke, who lives here, yet only a few box players have shown up.  Two of them are fiddlers with hand injuries!  Another switched to the PA.  There are more pipers!  It's always been a puzzle to me. 
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: KLR on October 04, 2014, 03:02:02 PM
Tim Edey made a whole DVD on playing Irish music on the D/G.  It's the real thing, to say the least.  There are a few vids of him playing that system on YT.  I've always been a bit puzzled by the insistence on semitone boxes being the one and only way to go, does ITM really live or die on our ability to easily produce a Bb?   ;D  That would be news to flute players and pipers.  If you went back in time and gave Michael Grogan or Paddy O'Brien a quint box to play this conversation would be lopsided.

Really like your playing too, Ashley!
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: JohnS on October 04, 2014, 06:05:01 PM
G dorian does pop up as key for Irish music, particularly in the Clare repertoire, so a Bb is certainly handy.  However I would say that the main benefits of semitone boxes would be the nice tight intervals across the rows for your cuts and rolls and the ability to do finger slides from the inside row to the outside, frequently used for triplets.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Stiamh on October 05, 2014, 03:13:52 AM
I've always been a bit puzzled by the insistence on semitone boxes being the one and only way to go...

I think TomB-R answered that point pretty conclusively above Kevin. If you have any feeling for Irish music then with application you'll be able to make it sound good on any old kind of accordion. But there are plenty of good reasons for choosing a semitone box. I myself considered D/G before choosing C#/D but having played whistle for years I didn't want to be limited to the repertoire you can play on a D whistle. The important thing is surely, whatever system you have, get stuck into it and get the most out of it that you possibly can. You'll never make a fiddle out of it whatever you do.

Ashley, your playing is obviously solid, accomplished and rich. Personally I'd like to hear the tune cut free from the bass accompaniment, which apart from forcing the melody into a bit of a strait-jacket seems disproportionately loud, what do you think?  :|glug
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Vector on October 05, 2014, 07:56:55 PM
Really nice playing Ashely!

http://youtu.be/f4_2mugHPW0

there is a video of me playing some ITM although it is an A/D/G I'm not using the a row at all. any good?
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: TomB-R on October 05, 2014, 11:11:26 PM
One may play Irish tunes to their heart's content on D/G or any other quint tuned box, but we are talking about
'Irish press and draw style' on this thread.
You can't get away from the fact that Irish style press and draw can only be produced properly on a semitone box.
On a quint tuned box.. you may well call it press and draw, but 'Irish style' it is not.
I think you are "begging the question" in the classic sense of the term, justifying your own argument with an assertion contained in your argument.
"Irish press and draw can only be played on a semitone box because Irish press and draw can only be played on a semitone box."
Evidence, proof!

Do you agree with others that P&D relates more to C#/D "melodeon style" playing, or do you think it refers to B/C, or do you think it applies to any semitone box, in which case, on your argument, the term becomes meaningless.

(You'll notice that I'm not actually disagreeing with what you say!   ;))
Tom
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: gettabettabox on October 06, 2014, 01:22:07 AM
I tried a Google search, and there seems to have been some detailed research in to this.
Three-line summary:
In the early 20th century Irish players had single row melodeons which forced a particular style of playing and ornamentation.
In the 1950s the different style of playing evolved based on two row semitone boxes that were then widely available.
Then it seems Jackie Daly led a movement back to an elaborated version of the old style, still using two row boxes.

See http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/41699846?uid=3738032&uid=2&uid=4&sid=21104228556611
and
http://buttonbox.ru/books/graeme_smith.pdf

anahata's earlier posting reflects my take on this subject. (Jackie daly yes, performing profile/ exposure etc.. but johnny O'Leary and others i'm sure, ahead of him)
....single row origins, easing on to the ''chromatic'' boxes as they were called, but mostly played with a dominant row style.

Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: richard.fleming on October 06, 2014, 07:51:31 AM
:-
"A 'press and draw' player playing a B/C box in a session would not have endeared him/herself to fiddle and flute players
and I have no doubt that this scenario would have fed into the widespread view of the 'press and draw' system being inferior."

End of quote.

Do you mean by this someone playing a B/C box like a melodeon and hence in C?

When I first got among Irish musicians back in the '60s many of the box players were musically very illiterate, and had simply worked out by ear how to use whatever box they had - usually B/C- to play tunes in the right key, armed with the knowledge that you had to play 'across the rows' to do that, or as one said to me, to 'mix a few of the notes from the other row in'.

 I also sometimes wonder, from my own musically illiterate standpoint, if even the great Joe Cooley when given a box in different keys would simply play with the usual fingering and let string players tune to the result.

I'm rubbish at quoting from other posts too - another illiteracy!

Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: KLR on October 12, 2014, 06:12:29 PM
Quint box demonstration:  Tim Edey Performing on the C/F Sandpiper melodeon/Accordion - YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=74ityQYFObg)  Sounds like Irish music to me.

Same with flute. If you want to play Irish flute, you get a simple system flute. There are loads of silver Boehm flute players (classical background) happily playing along in sessions. Joanie Madden is the one proof that the music can be played to a high level on Boehm flute.

Not a Noel Rice or Seán Moloney fan, eh?  They do great work on the Boehm as well.  Seán is on YouTube I think.  You also had Paddy Carty, who could play any tune - I have a cut of him playing the Beeswing in its original key of Bb, for instance - on a Radcliffe system flute, which was a competing system to the Boehm in the 19th century that catered to flautists who wanted a chromatic instrument that retained some of the fingering of the old simple system flutes. 
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: KLR on October 12, 2014, 09:50:07 PM
Don't you think it's bona fide Irish music and great playing, though?  Whatever the exact notes are.

Sorry to inadvertently drag us off topic, I do love to chat about this stuff with you, "Steiavbh" or whatever he's calling himself this week  ;), and the handful of other people on this board who listen to or play Irish music. 
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: nfldbox on October 13, 2014, 02:27:47 AM
Oh bother. Do I really want to get into this? But while Tim Edey is an amazing player, and the tune is certainly Irish, the CF box works against either the CD or the BC mode of playing. There are all kinds of transitions missing there.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Earbrass on October 13, 2014, 09:41:23 PM
Careful now. These kinds of debates can so easily turn nasty:

http://www.irishexaminer.com/ireland/polish-man-was-hit-with-fish-in-row-over-music-290247.html
  :o
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: MartinW on October 13, 2014, 11:31:26 PM
Sounds fishy to me.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: gettabettabox on October 13, 2014, 11:50:14 PM
yes, definitely something fishy...hard to believe a 'full' bottle of wine was involved?
and just in case you think it was the bottle that did the damage, the current specimen rod-caught Pollack for irish waters is over 19lbs, which I think is about shand morino weight.   (:)
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: KLR on April 22, 2015, 05:20:42 AM
BUMP

From an old edition of Treoir, the journal of CCE, the pdf file itself may be found at the Comhaltas Archive  (http://comhaltasarchive.ie/search)website, its name is TRE-1969-7.original.  The anonymous author describes the two styles of accordions at the beginning of the article, and has various further comments on what adjudicators at competitions should look out for in contestants' playing - proper ornamentation, rhythm, etc. 

Quote
An Bosca Cheoil

(As "NOTAI 00 MHOLTOIRI)

There are many styles of producing traditional Irish music on this instrument but in the main two direct styles, let us say "X" and "Y”.

“X” STYLE

The older style, in which good rhythm Is most prominent. Usually this style is achieved without much access to the second row. In one key, let us say "D," the style is on the press, in another key, let us say "G," the style Is on the draw, still with little access to the second row. This style may be frowned upon by the more modern accordeon player, but often it is the more accurate of the two styles in reproducing traditional music as the ornamentation is not too chromatic (i.e. bringing in too many notes foreign to both the tune and the key), and is very often clearer music. This style ought to be encouraged more as a very good musician could produce music closer to that of pipes, flute or violin. (Accordeon usually used D/D4).

“Y" STYLE

(Accordeon usually used B/C)

This is a style in which access to the second row is most prominent in both keys "D" and “G." It is usually termed as “playing on the draw" which really does not accurately describe the style. It is usually easy to detect this style, played on the inside row using one to two notes on the outside rows to complete the scale and many others outside as ornamentation. This style can also be an accurate imitation of traditional Irish music but to-day musicians tend to over-use the outside row for ornamentation, hence producing grace notes, triplets, etc., quite foreign to the music, also contributing to muffling of the melody and losses of time, etc.

The original article included the cryptic line "(Accordeon usually used D/D4)."  This was a scan of a paper document using optical character recognition software and the original undoubtedly said "D/D#."  Mistakes like these occur all the time using this type of program. 
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: Stiamh on April 22, 2015, 01:42:12 PM
The anonymous author...

Anonymity for the purposes of self-protection, perhaps...

I wonder to what extent the accordion "usually used" was D/D#. Cooley, yes, John Clifford in his pre-PA days, yes... Jackie Daly says that C/C# was in common use (played C#/D style) before C#/D boxes became available.

Coincidentally last night I watched the Sé Mo Laoch re-run of a programme on Johnny Leary (http://"http://www.tg4.tv/play.php?pid=4181222896001&title=S%C3%A9%20Mo%20Laoch&series=S%C3%A9%20Mo%20Laoch"), in which (starting at about 10:40) Johnny L says that, when he was 13 or 14, Padraig O'Keeffe told him that he was "learning the wrong scale" on a B/C box and that he should get "an E/D well that's a C#/D, he said". (If anyone can interpret Johnny's words more accurately, please correct me here.) Since Johnny was born in 1923, this would have been in the mid-1930s!

Very interesting programme with lots of well-known Sliabh Luachra players featured or in the background.
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: KLR on April 22, 2015, 05:08:33 PM
O'Keefe could figure out what was going on easy enough, he played the melodeon himself I believe.  So if Johnny was playing on the inner row and the music was coming out in C you need a box with a D row, and thus the outer row would be in C#.  Musicians have always loved higher pitched instruments like D/D# boxes too, you have all those high pitch flutes and uilleann pipes, and fiddlers in Donegal tuning up too; although you also have plenty of examples of fiddlers who favored tuning down a titch - including John Doherty.

Looking at the scans of old catalogs Stephen posted here you see C/C# all over the place, it was the original layout proposed for a chromatic melodeon by concertina maker George Jones after all.  The accordion companies were far removed from the players too and took decades to actually respond to their demands, probably only via noticing what was selling and just marketing more of the same, thus your Double Rays with basses in B and C...
Title: Re: Irish press and draw style
Post by: rees on April 22, 2015, 08:25:02 PM
C/C# was also the most common keys in England and Scotland until the D/G and the B/C boxes came in.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal