Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: PowersForGood on October 06, 2014, 04:58:50 AM

Title: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: PowersForGood on October 06, 2014, 04:58:50 AM
Hi folks,

I've recently acquired a beautiful B/C Castagnari Dinn III, after some time playing a punchy Saltarelle Irish Bouebe. My question is about the straps. If I wear both the straps on the Castagnari, loosened all the way, the box sits several inches above my lap, which means that the weight is on my back and shoulders. If I use just one strap over the right shoulder then the box will sit on my left leg, but not as far over as I'd like and I need to slump a little bit to put the full weight on my leg. With the Saltarelle I don't have either of these issues. Are the straps that came with the Castagnari too short? Do most of you play with the box on your leg or do you play with it raised up onto the stomach/chest?

Thanks,
Chris
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 06, 2014, 07:59:56 AM
Hi folks,

I've recently acquired a beautiful B/C Castagnari Dinn III, after some time playing a punchy Saltarelle Irish Bouebe. My question is about the straps. If I wear both the straps on the Castagnari, loosened all the way, the box sits several inches above my lap, which means that the weight is on my back and shoulders. If I use just one strap over the right shoulder then the box will sit on my left leg, but not as far over as I'd like and I need to slump a little bit to put the full weight on my leg. With the Saltarelle I don't have either of these issues. Are the straps that came with the Castagnari too short? Do most of you play with the box on your leg or do you play with it raised up onto the stomach/chest?

Thanks,
Chris

The number of straps and playing position is a very personal thing and has been discussed several times on this forum. As I've said elsewhere (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,15417.msg189483.html#msg189483):
 
...there are no rules, except that:

1. You should be comfortable when you play, with no undue strain anywhere.

2. The RH end of the instrument should remain as still as possible while you are playing. Any side-to-side waggling movement during bellows direction changes means that energy is being wasted in moving the instrument and not moving air through the reeds (which is what's needed).

The situation is slightly different depending on whether you sit or stand to play. When sitting, I use one or two straps, but importantly, I usually cross my legs and rest the end of the instrument on one thigh and tucked up against the inside of the other thigh. This effectively keeps the instrument end as stationary as possible, as in item 2 above. It's comfortable for me, so this also honours item 1.

My straps are long enough to allow me to do this, but I can see that someone longer in the body than me (I'm a short person at 5' 3") may have difficulties with standard straps as supplied by the maker. In your case, it seems as if the straps are too short for you, so look around for some longer straps ('Mally' straps (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/products_id/596) are longer than most), or else cobble together a strap extension of some sort from extra leather, an old belt, rope, baler twine, etc. I've even seen an old neck-tie pressed into use.

When playing standing up, the exact length of strap(s) is less critical, as the instrument is not going to rest on anything such as your thigh. You just need to ensure that your particular preferred combination of straps(s), thumb-strap (if fitted/used) and right hand position allows you to play comfortably and with minimal movement of the RH end of the instrument, satisfying items 1 and 2 once again.

Don't be afraid to experiment and find out what is right for you.
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 06, 2014, 08:27:09 AM
Further to my previous post...

There aren't many videos of me playing on Youtube, but here's one of them recorded a few years ago by Darren (Dazbo of this parish). As usual, I look very serious but it does show my cross-legged sitting position well.

Waltzing Over the Water (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LnNRC_Z2GJ4).
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Theo on October 06, 2014, 10:05:43 AM
Are the straps that came with the Castagnari too short? Do most of you play with the box on your leg or do you play with it raised up onto the stomach/chest?

The answers to those questions depend on you. If a strap feels too short for you then try lengthening it and see how you get on.  You can make a temporary additional length by using any handy bit of cord between the top strap bracket and the top end of the strap.  Once you have found a length that works for you then you can then you can make a neater and more long-lasting arrangement.  There are many different ways that players use to find a comfortable playing position and strap arrangement so just experiment until you feel comfortable.
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on October 06, 2014, 03:53:41 PM
I just bought a ready made str*p section, that I have used to successfully lengthen the str*p on my wee Voce D'Oro. It cost £5.95 plus postage, from CGM

http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Shoulder_Straps.html#29


John
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Stiamh on October 06, 2014, 04:23:58 PM
If you're playing Irish music on your B/C, and even if you're not, consider doing what the majority of people who play Irish music do: play seated, using a single long strap over the right shoulder (unless you are short or slight of build you will need something longer than what Italian makers supply as standard), with the treble cabinet of the instrument resting on your left thigh.

(Quite a few players rest the inside bottom edge of the treble cabinet outside the left thigh, and some inside the right thigh, but I'd think the majority allow the box to rest on top of the left thigh.)

You will need to develop an efficient bellows technique that will prevent waggling and keep the instrument stable on your leg without undue pressure on your right thumb (or whatever part of your hand is in contact with the edge of the treble keyboard). This is a very good idea even if you are using a different strap configuration.

Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Steve Fox on October 06, 2014, 05:02:06 PM
My problem is when I play for Morris, standing and wearing 2 straps.  I am constantly in fear of the strap over my left shoulder falling off, and often it does.  Has anyone else experienced and solved this problem?
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Lester on October 06, 2014, 05:05:52 PM
My problem is when I play for Morris, standing and wearing 2 straps.  I am constantly in fear of the strap over my left shoulder falling off, and often it does.  Has anyone else experienced and solved this problem?

Just throw the left hand strap in the bin, if it keeps falling off it ain't doing anything useful   >:E
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on October 06, 2014, 05:35:16 PM
Back strap?

John
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 06, 2014, 05:41:58 PM
Yes, a back strap is the answer. Both my morris musician friends use them.
One has a proper black leather strap that push buttons to fix. The other gets tied into her box by whoever's around by simply using a small piece if rope to hold the two main straps together.
Sometimes if seated, I feel my left hand strap is sliding off. I always use 2 straps and usually nestle the box into my right hand inner thigh, so a left had strap coming off is really only nuisance value as it's stable without.
Q.
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on October 06, 2014, 05:51:05 PM
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Back_Straps.html

Back straps


John

(I'll be asking Charlie for commission soon  :Ph )
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: steverh on October 06, 2014, 06:07:31 PM
Re Steve Fox's question, I experienced the same thing with the left strap slipping off while playing for Morris while standing. Following advice somewhere on this forum, I put on the two straps as normal, then just lift the left strap over my head so both straps come down on my right hand side at the front, having, of course, adjusted the length accordingly. It's easier than it sounds, and holds the box solidly on a slippery kit waistcoat. I've not tried back straps but I'll be looking into it as enough players here recommend them.
Steve
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: george garside on October 06, 2014, 06:31:53 PM
for some people there  seems to be a distinction  between comfortable straps    and  following tradition or  trying to be trendy!

Logic , at least my version thereof,  says that ''comfortable''  is required for best  musicianship. For what its worth I use two with exactly the same adjustment standing or sitting  and usualy a back strap as well if playing for a ceilidh.

george
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Steve Fox on October 06, 2014, 09:41:22 PM
Thank you, everyone, for your suggestions.  I shall try a back strap.  I don't know whether they are trendy or not, George, but my prime concern is to be comfortable playing.
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Mcgrooger on October 06, 2014, 10:50:20 PM
My problem is when I play for Morris, standing and wearing 2 straps.  I am constantly in fear of the strap over my left shoulder falling off, and often it does.  Has anyone else experienced and solved this problem?

My patent (I wish!) solution if I need to play standing is to have a long left strap, put one over each shoulder as you are now, then lilft the left strap over the head so that both come over your right shoulder. It's much more stable than just using a single strap, imho.  As shown at the very beginning of this vid:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KoIQFhLlyjU
With regard to the original question, I've had to extend my Saltarelle straps with short climbing slings, whichever box I use 'em on.
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: martin p on October 06, 2014, 10:58:14 PM
A Back  strap is definitely the answer for stood up Morris playing, especially if you jig about as I do. However, one major drawback is that back strap tends to spoil the cut of one's waist coat!
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: gettabettabox on October 06, 2014, 11:13:05 PM
right strap, left strap, back strap, crotch strap, parachute.
best to be prepared.   (:)
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: gettabettabox on October 06, 2014, 11:21:37 PM
and to the original poster, (playing a small dinn 3 and i'm guessing for irish tunes,)  a single right shoulder strap, of a length suitable to yield a similar position as your bouebe. swap the strap for a try out?
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: PowersForGood on October 07, 2014, 01:30:56 AM
Thanks folks. Very helpful... mostly  ;)
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Steve C. on October 07, 2014, 01:41:34 PM
Powers, you have asked one of those "third rail" questions….sometimes fatal….
You might also look at your right hand technique/position, how consistently and firmly you keep your thumb placed….
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 12, 2014, 01:57:00 PM
My problem is when I play for Morris, standing and wearing 2 straps.  I am constantly in fear of the strap over my left shoulder falling off, and often it does.  Has anyone else experienced and solved this problem?
Ah! I recognise this. Started happening without warning middle of last year. Took me by surprise. I didn't actually do anything about it. Just learnt to carry on playing through it. It can be done quite easily with practice. Hardly ever happens now and not an issue when it does.

I didn't want to use a strap across the back as I sometimes get a problem with my left strap interfering with the circulation in my right arm, so I drop it to relieve pressure (my doctor doesn't think it's significant of any serious health problem). I normally prefer playing with two straps rather than one so I live with it.
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Theo on October 12, 2014, 07:15:35 PM
It helps to stand with a good posture, head erect, back straight, shoulders not forward.  It's good fir you in other ways too!
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Steve Fox on October 12, 2014, 07:50:35 PM
I have to confess that I hadn't thought of checking posture.  Thanks for pointing that out.
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on October 12, 2014, 08:00:05 PM
If I stand up straight, and throw my shoulders back. My arms may not be long enough to reach the buttons  :|glug


John
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: george garside on October 12, 2014, 08:44:41 PM
It helps to stand with a good posture, head erect, back straight, shoulders not forward.  It's good fir you in other ways too!

seconded!

g
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Sue on October 17, 2014, 05:39:01 PM
My problem is when I play for Morris, standing and wearing 2 straps.  I am constantly in fear of the strap over my left shoulder falling off, and often it does.  Has anyone else experienced and solved this problem?

My patent (I wish!) solution if I need to play standing is to have a long left strap, put one over each shoulder as you are now, then lilft the left strap over the head so that both come over your right shoulder. It's much more stable than just using a single strap, imho.  As shown at the very beginning of this vid:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KoIQFhLlyjU
With regard to the original question, I've had to extend my Saltarelle straps with short climbing slings, whichever box I use 'em on.

 We are all different and I'm only 5' 1" and have narrow shoulders.  I've never felt in control of the box with only one strap, when I use two the left one keeps falling off - I probably drop my shoulder when playing on the pull. A back strap didn't help as I like a little room to manoeuver the box, so I have ended up with two back straps, the top one almost round my neck.  In sessions I also play a concertina, at Morris I also dance so it was becoming quite a pain taking the melodeon on and off.
I bought an extension strap and tried playing with both straps over the right shoulder as you describe.  Brilliant!!!  Not only was it comfortable and easy but the melodeon felt so natural and easy to play.  So a BIG thank you as that has really helped.
Sue
Title: Re: Are my straps too short? Length and positioning...
Post by: Mcgrooger on October 17, 2014, 07:14:45 PM
Yay!!!  You're my second convert - I'm proper chuffed! :||: :||: :|||: (:) 8)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal