Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: ganderbox on April 07, 2009, 06:48:25 PM
-
I was just thinking about 3 row keyboard layouts, in particular GCFs. I had a look at the Hohner Corona example on this site, and it struck me that they are very short on accessible accidentals, just having one button at the bottom of each row (not very useful if you are playing up at the top). I also thought that, if you consider a GCF as a GC with an extra row, perhaps it would be better to have a slightly different bass layout,(especially another F bass on the middle row, instead of the D bass on the pull).
I wondered if Castagnari et al use that layout, or if anyone out there has a GCF with a different layout?
Pauline
-
Yep, the accidentals on a Corona aren't very practical, aren't they! On my ADG I replaced the accidental notes on the G row with low B/D, the same notes as on a 2-row G with low notes, which I find more useful! And you are right the basses could be improved. You can have treble and/or bass notes changed by a technician, many players do that to suit their preference or playing needs.
Check the other layouts in the 3-row section, you will see variations.
-
I don't have as much trouble with the accidental buttons since I started using my thumb for playing them.I would like a high C# push note to go with the push Amaj bass and a low Bb would be much appreciated.
There are several duplicate notes on the three row Hohners that could be retuned to reversals or extra accidentals.I'm trying not to use them so that if or when I ever get mine retuned I won't be missing those notes.I'm thinking of retuning the duplicate low 5th notes on the second button pushes of the F and C rows as well as the duplicate high A draw on the 10th button of the G row and the high D draw on the 11th button of the C row.
There are other duplicates on some of the middle buttons but that makes things complicated if you try playing in different keys.
Chris
-
Test
-
n
-
I guess this message board automatically rejects posts using a tilde over the letter n in Norteno.
This will be the fifth or sixth time I have tried to post this.....
"Of course Mexican Conjunto and Norteno (nor-tayn-yo) players often remove the bass reed blocks entirely."
That is the reason for my previous "test".
-
A G/C/F is a C/F with an added G row
-
A G/C/F is a C/F with an added G row
or a G/C with an added F row?
-
A G/C/F is a C/F with an added G row
A G/C/F is a C/F with an added G row
or a G/C with an added F row?
This is precisely what I was thinking...which way do you see it?
I've always thought of ADGs as being DGs with an added A row (so you could join in when the fiddles and PAs strike up a tune in A!), but now that I also play a GC with accidentals, I definitely see a GCF as a GC with an added F row.
Whichever way, there is obviously some compromise in the basses, especially for playing in minor keys. Although you can play tunes easily in Am and Dm, you can't have all the basses you might like without losing some you would need for other keys. That was why I was wondering if anyone had a different layout, perhaps based on a GC rather than a CF.
One advantage I would find with a GCF is that the basses for the GC rows would be higher up, and nearer the air button. I am struggling a bit on my new Loffet to reach the bottom basses and still keep control of the air button...the basses are further apart from each other than they are on my Dony, and the bottom buttons are a good half-inch lower, which makes a big difference with small hands!...and I'm actually wondering about modifying the air button.
Pauline
-
This is precisely what I was thinking...which way do you see it?
I don't! For me the third row gives so little advantage for quite a big weight penalty that I stick with a two row with a 4 button third row of accidentals. That lets me play quite happily in A. One day I'm going to add some extra basses to it!