Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Ted on April 08, 2009, 03:10:03 AM

Title: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: Ted on April 08, 2009, 03:10:03 AM
I've just put up some pictures of 'Ma' McNulty's little Baldoni on my web site:
www.tedmcgraw.com -> Button Accordion pages -> Baldoni. As time permits I hope to add much
more stuff to this section.
This box was built in 1929 or very close to it, by the Iorio Co. in NY city.
It wasn't until after WW2 that the Baldoni's were imported from Italy. I'm not that swift with
pictures and had trouble finding a workable format for this display, so I would appreciate your comments not only on the box, but also on the format - thanks!
I'd be VERY interested if anyone has compared the insides of one of these Baldoni's to a Superior.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on April 08, 2009, 03:23:15 AM
Ted,

I think Iorio only started to make them about 1935, don't forget I showed you where it says MADE IN ITALY on mine (from around 1932-4), though that had been covered up with a celluloid plate that fell off...

Congratulations on getting "Ma" McNulty's one, that's quite something!

Stephen
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: Ted on April 08, 2009, 02:40:54 PM
Hi Stephen. I've forgotten which of your boxes had that sticker but I'm certain it wasn't that cream colored Baldoni that was recently restored with the new bellows. That instrument, Ma McNulty's and Bill Sullivan's are of the same vintage. I know from Bill himself that his was purchased in 1929, a year after Peter Conlon's (they were contemporaries and used to play together). Also, according to Al Iorio, who is still very much alive, an employee of their co. named Augusto did all the engraving for the Baldoni's, Walters, and their own Iorio's. Al Iorio & Aldo Mencaccini (who is also still very much alive) both said Iorio made these boxes in NY thru the mid 30s' and stopped when parts started to dry up because of the war. All the reeds came from Italy and were controlled/imported by Aldo at that time. I've seen 2 other boxes with the 'Made in Italy' sticker and these were of the post war format. Why do you think your box with the sticker was from around 1932?
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 08, 2009, 02:54:42 PM
Hi Ted - just had a look at your website - I'm amazed at the recordings that you have - I'm a  great Jimmy Shand & Will Starr fan and I was drooling looking at your listings. FAB!

The pictures of 'Ma's Baldoni' were ok - but the first picture didn't display in my browser but that's probably my comp. Otherwise - pretty good format.
AL (:)
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on April 08, 2009, 04:07:42 PM
I've forgotten which of your boxes had that sticker but I'm certain it wasn't that cream colored Baldoni that was recently restored with the new bellows. That instrument, Ma McNulty's and Bill Sullivan's are of the same vintage.

Ted,

Ah but it is that cream one, which I'd say was made only a handful of years after the other two (hence my "c.1932" dating of it) and it isn't a sticker, the words are engraved into the celluloid, but had been concealed under a piece of that same material! I'll take a photo later, when I've more time.

Anyway "thru the mid 30s" would fit in with Iorio starting to make them around 1935, and Augusto (the engraver) didn't necessarily only do work for Iorio...
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: BruceHenderson on April 08, 2009, 04:30:53 PM
  I've just put up some pictures of 'Ma' McNulty's little Baldoni on my web site: (snip)

    Nice photos and nice accordeon, Ted.  Congratulations on owning it!
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: Ted on April 09, 2009, 04:20:23 AM
Stephen, I'll stick to my story that Al Iorio told me they made the boxes of that style at that time, 1920's thru the mid '30's. As for bits of extra celluloid, look at the ends of the McNulty box keyboard. Under the engraved cover plate there are 2 pieces of 'extra' cellluloid at each end used as a filler. It's the only time I've seen that but I think it leads to bits and pieces of material weren't wasted. I do agree that Augusto, and others, could have done work for others, for example the bellows could have been supplied to Iorio by a specialist craftsman in Brooklyn.
Iorio had 80 people making accordions, mostly piano boxes, in their pre-war NY factory. It was a big manufacturing operation. Baldoni & Walters were only small retail shops who also did some minor repair work. Let's keep banging this one around - perhaps we need some more input.
Ted
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on April 09, 2009, 04:23:39 AM
I'll take a photo later, when I've more time.


So here are some newly-taken photos of mine:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P1020945.jpg)

Unfortunately the grille and the original owner's name have been removed from it.

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P10209352.jpg)

The MADE IN ITALY stamp (when I looked at it, I realised it was stamped, not engraved, on this one) is in the bottom left corner:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P10209372.jpg)

You can see the outline of the celluloid strip that was hiding the stamp.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on April 09, 2009, 04:56:11 AM
Stephen, I'll stick to my story that Al Iorio told me they made the boxes of that style at that time, 1920's thru the mid '30's.

Ted,

Well certainly somebody wanted to hide the fact that mine was made in Italy...  :o

But my impression at the moment, based on various instruments here in Ireland, is that Iorio probably made them at the time they occupied the 9th floor of the Carl Fischer Musical Inst. Building, which was from 1935 to 1947.

Iorio Accordion Factory, 1939:
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/Iorio_insidefactory.jpg)

This one, from later in the '30s, is an Iorio:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/baldoni13row2.jpg)

Quote
Let's keep banging this one around - perhaps we need some more input.

Absolutely! There's plenty more to be learned about these wonderful boxes...  :||:
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: hibbs3 on April 09, 2009, 05:40:59 AM
My Black Baldoni, a brother perhaps to Stephen's 1 row, has green plastic strips on each end of the rear of the bass end, placed in the same spot as where "Made in Italy" is stamped on Stephen's 1 row, one on the upper part, one on the lower...I'll take some pictures and post...should I perhaps remove these plastic strips? Might they conceal something?
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on April 09, 2009, 12:15:50 PM
My Black Baldoni, a brother perhaps to Stephen's 1 row, has green plastic strips on each end of the rear of the bass end, placed in the same spot as where "Made in Italy" is stamped on Stephen's 1 row, one on the upper part, one on the lower ... should I perhaps remove these plastic strips? Might they conceal something?

Ryan,

I'd very strongly suspect that at least one of them (probably the lower one) conceals a similar MADE IN ITALY stamp, though maybe the other was only put there to "balance" it and make it look like a deliberate feature. We didn't deliberately remove the strip off mine; it simply fell off while Charlie was working on it - deliberate removal might prove difficult and even cause harm.  :(
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on April 09, 2009, 12:57:58 PM
The MADE IN ITALY stamp (when I looked at it, I realised it was stamped, not engraved, on this one) is in the bottom left corner:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P10209372.jpg)


But it is engraved on my red O'Byrne de Witt Baldoni Bros, that was made about 1950:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P10209712.jpg)

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P10209702.jpg)

Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 09, 2009, 01:49:44 PM
This is a really interesting thread - and I'm becoming fascinated by these beautiful boxes. Is there a potted history somewhere that I could go to  - as I'd love to know more about them. Given that I know nothing at all about these boxes perhaps someone could give me and perhaps others a bit more background info about them? Would be very much appreciated.
AL
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on April 09, 2009, 02:11:51 PM
Is there a potted history somewhere that I could go to ...

Al,

I'm afraid we're writing it as we speak, but the first Irish-American box was the Baldoni one (below) made for the influential melodeon player P. J. (Peter) Conlon in 1929.

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/BaldoniPJConlon.jpg)

They were made to be very loud so they could be heard in the Irish dancehalls of New York, Boston and Chicago, before the days of amplification, and sold mainly by Baldoni, Bartoli & Co. and Walters in New York , as well as Superior and Iorio, and (post-WWII) by O'Byrne de Witt in Boston and the Italian Accordion Manufacturing Company in Chicago (below).

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/ItalianAccordionMfgCo.jpg)

Edited to add scans from catalogues.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: Ted on April 09, 2009, 05:14:22 PM
Yes, gets more interesting every day. I'll ask Al Iorio if he can zero in on those date ranges. He was just barely a teenager in that decade. Stephen, do the inside mechanism of those early Baldoni's you say were made in Italy differ from those of the later 30's which were made in NY?
Regarding that red 1950 Baldoni, my guess would be it was made by Moreschi in Italy. Also I have a picture of Paul Groff's Walters that was made in Italy by Sonola, after 1950.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: hibbs3 on April 09, 2009, 06:00:40 PM
Paul Groff's "Sonola" Walters is a nice box indeed, and the grille is undoubtedly from Sonola. I've attached a picture of one of the strips on the rear of my Baldoni's bass end... see what you think  :-\
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on April 09, 2009, 06:18:31 PM
I've attached a picture of one of the strips on the rear of my Baldoni's bass end... see what you think  :-\

Hmmm, looks decidedly odd! It doesn't really make any sense like that, unless it's there to hide something...  ???
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: hibbs3 on April 09, 2009, 06:46:11 PM
Weird, isn't it! I vaguely remember seeing F.H pencilled on the interior, which I thought might have something to do with Walters, but I never went anywhere with it. The other side of the bass rear has another green strip in the same exact spot...these strips seem to be a strip or pressboard or cork, with a green shimmery plastic strip glued ontop of it... ???
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on April 14, 2009, 02:51:55 AM
Stephen, do the inside mechanism of those early Baldoni's you say were made in Italy differ from those of the later 30's which were made in NY?

Ted,

It's not me saying they were Made in Italy - but their Italian manufacturer! I'll get some pictures of the later ones - I don't have one myself, but I do know people who have them...

Quote
Regarding that red 1950 Baldoni, my guess would be it was made by Moreschi in Italy.

As you know, it can be very hard to say who the actual maker was (or is today, for that matter!), but my O'Byrne de Witt Baldoni Bros. does bear a strong resemblance to this Flli. (= Fratelli = Bros.) Baldoni, Castelfidardo piano accordion, especially the "buckteeth" couplers and the decoration with aluminium strips:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/FLLIBALDONIPIANOACCORDION2.jpg)
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on April 14, 2009, 03:07:26 AM
The MADE IN ITALY stamp (when I looked at it, I realised it was stamped, not engraved, on this one) is in the bottom left corner:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P10209372.jpg)

You can see the outline of the celluloid strip that was hiding the stamp.[/center]

And here's a picture of the back of that Baldoni, as I bought it (for $28!), showing the celluloid strip (top right) still in place:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/BALDONI10KEYBACK2.jpg)

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/BALDONI10KEYBACK4.jpg)

Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: hibbs3 on April 14, 2009, 04:14:07 AM
What a lucky find it was for you! It's good to see it in tip top condition once again... mine is in need of a good tuning...I'm also having another reedblock constructed to fit onto the other set of holes that are covered currently, making it it's true potential 8v >:E
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: BruceHenderson on April 14, 2009, 03:36:52 PM
The MADE IN ITALY stamp (when I looked at it, I realised it was stamped, not engraved, on this one) is in the bottom left corner:

You can see the outline of the celluloid strip that was hiding the stamp.

And here's a picture of it, as I bought it (for $28!), showing the celluloid strip (top right) still in place: 

   There were very stringent rules throughout the 20th century that required that internationally-traded items be marked with the country of origin (regulation of International trade was thought to be important for "keeping wealth in a country" and "keeping currency strong").  These rules changed in detail and stringency of application over the years but were particularly strongly enforced between the World Wars and the years after WWII.  I suppose that an instrument carcass meant for Italian assembly might have been marked "Made in Italy" during it's basic manufacture but if it was shipped to the US for final assembly, the maker may have wanted to cover this marking and may have been legally obliged to.  But I don't know enough about the fine details of partial and final international manufacture and their application during the times of these instruments to do more than broadly speculate.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on April 14, 2009, 03:46:17 PM
I suppose that an instrument carcass meant for Italian assembly might have been marked "Made in Italy" during it's basic manufacture but if it was shipped to the US for final assembly, the maker may have wanted to cover this marking and may have been legally obliged to.

Bruce,

Maybe, but bear in mind that such accordions were only built (in small quantities) for the Irish-American market, they weren't sold anywhere else in the world, plus that both Baldoni and Walters claimed to have made them themselves!
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: hibbs3 on April 14, 2009, 05:54:59 PM
So were the Superior accordions only the real brand to make their own boxes? Whilst Baldoni and Walters had Iorio or some maker in italy manufacturing theirs?
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on April 14, 2009, 06:01:22 PM
So were the Superior accordions only the real brand to make their own boxes? Whilst Baldoni and Walters had Iorio or some maker in italy manufacturing theirs?

I don't think either Baldoni or Walters ever made their own boxes, though maybe they sometimes customised them for people, much as Saltarelle do today. But Superior seem to have made their own, and certainly Iorio did, like the Tom Carmody one that my friend Danny owns.

Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: hibbs3 on April 14, 2009, 07:08:03 PM
Did your friend Danny find his Carmody in an attic somewhere? I remember Lars mentionning to me that someone he knew had taken to D/C# style (not exclusively) after finding one of these old boxes in someone's attic, and for some reason the name Danny seems to fit...? ???
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: Lars on April 14, 2009, 08:22:02 PM
Yes, I did mention that, though not completely. I saw some pictures of that box in Galway last summer, and was told that it was found by Dannys relatives in the US, coming into his posession that way. It may or may not be true - but again, nice box, and to see one clearly marked "Iorio" proves that they made diatonics under their own name, not just for Walters and Baldoni.

My 6v Baldoni, early-mid 40's I believe has "Serial #1318" on a small plate on the back - but that plate just covers the ingraved "Made In Italy", just like your red 2 row, Stephen. Not that I ever doubtet that is was completely italian, but it just underlines the fact that Baldoni did their best to disguise the fact that it was not a US made box - a serial number added plus the Irish and American flags also contributes to the whole Irish-American thing. Another note would be that the Italian-Americans and the Irish-Americans did not always get along very well - both suffering from prejudice ("Spaghettis" and "Micks"). The book "See you at the hall" by Susan Gedutis has a few good notes on the matter of different parts of town (Boston) being territorial to immigrants from certain countries, and a classic would also be the old Flanagan comedy - "What's the uproar about! This is no spaghetti place! If you can't sing an irish song, don't sing at all!" in response to the poor Tony singing "Il sole mio". An innocent, but clearly ridiculing, remark toward the Italian-Americans and their music.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: BruceHenderson on April 14, 2009, 08:57:49 PM
I suppose that an instrument carcass meant for Italian assembly might have been marked "Made in Italy" during it's basic manufacture but if it was shipped to the US for final assembly, the maker may have wanted to cover this marking and may have been legally obliged to.

Bruce, Maybe, but bear in mind that such accordions were only built (in small quantities) for the Irish-American market, they weren't sold anywhere else in the world, plus that both Baldoni and Walters claimed to have made them themselves!   

   Sorry to not be clear.  My guess here (and it was only a guess surrounded by much ignorance) was that the basic celluloid covered body may have been made in Italy (and marked as such) but shipped to the US for final decoration, processing, assembly and tuning. I'd call that box "American-made for an Irish-American market" but the basic instrument frame might have originally been marked "Made in Italy" and at least somewhat appropriately for the rules in effect at the time.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on April 16, 2009, 04:30:24 AM
Did your friend Danny find his Carmody in an attic somewhere? I remember Lars mentionning to me that someone he knew had taken to D/C# style (not exclusively) after finding one of these old boxes in someone's attic, and for some reason the name Danny seems to fit...? ???

Indeed "not exclusively" D/C#; he's a former All-Ireland Champion on the B/C box, who's more recently started to play some B/C/C# under the influence of Martin McMahon, and now D/C#.  :o

... to see one clearly marked "Iorio" proves that they made diatonics under their own name, not just for Walters and Baldoni.

And it's not the first Iorio that Charlie Harris has worked on, he's shown me another one.

For that matter, though these Baldoni/Walters/Iorio/Superior boxes were originally made exclusively for Irish-American players, many of them have since found there way "back home", often in the hands of their original "returned Yank" owners, or to family members. I remember being proudly shown one of Gene Kelly's accordions by a box-playing member of his family in Co. Kilkenny some 20 years ago, though sadly it was unplayable at that time, or meeting Jack Doyle (who'd retired back to his native Kerry) playing a Baldoni that he bought new.

(A "returned Yank" is an old expression for an Irish person who has lived for some time in the U.S., & returned to Ireland.)
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: hibbs3 on April 20, 2009, 09:56:28 PM
Were many of these boxes made with 17 buttons? I've only ever heard of one 1930s box with the full 19, but never seen one...I didn't think they made the full 2 row D/C#s until the 40s, but it seems they were around long before that
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: hibbs3 on April 20, 2009, 09:58:19 PM
and this has found it's way to the bay :

http://cgi.ebay.com/RARE-ANTIQUE-ACCORDION-JORIO-BROS-NY-ORNATE-PATRIOTIC_W0QQitemZ330322928061QQcmdZViewItemQQptZKeyboards_MIDI?hash=item330322928061&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14&_trkparms=72%3A1205%7C66%3A2%7C65%3A12%7C39%3A1%7C240%3A1318%7C301%3A1%7C293%3A1%7C294%3A50
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: Stiamh on June 18, 2009, 04:06:25 PM
Ted was in Montreal last night with the newly refurbished Ma McNulty machine. It was a blast (literally) to have a go on - thanks Ted! Mind you, sitting next to Ted, I think I would have suffered permanent hearing damage had he played much longer.

Tiny little thing, you'd never guess there were 2 low and 4 medium voices hidden inside. Another very neat feature - talking of there being nothing new under the sun - is the handy little switch behind the keyboard to cut the low voices in and out.

How did we get lumbered with unsightly couplers on the front and knobs on the top?
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: hibbs3 on June 18, 2009, 09:37:00 PM
Did Ted mention who did the work on the box?
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on June 23, 2009, 04:11:49 AM
Another very neat feature - talking of there being nothing new under the sun - is the handy little switch behind the keyboard to cut the low voices in and out.

How did we get lumbered with unsightly couplers on the front and knobs on the top?

Believe it or not, switches behind the keyboard go back at least to the 1850s, and they'd be typical on multi-voiced instruments from the 1920s & '30s, like the older Baldonis. Here's the one on mine, and the typical swivelling brass clamp for the thumb-loop too:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P1030518.jpg)

It also has this very neat "indicator" on top of it, to tell you if she's firin' on only (the middle) four;

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P10305172.jpg)

... or on all six (with bassoon & piccolo);

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P10305162.jpg)

... like you'd get on some top-of-the-range piano accordions from the same era.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: HallelujahAl on June 23, 2009, 04:15:18 AM
Quote
How did we get lumbered with unsightly couplers on the front and knobs on the top?
I have often wondered about that - when did couplers on the front first come in?
AL
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on June 23, 2009, 04:36:40 AM
Quote
How did we get lumbered with unsightly couplers on the front and knobs on the top?
I have often wondered about that - when did couplers on the front first come in?

AL,

I'm up very late, are you very early?  :o

Anyway, the first grille mounted couplers (or switches on some early designs) only started to appear in the mid/late 1930s. This picture of the great Guido Deiro is said to date from 1935, which would make these sticking-straight-out "buck-teeth" ones very early examples, if it's correct:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/GuidoDeiro1935.jpg)

You'd more-usually associate them with the first fully-streamlined models from a few years later, like this early-1940s' 9-coupler Paolo Soprani:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/PaoloSoprani1940s.jpg)

Whilst this early-1940s' Baldoni has a switch in the grille:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/baldonisquarebuttons2.jpg)
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: Stiamh on June 23, 2009, 01:03:17 PM
Did Ted mention who did the work on the box?
Yes, The Button Box. New bellows ordered from Italy plus a reed overhaul.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on July 03, 2009, 04:08:36 AM
Stephen, do the inside mechanism of those early Baldoni's you say were made in Italy differ from those of the later 30's which were made in NY?

It's not me saying they were Made in Italy - but their Italian manufacturer! I'll get some pictures of the later ones - I don't have one myself, but I do know people who have them...

Ted,

I was visited by Anders Trabjerg today, the owner of the black 1.3-row in the photo...

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/baldoni13row2.jpg)

... and he told me that yes it does have a different, and (in his opinion) inferior, mechanism with thin steel levers instead of the thick aluminium ones found in both my 10-key Baldoni, Bartoli & Co. and his "Simon McArdle" Walters.

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/walters1-row2.jpg)

He's promised to send me photos of the mechanism in the black one.

Regarding that red 1950 Baldoni, my guess would be it was made by Moreschi in Italy.

As you know, it can be very hard to say who the actual maker was (or is today, for that matter!), but my O'Byrne de Witt Baldoni Bros. does bear a strong resemblance to this Flli. (= Fratelli = Bros.) Baldoni, Castelfidardo piano accordion, especially the "buckteeth" couplers and the decoration with aluminium strips:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/FLLIBALDONIPIANOACCORDION2.jpg)


Also, quite coincidentally, I was researching something else tonight when I stumbled upon an excellent list of Italian accordion manufacturers 1850-2003 (http://www.vapaalehdykka.net/upload/italialaiset_harmonikanvalmistajat_1850-2003.pdf) in chronological order, which lists F.lli. Baldoni as having been in business from 1946-73, and also a Luigi Baldoni, 1912-41.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: hibbs3 on July 05, 2009, 01:03:17 AM
I would think Lars could get us some nice snaps while on vacation there ;)
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on July 05, 2009, 02:17:31 AM
I would think Lars could get us some nice snaps while on vacation there ;)

Well, he and Anders spent 5 1/2 hours with me on Thursday, looking at everything from Demian accordions to 1950s Paolo Soprani catalogues, but I don't think there were any snaps taken here...

Maybe in Galway though?  ???
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: Lars on July 05, 2009, 08:52:34 PM
I'm back in Denmark, not sure when I'll be back in Galway.

That Thursday gave me a melodeon overload - I just need a few months getting it all processed. No matter WHAT came up in talking about the old boxes, Stephen just pulled one (or 10) out of his collection for a little show-and-tell. VERY VERY informative, and some real historical gems in there. Along with a rather nice pair of Baldonis...
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: pgroff on September 20, 2009, 01:37:49 PM
Hi everyone,

In another thread titled "Baldoni"

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2147.0.html

Ted mentioned recent conversations the two of us have had. I was honored that he drove many miles, more than once, to meet me near the storage depot for leftover inventory from my old music shop so that we could look together at old instruments. It also gave me a chance to drive a piano to his tunes on the Ma McNulty Baldoni (and his lovely new Beltuna).

triskel suggested it would be best to add comments on the history of the *early* Baldoni Bartoli & Co instruments to this thread.

So.... here are two instruments, probably from the 1930s. Very similar in many ways (despite one being a 13 key 8 voice 4 bass, and the other a 10 key 6 voice 2 bass), especially in the engraving. Each of the accordions pictured here has the "added strip of celluloid" at the back, which in each case very clearly does cover a "Made in Italy" stamp or engraving - the thin celluloid cover strip has shrunk over the years so that the words beneath are visible.

The 13 key shown below has the more complex keyboard silhouette I mentioned in my earlier posting (as does a yellow pearl unmarked 10-key instrument with similar engraving, from the Rata collection, that was illustrated in an old issue of Concertina and Squeezebox*). The black 10 key instrument shown below has what I call the simpler keyboard silhouette. I know that the more complex keyboard silhouette may have been used at a later date by Walters, but I am suspecting that *in these B & B instruments with this particular design of lyre engraving* the more complex keyboard is an earlier feature than the simpler type.

It might seem counterintuitive that a "more advanced" 13 key 8 voice would be made before the 10 key 6 voice, but that's what I'm suggesting as a hypothesis in the case of these two boxes. In the evolutionary history of living organisms, there are also many cases of simplicity being "derived" (evolving at a later time in a lineage from an ancestor that was more complex)! We do know that very early B & B 10-keys such as those made for William Sullivan and Ma McNulty had a complex keyboard sillhouette (though a slightly different silhouette; those two instruments, like some others I have seen with flags engraved on the accordion case itself, seem to form a different construction series from the ones I illustrate here).

The 13 key shown here also has the American flag with only 4, not 6 stars. Again, I hypothesize (propose an idea to be tested against further evidence) that this 4 star flag is earlier than the 6 star flag.

Not that I attach huge significance to internal numbers, but both these instruments have penciled numbers in several places inside the instrument: "2" for the 13 key, "19" for the 10 key. If the 13 key is actually later, then maybe these are batch numbers and started over for the 13 key instruments. But I seem to remember seeing photos of an instrument that might have been made between these two, an 8 voice 10 key with the number "15."

Anyone here with good period catalogs, or with another similar instrument that might have a number inside, is welcome to correct me or add more information!

*Vol. 3, #1-2, p. 50. See also the faux-piano diatonic on p. 51 that is very similar to another Baldoni I own.

Paul Groff
Miami, Florida, USA
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: boxlad on April 01, 2010, 12:14:45 AM
Two nice pics I found while researching these old boxes. Johnny Bresnahan playing a nice looking Baldoni Bartoli with John Maloney on banjo and also a lovely shot of a dance hall trio from the early forties I would imagine

Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: pgroff on April 01, 2010, 01:45:49 AM
Hi Ray,

I love those photos, and posted the link to them on www.banjohangout.org where some guys keep trying to argue the use of 19 fret, high quality tenor banjos in Irish music is recent or unusual! Maloney seems to have a good 19 fret Paramount if I have that right. You can almost smell the cigar smoke (and maybe the beer) and feel the dance rhythm. It makes me think of some of the PJ Conlon recordings with piano and banjo and the accordion crashing like huge waves.

I think Johnny Bresnahan is playing John (Jack) Storer's box, and (though it's hard to see, so this is just a hypothesis) it looks to me that by the time these photos were taken a few extra buttons had been added as a partial inner row. There are earlier photos of Storer himself holding the accordion (if it is the same) when it had only 10 melody keys.

PG
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: boxlad on April 01, 2010, 09:21:07 AM
Hi Paul,
That's where I found them alright! And now they are on melodeon.net for all to enjoy. What great shots! The cigar is great and that classic mike also. Could there be more atmosphere in the photo?......it would be very tough!!
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: pgroff on July 08, 2010, 05:47:27 AM
Ray and all,

Speaking of Banjo and Baldoni (three posts back), and of the J. J. Dwyer Baldoni (four posts back), I just turned up some circumstantial evidence that *just possibly* J. J. Dwyer might have played tenor banjo himself.

Really, that might be a stretch.  But at the very least, there is a 1928 Gibson TB3 archtop tenor banjo that has "J. J. Dwyer" engraved on the armrest!

See my "request for help" thread on the banjo hangout for more detail:

http://www.banjohangout.org/topic/182204

This banjo has now been located and now I am hoping the 1/2" bit of celluloid missing from the accordion grille will be found in the banjo's case compartment   ;-)
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: boxlad on July 11, 2010, 08:11:39 AM
Paul,
Nice work. That's great that you located the banjo and so fast! What are the chances of two 'J.J. Dwyer's hanging out around the same time and playing traditional Irish music and both being able to afford fine instruments like these? Not likely I would have thought.
If all else fails you could try dusting for prints in some obscure parts under the frame and seeing if you get any matches on both instruments....OK that might be a little over the top!!
Good luck with it and keep us posted on any developments. I will be eagerly watching the banjo hangout responses.   
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: pgroff on July 11, 2010, 09:48:28 AM
Hi Ray,

Thanks for the encouragement, and here's an update since some of the recent banjo correspondence has been in private messages, not on the banjo hangout forum.

I do have a suspicion that the "Banjo J. J." and the "Box J. J." might be one and the same man, but Joe Spann (Gibson banjo historian and professional genealogist) cautions me that there were 151 John J. Dwyers recorded in the USA in the 1930 census!  Humbling.

Intuition can be misleading and is not the same as evidence, but sometimes intuition is vindicated. It's worth keeping in mind the possibility that the two instruments might have had the same owner, so we can be alert to more evidence if that surfaces. Interesting that the dates of the instruments are fairly close, that both are very high quality, both suitable for Irish traditional music (the Baldoni basically dedicated to that purpose, the Gibson could be used that way or to play other music that the Irish dance bands also played), both turned up in New York state many decades later.  Most of the earliest "Irish American" Baldoni-Bartolis, as custom decorated instruments projecting identity, were engraved with the original owner's name -- but this is much less common among tenor banjos from that time.  So we know at least that the "Banjo J. J." had in common with "Box J. J." a taste for a personalized instrument.

The current owner of the J. J. Dwyer banjo was kind enough to send me photos of the whole instrument (before and after its reversible conversion to a 5-string by bolting on a substitute neck) and the engraved armrest.  The banjo had what collectors call "case candy" (artifacts such as strings, tuning wrench, etc. in the case compartment) -- unfortunately no mention that the little piece of celluloid broken from the Baldoni's grille turned up in the banjo case!  Maybe fingerprints or DNA ;-)

My main disappointment has been that the Gibson banjo shipping records are not available for the period of this banjo.  Gibson researchers have been uncovering a lot of detail in shipping records for some of the pre-WW2 Gibson banjos (such as records of individual banjos being shipped out and returned multiple times before sold, records regarding the orderers of custom banjos, records of the exact music or furniture store where and when sold, etc.), but we don't seem to have that for the 1928 banjos.*

But I have located some very colorful newspaper references to the family of a J. J. Dwyer in the greater NY area, and over time maybe more specific news of one or more more musicians by that name will come to light!

On another note -- did you go over to Willie Week?  Heard it was great....

PG

* BTW that research, by Mr. Spann and others, tells us that just before the stock market crashed in 1929 the instrument factories and distributers had huge inventories of musical instruments in various stages of completion, but sales dropped to nothing after the crash and took years to recover. Those stockpiles of instruments and parts took the better part of a decade to sell off... leading to some anachronisms among instruments started in the 1920s and finished in the 1930s, or cobbled together in the 1930s from parts made at different times.  I think that knowledge re: fretted instruments is worth remembering when we try to make sense of some of the anachronistic features we see in the accordions labeled Baldoni-Bartoli or Walters. All this on top of the issues that both those accordion shops were obtaining their instruments or at least some parts from various sources before finishing, decorating and labeling them.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: melodeon on July 11, 2010, 03:06:33 PM
My first banjo was an all original TB-3 which I bought from an old Russion lady; I believe in 1971. She advised taht her husband bought it new
 in 1925. It too, had all the "case candy".  I built a 5 string repro neck.. saved all the original parts. It now resides in Maryland. A classic "ball bearing" banjo.

While not as famed as your Dwyer, mine had quite a history.  America to Russia, Russia to England , England to Pacific Grove Calif..

The Banjo Hangout is a marvel.

Hope you find your celluloid bit.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: hibbs3 on July 22, 2011, 01:45:24 AM
I'm wondering if anyone knows the significance of this leather piece on the inside of the lid of the case belonging to my Baldoni.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: Theo on July 22, 2011, 10:14:57 AM
It could be an attachment for a strap to stop the lid falling all the way back.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: Lars on July 27, 2011, 07:35:02 PM
It seems to be a recent fitting - I just checked the lid of my own vintage Baldoni case, and it shows nothing of that sort. From the pictures it looks like the ends are slottet - a bit like those leather pads attached to narrow straps for a comfortable feel to the stress-point on the shoulder.
Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: triskel on September 21, 2013, 12:35:13 AM
* BTW that research, by Mr. Spann and others, tells us that just before the stock market crashed in 1929 the instrument factories and distributers had huge inventories of musical instruments in various stages of completion, but sales dropped to nothing after the crash and took years to recover. Those stockpiles of instruments and parts took the better part of a decade to sell off... leading to some anachronisms among instruments started in the 1920s and finished in the 1930s, or cobbled together in the 1930s from parts made at different times.  I think that knowledge re: fretted instruments is worth remembering when we try to make sense of some of the anachronistic features we see in the accordions labeled Baldoni-Bartoli or Walters. All this on top of the issues that both those accordion shops were obtaining their instruments or at least some parts from various sources before finishing, decorating and labeling them.

You remind me of the major price reductions to be seen in the U.S. Paolo Soprani and Serenelli Ruatta catalogues that I have from that era - accordions evidently got to be hard to sell, and maybe progressively worse, since prices kept dropping...

The Second World War had a big effect too and some musical instrument makers only managed to keep going at all by cobbling together instruments from left-over parts - hence, for example, some very hybrid models of Gibson guitars made in those years, whilst Martin had to drop the "herringbone" trim from their legendary D-28 guitars because they could no longer get supplies of it from Germany.

Also, Iorio could no longer get supplies of accordion parts, especially reeds, from Italy (as Ted has mentioned) and that, I think, is why the "Irish" boxes made c.1942-46 (with the square buttons) were apparently all made by the small New York makers "Superior", run by Frank Umbriaco. It was only from 1946-47 onwards that the Italian factories started producing and exporting again, and Baldoni Brothers in Castelfidardo became the next producers.

Title: Re: Baldoni Bartoli box in D
Post by: pgroff on September 21, 2013, 09:59:24 AM

You remind me of the major price reductions to be seen in the U.S. Paolo Soprani and Serenelli Ruatta catalogues that I have from that era - accordions evidently got to be hard to sell, and maybe progressively worse, since prices kept dropping...

Also, Iorio could no longer get supplies of accordion parts, especially reeds, from Italy (as Ted has mentioned) and that, I think, is why the "Irish" boxes made c.1942-46 (with the square buttons) were apparently all made by the small New York makers "Superior", run by Frank Umbriaco. It was only from 1946-47 onwards that the Italian factories started producing and exporting again, and Baldoni Brothers in Castelfidardo became the next producers.

Hi Stephen,

Great to see your comments here.  As more of these instruments have surfaced, we've been discussing them in your absence but missed your insights.

I noticed similar price reductions in some of my 1930s pricelists from Chicago importers.  Times were tough! Of course, if you look at postwar Baldoni ads you can also see instruments on sale, "prices slashed."  I guess tough times or at least price reductions are a recurrent theme in the accordion business.

Yes also about supply problems in WW2;  Joe Derrane has mentioned the wartime interruption of reeds from Europe for the Irish-American accordions and we can see that many of the instruments' specifications changed in the 1940s.  Aldo Mencaccini used to tell me that certain 1940s (and 1950s) Walters that I showed him were "made by Frank Umbriaco;" of course Aldo was on the scene at the time.  As well as those Walters, I think some of the Baldoni-Bartolis and possibly the O'Brady blue melodeon with no retailer's label* also may have come from Umbriaco's sources (along with his own Superior-labeled boxes).  These would often be boxes with wide bellows frames trimmed in celluloid to match the left and right cases.  You didn't say as much, but to clarify, I'm not sure that *all* the Irish-American boxes with square or rectangular buttons came from a single source, and indeed some round-button Walters from the late 1940s share many features with some of the rectangular-button boxes, so their maker may have made boxes with both button shapes. 

Then, I understand you have good evidence that the Baldoni brothers made some of the earliest postwar Irish-American boxes . . . but do you think the Baldoni brothers also made the Baldoni-Bartoli boxes with the curved aluminum logo, such as the black Healy 13 key**  and the brown Conville 15-key (shown below; I also know a similar blue one)? I speculate that these were very early post-war boxes, but their connection to the Baldoni brothers is less clear to me. 

The 1920s -  1940s period is especially interesting to me because during that period no two of these Irish-American boxes that I've seen are exactly alike. I like to imagine possible thought processes of the musicians, the retailers, and the actual makers -- their experimentation to arrive at a better box, their workflow including outsourcing and bricolage, and often a concern with "branding" (on the part of the shops and/or the musicians) -- in a very complex and dynamic musical scene. The social and political context of the iconography of 1920s examples is interesting in itself.

PG


*O'Brady unlabeled blue box, ca 1944 or earlier:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3158.msg39359.html#msg39359
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=12224.5

**Healy box:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=8225.0
http://www.flickr.com/photos/69427983@N08/sets/72157627915416485/

(Conville 15 key box shown below (before restoration by Peter Cashman), with permission of its current owner, also similar details on a 1940s Moreschi PA.)

Edited to add:  and for more of that late-1940s brown faux-tortoise celluloid, here's Miss Rheingold 1949.  Too bad it's a concertina, but I have a feeling quite a few of these Baldonis also spent some time around Rheingold, if not with Miss Rheingold herself.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Miss_Rheingold_-_Pat.jpg
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal